Legislative Assembly of Ontario · Committee

Thursday, January 15, 2026

Standing Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs

The official transcript of the meeting, from Hansard, by heading. Ministers, officials and witnesses appear as the transcript names them; committees have no live transcript, so the record appears once the Assembly publishes it.

Thursday, January 15, 2026

Read from the beginning of the meeting

Meeting ended

Métis Nation of Ontario; Carefor Health and Community Services; Rothmans, Benson and Hedges

05:51:17Official transcript

Mr. Tyler Allsopp

I have a brief question for Lexi for Rothmans, Benson and Hedges. I do want to thank Madame Collard for her question as well, because it did raise my eyebrows. I thought, you know, we have vision for a smoke-free future from a tobacco company. It’s sort of like in the horror movie when the call is coming from inside the house. So I was a little bit surprised by it, but you’re right. I mean, it’s patches. It’s gums. It’s vapes. It’s all those other products as well. I had a gentleman from a local company that makes e-juice for vapes called Stinky Canuck which was concerned about the taxation rate on non-combustible tobaccos and the increase in the federal—

Official source

05:52:01Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Well, thank you very much. It’s nice that it was a short question, because it’s going to get an even shorter answer. Thank you all. That does conclude the time not only for that question but for this panel. We want to thank all the panellists for having spent all that time preparing and to be here, and share that with us, and even cause some serious questions about how we can become that. We very much appreciate all the work you’ve done to help us along with our pre-budget consultations. So thank you very much. While we’re saying goodbye to that panel, our next panel is a rather short one.

Official source

Township of Bonnechere Valley

05:52:41Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

There’s only one delegation. It’s the delegation of the township of Bonnechere Valley. It is a virtual meeting, and I believe we have it already on the camera. So if everybody will get in their seats, we will start the festivities. As you likely have heard from the other presenters, you have seven minutes to make a presentation. At six minutes, I will give notice that it’s one minute left, and at seven minutes, we’ll conclude that and then we’ll have a round of questioning from the committee. So with that, the floor is yours. We do ask that you introduce yourself for Hansard to make sure that we can attribute the comments to the right person. With that, the floor is yours.

