Legislative Assembly of Ontario · House

Monday, May 12, 2025

The official record of the sitting, from Hansard, by section and topic. Passages link to the Assembly’s video of Members’ Statements and Question Period where it is posted.

Monday, May 12, 2025

Read from the beginning of the sitting

Sitting ended

Petitions

Medical assistance in dying

1:02 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Bobbi Ann Brady

I have a petition here entitled “Petition Regarding Conscience Protection for Medical Professionals.” The petition states that medical assistance in dying, MAID, is increasingly controversial as it expands to more Canadians. The petition goes on to read that medical professionals in Ontario have conscientious objections to providing MAID, yet the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario forces medical professionals to provide referrals even in cases of conscientious objection. It reads, “Therefore we, the undersigned, petition the Legislative Assembly of Ontario” to legislate conscience protection for objecting medical professionals. I fully support this petition, will affix my signature to the bottom and send it to the Clerks’ table with page Ivan.

Official source

Visitor parking fees

1:03 p.m.Official Hansard

Mrs. Jennifer (Jennie) Stevens

I am presenting this petition on behalf of Judith Brooks of St. Catharines. She has affixed her name to this petition to ban paid visitors’ parking at multi-unit residential apartment buildings throughout Ontario. She, as well as all who have signed this, are saying that parking meters are being installed at multi-unit rental apartment buildings across St. Catharines by corporate landlords. Visitors to these buildings often include personal support workers, who are being charged heavy parking fees. St. Catharines city council actually passed a motion in November 2023 asking that the province of Ontario ban paid visitors’ parking at multi-building units. Residents of the residential multi-unit rental buildings reflect all demographics. They’re asking and petitioning the Legislative Assembly of Ontario to direct the Minister of Housing to issue an order that states that owners of residential multi-unit apartment complex buildings are banned from installing parking meters and charging visitors to park at the buildings when they’re spending time with seniors and residents in these buildings. I fully support this petition. I’ll affix my name to it and send it down to the table with Emily.

Official source

Education funding

1:05 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Chandra Pasma

I’m pleased to rise to table a petition entitled “Fund Ontario Public Schools.” The government has cut $1,500 per student since they came into power in 2018. This has left our children without the supports and the resources that they need, in much larger class sizes, in schools that are not safe and healthy. The provincial government could choose at any time to reverse those cuts and make sure that they properly fund schools so that our kids receive the supports that they need. The petitioners are calling on the provincial government to do that, rather than attacking local democracy. I’m happy to table this petition. I wholeheartedly endorse it, will sign my name to it and send it to the table with page Massimo.

Official source

Affordable housing

1:06 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Kristyn Wong-Tam

I’m very proud to rise in this House to present this petition calling on the Legislative Assembly of Ontario to do the following: reverse the recent rent control protections that were eliminated for new rental units; end vacancy decontrol—landlords should not be allowed to increase rents whenever they want, especially when a tenant just moves out; end the above-the-guideline rent increases; have the landlords repair and maintain the units—and that they should not be paying extra for that; and strengthen the Residential Tenancies Act to protect the tenants from renovictions, demovictions and illegal evictions. I’ll be proud to sign this petition and send it back to the centre table with page Hayden.

Official source

Education funding

1:07 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Peggy Sattler

I have a petition calling on the Ontario government to properly fund public schools in this province. The petition notes that several school boards in Ontario are currently under investigation by the Ministry of Education. One school board, Thames Valley District School Board, is actually under supervision right now. A lot of the financial pressures that school boards are facing are a result of the $1,500 cut to education funding that this government has implemented since they were elected in 2018. The issues that school boards are experiencing right now could easily be addressed if the provincial government restored that funding and gave our school boards the revenues that they need to provide supports for kids in our classrooms. The petition calls on the government to ensure that the coming provincial budget allocates funds to avoid any cuts—further cuts—to education funding, that classroom funding that has been lost since 2018 be restored, and that the government move to bring stability to our public education system. I fully support this petition. I will affix my signature and send it to the table with page Henry.

Official source

Health care

1:08 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Bobbi Ann Brady

I have a petition here asking the government to prohibit medical and surgical transitioning for minors. The petition explains that children with gender dysphoria require time, rather than medical or surgical transition. Those who have signed the petition are concerned that children as young as eight or nine are receiving puberty blockers and teenagers are receiving irreversible procedures. The petition reads, “We, the undersigned, petition the Legislative Assembly of Ontario to prohibit regulated health professionals in Ontario from providing puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and transitional surgeries for minors under the age of 18.” I support this petition. I will affix my signature to the bottom and send it to the table with page Ivan.

Official source

Education funding

1:10 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Jamie West

This petition is to help fund Ontario’s public schools. This has to do with the people of my riding and of Ontario wanting the provincial government, the Conservative government, to fund public schools properly. We know that since 2018 there has been a cut of $1,500 per student. Right now, the Minister of Education is talking about doing audits and maybe taking the boards under direct provincial control so you can facilitate cutting services in the school boards. People who have signed these petitions are concerned that there have been cuts already that have led to children, especially those with special needs and autism, not getting the services they should be required to have and those children being sent home without education. I fully support this petition. They’re asking for the government to fund the schools properly and stop the panic that they’re creating with the families and businesses and workers across our province. I support this petition. I think that we need to fund our schools efficiently if we want our kids to get the jobs of tomorrow and the proper education that they require. I’ll affix my signature. I’ll provide it to page Aashman for the table.

Official source

Opposition Day

Hospital funding / Financement des hôpitaux

1:11 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Marit Stiles

I move the following motion: Whereas hospital infrastructure is vital to protecting the health of the public and in strengthening Ontario in the face of economic uncertainty; and Whereas the government has identified priority nation-building infrastructure projects, but failed to include any health care infrastructure; and Whereas there are significant hospital infrastructure projects which have experienced long delays and funding cuts under Liberal and Conservative governments; and Whereas hospital infrastructure improvements create good union jobs for construction tradespeople; and Whereas hospital expansions create good union jobs for health care workers; Therefore, in the opinion of the House, the government must designate critical hospital infrastructure as nation-building projects and fund them in the 2025 budget, including specific commitments to new hospitals for Durham region, Brantford, Kitchener-Waterloo and Brampton; reopening the Minden hospital; expanding the Windsor-Essex regional hospital, Queensway Carleton Hospital, Arnprior regional hospital and Hamilton Health Sciences; redeveloping the Weeneebayko General Hospital and Health Sciences North; renovating the Thessalon Hospital, Matthews Memorial Hospital, Manitoulin Health Centre and Red Lake Margaret Cochenour Memorial Hospital; and restoring 24/7 emergency services and urgent care to Welland Hospital, Douglas Memorial and Port Colborne.

Official source

1:13 p.m.Official Hansard

The Speaker (Hon. Donna Skelly)

MPP Stiles has moved opposition day motion number 3. I recognize the leader of His Majesty’s official opposition.

Official source

1:13 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Marit Stiles

Across Ontario, people are doing their part. They’re showing up for each other. They’re working hard to build a strong future here in our beautiful province. But when they walk into an emergency room, they’re told to wait. When they need surgery, they’re told they have to leave town. When they ask for help, they’re told, “Not yet.” Hospitals are crumbling. Urgent care and emergency rooms are closing. Communities have been waiting for too long. That’s why today we are putting forward a motion to build care and strengthen Ontario. We are making hospital projects across the province nation-building projects: —new hospitals for Brampton, Durham, Kitchener-Waterloo and Brantford; —reopening the Minden ER; —expanding care in Windsor, Hamilton, Niagara, and all across the north; —renovating hospitals in Red Lake, Manitoulin, Thessalon, and more; and —restoring 24/7 urgent care in Welland, Port Colborne and Fort Erie. These are life-saving, job-creating, shovel-ready investments. Speaker, let’s build care and strengthen Ontario. Interjections.

Official source

1:15 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Marit Stiles

You know what, sit down. There’s a very tall member across the way who likes to stand in the camera when I’m speaking. I’ve noticed it a number of times. I would appreciate it if you didn’t do that anymore, okay? Speaker, last week we learned that Ontario’s manufacturing sector is facing the sharpest decline in the country. That’s now 33,000 manufacturing jobs that have been lost under this government. In Windsor, unemployment is spiking. In Oshawa, GM is cutting shifts. In Thunder Bay, Alstom workers are facing layoffs again. And the Premier’s response? “Wait and see.” Ontario workers don’t need a Premier who crosses his fingers and then just waits to see what’s coming. They need a plan, they need a path forward, and they need a government that actually shows up. That’s what it means to strengthen Ontario. As the official opposition, that’s our focus every single day. A few months ago, the Premier pulled US-made alcohol from LCBO shelves. It was to send a message, and I supported that. But now? Bacardi is back, with no explanation. If you want to show strength, act like it. The Premier needs to pick a lane, because mixed signals are not sending the right message; they’re weakening it. If this government wants to send a message, here’s another one that they could use to get started with—they could get people vaccinated. It’s 2025, and we are in the middle of a measles outbreak. Over 1,300 confirmed cases—the worst we have seen in decades. We’re now outpacing the United States in a disease that we know how to prevent. Dr. Robin Lennox, our MPP for Hamilton Centre, has been raising the alarm from day one, calling for clear public communication, a province-wide education campaign about the free MMR vaccine, and a coordinated strategy with public health units. We have seen how fast misinformation can spread. We need to meet it with urgency, clarity and fast action, because when public health is at risk, there is no time for “wait and see.” So let’s work together, and let’s protect our communities. That’s how we are going to strengthen Ontario. This government says it wants to invest in nation-building infrastructure. But here’s the reality: They’re pushing forward with a $100-billion tunnel, while hospitals across Ontario are stuck waiting. You want to build something that strengthens Ontario? Then build hospitals. Build urgent care centres. Build the infrastructure that people are counting on, from Brampton to Ottawa to Windsor to the north. Don’t chase vanity projects. Fund the services that actually save the lives of people right here in the province of Ontario. This motion, although it lists a lot of projects, isn’t just about a list of projects; it is a blueprint for a stronger Ontario. These hospitals have been studied. They have been planned. They have been promised. Some are shovel-ready right now. Some are long overdue. All of them are needed right now. When you build care, you don’t just shorten wait times; you give people peace of mind, you create good union jobs, you strengthen local economies. And that is how we build a province that’s ready for whatever is coming next. This motion is a test of our priorities. If you believe that a sick child in Brampton deserves a hospital bed, support this motion. If you believe a laid-off worker deserves a job building care, support this motion. If you believe Ontarians deserve a government that meets the moment, support this motion. Let’s build care. Let’s strengthen Ontario. And let’s get the job done, together.

Official source

1:20 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Lee Fairclough

I’m pleased to speak this motion today, as hospitals are an essential part of our public health care system. I’ve worked in health care for 27 years, at Princess Margaret Hospital, which is part of the University Health Network, and most recently at CAMH. I also had the privilege of serving as the president of St. Mary’s hospital in Kitchener—a job I started in January 2020, just nine weeks before our world changed as we experienced the global pandemic and lockdowns to protect lives and our hospitals from becoming overwhelmed with severely ill and infectious patients. St. Mary’s hospital’s infrastructure dates back about 100 years, and it showed. Throughout my tenure, I worked with our board of directors and community leaders, including local members here, to advocate for funding to build a new, modern, larger hospital, combining the programs of St. Mary’s hospital and Grand River Hospital. It was the last announcement made under my tenure—just before leaving to run for office—and we had made a clear case for change. There’s actually very good data available to inform choice on hospital redevelopments and communities most in need—where there’s population growth; where repairs are too costly or the buildings are getting beyond the ability to repair; where there are still tiny, four-bed rooms with shared bathrooms that you can’t even fit a walker through the door of. The government’s job is to be systematic in picking hospitals based on objective criteria, and I think it’s important that the current government should take that very seriously too. I know, for example, that the redevelopment of Grand River Hospital and St. Mary’s hospital, as a large joint project, met these criteria, and it was well recognized that it was needed. Trillium Health Partners, a big redevelopment, was a project started under the previous Liberal government and now continued by this one. It’s another example of a community in desperate need of expanded hospital services. I recall that in one of my previous roles, I visited many hospitals back in 2019 to look at the state of hallway health care. I recall one hospital that was in a community that so desperately needed more capacity, so, appropriately, it was funded and moved forward. Given the population growth and the long capital project wait-lists, it’s important that these hospitals, like the one in Kitchener-Waterloo, move forward and the work gets under way. Whether a nation-building project or not, these investments are needed. I appreciate this bill comes forward to signal it’s an opportunity to ensure that these projects progress at pace. But the reason I ran for public office was not because we had an old hospital; it was because under this government, I saw a loss of transparency and accountability, and our public health system weakened. We lost a view as to how our system was performing and where attention needed to be paid, while I saw our public resources redirected to private benefit that cost our public payers more without accountability on outcomes. One example of this was Bill 124. Today is the first day of nurses’ week. Nurses get into nursing because they care. They want to make it better. This bill, now deemed by the courts as a violation of charter rights, tied the hands of every hospital in Ontario to be able to appropriately reward nurses during that period. To no one’s surprise, nurses capped at a 1% wage increase felt disrespected and unvalued. Too many left when we needed them most—and some to private nursing agencies. Like most hospitals, we had no choice but to fill that gap with private agencies that cost significantly more, who were happy to make a profit from public dollars at a time when we were the most in need. It was almost as if it was all by design. The government decided to only provide funding for about 75% of those wage settlements. Meanwhile, our public hospitals are now expected to find a way to fill that gap. Many had no choice but to make cuts in services, including emergency departments, that rarely happened before 2018. These closures come at a time of crisis in primary care. With record numbers of people without primary care, more are forced to turn to emergency departments. Even on primary care, we’re seeing announcements this week—but in 2018, we had over 90% attachment, which means that people had access to primary care. And that has significantly dropped off. The nation-building project that started six decades ago is public health care, and that is the project I believe most Canadians and most Ontarians support. It is what I heard on the doorsteps thousands of times this past election. Yes, we need hospitals, and we need stable funding to run them. We need our workforce to be valued and respected, and we need the other parts of the system—primary care, home care, long-term care, mental health care, and prevention—to be properly resourced. We need it to be strategic. These are not insurmountable challenges, and they require a government to make deliberate choices to support them. Our public health care system isn’t just a collection of policies and buildings; it’s a profound expression of Canadian values. We value fairness, compassion and the dignity of every person. The people of Ontario deserve nothing less than a health care system that honours these fundamental Canadian values, and I urge this government to respect those values.

