Mme France Gélinas
Yes, my colleague talks about measles. What the class order does is that it gives it legal force. This is a power that the medical officer of health of every public health unit already has but very, very seldom uses. But now, if they need to use the class order to order isolation, quarantine or other health measures, they will have to have the blessing of the Chief Medical Officer of Health. We have a Conservative government here that talks about red tape all the time. Why do we have all of those rules and why do we have all of those sign-offs and all of this? Well, if this is not red tape, I don’t know what red tape looks like. You already have a medical officer of health of one of the health units that will use any power that they have to try to control an outbreak, to try to control a communicable disease. They come to the conclusion that a class order is needed for isolation, quarantine or other health measures. Usually, once they make that kind of decision, it’s because there’s an urgency to it because you’re afraid the disease is about to spread to a whole bunch of other people and you want to protect your community. But now it doesn’t matter that you have the knowledge, the skills and you very seldom use this; you will have to do the second step of making sure that the Chief Medical Officer of Health agrees with you. I have nothing but good things to say about Dr. Moore, our Chief Medical Officer of Health here in Ontario. I have nothing against this doctor. What I have a problem with, though, is that, as I said, in Ontario, the Chief Medical Officer of Health is an employee of the Ministry of Health, of the Minister of Health. In other provinces, they are an independent officer. They don’t take the political side into decision-making. They decide for themselves, based on medical evidence, what are the best decisions for their province—but not in Ontario. You will remember, Speaker, that I have tabled a bill to change this so that the Chief Medical Officer of Health of Ontario would be an independent officer. Right now, it has the role of an independent officer, but it is an employee of the minister. Let’s finish that; let’s make sure that they continue. I would feel more comfortable if the Chief Medical Officer of Health was an independent officer of the Legislative Assembly because I would know for a fact that the decision-making is based on medical evidence, on what is best for the community. I still don’t think it’s a good idea to add a step, but I would feel more comfortable. What we have in Ontario, where the Minister of Health can say, “No, we don’t want you to do this”—and he won’t be allowed to do this and keep his job, I have a problem with that. So schedule 4 is red tape—it’s not a reduction, it’s a red tape addition that is not needed, that is not going to keep people healthier, that is not going to do any of that. Public health does not issue class orders very often. When they do, most of the time it is a very timely, urgent situation, and now we’re asking them to go through more steps. This is not a step in the right direction. Schedule 5 talks about the Mandatory Blood Testing Act: “The Mandatory Blood Testing Act … is amended to allow nurse practitioners to perform many of the functions in the act that must currently be performed by physicians.” We have this all over the health care acts in Ontario where we limit practitioners to do certain things. What this is all about is that it has to do mainly with EMS—emergency medical people, so think about paramedics, firefighters, police officers. If, during their work in the line of duty, or call it whatever, they come in contact with bodily fluids—think about spit, think about blood, think about anything else; any bodily fluid that they come in contact with—they will be tested to see if they came in contact with communicable diseases. So you’re talking HIV/AIDS, you’re talking hepatitis A, hepatitis B, hepatitis C etc. Right now, if you are a paramedic, a firefighter, a police officer, you’re at the scene of an accident, there’s blood all over the place, the person is stuck in the car, you do what you do with the jaws of life to get the car apart, to get the person out of this, they all come out of there covered in blood—not that they wanted to, but they did what they had to do to help the person in their time of crisis. They have to be tested. Now, in my riding, where out of 90,000 people, 40,000 of us do not have a family physician, you have to find a family physician who will do a requisition for you to be tested because you have been in contact with blood; now with schedule 5, nurse practitioners will be able to do this. Why nurse practitioners were not able to do this all along—this is not a change to the scope of practice; nurse practitioners are allowed to order blood tests, they are allowed to order tests for HIV, for hep C, for all this, but the law said that they were not able to do that, so now we’re changing the law to take out the fact that they were not allowed to do this—they are. But there’s all sorts of stuff like this. Did you know, Speaker, that if you went into a nurse practitioner-led clinic, they all have an AED—a defibrillator—but they were not allowed to use them? So if you had a heart attack in the nurse practitioner-led clinic, they would get the secretary to apply the AED because a nurse practitioner was not allowed to apply an AED. It’s not only that—pregnancy tests. Nurse practitioners were not allowed to dip a stick to see if you were pregnant. So what did the nurse practitioner do? They would ask the secretary or anybody else that happened to be in the waiting room, “Could you dip that for me, please? Because I’m not allowed to do that.” Then they could read it and say, “Yes, you’re pregnant” or “You are not”—whatever. There are all sorts of really archaic limitations on different health professionals. I could go on with what physiotherapists are not