Official source

05:53:26Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

Thank you so much. My name is Annette Gilchrist. I’m the CAO, clerk and deputy treasurer for the township of Bonnechere Valley in beautiful Renfrew county. We appreciate the opportunity to bring forward the challenges that municipalities are having raising revenues to achieve fiscal sustainability. Without sustained revenue, municipal governments will continue to struggle with their fiscal well-being while trying to make their communities strong places to live, work and play. We just wish to highlight three issues of critical significance. One, across Ontario, municipal costs and responsibilities are growing, and municipal revenue is not keeping pace. Even prior to the pandemic, the municipal fiscal gap and aging infrastructure were creating challenges too large to address through property taxes and user fees alone. We now have additional pressures related to the opioid crisis, homelessness and a lack of resources for health, mental health and local trades, as well as increasing public demand for services and provincial regulatory and reporting requirements. Municipalities own two thirds of all public infrastructure, and in the fall of 2008, the Provincial-Municipal Fiscal and Service Delivery Review put the cost of bringing municipal infrastructure into a good state of repair at $22.4 billion, with an additional $3.7 billion investment needed annually to meet current and future needs. Municipal infrastructure accounts for nearly half of the province’s public infrastructure stock. Municipal governments have been taking on more debt; however, debt can only finance capital projects, not operating costs. Municipal operating costs are growing at $1 billion annually just to maintain current services. Costs are driven by factors such as rising insurance, electricity rates, increased demand for services, provincial legislation and areas like emergency services. However, not all municipalities—especially those with limited fiscal capacity—can afford to take on debt. The right balance of intergenerational equity is another key consideration. In this time of economic uncertainty, and recognizing the unique challenges our communities are facing, we ask the committee to review options to support municipalities through the provincial budget so that we can build a stronger Ontario together. One option would be to consider a rebate on 100% of the HST. On services where municipalities paid GST at the 5% rate, we now pay an HST at 13%. Of this tax payable, we receive a 100% rebate from the former GST of 5% and a 78% rebate on the former RST of 8%. This means there’s a portion of the tax paid on services that is not recoverable for us. Previously, there were also cases where the RST payable is there now because it’s charged through the HST at 13%, but wasn’t charged before. Examples of cases like that include: —energy—diesel, gasoline, electricity, natural gas; —conferences; —membership fees; —landscaping; —snow removal; —professional fees—legal, audit, consulting; —service contracts; and —all of those things that are contracted, like public transit services, garbage collection, security, janitorial. As much as the municipality bore no taxation liability on these items under the previous regime, an additional tax levy of 22% of the provincial portion, or about 1.76%, has become payable and added to the cost borne by every municipality. For Bonnechere Valley, in 2024, it was about $66,402, which required a 1.6% tax increase to be borne by our residents. According to the provincial summary, 1.76%, when applied to the expenses of contracts and materials on the FIRs across Ontario for all the municipalities was about $285,835,808. The province of Ontario received $3 billion more in HST revenues, net of rebates and refunds, in 2022 than in 2021. The previous annual increases were about $1.5 billion and $500 million. That’s double the revenue, and it is probable that going forward in 2023-24 and all the way up to 2025, with inflation continuing, these will again be doubled and might be as high as $6 billion. One per cent of this 2022 net HST revenue would be about $368 million, more than enough to cover the 1.76% unrebated portion paid by municipalities, or enough to implement a 1% sales tax dedicated to municipal infrastructure out of the annual increase. Other funding considerations that we would like to ensure the committee continue to support would be the Ontario Municipal Partnership Fund and the continuation of the Ontario Community Infrastructure Fund, at not less than $400 million beyond its current five-year term, which is ending in 2026, with no reductions in subsequent provincial budgets, and also that it be indexed to the Ontario Consumer Price Index on a calendar-year basis and disbursed in the first quarter of each fiscal year to municipalities. That would be a guaranteed annual envelope and allocation percentage, by municipality, to enable long-term capital planning and stable cash flow management. We also really appreciate the $77 million that the province provided last fall to offset unusually large OPP billing increases and the 11% cap on 2026 increases.

Official source

05:59:10Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

Okay. The fiscal challenges municipalities are facing extend beyond the OPP billing model, and we are concerned that year-over-year increasing costs of 26% to 34% requires some review. We do acknowledge that many of these duties for the police are not as originally envisioned and are mission creep or wide policing. We are going to be asking the Solicitor General to conduct a comprehensive review. However, in the interim, we would ask the committee to consider preserving short-term stability, while pursuing reform through caps on municipal increases into the single digits, similar to other municipal policing counterparts, such as Ottawa or the Toronto Police Service, which are only reporting increases of between 1.7% and 4.3%. Thank you.

Official source

06:00:00Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much for the presentation. We will start the questions with MPP Collard.

Official source

06:00:06Official transcript

Mme Lucille Collard

Thank you, Ms. Gilchrist, for your presentation. There was a lot that you unpacked in terms of the financial pressure put on your municipality. I’m just wondering if you could recap your specific ask to the province to take into consideration for the next budget.

Official source

06:00:25Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

Yes. The specific ask would be a completely funded HST rebate. Right now, we are not getting 1.76% back for all the 444 municipalities across the province. Also, just a continuation of the OMPF fund, the OCIF fund and a cap on policing to single digits, as opposed to double digits.

Official source

06:00:46Official transcript

Mme Lucille Collard

All right. We’ve heard from other municipalities earlier that the levy that the MPAC is collecting for assessments it’s not doing is also a financial pressure. Are you going through the same motion?

Official source

06:01:01Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

Our levy that’s paid to MPAC is through the upper tier for Renfrew county, so I don’t see those dollars, but yes, that is a pretty large number, based on anything that I have seen in the past.

Official source

06:01:15Official transcript

Mme Lucille Collard

You mentioned, at the beginning specifically, the added pressure on the municipalities to deal with the opioid and homelessness crisis. I’m from Ottawa, so I totally understand. We need to do so much more on that front, because it’s having an impact on our communities, our health care system and everything else—and municipalities, for sure. But money is not everything in this case. Do you have recommendations for the province to intervene and help municipalities deal with that crisis?