Official source

1:24 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Robin Lennox

I would like to start today by recognizing that this motion is meant to support our publicly funded health care system, the thing that, in Ontario, we should all be wanting to reinforce and to strengthen, because it serves all Ontarians. Just the weekend before last, I was doing a shift in hospital covering for a colleague, and as I walked by the emergency department to see my patient, I walked by a hallway in the emergency department that was stretcher and stretcher and stretcher and stretcher—so many that we now know exactly how those stretchers are labelled in the hallway so that we can find our patients. We also now have terminology for our patients—“SR” for “sunroom,” because we always have patients sitting in our sunrooms to be seen, trying to sleep even though the windows are blaring. We also now know what it is to often see patients with cognitive impairment having to sit permanently by the nursing station because there’s no quiet room for them to be in to get the attention they need. So they’re sitting in the nursing station among all of us doing our charting because that is the only place for them to be. This has become normal, but it shouldn’t be. It is extremely abnormal, and it is different than how it was when I was practising seven years ago. We know that in Ontario, our health care system has been intentionally strained and intentionally underfunded; that despite hearing that ending hallway health care is a priority, there has been no meaningful change under this Conservative government; and that, despite health care being our largest budget item, we in Ontario still spend the least per capita on health care of any other province. In addition to that, we know that we have less than half the hospital beds that we had 30 years ago, but that doesn’t mean that less people are ending up in hospital. I commend the effort of our caucus to try to promote the need for increased hospital investment, increased hospital infrastructure and reopening services that have been closed, because we know that people turn to hospitals in their time of greatest need. The worst thing that can happen to someone is to show up at a hospital door, see a “closed” sign and be told to keep driving to try to find help somewhere down the road, and that has become our new normal. I look forward to hearing more about this motion.

Official source

1:25 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Tyler Watt

Let me begin by saying this: I wholeheartedly agree with the spirit of this motion. Ontario must treat hospital infrastructure as a priority. Our province is growing, our population is aging, and the wear and tear on our health care facilities is undeniable. As a front-line nurse at the Queensway Carleton Hospital in Nepean, I see every single day the human cost of our crumbling hospital infrastructure. We are past the point of asking whether hospital infrastructure is vital. That’s a settled question. Hospitals are where life begins and, too often, where it ends. They are where Ontarians go in moments of crisis and vulnerability, trusting that help will be there. But increasingly, we are pushing our hospitals to their limits and the people who work inside them to a breaking point. We’ve seen this government roll out a list of their priority projects, like a fantasy tunnel in Toronto or a luxury spa at Ontario Place. I’m not fully understanding why this is the focus for this government while our hospitals are overcrowded, our ERs are literally shutting down, and our aging facilities aren’t able to keep up with increased demand. At Queensway Carleton Hospital, which serves one of the fastest-growing populations in the city of Ottawa, we are well beyond capacity on a daily basis. Our emergency department was built to handle about 60,000 patient visits a year; last year, we saw nearly twice that number. Patients are being treated in hallways. Stretchers are lined up in waiting rooms. And we, the nurses, doctors and staff, are expected to make it all work in the same space, with the same aging infrastructure and fewer resources. Let me be clear: I am proud of what we do for our patients at the Queensway Carleton Hospital. Our resilience speaks volumes. But it shouldn’t be that way. The current conditions of hospitals throughout Ontario are unsustainable. And they’re, frankly, unsafe. Hospitals across this province are literally falling apart, and yet this government doesn’t seem to care. Last week, I asked the health minister if she would commit to investing in and funding the much-needed expansion of the Queensway Carleton Hospital emergency room—a simple yes or no question, which she refused to answer. What message does that send? It tells Ontarians that our health doesn’t matter, that access to emergency care doesn’t matter, that the dignity of patients and the well-being of front-line workers doesn’t matter. But we know that this isn’t true, because hospital infrastructure does matter, not only to health care delivery but to our economy. Investing in hospital expansions creates good, family-sustaining union jobs for construction workers, for tradespeople and for the next generation of skilled health care professionals. Every crane in the air is a signal of hope. Every new bed opened is a promise fulfilled. We have shovel-ready projects ready to go. We have aging facilities desperate for renewal. We have communities in crisis. What we don’t have is the political will. This motion calls for long-overdue action in places like Durham region, Brantford, Kitchener-Waterloo, and Brampton. It calls for expanding the Windsor-Essex regional hospital and Queensway Carleton Hospital, my hospital, where every additional square foot means better care, faster treatment and safer working conditions for staff. As I said, I’m supportive of this motion, and I’m thrilled to see the Queensway Carleton in the list. I do wonder, though, why certain hospitals were left out. For example, where is the Kingston General Hospital listed—a hospital that serves not just Kingston, but the entire southeastern Ontario region. Its aging infrastructure requires modernization to meet today’s demands, and yet it wasn’t mentioned—so I’m just curious why. It’s not enough just to name some hospitals in some regions. If we’re serious about building a strong health care system, we need a framework that prioritizes need, capacity and regional equity. This isn’t just a to-do list; it’s a moral obligation, one that we owe to every patient who waits too long for care, to every family who drives hours for a hospital bed, and to every nurse or doctor who burns out trying to do more with less. Let me tell you what not investing looks like. It looks like nurses leaving the profession. It looks like hallway medicine becoming the norm. It looks like delayed surgeries, cancelled appointments, and patients dying from preventable deaths. As a nurse, I can tell you this: No amount of training can make up for a system that’s physically broken. I urge every member in this House, regardless of party affiliation, to seriously consider this motion. It is a question of what kind of province we want to live in—one where your postal code determines your access to care, or one where every Ontarian, north or south, urban or rural, can count on a strong, modern, well-staffed hospital when they need it. We can’t fix hallway medicine without fixing the physical capacity issues. We can’t recruit and retain health care workers without giving them the facilities they need to do their jobs safely. And we can’t call ourselves a strong, prosperous, nation-building province while our hospitals fall into despair. So let’s stop pretending that the only infrastructure that matters is roads and bridges. It means hospitals and hospital beds. It means MRI machines. It means emergency departments that stay open. It’s time we invest in hospital infrastructure and show the people of Ontario that their public health care system is not negotiable.

Official source

1:30 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Tyler Allsopp

Before I begin today, I just want to say to my colleagues on the other side of the House, if any of you for any reason need to stand up, stretch your legs, visit a neighbour, feel free. It is an honour to speak about a topic that is crucial to the well-being of our communities and the future of our province: hospital infrastructure. As we navigate the complexities of modern health care, it is imperative that we invest in and enhance our hospital infrastructure to meet the growing needs of our population. Under the leadership of Premier Ford and Minister Jones, our government is making capital investments across the province so we can sustainably support the health care needs of Ontario—just like in my home riding of Bay of Quinte, with our new Prince Edward County Memorial Hospital state-of-the-art, $200-million mass timber build. We cannot wait for that hospital to be completed. Interjection.

Official source

1:30 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Tyler Allsopp

Thank you very much. These investments mean more hospital beds in communities, more diagnostic testing like MRIs and CTs closer to home, and more skilled health care workers to provide care. Our government is building a convenient and connected health care system that puts people first. That is why Ontario is delivering on the most ambitious plan for hospital expansion in the province’s history. Ontario’s plan will lead to investments of nearly $50 billion over the next 10 years in health infrastructure, including close to $36 billion in capital grants. This includes supporting more than 50 hospital projects that would add approximately 3,000 new beds over 10 years to improve access to reliable, high-quality care. For example, Durham region is experiencing significant population growth, with a rising level of alternative-level-of-care, or ALC, rate. Addressing these pressures is essential to ensure that residents receive timely and effective health care services. Among our approved projects is the hospital redevelopment project at Lakeridge Health’s Bowmanville site. Planning and design work is currently under way for the Bowmanville redevelopment, and in summer 2024, Infrastructure Ontario initiated the process to select a team that will be delivering this project. The Ministry of Health continues to work closely with Lakeridge Health and other partners, such as Ontario Health, to determine how the hospital’s short-term and long-term program and service needs can be met in alignment with capital planning needs. To date, our government has provided more than $12 million in capital planning grants to support Lakeridge Health’s master planning, including the Bowmanville redevelopment project. It is important to note that planning for major capital projects like Lakeridge Health’s proposed new hospital is a complex process to address the health service needs within that community. Our government is supportive of Lakeridge Health’s plan for the future, involving a multi-phase redevelopment that will ensure families across the Durham region can access the care they need when they need it. The plan includes redevelopment of hospital campuses across the region, as well as a new hospital site in Whitby that will expand services and add more beds to connect more patients and their families to convenient care closer to home. Ontario will continue to work with Lakeridge Health as it moves forward with its plan and continues planning for the site of its proposed new Whitby hospital. To support the early planning work for its master plan, a total of $2.25 million was approved as a planning grant by the ministry. Lakeridge Health is planning expansion of its services and hospital campuses to add new hospital beds and enhance services throughout the region, including: —redeveloping the Bowmanville Hospital by adding up to 32 new beds and building new facilities to expand in-patient and ambulatory care services and the emergency department; —planning for a new post-acute-care centre in Pickering; and —creating space for acute-care capacity at the Oshawa site by relocating some services to a new post-acute-care centre in Pickering. Later phases of the redevelopment plan under consideration include expanding the Ajax Pickering Hospital to connect more people to clinical and support services. Earlier this month, our government broke ground on an expanded emergency department in Renfrew county. The largest redevelopment in St. Francis Memorial Hospital’s history, in Barry’s Bay, will connect more people to quality emergency care close to home. Once opened, the new, state-of-the-art emergency department will accommodate an estimated 11,900 visits each year and will include a dedicated isolation room equipped with negative air pressure to keep patients safe by preventing the spread of airborne infectious diseases; a new entrance for ambulances to use, improving patient flow; quiet room space for mental health patients and families; an upgraded trauma area to ensure timely responses to emergencies; and improved infection prevention and control measures, because our government understands that when someone experiences a medical emergency, it is vital that they get the urgent attention they need quickly. That is why we’re investing an additional $44 million this year in 165 high-volume and smaller emergency departments to reduce wait times and provide people with faster and easier access to timely care close to home. This funding is in addition to the $90 million that our government invests each year to reward emergency departments that put in place innovative solutions to reduce emergency department wait times, including hiring additional health care staff, accessing more transportation to help transfer medically stable patients out of emergency departments, and creating new beds. We know that emergency departments have faced capacity pressures. That is why our government has offered a range of initiatives to support rural and northern hospitals. The Northern Ontario Resident Streamlined Training and Reimbursement program, or NORSTAR, enables medical students to provide immediate and longer-term physician support to northern Ontario communities. The Ontario Health emergency department staffing stabilization strategy is a joint Ministry of Health and Ontario Health nursing action plan to stabilize emergency department nursing coverage by investing $4.7 million to bolster and stabilize the emergency department nursing workforce through emergency department training initiatives and the establishment of clinical leadership and support by hiring regional emergency department educators for on-site nursing education in hospitals. The community commitment for nurses program offers nurses a $25,000 incentive in return for a two-year commitment in areas that need nurses most. The Supervised Practice Experience Partnership offers internationally educated nurses the opportunity to meet their evidence of practice and language proficiency requirements to achieve their nursing licence. The Enhanced Extern Program also offers employment opportunities in hospitals to clinical learners such as nursing and medical students to work in an unregulated capacity as externs. The Nursing Graduate Guarantee funds employers to provide new nurses, including those who studied out-of-province and abroad, with temporary full-time employment above employers’ staffing complement. Over $76 million has been funded to nearly 60 health care organizations and has employed up to 2,200 new nurses in 2023-24. The Temporary Fee Reimbursement Program reduces financial barriers to registration for internationally trained and retired nurses by covering application, examination and registration fees. The Emergency Department Peer-to-Peer Program supports emergency department physicians through access to immediate, on-demand coaching, mentoring and support from a credentialed peer emergency department physician via virtual channels. The program initially launched as a pilot in October 2022 across six emergency department sites and completed its pilot phase in December 2022. Following this, the program was expanded to 27 emergency department sites and then to every emergency department in the province by June 2023. The emergency department Pay-for-Results Program supports emergency departments that provide emergency care to fewer than 30,000 patients a year so they can hire and retain the staff they need to keep their emergency departments open. And the Clinical Scholar Program was launched in June 2023 and supports both recruitment and retention by creating mentorship opportunities. Through this program, experienced front-line nurses provide at-the-bedside mentorship and support to new graduate, internationally educated or upskilling nurses to confidently transition into new health care working environments and nursing practice. This includes emergency department settings. In Orangeville, we are building new emergency and diagnostic imaging departments that will increase patient capacity and ensure the hospital is better equipped to deliver state-of-the-art care for patients and families, now and in the future. Kim Delahunt, the president and CEO of Headwaters Health Care Centre, said, “We are deeply grateful for the investment being made to renovate and expand our emergency and diagnostic imaging departments. This will transform patient care and experience at Headwaters and support the teams that work in these departments. It will enable us to continue to provide excellent care, close to home, for the rapidly growing population and patient volumes that we see in Dufferin-Caledon.” And we recently broke ground on a new emergency mental health and addictions services unit in Guelph, Ontario. Once opened, Guelph General Hospital’s new mental health and addiction services unit will include: —expanding capacity in the short-stay assessment unit from four to eight beds, to monitor and treat more adult patients experiencing psychiatric emergencies; —a new emergency follow-up service that will increase individual and group counselling services by 14%, to help more than 2,200 patients stabilize before being discharged and reduce readmissions; —a new walk-in patient intake zone; —additional ambulance capacity, from two to three, by building a new three-bay ambulance garage with a dedicated off-load area, reducing off-load wait times in the emergency department; and —a brand new reception area in the emergency department, including a new waiting room and triage area. Earlier this year, we celebrated the completion of a historic Cambridge Memorial Hospital expansion. The hospital’s largest redevelopment project will connect more people to an expanded emergency department, surgical suites, and an intensive care unit. Our government invested over $220 million to support the project, which renovated and redeveloped over 400,000 square feet of hospital space to build a new in-patient care tower. This new, state-of-the-art facility will increase the hospital’s ability to care for more people by over 30% and improve care for patients undergoing life-saving surgery or requiring emergency care. By expanding access to hospital care in Hamilton, Juravinski Hospital will become the largest in-patient facility in south-central Ontario, with more than 500 in-patient beds, and will help the region meet the needs of its growing population, making it faster and easier for people to connect to a range of specialized adult care and services. Tracey MacArthur, president and CEO of Hamilton Health Sciences, said, “The Juravinski Hospital will bring the hospital’s nearly 100-year-old spaces into the 21st century. Our patients and teams expect and deserve nothing less than access to modern, accessible health care facilities to support world-class care. We are grateful for the provincial government’s ongoing partnership and investment in this vital community health project.” In November, our government announced that we are making it faster and easier for people living in Burlington, Ontario to connect to high-quality, comprehensive mental health and addiction support services closer to home by building a new health unit at Joseph Brant Hospital. Our government’s investment will build and create a larger state-of-the-art space for in-patient and outpatient services, to ensure the hospital is better equipped to deliver timely and high-quality mental health and addictions care for more patients and their families in a safe and comfortable setting. In Kawartha Lakes, we are building an expanded emergency department at Ross Memorial Hospital that will include the creation of a new, state-of-the-art mental health emergency services unit. This expansion will improve patient safety and ensure the hospital is better equipped to provide timely care for mental health patients.