allowed to do. Anyway, there’s all sorts of stuff. This is one little step in the right direction. When EMS, police officers, firefighters are in contact with blood, it is not them who get tested, it’s the person who had the accidents who we test. If the person who had the accidents, the person whose blood was all over the place, is HIV-positive or hep C-positive or whatever, you can initiate treatments on the first responders and you can initiate a follow-up with the first responders that had contact with the bodily fluid to make sure that we keep them safe, we keep them healthy and we treat them if they were in contact. That we now remove this limitation on nurse practitioners is absolutely a step in the right direction, but I could give you a long list of other things, other limitations to the scope of practice of health professionals that make absolutely no sense but are there in the laws and in the regulations in Ontario. We’re taking one away—yay. There are about 500 more that need to be looked at, and I hope that, eventually, we will look at the other ones, but one little step in the right direction so that we can keep our first responders as safe as we can. I’ll go to schedule 6. Schedule 6 is called the Personal Health Information Protection Act. The schedule amends the personal health information—basically, to make amendments. “The act currently provides for an organization to be prescribed as a ‘prescribed organization’ for the purposes of ... the act.” A prescribed organization is basically who is allowed to have access to your health care information. In health care, it’s a relationship between two people most of the time: the one who provides the care and the one who receives the care. In order to achieve quality care, there has to be a high level of confidence between the two. There has to be a high level of trust. You have to be able to tell your health care provider things that you probably would have never told anyone before, things that you really want to keep private, but you have to share those with your health care providers in order to get the right diagnosis, in order to get the right plan of care. This can only happen when there is a really high level of trust between the two. I will start with the problems with schedule 6. The number one problem is that the Information and Privacy Commissioner—who’s just been renamed, Patricia Kosseim—she recommended removing schedule 6 from the bill, and she issued a recommendation to strengthen transparency and ensure equitable access to health information. The Information and Privacy Commissioner “issued recommendations on how the policy objectives underlying the bill could provide more meaningful access rights, while also being clearer and more practical to implement and enforce.” She also expressed concern over the lack of clarity regarding the scope of personal health information to be collected, used and disclosed. Under the new system, the absence of defined limitations could lead to overcollection and misuse of sensitive information. The Information and Privacy Commissioner noted potential conflict arising from Ontario Health’s dual role as both a health data repository and the administrator of digital health ID. This overlap could compromise the impartiality and integrity of data and governance. I wanted to read that into the record. I’m not opposed to electronic health information. Other provinces have done this, and it is successful and it’s a way to identify yourself. But you have to bring those kinds of changes in a way where the public is fully informed and, certainly, the Information and Privacy Commissioner supports you because, as I said, your health care information is very personal. It has information in there that only health care providers that are there to help you should have access to. People know this. People know that when you go see your doctor, your nurse practitioner, your physio, your dentist, you know that the information that they collect, nobody will have access to. But now that we are going to this online, the language in the bill makes many people uncomfortable as to how much information will the minister have access to. How much information will the Ministry of Health have access to? How much information will the people working for Ontario Health have access to? As I say, going to an electronic health card, electronic health records, are all things that are the way of the future; it is the way that people want to go. But you have to go there in a way that—I call it do your homework. Make sure that you have connected with patients, with hospitals, with health care providers, with the Integrity Commissioner to make sure that everybody is online, that this is the way to move forward. And then it becomes a whole lot faster to put anything like this in place. I think Ontario has the know-how, they have the technology, they have the goodwill to do this. Schedule 6, the Personal Health Information Protection Act, speaks to this. They want to protect your health information. That’s the name of the act: the Personal Health Information Protection Act. It wants to do the right thing, but when you come out with an act and you have the Information and Privacy Commissioner asking you to remove that schedule from the bill, that’s kind of a big setback. How come you did not collaborate with the Information and Privacy Commissioner ahead of time? Did you do your homework? Did you talk to hospitals? Did you talk to providers? Did you talk to lawyers? Did you talk to Ontarians in general as to what they would like to do? To say that your information will only be shared if there is agreement—we all know, Speaker, that when the agreement is three pages long and then you have to agree in order to be able to see a doctor, everybody will say, “I’ve waited in the waiting room for”—I don’t know; in my neck of the woods, we don’t measure wait time in minutes or hours anymore, it’s in days.
Official source