Official source

06:01:51Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

Right now, there’s an overdose media message that the health unit just put out in Renfrew county, in Renfrew and Arnprior right at the moment, unfortunately. We have a kit here. I think continuing to make those naloxone kits available, continuing to make services available for mental health and addictions is very, very important. I do understand that that’s impacting, as I said, the spread of the cost of policing, where that might not be their core role. How do we help them? I know we have the Renfrew county VTAC that is working very hard to fulfill some needs in the health sector where, if an OPP officer has taken somebody to the hospital, they don’t have to sit with them the whole time. They can call in a paramedic to be able to sit with them. I just think continued funding for those types of programs, where we can relieve a little bit—that’s not the officer’s job, to sit there at the hospital for three or four hours. It’s very expensive—lots of overtime—but if we can have funding for paramedics, who are at a lower salary and probably have more medical training than the OPP officers, more funding for those types of situations where they’re able to assist and sit with them. We have a mental health unit that travels around and someone very specific with the OPP as well. Any funding that the province is able to provide for those types of initiatives would be appreciated.

Official source

06:03:34Official transcript

Mme Lucille Collard

I don’t know the amplitude of the opioid crisis or the homelessness crisis in your particular community. You talked about that program about having a mobile health care unit. What other types of initiatives do you have to deal with that situation? What’s the situation also with your food bank, if you have one?

Official source

06:03:57Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

Yes, we do have a food bank, and the numbers in the food bank are very, very scary. They are continuing to increase. So many more people used the food bank in the last year, and so we continue to work with them and try to assist them wherever we can. They actually have space in one of our old fire halls, so it allows them to have space rent-free. The county of Renfrew has the Mesa program. They have a HART hub in the city of Pembroke, so we’re working very hard to have spaces that people can go to, and turn to, and also—

Official source

06:04:37Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

—that we have the situational leadership table, so coordinating services between medical and policing and family services and all of those types of things. I think they’re doing a very good job but we always could use more support if there is support available.

Official source

06:05:04Official transcript

Ms. Bobbi Ann Brady

Thank you, Annette, for your passionate presentation. As an MPP for a very rural and agricultural area, I grow increasingly worried about how areas like my riding—and also your area—cope with managing development pressures. I’m not convinced that people pay for themselves and that bigger is better, and I feel as though if people did pay for themselves, we wouldn’t be hearing from municipalities that have seen accelerated growth. We wouldn’t be hearing them articulate the same concerns and struggles that you have articulated today. So I’m wondering how your township utilizes its official plan and zoning bylaws to actively protect prime agricultural areas.

Official source

06:05:53Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

We do have some agricultural areas in Bonnechere Valley, and they are very fiercely protected through the official plan for the county of Renfrew. So there’s no severances and there’s no building unless it’s obviously farm use. Also, we do always look at add-ons for farm use because we do want to promote agriculture and tourism, forestry and aggregates. All of these things are very important to our local economy here. So we try to make sure that development is more in settlement areas. We have the village of Eganville, which is our small urban centre. We just had a couple of large apartment buildings go up there in place of an old convent building that had been abandoned, that was torn down, so that housing is there. We worked very closely with that developer to make sure that we had everything that we needed. We don’t have an engineer on staff, because we’re small, so we have to contract out for that. Basically, what we did was a peer review and that developer was able to pay for that.

Official source

06:07:08Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

And actually, the additional people on our water and sewer allowed us to have an increase of only 3% this year because it added 7% to our user fees for water and sewer, so that actually really helped for that service.

Official source

06:07:24Official transcript

Ms. Bobbi Ann Brady

I’ve been to Eganville, it’s a beautiful area, on my way from Grumblin’ Granny’s in Barry’s Bay. Thank you for your answer, and I’ll just leave one last comment that I fear that we see these increased needs for addictions, mental health and homelessness because we continue to move people around and they’re growing in areas where we’re not accustomed to growing that quickly. But I appreciate your response on protecting farmland, and thanks for coming today.