Official source

1:42 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Tyler Allsopp

This expansion will also include a new trauma room with improved infection-control measures to provide emergency department staff with additional space to treat patients requiring life-saving care. At St. Joseph’s Healthcare Hamilton, our government is connecting more newborns and their families to better, more convenient, specialized neonatal intensive care and birthing support through the redevelopment of the special care nursery. Through this redevelopment, the current special care nursery will be renovated to create a larger and more comfortable space to ensure that newborns and their families have better access to specialized neonatal intensive care and family-centred birthing supports, including: —enhanced infection prevention and control measures, to ensure the health and safety of critically ill newborns; —more private rooms, to address privacy concerns and create lower-stimulus environments for newborn patients; —capacity to accommodate state-of-the-art design standards which provide more space for specialized care; —a designated room to store pumped or donated milk; and —other supports tailored to the early developmental needs of infants, including respiratory treatments, lactation and nutrition supports. Those projects are just some of the many examples of the bold action that our government is taking to invest in our hospital infrastructure, supporting world-class health care facilities for patients, families, health care professionals and communities. In conclusion, investing in hospital infrastructure is essential for the health and the well-being of our communities. It ensures that patients receive the best possible care in a safe and modern environment. Our government’s dedication to investing nearly $50 billion over the next 10 years in health infrastructure is a significant step in the right direction. However, it is up to all of us to support these efforts and work together to build a healthier future for Ontario. Thank you for your attention. I look forward to working with all of you to achieve our shared goal of a world-class health care system.

Official source

1:50 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

I’d like to recognize the member for Niagara Falls.

Official source

1:50 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Wayne Gates

I obviously support the motion, but I want to talk about Fort Erie and talk about Douglas Memorial Hospital. It used to be a 24/7 urgent care centre, but this Premier and Niagara Health decided to cut the hours down to 10 hours a day. It made absolutely no sense then, and it makes no sense today. Speaker, 38,000 people live in Fort Erie. They rely on that urgent care centre. Think about this: 12,000 of those residents don’t have a family doctor. Where are they going to go? They can’t go to the family doctor. And now they’re cutting the hours in urgent care centres so there’s no overnight—so they have to go to the emergency room either in St. Catharines or in Niagara Falls. Our emergency rooms today have 12- to 19-hour wait times just to get in. It makes no sense. The Auditor General’s report was very clear, and these guys over here should listen. It said that if you want to improve wait times in your emergency rooms, invest in urgent care centres—not cut them and close them. It makes no sense to me. Then I take a look at Fort Erie—I kind of break it down into families. You know that 60% of the people who live in Fort Erie are over 55 years old. A lot of them don’t drive. There’s no reliable transit. It makes no sense, what this government is doing. So when they talk about investing in health care—that’s not happening in Niagara. I want to talk about what happens at an urgent care centre. I’ll give two examples. There’s a gentleman who had a heart attack—he wouldn’t have made it to Niagara Falls; he wouldn’t have made it to St. Catharines. He made it to the urgent care centre, and those doctors and those nurses saved his life. And they came and thanked that hospital for doing that. But he would have been dead. There’s a young kid, 11 years old, who had an appendix attack. And guess what happened? He wouldn’t have made it to Niagara Falls. He wouldn’t have made it to St. Catharines. But he made it to that urgent care centre, and it saved his life. That’s the difference, when you have an urgent care centre 24/7. It saves lives. Why do I have to, every single day, worry that if I’m not going to get into an urgent care centre because it’s closed, I may die? Nobody should die in the province of Ontario—one of the richest provinces in this country, quite frankly—because they’re not getting health care when they need it, where they need it and why they need it. It makes no sense. I’m going to finish by saying this: We heard today during question period, very clearly, that they spend $1 billion on agency nurses, and they tried to defend that. They said, “Oh, that’s good. These are good nurses.” We’re not talking about the nurses. We’re talking about the $500,000 to $600,000 of that money that went to a corporation or private company that’s run by the Harris family. That’s what we’re talking about. And then we heard about Shoppers Drug Mart—$62 million. So I say to them: Take that $1 billion, take that $62 million, and put it into urgent care centres, put it into the community of Fort Erie. That’s what should be happening in health care today.

Official source

1:53 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

I recognize the member for Ottawa South.

Official source

1:53 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. John Fraser

I just want to preface this by saying that I’m going to support this motion, but I want to express some concerns about the motion—because I do understand that the Prime Minister has indicated that it could be a priority. To be honest, right now, I’m not sure that we have a problem with building hospitals in Ontario as much as we have as to what’s happening in hospitals here in Ontario. I don’t want to complain, but I would have rather seen that in the motion. The second thing is, we’re kind of picking winners and losers here. Bruyère Continuing Care, which is in Ottawa–Vanier and in Ottawa Centre, is not included in it. It has one building that’s over 100 years old and another building that’s approaching it. They have a project. They’ve been skipped. They’ve been missed for years and years and years. So while I support what’s behind the motion, I’m concerned, number one, that we’ve picked winners and losers and we’ve excluded institutions—in Kingston as well. I think it’s a valid concern. And the second thing is, the problem that we have right now is not building hospitals. These guys—it’s easy; they like to build. That’s what they do. They just can’t get what happens inside right, and that’s bad for people.

Official source

1:55 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Alexa Gilmour

In 2023, just a few months before she died, I memorized my grandmother’s hands—102-year-old hands. So fragile, so petite, bony and curled in—the way all of our hands might go if we are lucky enough to live to be 102. I had hours and hours to study them after the ambulance delivered her to the hospital. St. Joe’s emergency was full. We had to go to a new hospital, and we were placed—you won’t be surprised—in a hallway to wait. As she tried to get comfortable on a gurney, the sympathetic looks from the health care workers as they went by gave us some comfort, as they moved away from her to serve or save some other life. These elderly hands, I thought—these hands that served as a bomb girl in World War II; these hands that helped to build a shelter for unwed mothers in Orillia decades and decades ago; these hands that nurtured four children and nine grandchildren and seven great-grandchildren—deserved more dignity, more compassion and more care than a public hallway in a hospital could give. As we contemplate nation-building projects and what is primary to Canada, I can tell you that it is not tunnels under the highway. Think Tommy Douglas and health care—building up our public health care system, providing good union jobs to construction workers and to health care providers that will lead to caring for our loved ones when they are most in need. From the premature babies to our elders, this government is failing our families. That is why it’s time to include hospital infrastructure in the nation-building projects of this government. So, in remembrance of my nana and for the people of Parkdale–High Park and St. Joseph’s Health Centre, I’m going to vote in favour of this motion. I’m going to invite and urge my colleagues across the aisle to think of whom they would like to dedicate their votes to.

Official source

1:57 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

It’s a real pleasure to be able to stand up and speak in favour of this NDP motion to reopen the Minden emergency room; to restore emergency room services in Welland, Port Colborne and Chesley; to rebuild and build new hospitals and renovate the hospitals that we have across this province; and to do this as part of a nation-building exercise that we need to undertake because we are under economic threat from the United States. One of our biggest competitive advantages in Canada is our public health care system. In the United States, they spend $12,000 per person on health care; we spend half of that, yet we live longer lives and our babies are born healthier. Our public health care system is the thing that defines us as Canadians. When businesses are deciding whether they’re going to locate in Canada or the United States, one of the things they look at is the employer premiums, health care premiums—much, much more affordable here in Canada. This government is playing games with numbers. They continue to say, “Oh, we’re investing a million dollars here, a million dollars there.” But the fact is that they announced in the budget $7 billion in health care that they did not actually invest in our health care services last year. We have the lowest per capita spending on health care of any province in the country. We would have to invest another $12 billion just to reach the provincial average. And what happens is that people are not getting the services they need because this government is under an ideological campaign to privatize and Americanize our public health care system. They are wasting our money. Today, the CCPA put out a report that they are spending $9.2 billion on private, for-profit nursing agencies. There are private, for-profit corporations performing surgeries at three times the rate in our public hospitals. So I’m asking the government to change course—to look at public health care as a competitive advantage, as a way to build our nation; to stop using our health care system as a cash cow for private corporations; to stop treating our Ontario patients as sacrificial lambs for corporate profits—and instead to rebuild public health care and our competitive advantage in this province.

Official source

2:00 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Rob Cerjanec

I appreciate the opposition day motion today from the NDP, as it talks about hospitals and health care as nation-building exercises. I agree. They absolutely can be nation-building exercises. Just because someone lives in Ontario, sometimes they may need to go somewhere else to get care in the country, or vice versa. We know that between different provinces, that does happen from time to time—so, 110%, I do think it can be nation-building. I appreciate that the NDP has identified health care issues, but in areas that are primarily where we tend to see NDP representatives, instead of other places in the province as well—when I look at York region, for example, or as the member from Ottawa South said, other areas of the province. While it’s a good motion, a good start, I think it’s important that we’re also looking at the entire province. We’ve seen, over the last seven years—and this is a Conservative government that ran on ending hallway health care; in fact, it has doubled, and that is a really, really big challenge for people in my riding. It’s something that I’m hearing about from constituents in my riding—not only on the campaign trail, but afterwards as well. The emergency room department at Ajax Pickering Hospital is struggling under the pressure that our health care system is facing, not just in Ajax and Durham region, but, really, all across Ontario. Right now, it’s seeing about 15,000 additional visits per year more than it was designed to handle. When that hospital was originally built, it was built to handle about 20,000 visits a year. In 2009, under a previous Liberal government—I know members on the other side sometimes talk about, “Oh, Liberals didn’t do this or that.” Under a previous Liberal government, it was renovated to handle about 60,000 folks. And right now, the hospital in my riding of Ajax is seeing 75,000 visits per year. I hear stories of my constituents waiting more than 12 hours to be seen, or even longer—folks who are coming in with chest pains, folks who are coming in with other medical problems and issues that they’re facing. That’s something that I hear quite frequently in my community when I’m out and about. Our health care workers are doing their best. In my view, they are doing their best under what is a really, really challenging situation. My constituents are worried about what’s going to happen to them if they need emergency care. Ironically, on the day of the federal election, I was in my constituency office—a woman came in to see me because she was dealing with a situation that involved her mother, who’s 94 years old. Her mother had been waiting in the emergency room department for over three days, set aside over in a hallway, but kind of at the end of the hallway, where, she described to me, many other elderly patients are just kind of parked until a room is available, until something opens up. She came into my constituency office, understandably upset, understandably concerned about the well-being and the health of her mother. She went on to tell me, “We’ve been taking shifts, sitting by her, helping her in the hospital, helping her with feeding”—helping her in this situation that her mother is dealing with. But not every person who’s in the hospital has a family support system, who can be there in shifts, helping feed their parent, their loved one, the person who raised them. That’s something that I hear quite frequently. It just so happened, on that day I was in the constituency office, and she came in and needed somebody to talk to. So we’ve been helping her and working with her. But I had to be honest. The current situation, frankly, is not good enough. It’s not good enough for my constituent who came in to see me, or her mother, 94 years old, out in the hallway. I followed up with my constituent, and I asked her what has happened since. After a lot of pushing, after three days and six hours—what they did in the hospital is, they had to open up a different, extra little room that wasn’t really equipped as a room where you would have patients, typically. They transferred her into there—in a gym, essentially, with four beds. There are no call buttons. I was told, a little bell—“Oh, you need help?” A little bell, like you would see in probably 1900—but this is today. This is 2025, and this is the state of our health care system in Ontario, because more funding is needed in our health care system. I heard the member opposite speak about Durham region. That’s an actual story from Durham region. That’s taking place right now. I’ll say this: We have not seen specific commitments on improving the Ajax Pickering Hospital emergency department capacity. More recently, we saw how this government ended up fighting with the mayor of Whitby—ended up fighting with folks in Whitby who were advocating and standing up to get a new hospital there. It was only after public pressure, it was only after community pressure of more than 4,000 people signing petitions, advocating—that pushed this government to say, “Oh, a little bit more.” But what we’ve seen time and time again—it’s a day late and a dollar short. So my belief is that this government should be doing a lot more right now. I think the opposition day motion helps move it in that direction, but, in my view, quite frankly, not far enough. So we need to see action taking place.

Official source

2:05 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

I’d like to talk a little bit about Health Sciences North, which is the name of the hospital in Sudbury. It’s a hospital that we call the heartbeat of regional health care. It serves more than 569,000 people over 300,000 square kilometres. It is a lifeline for 23 small health care facilities in our region that all refer to Health Sciences North for secondary and tertiary care. They have a lot of learners—2,900 learners every year. They were named the best cancer treatment centre out of the 14 cancer treatment centres in Ontario. Interjection.

Official source

2:05 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

Yes, for sure, for sure. Many in northern and rural Ontario have unique health care challenges. People in northern Ontario have poorer health outcomes. The rate of addiction and related death is way higher than anywhere else in our province. We have a lot of underserved children and youth population. Did you know, Speaker, that on an average day, the hospital will have 130 patients in what they call “unconventional bed space”? When you go to Health Sciences North, there isn’t a corner that hasn’t got a bed and somebody admitted into it. Think about it: You are sick enough to be admitted in a hospital, and 130 of those people sick enough to be in the hospital will be in a hallway, in a TV hall. Some of them are even downstairs, very close to the morgue. It just grosses me out. The hospital needs expansion. We had four hospitals in Sudbury. You remember Mike Harris—the health restructuring? We went down to one. It was too small. They have been waiting for money for expansions for decades. Apparently, it takes 15 years to build a mine. It takes over 20 years to build an addition to an existing hospital. Health Sciences North cannot wait any longer. Let’s make sure that we get the number of beds that are needed to care for the people of the north. That means funding Health Sciences North.

Official source

2:06 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

Further debate? I recognize the member from Beaches–East York.

