Ms. Annette Gilchrist
Thank you so much. My name is Annette Gilchrist. I’m the CAO, clerk and deputy treasurer for the township of Bonnechere Valley in beautiful Renfrew county. We appreciate the opportunity to bring forward the challenges that municipalities are having raising revenues to achieve fiscal sustainability. Without sustained revenue, municipal governments will continue to struggle with their fiscal well-being while trying to make their communities strong places to live, work and play. We just wish to highlight three issues of critical significance. One, across Ontario, municipal costs and responsibilities are growing, and municipal revenue is not keeping pace. Even prior to the pandemic, the municipal fiscal gap and aging infrastructure were creating challenges too large to address through property taxes and user fees alone. We now have additional pressures related to the opioid crisis, homelessness and a lack of resources for health, mental health and local trades, as well as increasing public demand for services and provincial regulatory and reporting requirements. Municipalities own two thirds of all public infrastructure, and in the fall of 2008, the Provincial-Municipal Fiscal and Service Delivery Review put the cost of bringing municipal infrastructure into a good state of repair at $22.4 billion, with an additional $3.7 billion investment needed annually to meet current and future needs. Municipal infrastructure accounts for nearly half of the province’s public infrastructure stock. Municipal governments have been taking on more debt; however, debt can only finance capital projects, not operating costs. Municipal operating costs are growing at $1 billion annually just to maintain current services. Costs are driven by factors such as rising insurance, electricity rates, increased demand for services, provincial legislation and areas like emergency services. However, not all municipalities—especially those with limited fiscal capacity—can afford to take on debt. The right balance of intergenerational equity is another key consideration. In this time of economic uncertainty, and recognizing the unique challenges our communities are facing, we ask the committee to review options to support municipalities through the provincial budget so that we can build a stronger Ontario together. One option would be to consider a rebate on 100% of the HST. On services where municipalities paid GST at the 5% rate, we now pay an HST at 13%. Of this tax payable, we receive a 100% rebate from the former GST of 5% and a 78% rebate on the former RST of 8%. This means there’s a portion of the tax paid on services that is not recoverable for us. Previously, there were also cases where the RST payable is there now because it’s charged through the HST at 13%, but wasn’t charged before. Examples of cases like that include: —energy—diesel, gasoline, electricity, natural gas; —conferences; —membership fees; —landscaping; —snow removal; —professional fees—legal, audit, consulting; —service contracts; and —all of those things that are contracted, like public transit services, garbage collection, security, janitorial. As much as the municipality bore no taxation liability on these items under the previous regime, an additional tax levy of 22% of the provincial portion, or about 1.76%, has become payable and added to the cost borne by every municipality. For Bonnechere Valley, in 2024, it was about $66,402, which required a 1.6% tax increase to be borne by our residents. According to the provincial summary, 1.76%, when applied to the expenses of contracts and materials on the FIRs across Ontario for all the municipalities was about $285,835,808. The province of Ontario received $3 billion more in HST revenues, net of rebates and refunds, in 2022 than in 2021. The previous annual increases were about $1.5 billion and $500 million. That’s double the revenue, and it is probable that going forward in 2023-24 and all the way up to 2025, with inflation continuing, these will again be doubled and might be as high as $6 billion. One per cent of this 2022 net HST revenue would be about $368 million, more than enough to cover the 1.76% unrebated portion paid by municipalities, or enough to implement a 1% sales tax dedicated to municipal infrastructure out of the annual increase. Other funding considerations that we would like to ensure the committee continue to support would be the Ontario Municipal Partnership Fund and the continuation of the Ontario Community Infrastructure Fund, at not less than $400 million beyond its current five-year term, which is ending in 2026, with no reductions in subsequent provincial budgets, and also that it be indexed to the Ontario Consumer Price Index on a calendar-year basis and disbursed in the first quarter of each fiscal year to municipalities. That would be a guaranteed annual envelope and allocation percentage, by municipality, to enable long-term capital planning and stable cash flow management. We also really appreciate the $77 million that the province provided last fall to offset unusually large OPP billing increases and the 11% cap on 2026 increases.
Official source