Official source

06:08:00Official transcript

Mr. Stéphane Sarrazin

Thank you, Annette, for the presentation. I have to say, I was a mayor myself, and one thing I noticed is that municipalities in the past didn’t increase taxes. I don’t know if it was the same story in your area. It seems to be, if we’re looking at a 20-year trend, they would raise taxes by almost 1%. I guess, at the end of the day, we got caught in this because everything—we should have at least increased it by the cost of living over the years. I don’t know if you agree with that. I think, if I’m not mistaken, in 2022, you raised tax by 0.39%, is that—

Official source

06:08:44Official transcript

Mr. Stéphane Sarrazin

Okay. But one thing I want to say, though, I know what we’ve been hearing lately is that municipalities are really having problems with funding. Everything costs more, the services, all of these engineering firms, all these service providers. What I’ve noticed—I don’t know; I can compare it to my area—but I’ve never seen so much money flowing from the provincial government. We doubled the OMPF, or almost doubled it. In my region, we had the water, sewer, road infrastructure grants. Some of the municipalities, they got $30 million, a lot of money. I’m just wondering: I can’t say, because I haven’t been in politics for 30 years, but it seems like in the last six, seven years with this government, we’ve been financing, funding a lot of projects in my riding. We’re adding an arena. We just received $10 million. I don’t know. It would be fun to give out more money. I think the government is really doing well with municipalities, but we don’t get the credit for it. I don’t know if you can comment to this.

Official source

06:10:00Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

What I would say is, yes, we do appreciate the increasing of the OMPF, the increasing of the OCIF and the funds that are coming, but I think it’s a bit of both ways. I think you’re right. I think you have to look at the economy, because right now, we have a couple of businesses that are closing. We have a major bank that’s leaving us. We have to kind of wait it out. We don’t want all the jobs to go. We don’t want people to lose their homes, so we have to gauge that, but I agree with you. CPI plus 1% for capital reserves is the policy that we follow here and that we like to stick to, but we’re conscious of the challenges that people are having, that they need to go to the food bank. So we want to make sure that we keep things affordable. Usually, we try to stay about 4% or 5% to continue on, but, yes, there were times in the past where maybe things were not going up 2% for a lot of local municipalities. But I would say the same thing for the province. The OMPF fund wasn’t being indexed. The infrastructure funding wasn’t being indexed. That fund, even though it’s been doubled now, probably really just followed a trend and hasn’t been indexed to the full degree that it could. It was cut significantly, so it’s probably not even that. I don’t know if it’s back to where it was when you go back to 2008. If we’re working with the same amount of dollars we had in 2008, it’s great that we just doubled it, but if it’s the same dollars from then, that’s not really a great system for us. We talked about farmland earlier. We can only tax them at 25%. The province used to kick in the 75%; they don’t anymore. Policing, as I said, has gone 35% in some cases. How do you keep up with those types of things? Our 4% or 5% is not going to cut that. Of course, the province is in the same boat. It’s all aging at the same time, all of this infrastructure, this great growth that the province of Ontario had. Now we have to maintain it all and, yes, that’s just going to cost. I think that, yes, we need to get on a track with the province and with municipalities where we are looking at the consumer price index. Yes, I certainly agree with that.

Official source

06:12:43Official transcript

Mr. Stéphane Sarrazin

Just if I can add, every time we announce some funding, like a billion dollars of funding for the water and sewer infrastructure in my riding—I’ve got maybe nine municipalities, and I think within the last four years, we got over $150 million. I’m thinking I’ve never seen that kind of money flowing in my riding. I don’t know. I’m just thinking— Interjection.

Official source

06:13:11Official transcript

Mr. Stéphane Sarrazin

No. You must have must have some good grants with these projects, water infrastructure, water safety and even the one for recreation buildings. Did you manage to get some of this funding?

Official source

06:13:25Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

We received some funding—nothing in the amounts that you are speaking about, even in the entire Renfrew county, but yes. No, absolutely. We apply for everything that we can. We get some approvals. We get some denials. Sometimes—

Official source

06:13:42Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time for that question. We’ll now go to MPP Bell.

Official source

06:13:49Official transcript

Ms. Jessica Bell

Thank you so much for coming and speaking today. As you were talking, I was so impressed by the figures, the details and the specificity you had on the numbers. I thought to myself, “Could this be a CAO?” Then I looked at your title and I realized, yes, you are a chief administrative officer. Thank you for holding our attention this afternoon. I have some very specific questions about your presentation. You mentioned the request to fully recover the amount you pay on HST. You mentioned it was about 1.6%, I believe. How much would it actually save if you were able to recover that money? And if you had that money, what would you spend it on as a municipality?