Official source

2:07 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Mary-Margaret McMahon

Beautiful Beaches–East York, yes. I’m happy to be here to represent my glorious riding. Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you to my colleagues for bringing forth this opposition day motion. Today, I’ll be taking my time to showcase magnificent Michael Garron Hospital in beautiful Beaches–East York. For over 90 years, Michael Garron Hospital has delivered quality and crucial care to more than 400,000 people from over 20 distinct neighbourhoods. From a hard-working and determined emergency department; to specialized cardiology and neurology services; to youth mental health treatment; to innovative research projects focused on improving health care and access for community members; to its exemplary response to COVID-19, which ended up being a role model for community outreach city-wide, and, actually, right across the province, Michael Garron Hospital is a staple institution in our tapestry of communities. Michael Garron Hospital is responsible for one of the fastest-growing emergency departments in the greater Toronto region, constituting the second-highest growth rate among hospitals in the region. Despite being designed to see only 60,000 people per year, its emergency department volume has exceeded 100,000 patients annually. Consequently, Michael Garron’s emergency department operates in surge capacity for nearly three quarters of the year—can you imagine—ensuring almost double the amount of planned patients are provided with excellent care for nearly nine months. Think about the nurses and health care workers who are already underpaid, overworked and neglected having to work in unsafe conditions every day because they are answering their community’s calls for help. And this figure is slated to only get worse, with major residential densification projects estimating a more-than-135,000 influx of residents to east Toronto over the course of the next five years. This government has not listened to the calls for investing in Michael Garron Hospital—the calls from constituents, community organizations and politicians alike, including yours truly. I have asked about this support in both verbal and written questions in this chamber and have only received weak—weaker than weak—responses from the Minister of Health. The first phase of Michael Garron’s redevelopment, the new Thomson Centre, opened in 2023. It is glorious, but in-patient capacity did not increase. Michael Garron Hospital requires approval of phase 2 of its hospital campus redevelopment. This project encompasses the replacement of critical acute-care services, including operating rooms, adult and newborn critical care units, birthing units, cardiac in-patient units, and the emergency department. They are once again being innovative by operating the hospital while growing and redeveloping its footprint all on its current location, but they are in desperate need of sign-off by this government, as phase 2 will take years and years to build, and we have no time to wait. I’m happy to support this opposition day motion. I’d love for Michael Garron to be added to the list.

Official source

2:10 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Jeff Burch

In my riding, the Welland Hospital is in urgent need of modernization, and a rebuild is part of the current hospital plan, but to even begin this process, Niagara Health requires a planning grant. Despite repeated requests for this pre-capital grant, final approval has not been given, and this has created anxiety in our community about the future of the Welland Hospital—a hospital my predecessor Cindy Forster had to fight to keep open at all under a previous Liberal government. This motion is an opportunity to get this project moving forward. From 2020 to 2024, Welland’s population grew from 57,000 to 64,000, and the hospital’s full catchment area is growing just as quickly as the population ages. Given the growth and Niagara’s aging population—one of the highest concentrations of seniors in the entire country—it’s imperative that we rebuild a full-service hospital in Welland and prevent the closure of the urgent care centre in Port Colborne. Residents in south Niagara deserve equitable access to health care and hospital care, including emergency services. Using the name “South Niagara” to describe a hospital in Niagara Falls does nothing for the people of south Niagara who want health care services close to home. Speaker, we all know that investing in hospital infrastructure at this uncertain time will mean good-paying jobs in the skilled trades for carpenters, electricians and many others, as well as economic spinoff effects for communities like Niagara all across Ontario. We need a new, modern, full-service hospital in the city of Welland. I urge the government to get on board with this important motion so that my constituents can have confidence in the future of health care in Niagara and across Ontario.

Official source

2:13 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

I recognize the member from Kingston and the Islands.

Official source

2:13 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Ted Hsu

Hospital infrastructure is vital infrastructure. I’m disappointed that there’s a long list of hospitals in this opposition day motion from the NDP but that Kingston is not mentioned in the motion. Kingston General Hospital—the main building—is 190 years old. The Kingston Health Sciences Centre has been planning what they call the “phase 2 redevelopment” since 2015. The first plan, which involved building a new tower, was stopped by Infrastructure Ontario in December 2023. They’re working on a different plan now for vital renovations and modernizations. Kingston Health Sciences Centre is a tertiary care academic health sciences centre. It’s critical hospital infrastructure for southeastern Ontario. So I’m disappointed that it’s not part of this long list on the NDP opposition day motion.

Official source

2:14 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Sol Mamakwa

Meegwetch, Speaker. When we talk about hospital infrastructure, I think one of the things that we need to understand and talk about is the social determinants of health. In Kiiwetinoong, the current approach to hospital infrastructure perpetuates a sickness system in the north. It only reacts to the health of the people living in the north when we are sick, instead of preventing health care crises in the first place. I know that in Kiiwetinoong, First Nations communities are directly impacted by the social determinants of health, including Indigenous determinants of health—to name a few, it would be colonialism, racism, poor housing conditions, experiencing disability, gender-based violence, and the lack of clean drinking water. There are so many examples that we can share, in the north—Sioux Lookout Meno Ya Win Health Centre long-term-care facility, Wiigwas elder centre in Kenora. Those are some of the issues that we face. Again, if the government wants to move from a sickness system to a health care system for all of Ontario, they must start investing in health care infrastructure with the social determinants of health in mind. Meegwetch.

Official source

2:16 p.m.Official Hansard

M. Stephen Blais

Cette motion semble énumérer tous les hôpitaux que le NPD veut améliorer et/ou agrandir. Il est certain que l’infrastructure hospitalière est importante pour bâtir une nation, pour bâtir un Canada plus fort. Malheureusement, mais peut-être pas très choquant, le NPD, comme le gouvernement, ignore les besoins de l’est de l’Ontario et ceux de la communauté franco-ontarienne. Nos communautés franco-ontariennes ont également besoin des infrastructures médicales. Comme plusieurs communautés en Ontario, elles sont mal desservies, avec de longs délais d’attente dans les salles d’urgence. Comment le NPD peut-il parler d’infrastructure ou de construction nationale tout en excluant les soins de santé et l’infrastructure pour nos communautés franco-ontariennes? Comment? Aucune mention de la communauté franco-ontarienne dans votre motion. Renouveler la fierté des Canadiens et la valeur de notre système de santé universel d’un océan à l’autre contribuerait grandement à bâtir un Canada plus fort, mais cela ne peut pas être réalisé si le NPD ou même le gouvernement oublient nos communautés franco-ontariennes. Reconnaître la valeur et l’importance de nos communautés franco-ontariennes est essentiel pour bâtir la fierté nationale et un Canada plus fort. Madam Speaker, how can the NDP expect to build nation-building health care from one part of Ontario to the next—from one part of Canada to the next—if they ignore Franco-Ontario communities in eastern Ontario. These communities are under-serviced by health care services at the moment. They see enormous delays in emergency rooms. It seems to me that the NDP have gone out of their way to ignore mentioning Franco-Ontarian communities in eastern Ontario.

Official source

2:20 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

The member for Ottawa West–Nepean.

Official source

2:20 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Chandra Pasma

The Queensway Carleton Hospital is a jewel of Ottawa West–Nepean, and I know the residents are incredibly proud of the high-quality health care that we receive, the excellent doctors, nurses and health care workers that work there every day, but the hospital is just not the right size for the population that it serves. I regularly hear heart-wrenching stories about the kinds of waits that people endure, particularly in the emergency department. I spoke with one person whose mother had a pulmonary embolism, and they waited 13 hours in the Queensway Carleton. A pulmonary embolism is not only very dangerous, it’s very painful. Imagine sitting there in that kind of pain, knowing that you are waiting because there are other people who have more urgent problems than a pulmonary embolism. It’s incredible that this is happening, Speaker. I also spoke to someone who thought they were having a heart attack—10 hours before they were seen by a doctor. This shouldn’t be happening in Ontario. The Queensway Carleton has a plan to double the size of the hospital, double the size of the emergency room. They’re ready to put shovels in the ground now if the government would just commit the funding. The people in Ottawa do not need a $100-billion fantasy tunnel under the city of Toronto; they need timely access to health care in their own community. I urge government members to vote for this motion to support the rights of people in Ottawa to access timely health care, and I especially encourage the members from Carleton and Renfrew–Nipissing–Pembroke, whose constituents use this hospital all the time, to support this motion.

Official source

2:21 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

I recognize the member from Mushkegowuk–James Bay.

Official source

2:21 p.m.Official Hansard

M. Guy Bourgouin

C’est drôle quand j’entendais le député d’Ottawa qui essayait de nous faire la morale sur les services en français quand ils ont été plus de 15 ans au pouvoir, et ça fait combien d’années, là, qu’ils sont— Interjection.

Official source

2:21 p.m.Official Hansard

M. Guy Bourgouin

Deux gouvernements consécutifs qu’ils n’ont même pas été un parti reconnu, puis là, maintenant qu’ils sont reconnus, ils se pètent les bretelles. On n’a pas de leçon à apprendre de vous, messieurs les libéraux. Mais, ceci dit, ça me donne la chance de parler de notre système d’obstétrique dans le Nord, parce que notre motion en parle et on veut défendre les droits. Mais il y a une réalité que le gouvernement doit voir quand on parle d’obstétrique dans le Nord. En 2023 à Hearst, le département d’obstétrique est fermé. Ça veut dire que les femmes qui vont avoir des bébés, qui attendent des bébés doivent aller soit à Thunder Bay, soit à Sudbury ou à Ottawa—ou où est-ce qu’il y a de la famille. Elles sont obligées de se déplacer à 37 semaines. Moi, à Noël, je viens d’apprendre que ma fille va avoir un bébé, notre premier petit-bébé. Je vais être grand-père pour la première fois. Mais, je suis chanceux; même à travers ça, je suis chanceux. Parce que moi, ma fille, vu qu’elle reste à Val Côté, qui est à peut-être 20 minutes de Hearst, elle peut venir à Kap. À Kap, il y a un système d’obstétrique, mais notre système d’obstétrique est financé pas tout à fait comme il devrait l’être, ce qui le met souvent en danger. Fait que, je pense que c’est important. On doit faire beaucoup mieux. On doit financer nos systèmes d’obstétrique, nos hôpitaux, dans le Nord pour ne pas mettre la vie des enfants en danger—surtout avec nos routes, comme on connaît, dans le Nord.

Official source

2:22 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

I recognize the member from Don Valley East.

Official source

2:22 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Adil Shamji

I’m pleased to rise in this chamber to address the opposition day motion before us which, very briefly, seeks to urge the government to designate hospital infrastructure projects as nation-building projects and therefore fast-track us for federal funding. I must admit that this motion and this call for action couldn’t come at a more important time: at a time when our health care system under this government faces its worst performance in Ontario history. We’re seeing ER closures that now number in the thousands. We’re seeing code zeros, a phenomenon during which patients call 911 but there is no ambulance available to meet them. Ambulance off-load times—the amount of time it takes for the transfer of care from a paramedic crew to an emergency department—are higher than it has ever been before. Alternate-level-of-care rates in our hospitals—higher than it has ever been before. We have more people who are paying for health care than ever before. We’ve just learned that recently $62 million has been spent for MedsCheck through Shoppers Drug Mart—considered to be an abuse of our public health care system. We’re seeing $9 billion spent on temporary, for-profit nursing agencies. We’re seeing home care falling apart. We’re seeing hallway health care at absolutely astronomical levels. I was just working in the emergency department in my hospital yesterday, and believe it or not, our medical short-stay unit is now in a public lobby. That wasn’t the case in 2018—nothing even close to that, seven years ago. But under this government, all we have seen is our health care system deteriorate. And so, in the wake of all of these failures under the current government, of course I would support a motion such as this one—one that seeks to increase funding associated with our health care system and specifically with our hospitals. But I will argue that this is actually a bit of a wasted opportunity and that there are certain premises in this motion that I find difficult to agree with, the first of which is that we are in this situation because of a past Liberal government. I would point out that, under the previous government, we built hospitals, redeveloped hospitals, invented the first nurse practitioner-led clinics, the first family health teams, had the lowest ER wait times in the province’s history—and then this government came along. So I have difficulty accepting that premise of this motion. I will also say that this motion misses important opportunities to fight for the right thing in our health care system. Now, what I’m going to say, I say in the spirit of trying to improve our health care system and make this motion as strong as we actually can make it: One of the biases that I find this motion perpetuates is this preoccupation that our health care system equates to our hospitals and our acute care. That is the most expensive form of health care—the kind of health care that people resort to when they have no choice because they are already experiencing severe illness. A proper health care system is founded upon primary care, home care, long-term care, community care, none of which are mentioned here. A proper health care system doesn’t just preoccupy itself with bricks and mortar, unless it is a health care plan that is put together by this government. This government consistently focuses on concrete and beds without focusing on the workers and the staff that are necessary in order to make those hospitals and beds actually work for the people of Ontario. And so, I worry that the foundation of our health care system, the most important part of our health care system, is left completely unaddressed. And finally, I will reiterate what my colleague just mentioned, which is, while no one can disagree with the fact that our hospitals do need more funding, I worry that I see no mention of our francophone hospitals and the elements of our health care system that serve our francophone community. One additional point that I will make is that, while you could make the argument—and it’s hard to find it offensive—that hospitals should be a nation-building priority of this government, I will point out that Prime Minister Carney has already designated at least $4 billion for the construction of hospitals. This is an opportunity not just to call for funding for hospitals, which is already being promised, but to fight for the other things that we desperately need in our health care system here in Ontario: to fight for funding for primary care, home care, community care, long-term care, and support for our health care workers—none of which, regrettably, is mentioned in this legislation. That being said, I will return to a point that I made at the beginning of my remarks, which is that, of course, hospitals could use more funding. I’ll point to one of the big hospitals that serves my riding in Don Valley East and that would be Michael Garron Hospital. I have heard, repeatedly, during question period, the Minister of Infrastructure comment on the funding that this government purports to have provided to this hospital serving my community. And yet what she chooses to ignore and to gloss over is every request for phase 2 funding for Project Imagine—which would actually be a project that increases the number of beds, because any projects up to now have not resulted in any net new beds. Our funding requests to actually create net new beds through the phase 2 Project Imagine proposal have been rejected by this government. It’s hard for me, though I will, to support this motion without pointing out the fact that one of the fastest-growing ridings in the province does not have its major hospital mentioned in it, and I would call for that if we ever had an opportunity for amendments. I’ve seen first-hand the challenges that our hospitals face. Michael Garron Hospital, I mentioned already: The medical short-stay unit is now in a public lobby; the emergency department, built for 60,000 people, now serves over 100,000 people. I’ve worked at Weeneebayko General Hospital in Mushkegowuk–James Bay, an old, old hospital in desperate need of replacement urgently—and not just in desperate need of funding for replacing that hospital, but for the training of its health care workers, for the hiring of its health care workers and for the support of all of the nursing stations that feed patients into the central location. Of course, I support the reopening of the Minden emergency department. I have been there at least on three separate occasions. I understand how the people of the Minden community and surrounding area are being robbed of the vital—what we call the golden hour in emergency medicine and critical care; the golden hour during which the right intervention and the right treatment with the right people in the right place can mean the difference between life and death. For those people who reside in and around Minden who will no longer be able to access emergency and specifically critical care within that golden hour, those all-important 60 minutes, I cannot speak to the importance of them having their emergency department restored—not just restored, but restored to 24-hour, seven-days-a-week service, not just bankers’ hours. Just last week during question period, we heard my amazing colleague from Nepean speak to the challenges that are being faced at Queensway Carleton. He’s a nurse. He’s there propping up the health care system and that hospital against the odds. We had the Minister of Health have the audacity to attack a health care worker and say that he was denigrating his own hospital that he works at. We need a culture of respect, of listening to experts and not just of building hospitals, but supporting our health care workers, like the one behind me who is trying to fight for his community and was talked down to by the Minister of Health. In closing, Madam Speaker, the current situation in Ontario is untenable. The government’s mismanagement of health care in Ontario is untenable. More funds are required, more hospitals and infrastructure are required, but more support for health care workers is required. The preoccupation with health care worker recruitment has to be balanced with an equal preoccupation with health care worker retention. Only if we can address all of these things, which are not fully captured in this motion—only if we can capture all of these things can we build and strive towards the health care system that all Ontarians deserve. I will support this motion, though I point out that there are many missed opportunities to make it as strong as our province deserves.

