Close Icon

Vote

Bill-4
June 1, 2025 (21 hours ago)
Ontario
First Reading
0 Votes
Full Title:
Healthcare

Summary

This bill changes the laws about how tissue (such as organs or samples) can be removed from a person’s body after they die. Currently, people need to give permission before their tissue can be used. The bill makes it so that permission is mostly not needed, except for children under 16, for whom a parent or guardian must give consent. People can object to their tissue being used if they do not want it removed after their death.

The bill also requires hospitals and health facilities to notify Ontario Health when someone dies or is close to death. Ontario Health will keep a registry of all the people who object or give permission for tissue removal or use.

The bill updates related laws to support these changes and to organize how the permissions and objections are handled.

What it means for you

If you are an adult, you do not need to give permission in advance for tissue removal, unless you object. You can also state before death if you do or do not want your tissue used. If you do not object, tissue may be used for transplants, medical research, or education, which could help save lives or improve health care.

Parents or guardians must give consent for children under 16. They can also object to tissue removal for their children. During medical emergencies or illness, hospitals will check if there is an objection or permission on record.

People or families who do not want tissue to be used need to communicate this clearly. Hospitals and Ontario Health will keep track of these objections and permissions in a registry.

This bill may make it easier to use tissue for important medical purposes but also emphasizes respecting people's choices and objections.

Expenses

The bill requires hospitals and other health facilities to notify Ontario Health when a patient dies and to report objections or permissions. It also requires the creation and maintenance of a new registry of objections and permissions. Data unavailable on specific costs associated with these activities; generally, these could involve administrative expenses for facilities and Ontario Health. There are no direct costs outlined in the bill, and any added expenses would depend on how many notifications and records are made.

Proponents' View

Supporters say the bill simplifies and streamlines the process of tissue donation. They argue that removing the need for consent in most cases could increase the availability of tissues for transplants, research, and education. They believe this could save more lives and advance medical science. Proponents also emphasize respecting individual and family wishes by allowing objections and creating a registry, making sure that people's choices are known and followed.

Opponents' View

Opponents are concerned that the bill might reduce individuals’ control over their bodies after death. They worry that making consent optional could lead to tissues being used without explicit permission, which may not respect personal or family wishes. Some also argue that the bill might lead to ethical and legal issues if people are not aware that their tissue could be used unless they object or take steps to refuse. Critics believe that greater transparency and consent processes are necessary to protect individual rights.

Original Bill