Official source

06:14:39Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

It depends on how much we’re investing, right? As was talked about earlier, if we’ve received some funding approvals and we are investing $5 million, obviously our HST on that increases. But just in 2022 alone, the amount of money that we invested would’ve brought us—if we would have got the full HST back—about $60,000, which is over 1.5% on our tax levy. Looking at that across the province, everyone is probably in the same boat. I’m sure the bigger areas would have spent more on HST, so their portion would be more, of course, than ours. But I think that, yes, $60,000 probably doesn’t sound like a lot for certain people, but for us, if we don’t have to put that out on our infrastructure projects, we can put that back—we can extend the project; maybe we can do another half kilometre of road, or we can add a little bit more pipe, or do some more catch basins or whatever it is we can do, whether it’s recreational for the arena. Really, that’s where I see the money going. We’re paying it to the province; the province is rebating a portion. It would be really nice if we could get the entire amount rebated, especially knowing that HST income has gone up substantially because of inflation. And the ability to pay, right? It really does spread it across. If I’m going to buy a $50 pair of shoes and you’re going to buy a $5,000 pair of shoes, you’re going to pay more into that HST. When you’re talking about who should pay for things, I think that’s a good way to get the funding.

Official source

06:16:32Official transcript

Ms. Jessica Bell

I can imagine your property tax base residents would also be pretty appreciative of any kind of savings that the province can give your municipality as well. Things are very expensive. Property taxes are going up and up, at least in my riding. I get a lot of concerns about that. My other question, and this is also very specific: Can you just explain a little bit more about what the OCIF fund is for? What do you spend it on?

Official source

06:17:04Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

Usually, we spend it on roads, but in 2026, we’re going to spend some of it on water and sewer. It’s basically spent on our infrastructure, and the infrastructure that we’re actually doing this on is 50 years old. It’s awful. It took us some time to get the project together and make everything happen and get some additional funding to go with the OCIF. But, yes, most of the projects that we’re doing are projects that are really—this is old infrastructure. We’re still working off trying to meet our asset management plan needs from 2013—it’s 2026. Like I said, I’m sure the province is in the same boat. Everything is aging, and we’re doing our best to invest whatever we’re given.

Official source

06:17:56Official transcript

Ms. Jessica Bell

I wonder if this is an issue in your area. In some areas across Ontario, the lack of high-quality infrastructure—water and sewage—is putting upper-tier and lower-tier municipalities in a situation where they can’t approve new housing starts because they do not have the resources to connect these new homes, these subdivisions, to the grid, essentially, and to the services that already exist. Is that a situation that you’re also experiencing in your area?

Official source

06:18:32Official transcript

Ms. Annette Gilchrist

We are very close to capacity. As I said, we just had two large apartment buildings—30 units each—get built, so that’s helped immensely. But yes, we are just about at capacity. We’re getting to a point where, if we get more interest, we’re going to have to upgrade the plant, and that is expensive. That’s not just pipes in the ground.

Official source

06:18:57Official transcript

Ms. Jessica Bell

Yes. In order for us to grow as a province, it’s very important that we’re building the infrastructure as we’re trying to increase housing starts at the same time. Thank you for identifying some of that tension that you face on a local level. These are all of my questions. Thank you so much for your time today.

Official source

06:19:21Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That does conclude the time for this time slot. We thank you very much for making the presentation, and good luck with getting all those jobs done. We really appreciate all the help you have given us in our discussions. That also concludes the events of the day. This concludes the public hearings for today. Thank you for your participation. This committee now stands adjourned until 10 a.m. on Tuesday, January 20, 2026, when we will resume public hearings in Kitchener, Ontario.

Official source

06:20:53Official transcript

Ms. Sandy Shaw (Hamilton West–Ancaster–Dundas / Hamilton-Ouest–Ancaster–Dundas ND)

Official source

06:21:04Official transcript

Ms. Effie J. Triantafilopoulos (Oakville North–Burlington / Oakville-Nord–Burlington PC)

Official source