Official source

2:30 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

The member for Scarborough Southwest.

Official source

2:30 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Doly Begum

We know too well the pain of visiting an ER room, waiting for hours and hours, or worse, taking a loved one who’s in excruciating pain and waiting for hours. I visited hospitals with portable clinics in the driveway of the hospital, and we heard about Michael Garron Hospital. We have also seen staff use storage rooms just so they can make space for beds in hospitals as well. We also know the shortage of staff in hospitals where ER rooms had to be closed down during the crisis. Imagine shutting the doors to a patient—hours of wait, months and months or years waiting for surgeries or appointments, all of which are costing this province money, but also costing lives, Speaker. Meanwhile, Ontario actually spends the lowest per capita funding when it comes to our health care. And this is a legacy that the Conservative government actually carried on from the Liberals. In 2015, 2016 and 2017, we saw some of the lowest per capita funding to health care in the province—in this country, actually—that this province had. And so it’s the years and years of neglect to our health care system that has cost us where we are right now, the health care crisis that we’re facing: the aging buildings, the shortage in staff— Interjections.

Official source

2:32 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Doly Begum

I know the truth hurts—the truth hurts for both sides. Speaker, this morning the CCPA revealed that over $9 billion of taxpayers’ funding were actually going to private nursing agencies, private agencies for profit—not to the nurses; to the agencies, Speaker. That’s what’s happening right now. That’s not nation building, especially at a time when we’re facing an economic crisis, when we should be strengthening our province. Today we have a solution. We have a solution to build this province, build this country. That’s the nation-building plan: to make sure that we are building hospitals, that we’re providing the support they need and making sure that we actually have the people in those hospitals as well. That’s our plan, Speaker—and we’re creating jobs.

Official source

2:33 p.m.Official Hansard

Mrs. Jennifer (Jennie) Stevens

I rise today on behalf of the residents of St. Catharines to address the urgent issue of hospital infrastructure and the state of our health care system. The Marotta Family Hospital in St. Catharines is at a breaking point. Residents are waiting up to 18 hours in the ER department. When this hospital was built, residents were promised a mental health wing, staffed and open 24/7. The reality is we lack the staffing infrastructure to open this wing. People in crisis are being directed to the emergency room instead of having dedicated support in place. Hospital infrastructure is not a luxury; it’s a lifeline. In St. Catharines, we are seeing first-hand the consequences of years of neglect, of funding shortfalls: overcrowded emergency rooms, aging buildings and staff stretched to the max. Yet infrastructure proposals that would provide relief and modernization have been stalled or shelved under successive Liberal and Conservative governments. Investing in hospitals means investing in people, Speaker. It creates space to retain and recruit desperately needed health care workers, from nurses and PSWs to specialists, who form the backbone of our public system and make it easier for residents to get the care they need. We are in a health care crisis. If we want to build a stronger, more resilient system, our hospitals must be a top priority, not next year, not this year, now—right now. From hospital parking fees to MRI wait-lists, Ontarians are being forced to pay the price. That’s why I’m calling on this government to designate critical hospital infrastructure as a priority in the 2025 budget. Show our front-line workers in Ontario that their health and safety come first, that our aging population in St. Catharines and across Niagara can access the quality care they’ve paid into for decades. People deserve a government that puts health care first, not one that pushes off their responsibility while patting themselves on the back for other infrastructure priorities. You have an opportunity to get this right and support this critical, common-sense motion.

Official source

2:37 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Catherine McKenney

I’d like to just point out that the redevelopment of the Ottawa Hospital’s Civic Campus was meant to be a transformative project, a long overdue investment to replace an aging facility and improve health care for residents from across the region. However, this project has become a textbook example of mismanagement, misguided priorities and the downsides, again, of privatization. The decision to use a P3 model has already led to significant delays and escalating costs. Originally projected to cost $2.8 billion with construction set to begin in 2024, the project is now delayed until at least the end of 2025, with costs now under review. This P3 model has failed to deliver on its promises. Instead of investing in the hospital itself, the government has pushed the costs of infrastructure onto local municipalities, asking the city of Ottawa to contribute $150 million of the $700-million local share, while the rest is expected to come from fundraising. But as construction costs rise and projects like a parking garage swallow more of the budget, we have to ask, where is the money for patient care? Every dollar spent on P3 delays is a dollar not being used for front-line staff, specialized equipment, expanded emergency services, and the 641 single-patient rooms this hospital was supposed to deliver. Ontarians deserve a government that listens to people, invests in public services, and makes decisions that benefit everyone, not just the bottom line.

Official source

2:40 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

I recognize the member for Sudbury.

Official source

2:40 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Jamie West

I want to start by thanking the nurses. It is Nursing Week, after all. Interjections.

Official source

2:40 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Jamie West

Absolutely. As we know, nurses have been short-staffed—affected by Bill 124. They’re subject to workplace violence. And a lot of that would be alleviated with funding. Getting to the motion, though, on infrastructure and extending infrastructure in hospitals: Health Sciences North in Sudbury was amalgamated by the Harris government and was built too small. So now we have dozens of off-site places for a one-site hospital which is broken. The investment into this organization would mean that we would put good tradespeople to work, we’d drive the economy, and we’d have a hospital large enough to accommodate people. Sadly, I was elected in 2018 because the Liberal government had created Health Sciences North as the foundation, and the boilerplate of hallway medicine is now spread across the province. The Conservatives have failed to address this, but they could if they would invest in our hospitals, our nurses and our health care.

Official source

2:40 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Catherine Fife

I just came from the Empire Club, where the finance minister was talking about how we need bold projects, nation-building projects, to stabilize the economy as we move through this, really, economic uncertainty as a province and also as a nation. We think, though, on this side of the House, that being bold means having safe hospitals, having accessible hospitals, having well-resourced and well-staffed hospitals. In our mind, that is a very bold plan. The list of hospitals that are contained within the motion would also stimulate those local economies for the skilled trades. You can’t outsource those jobs when you’re building to protect Ontario. Finally on this point is that when investors, when capital is looking to go someplace and move into another jurisdiction, they are looking for that social infrastructure, they are looking for the strong schools. But health care is the number one issue that attracts people into the province of Ontario, and they are not impressed with what they’re seeing. I just had surgery last Monday. I got great care in the hospital, but the hospital itself, the infrastructure, is failing people, and the people who work within that system feel it too. So let’s support those good people who are doing strong health care practices across our communities. Let’s support the innovation in those communities by investing strategically, by ensuring that every community has access to health care and that we as legislators are supporting those good people. This is smart investment. It is, in fact, very bold. I encourage everybody to support this.

Official source

2:41 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Anthony Leardi

We in the government benches have grown so accustomed to the NDP being opposed to building things in Ontario that it was a breath of fresh air when I read this motion—that the NDP finally decided to build one thing in Ontario, because they’re so against building everything else. They’re against building highways. That’s why they’re against building Highway 413. They’re against building tunnels. That’s why they don’t want a tunnel under the 401. They’re against building mines. That’s why they voted against the Building More Mines Act. They’re against building signature provincial recreation projects. That’s why they don’t want to redevelop Ontario Place. They’re against building roads. That’s why they love bike lanes. And they’re against building homes—because they want the government to put everybody else out of business and have the government build homes. But finally, the NDP have decided that they’re in favour of building one thing: They’re in favour of building hospitals, and that’s a breath of fresh air, I think. I think we can all agree with that. Of course, they probably don’t want to move too fast on building those hospitals. First, they will want to do 15 years of environmental studies and then another 15 years of consultation. And then, 30 years from now, they might eventually get around to maybe tendering one of those hospitals. You can’t expect the NDP to move too fast. Well, we’ve got the jump on them, because while they were deciding whether or not they wanted to actually build anything in Ontario, we have 17 major capital hospital projects already under construction in the province of Ontario, while the NDP were asleep at the switch. Here are some of those capital projects: —in Brantford, the emergency department expansion project for Brant Community Healthcare System; —in Cambridge, the main capital redevelopment project at Cambridge Memorial Hospital; —in Toronto, the redevelopment of the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health; —in Grimsby, under construction, the West Lincoln Memorial Hospital redevelopment project, through the Hamilton Health Sciences Corp.; —in Toronto, phase 1 of a new patient care tower for the Michael Garron Hospital; —in Niagara Falls, the new South Niagara hospital capital project, through the Niagara Health system; —in Picton, the Prince Edward County Memorial Hospital redevelopment for Quinte Health; —at the Scarborough Centenary site, a new dialysis unit for the Scarborough Health Network; —also in Scarborough, a diagnostic imaging fit-up for the diagnostic imaging/concourse at the Scarborough Health Network; —also in Scarborough, at the General site, a hemodialysis isolation unit, through the Scarborough Health Network; —in Toronto, an off-site and on-site dialysis centre, through Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre; —also in Toronto, provincial mental health and addictions capacity brain sciences centre project, through Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre; —in Thunder Bay, the cardiovascular surgery program, through the Thunder Bay Regional Health Sciences Centre; —in Toronto, a patient care tower, through Unity Health Toronto, St. Michael’s Hospital; —also in Toronto, stem cell transplant phase 2 expansion head start project, through the University Health Network; —also in Toronto, the new Toronto Western Hospital tower, through University Health Network; —and in Moose Factory/Moosonee, a new replacement hospital at the Weeneebayko Area Health Authority. Speaker, 17 capital projects currently under way—and those are just the ones that are under way. I haven’t included any of the ones that are in the planning stage or in the tendering stage or in the land acquisition stage. Those are just the ones that are currently under construction. I could go on and list a whole lot of other projects that are in the planning stage and in the tendering stage, but the list would be so long that I think a lot of members of the Liberal Party would reach retirement age before I got to the end of the list. Remember, it was the Liberal government that promised to build a new hospital in the greater Essex region. It was the Liberal government that promised to do that, and then they reneged on that promise. It was the current Premier who picked up that promise, and now that project is in phase 3. We’ve already gone through the first phase. There was the land acquisition phase—we acquired the land. Then there was the second phase, which was the design phase. That’s done. Now we’re in phase 3, the tendering of the project for the new regional hospital in the greater Essex region—a project that was promised by the Liberals. They reneged, and this government had to fulfill that promise. So this motion, by the way, is far too late. If you want to hear more about that project that I just talked about, in the greater Essex region, you should buy the member from Windsor–Tecumseh a coffee because he has a lot more to tell you. He could tell you, for example, how there were certain activists—locally known NDP and Liberal activists—who actively campaigned to block that hospital. He will tell you all the details. He’s intimately informed about that, and he’d be happy to tell you all about it for the price of a coffee. This motion—although it’s a pleasant motion to build something in Ontario—comes far too late. The NDP should have brought this motion 15 years ago, to get the Liberal government of the day moving to build something, because if they had built something in Ontario, then we wouldn’t have so many capital projects that have fallen so far behind in the province of Ontario, that the present Premier now has to make up ground for. Also, the NDP should have brought this far earlier than now because we already have 50 capital projects under way in the province of Ontario, many of which are already under construction. But it’s nice to see that the NDP have finally decided that there is just one thing they want to build in the province of Ontario.

Official source

2:46 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

Further debate? Further debate? The leader of His Majesty’s loyal opposition.

Official source

2:46 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Marit Stiles

I was listening very carefully to some of the comments made by others, and it sounded to me like we might have the support of all parties here. I certainly hope so, as so many of you spoke in such glowing terms about the motion and everything that we could be doing together here. At the end of the day, this motion is about delivering health care and a health care system that people were promised—making sure that it’s actually funded in the 2025 budget. I know that’s what we’re all looking for. It’s about getting shovels in the ground, creating good union jobs, and giving families all across this beautiful province the peace of mind that care will be there when and where they need it. Those are not far-off dreams. These are shovel-ready projects, some of them. Some of them have been long planned, long promised and, of course, in many cases, long overdue. People in Brampton shouldn’t have to be kept waiting. Families in Welland, in Windsor and in the north have been more than patient—and as you see, Speaker, we’ve included a lot of projects in the language of the motion. But, yes, hey, let’s build more. Let’s get it done. But they need a government that works and a government that delivers. This is a test of priorities. If the Premier wants to invest in nation-building infrastructure, as he says he does, he should start here—build hospitals, expand urgent care, reopen our emergency rooms. If this government is serious about strengthening Ontario, then these projects must be funded in this year’s budget. And that’s what we’re going to be looking for. Whether this government decides to support this motion—and I can’t see why they wouldn’t, but if they decide not to, then we want to see it in the budget. Let’s wait and see what they’re going to do in the budget. Let’s go. Let’s stop delaying. Let’s stop pretending that these are not urgent issues and urgent projects. Let’s build care. Let’s strengthen Ontario. Let’s get the job finally done.

Official source

2:47 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

Ms. Stiles has moved opposition day motion number 3. Is it the pleasure of the House that the motion carry? All those in favour of the motion will please say “aye.” All those opposed to the motion will please say “nay.” In my opinion, the nays have it. Call in the members. There will be a 10-minute bell.

Official source

2:48 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

Ms. Stiles moved opposition day motion number 3. All those in favour of the motion will please rise one at a time and be recognized by the Clerk.

Official source

2:48 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

All those opposed to the motion will please rise one at a time and be recognized by the Clerk.

Official source

Orders of the Day

More Convenient Care Act, 2025 / Loi de 2025 pour plus de soins commodesBill 11

2:48 p.m.Official Hansard

Resuming the debate adjourned on May 8, 2025, on the motion for second reading of the following bill:

Official source

2:48 p.m.Official Hansard

Bill 11, An Act to enact or amend various Acts related to health care / Projet de loi 11, Loi visant à édicter ou à modifier diverses lois en ce qui concerne les soins de santé.

Official source

2:48 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

I’m happy to have an opportunity to talk about what is now called Bill 11—that was Bill 231 before Christmas, but we’ve had an election; all of the bills got put aside, and they’re coming back one by one—An Act to enact or amend various Acts related to health care. Let me start by saying, we have more and more people coming to Queen’s Park—RNAO, the registered nurses’ association, was in the media studio this morning with a call to action as to, our health care system is in crisis. It’s in crisis like we have never seen before. Things have to change. They came to Queen’s Park. There were over a dozen—I don’t know, 20 of them—who came to Queen’s Park to really send a strong message. They have a new call to action for nurses—this is also the start of National Nursing Week. That started today. And their highly anticipated, evidence-based recommendations to transform the health care system for the benefit of all Ontarians—their new ECCO report, number 4, Enhancing Community Care for Ontarians. They released one in 2012, one in 2014, one in 2020. And now they’ve just released a new one centred on strengthening community care, which is pretty much in line with what this bill intends to do, but I would tell you that they come from a very different direction. OCHU, the Ontario Council of Hospital Unions, was also in the media studio this morning, pressing the government to take the crisis in our health care system seriously. What we are facing we have never faced before, but there are solutions out there, from communities, from volunteer organizations, from health care professionals, that the government needs to listen to. If you are expecting those solutions in Bill 11, one of the first health care bills to be tabled in this new Parliament, I want to tell you right now, Speaker, you would be sadly disappointed. This bill is not going to fix the crisis in our health care system. This bill is not going to tackle some of the, I would say, areas of health care where everybody agrees things need to change, everybody agrees as to how it should change, but yet, nothing is done and nothing is moving forward. The bill itself has six schedules. Some of them, I would say, are more important than others, but none of them are directed at solving the problem. I would like to thank Dr. Claudette Holloway, who is the past president of the Registered Nurses’ Association of Ontario, RNAO, as well as NP Lhamo Dolkar, who is the present president of RNAO, as well as their CEO, Dr. Doris Grinspun—Doris has been there, I think, for over 30 years—for their comments this morning. Nurses are asking to be heard. Nurses are asking to be taken seriously. They are on the front line. They know how many patients are being failed by the crisis in our health care system right now, and they would love nothing more than for the government to listen to nurses and see how to improve. I can tell you that they’re not advocating for nurses in their paper; they’re advocating for a strong and robust, publicly funded and publicly delivered health care system. Although they thank the government for many steps that they have taken, they draw a line in the sand when it comes to privately delivered, for-profit health care. RNAO doesn’t want anything to do with this; neither do most Ontarians—if they had a chance to be heard. We will start with schedule 1. Schedule 1 is called the City of Hamilton Act, 1999. “Section 11 of the City of Hamilton Act, 1999 is re-enacted to establish a board of health for the city. Currently the city itself has the powers, rights and duties of a board of health under the Health Protection and Promotion Act.” For reasons that I don’t really remember, about 30 years ago, things changed for public health in the city of Hamilton. We have 34 public health units. They cover all of our province. They basically all run the same way, except for Hamilton, and that comes from many decades ago—something that I don’t fully understand had happened. What will happen now is that the board of health in the city of Hamilton will be basically dealt with the same way that Toronto or Ottawa or any other exist. The city of Hamilton is ready to change to basically go in line with the type of governance that all 34 boards of health have in Ontario. They will have important responsibility. They will have a board of governance. Now the board of governance of Hamilton will be similar to the board of governance of the other 33 health units. The board will have responsibility for things like dental care. They have public health employees who go into the different schools to do screenings of children, to identify kids who would benefit from accessing dental services. We do have a program in Ontario to help pay for dental services for kids under 18 years of age—to gain access to a dentist through public health. They have public health inspectors who are also part of public health. They do inspections to make sure the water that we drink is safe to drink, the food that we eat in a restaurant is in compliance with the health regulations, and to prevent hazards, so we don’t get sick from the food that we eat etc. They also promote hygiene and safety and handle emergency preparedness. The board of health will also be responsible for Smoke-Free Ontario. Smoke-Free Ontario requires inspectors from Smoke-free Ontario, from the board of health, to go into pretty well everywhere we sell tobacco and cigarettes, to make sure that they don’t sell to minors and to make sure that they respect all the laws we have in place regarding advertising, regarding who can sell tobacco products and to who you can sell it. There are also many public health nurses. Most people now know about public health nurses because they were the people who were giving out the COVID immunizations, but they also do school immunizations. They continue to be very busy—although nobody wants to talk about COVID anymore, and I’m one of those. The pandemic is behind us, and please don’t bring it back. There are still many cases of COVID going. There are still many cases of measles—we are over 1,440, I think, cases right now that have been diagnosed in Ontario. We all know that all this is preventable. We have the MMR vaccine that has been available, free of charge, to Ontarians. During COVID, when schools were closed and public health could not gain access to the children in school, many children fell behind, either because they got their first dose but then the school was closed and they never got their second dose; or they were due for their first dose, but the school was closed—you get the idea, Speaker. So public health has a lot of catching up to do. Unfortunately, they have not received the resources to do that catching up. The budget for public health only increased by 1% for the next three years, at a time when Ontario and Canada are about to lose—we had eradicated measles in Ontario. I remember, in the 1990s, everybody was so proud that we achieved close to a 93% to 95% vaccination rate. Measles was eradicated in Ontario. We were able to protect vulnerable populations, whether it be the Mennonites or children or people who have low immune systems, because of the herd immunity that we had built in Ontario. All of this is at risk. We know how to fix this: Give public health the resources they need to do advertising, to do education, to reach out, to do vaccination clinics etc. They need resources to do that, and the government is not giving them their resources. Public health also deals with Healthy Babies Healthy Children. Anybody who’s had a child, and there’s a few of them in this house that have brand new babies, you think you know it all till you bring your baby home and realize that there’s a lot of questions you didn’t think about asking. Well, you can ask all of those to Healthy Babies Healthy Children at public health. They help every new parent with any kind of question that you have and they’re very helpful. I would say you could always call your grandmother—I’m a grandmother—but it’s also good to call Healthy Babies Healthy Children, and they do follow up. Public health also has epidemiologists who investigate outbreaks of diseases, identify the risk factors, inform the public on health interventions, look at patterns, cause and effect etc. Public health also has health educators and health promoters who develop programs and materials to teach communities about health topics and promote healthy behaviours. Health promotion and disease prevention go a long, long way towards keeping people healthy. Let’s face it, Speaker: We all want to be healthy. Nobody will say, “Oh, I can’t wait to be sick.” No. We all want to be healthy, and we want to stay healthy. One of the best ways to do this is for government to invest in health promotion. And if you are sick, your diabetes or asthma—disease prevention. How do you make sure that you can control your chronic diseases so that it doesn’t get worse? I don’t think I have heard anyone on the government side talk about health promotion and talk about disease prevention. We talk about primary care, we talk about hospital care and we talk about long-term care and home care, but health promotion and disease prevention are an integral part of our health care system. Lots of it is offered through public health. This is what we have in schedule 1 of the bill, with the City of Hamilton Act. I wanted to give a little bit of background as to what public health does, because now, through schedule 1, the city of Hamilton will have a board of health very similar to the other 33. It is a step in the right direction. This is something that the city of Hamilton has been ready for. They wanted to do the change, and now they will be able to do that change. So it’s a step in the right direction—no problem with schedule 1. Schedule 2, Connecting Care Act, 2019: The schedule amends the Connecting Care Act, 2019, to provide for the application of the French Language Services Act to the service organization. You won’t be surprised that this is something I have been pushing for, for a long time, as 40% of the people that I represent are French-speaking. Many of them are elderly; many of them are receiving home care. When everybody in your house speaks French, when your grandmother is receiving home care and the home care provider coming to the house does not speak French, believe me, they will pick up the phone and they will phone their MPP because they’re not happy about that. Unfortunately, when the government did changes to—I don’t know if you remember, but they used to be called CCACs, community care access centres. They were the ones who managed home care. It used to be called home care. Then it became CCACs. Then it changed names and became the LHINs, local health integration networks. Then it changed, and it’s become community care—something else. Now it’s called Ontario Health atHome. Nothing has changed. We still have a whole bunch of for-profits, mainly Bayshore and the kind that provide the home care. But the structure at the government level has changed through many, many changes, and through those changes, they dropped the obligations to follow the French Language Services Act. When Ontario Health atHome was brought, I was the one doing the clause-by-clause. I brought forward an amendment and said, “Hey, when it was the CCACs, you had to provide services in French in home care. When it was the LHINs, you had to provide services in French in home care. When it was the home and community, you had to provide services in French in home care. Now you’re changing it to Ontario Health atHome, and it’s not covered by the French Language Services Act. It must have been just a mistake. Let’s pass this amendment to make sure that home care continues to be covered by the French Language Services Act.” Much to my surprise, they voted against it. They, as in members of the Conservative Party, voted against that amendment. I was not happy.

Official source

3:02 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

They did not explain why they would vote against such an amendment. It had been there all along. Come on, you’ve changed the name, but home care is still the same thing; it’s a PSW or a nurse who comes to your house. No. But now, they are bringing it in schedule 2. So, what I could not get through an amendment, I am now getting through schedule 2 of Bill 11. It’s good news. Je peux vous dire que pour les gens que je représente, les services en français, surtout les services à domicile en français, c’est quelque chose de très important. La grande majorité des gens qui reçoivent des soins à domicile sont des gens âgés, et dans mon comté, beaucoup des maris, les hommes, sont décédés—travailler dans les mines en 1950, 1940, 1960, ce n’était pas facile—mais la femme, la veuve, est encore là. Elle a besoin de soutien à domicile. C’est une femme de son temps qui n’est pas nécessairement allée travailler, qui est toujours restée à la maison, a élevé ses 14 enfants et a pris soin de sa famille. Maintenant, elle a besoin de soins à la maison. Elle ne parle pas l’anglais et Bayshore lui envoie une préposée qui parle seulement en anglais. Les soins à domicile sont souvent des soins très, très personnels. On parle, là, de prendre un bain. On parle d’aller à la toilette. On parle de s’habiller. On parle des soins personnels, et quand tu dois faire affaire avec une personne qui ne parle pas ta langue, ce n’est pas évident d’avoir des soins de qualité. Donc, je vous dirais que la deuxième—je ne me souviens plus comment on dit « schedule » en français; laissez-moi vérifier—annexe, c’est quelque chose qu’on appuie et c’est un pas dans la bonne direction. J’aurais aimé que ça ait été fait quand le projet de loi pour changer les soins à domicile avait été mis de l’avant. Je peux vous dire que j’avais mis une motion pour faire un amendement pour s’assurer que la Loi sur les services en français était pour être là. Ça n’a pas passé, mais là, ça passe avec « schedule 2 ». I would tell you that I’m happy with schedule 2 and I’m happy that people who want services in French will be able to have them, but I don’t want to give anybody false hope. Our home care system was privatized under the Mike Harris government. People who are as old as me will remember that he was going to make home care “better, faster, cheaper.” Well, none of that happened. The only thing that happened is that now the for-profit company that provides home care services—they have the contract to provide home care services—cannot recruit and retain a stable workforce. Why can they not recruit and retain a stable workforce? Because what people want is a permanent full-time job, well-paid, with benefits, sick days, vacation days, and maybe the dream of a pension plan. What they get when they go work for home care is you sit by the phone to hope that you get a shift. You’re not paid to go between clients, so just imagine: I’m in northern rural Ontario, 33 little communities, 600 kilometres from north to south. They will come to me and show me, “I drove 731 kilometres last week.” They get 36 cents a kilometre as reimbursement, but they don’t get paid for the time it takes to go from one client to the next. Think about it, Speaker. In the middle of the winter, in a northern rural area, how long do you figure it takes to drive 731 kilometres in northern Ontario? It takes hours and hours. What other workers would be asked to work for 10 hours a week not paid? The people who work for Bayshore, for home care. This is not acceptable. Although schedule 2 talks about bringing French services to home care, and I’m all for it, I don’t want to give anybody false hope that this will fix our home care system. Our home care system is privatized. Bayshore continues to make hundreds of millions of dollars in profit. How do they do this? By not paying their staff a fair wage, by not giving them permanent full-time, by not giving them benefits or sick days or holidays or a pension plan or anything else. So, what happens? They cannot recruit and retain a stable workforce. Quality of care is based on continuity of care. When you have a different person coming every second day to give you your bath, it doesn’t take long that you don’t want to strip naked in front of a different stranger every week and you say, “I don’t want this anymore.” Then you end up in trouble, and then you end up at the hospital, and then you end up on the ALC list because it’s not safe to send you back home, because home care doesn’t meet your needs. This is just one example. I’m happy with schedule 2, which brings the French Language Services Act under Ontario Health atHome, but there are many, many other steps that need to be done to fix our home care system. If you go into any seniors’ club and ask, “Who is looking forward to going to a long-term-care home,” I guarantee you nobody raises their hand. People want to stay at home, and this is what home care does. When you have a robust home care system, people are able to stay home safely and respectfully. It is cheaper. It is what people want. It is better for the taxpayers. It has nothing but good things. But our home care system has been privatized, and what we have is private delivery who puts profit ahead of quality care, so they cannot recruit and retain a stable workforce. When Health Sciences North—that’s the name of the hospital in Sudbury—puts an ad for one PSW, they will have 500 applicants apply for one job. If Bayshore tries to recruit, they can’t. We get a busload of people every Saturday that come from down south, through agency nursing, to come and fill up shifts. Every day, I will have either a message on the voice mail or people who call the office to say the PSW didn’t show. What often happens is that if you’re in a wheelchair, or you need help to get out of bed, get dressed, go to the bathroom, get into your chair—but once you’re there, you’re good for half the day—Bayshore will call you at about 10 o’clock and say, “Oh, I’m sorry we missed your 7:30 appointment. We will be there at 3 p.m.” Be there at 3 p.m. to get me out of bed? Nobody wants to get out of bed at 3 o’clock in the afternoon. Everybody needs to go to the bathroom, maybe. Everybody wants to live a regular life. But if you refuse what Bayshore is offering you, Bayshore gets paid for the visit, you get no visit, the PSW doesn’t get a cent, and they increase profit. I’m tired of this, Speaker. I’m tired of this. Home care should exist to support people to the best of their ability, not to make private investors rich. So that’s basically what’s in schedule 2: We will now have services in French for a broken home care system. Then, schedule 3: Schedule 3 talks about the Health Care Staffing Agency Reporting Act. Basically, the schedule enacts the Health Care Staffing Agency Reporting Act. It “requires health care facility staffing agencies to submit reports to the minister containing aggregate administrative, billing or pay rate information for health care facilities to which the agency assigns prescribed” workers. They require “health care facility staffing agencies to comply with specified record maintenance requirements.” They authorize “the Minister of Health to publish certain information contained in the reports submitted.” They “describe elements of the crown’s liability and state that no person is entitled to compensation as a result of the enactment of the act,” and there are other regulations that “prevail over any agreement to the contrary.” Basically, what schedule 3 does is it tells us that the staffing agency will have to give a report to the ministry. It could be every three months, six months, two years—it doesn’t say. The report could be made public or maybe won’t be made public. Speaker, we have a crisis in health care. The use of agency nursing has exploded. The last stats that were shared with us, which go until 2023, show that $9.2 billion—not million; $9.2 billion—was spent on agency staffing by our hospitals in Ontario. This is really hard to wrap your head around—that of this billions of dollars, a small part of that money goes to the workers, but a big part of it goes to the agency who owns those workers. One of them came to me as a whistle-blower. They basically showed that they were able—the word that he used—to poach 500 nurses from the Toronto and area health care system. They basically go at shift change and look at the nurses crying in their car. Because the nurse, after their shift, if they know that they have failed their patient, if they know that the workload was not sustainable and they are burnt-out, they finish their shift and they go to their car and they start crying. They will go talk to that nurse and say, “You don’t have to work at that hospital anymore. Come and work for us. We will give you more money. You can pick your shift. You don’t have to do afternoons anymore. You don’t have to do night shifts. You don’t have to do weekends if you don’t want to. You don’t have to do statutory holidays. Come and work for us. You can pick your shift. You will work when you want to and you will make more money.” I don’t blame nurses for accepting to go work for a staffing agency. Think about it: You are burnt-out. You know that on the unit you were on, there should have been five nurses but there were only three of you. You know that the client you were looking after, you transferred her to the bathroom and she sat there for an hour and twenty minutes because you were too busy looking after other people. She was really angry when you got back, and very angry patients tend to be very violent—can be violent; not all people are. But think about it: Now you can go work for a staffing agency. You will make more money. You will get to pick where you go, when you go, and they are going in droves. But that means that of that $9.2 billion, the max is close to $4.65 billion—anyway, half of it went to profit. This is billions of dollars that had been transferred to our hospitals to care for people that never reached the bedside. They go into investors’ pockets. We can do a lot, Speaker, with $4.65 billion. We could do a lot of good change to our health care system if we had this. But all that schedule 3 does is it talks about how we’ll have a report that will come telling us how much staff they have provided. The report may be there every three months, six months, 12 months, two years—we don’t know; it may be made public or not. Those are very, very tiny steps. They’re tiny steps in the right direction, but the end goal is a whole lot further. The Premier of Ontario is also the lead for all of the provincial Premier get-togethers. Did you know, Speaker, that all of the provincial Premiers talked about agency nursing, because it’s not only happening in Ontario, it’s happening in all of the provinces? Every single other province has put in place ways to limit the use of agency nursing except Ontario. And now that Ontario is putting a step forward—there’s no limit in there. There’s no change in there. There’s nothing. I have put forward a private member’s bill to limit the use of agency nursing, to limit how much profit they can do, to put them under the Auditor General so that we know exactly how much profit goes out of those agencies and into investors’ pockets. At the bottom of it, it’s the harm that it does. Because a nurse that has never been—you have been a nurse for seven years working in, we’ll say, the medical surgery floor. Now you’re an agency nurse and they need a nurse on Monday morning in, we will say, obstetrics. You’ve never worked in obstetrics before. The other nurses that are there, who know the floor, who know how things work, are being paid less than the agency nurse and they have to teach the agency nurse how to do the work.

Official source

3:17 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

Same thing: You may have been an orthopedic surgical nurse for many, many years, you’re really good at what you do, but the shift that they call you in for is for psychiatry, in which you know nothing, but you will be there with the rest of the staff that is there. The rest of the staff know full well that you’re making 10%, 20%, double the salary that they’re making, but yet they have to help you do the work. This is not good for good relations between co-workers. Nothing good comes from the use of agency nursing. And before anybody comes at me: Yes, I come from northern Ontario. Yes, we have used agency nursing in northern Ontario forever on end. But we use agencies that used to cost—I don’t know—8%, 10% more than what you pay your regular staff. I can talk about Manitoulin Island. Manitoulin Island is beautiful. Everybody should come and have a look. There are 50,000 people that come out there in the summer to visit, so you go from an island of 3,000 people to 50,000. Yes, you will need a little bit more stuff. I don’t wish harm upon anybody, but somebody will sprain their ankle having a look at the beautiful waterfalls and somebody else will fall or whatever; the hospital gets a whole lot busier. So, yes, a few nurses come during the summer, all the way to hunting season, and then they go back home. It’s the same nurse that has been coming for the last 10 years. They don’t cost $200 an hour or anything like this. It is very different to say, “Oh, this exists in northern Ontario.” What existed in northern Ontario and what is going on now is on two different planets. What is going on now is a whole bunch of investors saw a way to make a ton of money off of the back of a health care system that is in crisis. And they are making billions of dollars, according to the last report, at the expense of quality care. So, schedule 3, Health Care Staffing Agency Reporting Act: Why do we have to take such small steps when the crisis is so big? Last time I talked about this bill, I said it’s important to water your flowers. Everybody knows if you want your flowers to bloom, you need to water them. But when your house is on fire, maybe it would be good to put a hose onto that house rather than go water the flowers. So we are watering the flowers—nothing wrong with watering the flowers—but the house is on fire. Maybe it would be good to have a little bit of water going that way—apparently not. That was schedule 3. I think that’s all I’m going to say about schedule 3. As I mentioned, most other provinces have changed. If you look at Quebec—not that far away from Ontario, not that different from us—they have passed a law that basically gives big municipalities—so they started with Montreal, Quebec, Trois-Rivières—all the big centres have to have a staffing plan, and they limit how much money they can use for agency nursing. They have given the big hospitals two years to do this. In the medium-sized cities, they have three years to do that, and in the smaller-sized cities, they have even a little bit more time, but all of them have to submit a staffing plan that shows how they’re going to limit and get rid of agency nurses. I can tell you, Speaker, that I kind of copy-and-pasted that bill from Quebec, and I brought it here in Ontario, to limit the use of agency nursing in—I started with hospitals and long-term care. It is feasible. Every other province is doing it. What is Ontario waiting for? This tiny wee step is not going to change anything. Many hospitals are facing, basically, big deficits in their budget. Every hospital is supposed to have a balanced budget. Many of them won’t be having a balanced budget, and in huge part, it’s because of the high, high cost of agency nursing. This has to change. Schedule 3 is not going to change anything. It’s going to have them report at some point something that may become accessible to all or not. We just don’t know. I will be re-tabling the agency nursing bill at the end of the month, and I sure hope that the government will be willing to support that. Next is schedule 4, Health Protection and Promotion Act: “The Health Protection and Promotion Act is amended to require medical officers of health to notify the Chief Medical Officer of Health and to receive the Chief Medical Officer of Health’s written approval before issuing a class order.” This is another one of those where I don’t know what they have against public health, but, yes, it’s kind of weird. The class order is something that is used very, very rarely. It’s when a medical officer of health issues a directive regarding a communicable disease. Most people will have become aware that such things as class orders exist through COVID, when one medical officer of health—“medical officer of health” is the name of the physician in charge of a health unit. We have 34 in Ontario, and then we have the Chief Medical Officer of Health, who, for reasons unknown in Ontario, is an employee of the Ministry of Health, as opposed to other provinces where they are an independent officer of the Legislature. They have the right to issue a directive regarding communicable diseases, and that would include mandatory compliance for individual entities. They can include isolations, quarantine or other health care measures—

Official source

3:40 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

Yes, my colleague talks about measles. What the class order does is that it gives it legal force. This is a power that the medical officer of health of every public health unit already has but very, very seldom uses. But now, if they need to use the class order to order isolation, quarantine or other health measures, they will have to have the blessing of the Chief Medical Officer of Health. We have a Conservative government here that talks about red tape all the time. Why do we have all of those rules and why do we have all of those sign-offs and all of this? Well, if this is not red tape, I don’t know what red tape looks like. You already have a medical officer of health of one of the health units that will use any power that they have to try to control an outbreak, to try to control a communicable disease. They come to the conclusion that a class order is needed for isolation, quarantine or other health measures. Usually, once they make that kind of decision, it’s because there’s an urgency to it because you’re afraid the disease is about to spread to a whole bunch of other people and you want to protect your community. But now it doesn’t matter that you have the knowledge, the skills and you very seldom use this; you will have to do the second step of making sure that the Chief Medical Officer of Health agrees with you. I have nothing but good things to say about Dr. Moore, our Chief Medical Officer of Health here in Ontario. I have nothing against this doctor. What I have a problem with, though, is that, as I said, in Ontario, the Chief Medical Officer of Health is an employee of the Ministry of Health, of the Minister of Health. In other provinces, they are an independent officer. They don’t take the political side into decision-making. They decide for themselves, based on medical evidence, what are the best decisions for their province—but not in Ontario. You will remember, Speaker, that I have tabled a bill to change this so that the Chief Medical Officer of Health of Ontario would be an independent officer. Right now, it has the role of an independent officer, but it is an employee of the minister. Let’s finish that; let’s make sure that they continue. I would feel more comfortable if the Chief Medical Officer of Health was an independent officer of the Legislative Assembly because I would know for a fact that the decision-making is based on medical evidence, on what is best for the community. I still don’t think it’s a good idea to add a step, but I would feel more comfortable. What we have in Ontario, where the Minister of Health can say, “No, we don’t want you to do this”—and he won’t be allowed to do this and keep his job, I have a problem with that. So schedule 4 is red tape—it’s not a reduction, it’s a red tape addition that is not needed, that is not going to keep people healthier, that is not going to do any of that. Public health does not issue class orders very often. When they do, most of the time it is a very timely, urgent situation, and now we’re asking them to go through more steps. This is not a step in the right direction. Schedule 5 talks about the Mandatory Blood Testing Act: “The Mandatory Blood Testing Act … is amended to allow nurse practitioners to perform many of the functions in the act that must currently be performed by physicians.” We have this all over the health care acts in Ontario where we limit practitioners to do certain things. What this is all about is that it has to do mainly with EMS—emergency medical people, so think about paramedics, firefighters, police officers. If, during their work in the line of duty, or call it whatever, they come in contact with bodily fluids—think about spit, think about blood, think about anything else; any bodily fluid that they come in contact with—they will be tested to see if they came in contact with communicable diseases. So you’re talking HIV/AIDS, you’re talking hepatitis A, hepatitis B, hepatitis C etc. Right now, if you are a paramedic, a firefighter, a police officer, you’re at the scene of an accident, there’s blood all over the place, the person is stuck in the car, you do what you do with the jaws of life to get the car apart, to get the person out of this, they all come out of there covered in blood—not that they wanted to, but they did what they had to do to help the person in their time of crisis. They have to be tested. Now, in my riding, where out of 90,000 people, 40,000 of us do not have a family physician, you have to find a family physician who will do a requisition for you to be tested because you have been in contact with blood; now with schedule 5, nurse practitioners will be able to do this. Why nurse practitioners were not able to do this all along—this is not a change to the scope of practice; nurse practitioners are allowed to order blood tests, they are allowed to order tests for HIV, for hep C, for all this, but the law said that they were not able to do that, so now we’re changing the law to take out the fact that they were not allowed to do this—they are. But there’s all sorts of stuff like this. Did you know, Speaker, that if you went into a nurse practitioner-led clinic, they all have an AED—a defibrillator—but they were not allowed to use them? So if you had a heart attack in the nurse practitioner-led clinic, they would get the secretary to apply the AED because a nurse practitioner was not allowed to apply an AED. It’s not only that—pregnancy tests. Nurse practitioners were not allowed to dip a stick to see if you were pregnant. So what did the nurse practitioner do? They would ask the secretary or anybody else that happened to be in the waiting room, “Could you dip that for me, please? Because I’m not allowed to do that.” Then they could read it and say, “Yes, you’re pregnant” or “You are not”—whatever. There are all sorts of really archaic limitations on different health professionals. I could go on with what physiotherapists are not allowed to do. Anyway, there’s all sorts of stuff. This is one little step in the right direction. When EMS, police officers, firefighters are in contact with blood, it is not them who get tested, it’s the person who had the accidents who we test. If the person who had the accidents, the person whose blood was all over the place, is HIV-positive or hep C-positive or whatever, you can initiate treatments on the first responders and you can initiate a follow-up with the first responders that had contact with the bodily fluid to make sure that we keep them safe, we keep them healthy and we treat them if they were in contact. That we now remove this limitation on nurse practitioners is absolutely a step in the right direction, but I could give you a long list of other things, other limitations to the scope of practice of health professionals that make absolutely no sense but are there in the laws and in the regulations in Ontario. We’re taking one away—yay. There are about 500 more that need to be looked at, and I hope that, eventually, we will look at the other ones, but one little step in the right direction so that we can keep our first responders as safe as we can. I’ll go to schedule 6. Schedule 6 is called the Personal Health Information Protection Act. The schedule amends the personal health information—basically, to make amendments. “The act currently provides for an organization to be prescribed as a ‘prescribed organization’ for the purposes of ... the act.” A prescribed organization is basically who is allowed to have access to your health care information. In health care, it’s a relationship between two people most of the time: the one who provides the care and the one who receives the care. In order to achieve quality care, there has to be a high level of confidence between the two. There has to be a high level of trust. You have to be able to tell your health care provider things that you probably would have never told anyone before, things that you really want to keep private, but you have to share those with your health care providers in order to get the right diagnosis, in order to get the right plan of care. This can only happen when there is a really high level of trust between the two. I will start with the problems with schedule 6. The number one problem is that the Information and Privacy Commissioner—who’s just been renamed, Patricia Kosseim—she recommended removing schedule 6 from the bill, and she issued a recommendation to strengthen transparency and ensure equitable access to health information. The Information and Privacy Commissioner “issued recommendations on how the policy objectives underlying the bill could provide more meaningful access rights, while also being clearer and more practical to implement and enforce.” She also expressed concern over the lack of clarity regarding the scope of personal health information to be collected, used and disclosed. Under the new system, the absence of defined limitations could lead to overcollection and misuse of sensitive information. The Information and Privacy Commissioner noted potential conflict arising from Ontario Health’s dual role as both a health data repository and the administrator of digital health ID. This overlap could compromise the impartiality and integrity of data and governance. I wanted to read that into the record. I’m not opposed to electronic health information. Other provinces have done this, and it is successful and it’s a way to identify yourself. But you have to bring those kinds of changes in a way where the public is fully informed and, certainly, the Information and Privacy Commissioner supports you because, as I said, your health care information is very personal. It has information in there that only health care providers that are there to help you should have access to. People know this. People know that when you go see your doctor, your nurse practitioner, your physio, your dentist, you know that the information that they collect, nobody will have access to. But now that we are going to this online, the language in the bill makes many people uncomfortable as to how much information will the minister have access to. How much information will the Ministry of Health have access to? How much information will the people working for Ontario Health have access to? As I say, going to an electronic health card, electronic health records, are all things that are the way of the future; it is the way that people want to go. But you have to go there in a way that—I call it do your homework. Make sure that you have connected with patients, with hospitals, with health care providers, with the Integrity Commissioner to make sure that everybody is online, that this is the way to move forward. And then it becomes a whole lot faster to put anything like this in place. I think Ontario has the know-how, they have the technology, they have the goodwill to do this. Schedule 6, the Personal Health Information Protection Act, speaks to this. They want to protect your health information. That’s the name of the act: the Personal Health Information Protection Act. It wants to do the right thing, but when you come out with an act and you have the Information and Privacy Commissioner asking you to remove that schedule from the bill, that’s kind of a big setback. How come you did not collaborate with the Information and Privacy Commissioner ahead of time? Did you do your homework? Did you talk to hospitals? Did you talk to providers? Did you talk to lawyers? Did you talk to Ontarians in general as to what they would like to do? To say that your information will only be shared if there is agreement—we all know, Speaker, that when the agreement is three pages long and then you have to agree in order to be able to see a doctor, everybody will say, “I’ve waited in the waiting room for”—I don’t know; in my neck of the woods, we don’t measure wait time in minutes or hours anymore, it’s in days.

Official source

3:54 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

You could be a day and a half in the emergency room waiting area of Health Sciences North before you are seen. If they ask you, “You have to agree to an electronic medical record in order to be seen,” everybody will agree to this because you want to be seen by a doctor, because you’re in pain, because you’re in need of care. Then it falls apart, because then there’s mistrust in the system because people want their personal health information. Personal health information is something very important. If you work in a hospital and you access a client’s health record that is not your client, you lose your job. It doesn’t matter if you are unionized, it doesn’t matter if you’re the chief executive officer; you are not allowed to do this. There will be very serious consequences if you go and access a health record of someone who’s not your own patient, that you didn’t need to go see. It has happened in the past. Everybody who works in health care knows full well you are not allowed. Nobody does it. There is a very good process in place to see who has access, what record, at what time, and for how long and all of this. They keep track. They check. If somebody is found to have accessed a record that they were not allowed to—if they’re not your patient, you’re not allowed to have access to those records—they lose their job. There are really, really severe consequences. But then the Personal Health Information Protection Act says that Ontario Health would have access to your record. Who is Ontario Health and who works there? The Ministry of Health would have access to your record—hmm. Does the Minister of Health really need access to a health record? How much of that in the record will be shared? It has not been defined. It is not clear, so it leaves a lot of people uncomfortable. As I say, the end goal is good; how we get there, not always as good. Je viens de voir qu’il reste seulement que quelques minutes. J’aimerais vous parler du projet de loi 11, qui était un projet de loi qu’on avait déjà discuté avant Noël : la Loi visant à édicter ou à modifier diverses lois en ce qui concerne les soins de santé. Le projet de loi a six annexes. La première nous parle de la loi sur la ville de Hamilton, pour s’assurer que Hamilton crée un conseil de santé pour la ville. C’est quelque chose que Hamilton veut depuis longtemps et c’est quelque chose qui devrait être en place, pour a). L’annexe numéro 2 nous dit que les soins à domicile seront couverts par la Loi sur les services en français. Les services à domicile—s’il y a une place dans le système où les gens insistent qu’ils veulent être traités dans leur langue, c’est dans les soins à domicile. Il y a une grosse partie de la population qui reçoit des soins à domicile qui sont des personnes aînées, qui n’ont pas toujours autant de facilité en anglais, qui vont demander—ou leurs familles vont demander pour elles—l’accès à des services de soins à domicile en français. Pour une raison qu’on ne sait pas, la Loi sur les services en français ne s’appliquait pas et maintenant elle va s’appliquer. C’est un gros pas dans la bonne direction. La prochaine, l’annexe 3, c’est par rapport aux agences de placement de personnel de soins de santé. L’annexe en elle-même dit que les agences de placement qui sont à profit vont devoir donner certaines informations à certains laps de temps, et que cette information-là peut devenir disponible au public ou pas. Les données sur les agences de placement de personnel nous disent que 9,2 milliards de dollars ont été dépensés par les hôpitaux de l’Ontario pour des agences de placement de personnel en soins de santé. De ça, près de la moitié n’a jamais été pour les soins; a été pour les profits. Toutes les autres provinces au Canada ont des lois pour limiter l’utilisation, pour limiter les coûts afférents que les agences de placement de personnel demandent, sauf l’Ontario. Là, l’Ontario va avoir une loi sur les agences de placement de personnel, mais qui en fait très peu. Tout ce qu’on leur demande, c’est de soumettre un rapport de temps en temps et peut-être que le rapport va devenir public. On a besoin de beaucoup plus que ça. J’ai un projet de loi pour limiter l’utilisation des agences de placement de personnel. J’espère que le gouvernement va être prêt à faire un plus grand pas. La prochaine, l’annexe 4, c’est la Loi sur la protection et la promotion de la santé, qui limite les pouvoirs des médecins-hygiénistes, qui doivent demander une approbation écrite du médecin-hygiéniste en chef pour mettre en place certains changements. On ne sait pas pourquoi on ajoute cette étape-là. Ce n’est pas nécessaire, mais ils l’ont mise quand même. L’annexe 5, c’est le dépistage obligatoire par test sanguin. Les infirmières praticiennes vont maintenant avoir le droit de faire ça. Elles ont toujours eu le droit depuis longtemps, longtemps, de faire des prescriptions pour des tests sanguins, mais n’avaient pas le droit de le faire lorsque c’était du personnel pompier, policier ou paramédic qui en avait besoin. Le dernier, c’est la Loi sur la protection des renseignements personnels sur la santé, qui veut amener les dossiers et la carte Santé vers les ordinateurs vers l’année 2025—un pas dans la bonne direction, mais qui doit être fait avec l’appui des gens qui sont un peu nerveux face à ça. Merci beaucoup, madame la Présidente. Thank you, Speaker.

Official source

4:00 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Lorne Coe

I wanted to thank the member for Nickel Belt for her presentation. It’s tough to talk that long, for an hour, right? I want to circle back, Speaker, through you, on mandatory blood testing. As you would expect, there are regular conversations that we have with the police services in our ridings—for me, it’s the Durham Regional Police Association, and Andrew Tummonds is the president. We talked a little bit about this bill recently, and he talked about the current process being—I want to make sure I get it right—slow and cumbersome, which can hinder timely investigations and the administration of justice. They’re pleased that they have the ability now, through this proposed legislation, to enhance public safety in my riding and other ridings in the region of Durham. Given the importance of these reforms, does the member from Nickel Belt stand with the police officers in Ontario in supporting this bill?

Official source

4:10 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

I’m always happy to stand with police officers, firefighters and paramedics. Basically, the people they’ve helped are the ones who will have their blood tested—not the paramedics or the police officers—to make sure that the people that they’ve helped—usually in a time of crisis, in an accident, where there is blood all over the place. Sometimes, people are vindictive and will spit on them and that kind of stuff. That person will need to be tested. If the firefighter, the police officer or the EMS had been in contact with bodily fluids from that person, it used to be that you had to find a physician who would write a requisition for the blood test to be done. Now you can ask a nurse practitioner to do the exact same thing. She or he has the power and knows how to do this. It will make things faster and less cumbersome—absolutely, a good step in the right direction. I support it 100%.

Official source

4:11 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

I recognize the member for Niagara Falls.

Official source

4:11 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Wayne Gates

I want to congratulate my colleague—an hour, to stand up here and talk. That’s not easy to do, and as you get older, you’ll find out why. The Conservatives are spending $9.2 billion on agency nurses. It makes absolutely no sense. I want to read the bill—More Convenient Care Act, 2025. I’m going to ask you a question that I think is fair and reasonable: How is this bill going to help people who don’t have a family doctor? We have 2.3 million people in the province who don’t have a family doctor today. What care are they supposed to get that’s going to be more convenient?

Official source

4:12 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

The member is absolutely right; we have a crisis in Ontario. I’ve compared it with—is it important to water your flowers? Yes. But when your house is on fire, this is where the water should go. The house on fire is the 2.3 million Ontarians who don’t have access to primary care; it is the 122 patients at Health Sciences North who are sick enough to be admitted into a hospital but are in a hallway or in a TV room or anywhere but a room, because our hospital is too small. All of this is a crisis. The government brought forward their first health care bill after an election. You figure that they would put all of their energy towards solving a crisis and put a bill forward that would really give hope. None of that is in the bill. You’re without a family physician, and this bill passes—you will be without a family physician.

Official source

4:13 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Lee Fairclough

Congratulations on a one-hour debate. I think that is quite impressive. I didn’t see all of it, because I was in public accounts, but I was trying to watch a little bit on the TV behind—what you were saying, as well. I want to ask you about the section on agency nursing. I don’t know about you, but I got a little bit hopeful that we might have some increased accountability around it, until I read the bill. I’m interested in you expanding a little further on your thoughts on the schedule related to agency nursing.

Official source

4:13 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

Agency nursing: It asks the agencies to give some information at some time frame not defined, that could or could not be shared publicly. That’s all it does. We have a crisis. We’re talking about $9.2 billion spent by our hospitals, not for care—half of this went to profit, because they had to use agency nurses. Every other province in Canada has put forward legislation to limit the use of agency nurses—the last one was Quebec, who is already moving forward in their big centres. We have a law in Ontario—I brought forward a bill that would do just this, to make sure that the billions of dollars that our hospitals spend on agency nurses could be put toward good, permanent jobs. We can do this, but it’s not in the bill.

Official source

4:14 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Paul Vickers

This bill aims to make it easier for Ontarians to access their health information online. By implementing this measure, we are ensuring that individuals can conveniently view their medical records, test results, and other important health data through secure online platforms. This increased accessibility empowers patients to take a more active role in managing their health, facilitates better communication between patients and health care providers, and enhances the overall efficiencies of the health care system. It also helps in reducing administrative burdens and wait times for accessing health information. Given these benefits, why does the member disagree with this initiative? Specifically, do you not agree that in our modern world we should be making health information more accessible online to Ontarians, and will you agree that the status quo is not good enough for patients to access their own health data?

Official source

4:16 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

I absolutely want health information to be available to patients. I absolutely want to live in 2025 and not in—whatever. But it has to be done in a way that maintains the trust between what I’ll call the “patient” and the “health providers.” If you don’t have a trusting relationship between the patient and the health provider, you cannot have quality care. And when you have the Information and Privacy Commissioner, who asks you to withdraw schedule 6—then it makes me nervous. If people don’t trust it, then you will do more damage to our health care system than good. Do I want this to happen? Yes, absolutely. Other provinces are doing it, and they’re doing it in a way that is supported by their agencies, by their privacy commissioners. I want us to get there. I want it to be accessible. It will help manage—it will bring efficiency. This is 2025. We should have it already—but do it in a way that where the Information and Privacy Commissioner gives you a check mark, “You’re doing good,” not a “Withdraw this.”

Official source

4:17 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

The member for Mushkegowuk–James Bay.

Official source

4:17 p.m.Official Hansard

M. Guy Bourgouin

J’aimerais te parler de l’annexe 2, parce qu’on sait comment les services en français sont importants, puis encore plus quand ce sont les services à domicile. On sait aussi que le gros enjeu, c’est de les garder. J’aimerais vous entendre sur ce point-là, parce que vous en avez parlé un petit peu, mais je veux vous donner l’opportunité d’en parler plus profondément.

Official source

4:18 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

Merci. Absolument, dans les soins à domicile, le plus gros problème, c’est que les cliniques privées, les Bayshores ne sont pas capables de recruter et de retenir le personnel. Pourquoi? Parce qu’ils n’offrent pas de bons emplois permanents, bien payés avec des vacances, des avantages sociaux et des journées de maladie. Peut-être qu’on pourrait rêver d’avoir un plan de pension. Qu’ils traitent leurs employés comme avant que Mike Harris ait fait la privatisation du système de soins à domicile, où est-ce que c’étaient des bons emplois—il y avait des infirmières qui travaillaient là toute leur carrière dans les soins à domicile. C’est ce que les gens veulent. Ils veulent demeurer chez eux. Ils veulent être soutenus de façon respectueuse, à la maison, chez eux, et ça, ça se fait au travers des soins à domicile. Mais les soins à domicile qui, à toutes les semaines, appellent pour dire : « Oh, on ne sera pas capable d’y aller; même si tu as besoin d’aide pour te transférer de ton lit à la toilette, pour t’habiller, tout ce qu’on te donne, c’est deux bains par semaine », ce n’est pas suffisant. Les soins à domicile ont besoin d’aide et ce n’est pas dans le projet de loi que tu vas trouver ça.

Official source

4:19 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos)

Further debate? I recognize the—

Official source