Legislative Assembly of Ontario · Committee

Wednesday, January 28, 2026

Standing Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs

The official transcript of the meeting, from Hansard, by heading. Ministers, officials and witnesses appear as the transcript names them; committees have no live transcript, so the record appears once the Assembly publishes it.

Wednesday, January 28, 2026

Read from the beginning of the meeting

Meeting ended

Ontario SPCA and Humane Society; Poverty Free Thunder Bay; Huron-Superior Regional Community of the Métis Nation of Ontario, region 4

01:34:32Official transcript

Ms. Shawna Beaulieu

Yes. That’s a prime example: Where animals are suffering, people are suffering; where people are suffering, animals are suffering, so we do need to address veterinary care access issues for people as much as animals. I think it does speak directly to that. There are all kinds of issues. I don’t have statistics that I can specifically speak about when it comes to domestic violence and animals, but it’s well known in the animal welfare community that it is an issue, that people won’t leave abusive situations because they have pets.

Official source

01:35:16Official transcript

Mr. Dave Smith

And they’re afraid that if they leave the pet behind, that the anger would be taken out on the pet.

Official source

01:35:24Official transcript

Mr. Dave Smith

Going back to your request and conversation about veterinary access here in the north, I understand the program that you’re referring to specifically was for large-animal vets because in the north we have more of a challenge with large-animal veterinarians. You did say you’re supportive of Lakehead’s initiative with a new veterinary school, but it will be years before it’s in the making. The concept behind that is very similar to FONOM’s where we know when people are trained in an area, they tend to stay in that area. Should we be looking at expanding that with vet technicians as well? Do you have a challenge with vet technicians in the north, attracting them, similar to what you are with veterinarians?

Official source

01:36:22Official transcript

Ms. Shawna Beaulieu

Yes, most certainly. The more veterinarians that will come out of that program, hopefully—we’re going to need more support staff, but there’s as much a shortage of registered veterinary technicians as there is veterinarians. Support staff could be a challenge. When we did have a full-time veterinarian, we were running a full-time clinic. Often, we would have gaps in registered veterinary technicians as far as support staff so we had to scale back our numbers of public services until we were able to fill those positions.

Official source

01:37:06Official transcript

Mr. Dave Smith

We’ve also had a request—and this is from a previous year—to expand the scope of practice for vet techs. Are there enough vet techs in the north that if we were to expand the scope of service for veterinary technicians so they could do some of the additional things that they are trained for, are there enough it would make any difference for you?

Official source

01:37:35Official transcript

Mr. Drew Woodley

I’ll jump in here. The model that the College of Veterinarians is developing around that would still tie registered veterinary technicians to a veterinarian. So, yes, they would have an expanded scope of practice, but it would still be connected to working for a veterinarian and working in a veterinary clinic where a veterinarian is present. Without that core of veterinarians in an area, the expanded scope of practice for the RVPs isn’t going to materialize because it’s not like they can roll into a town and hang up their shingle and start practising. They have to be tied to a veterinarian.

Official source

01:38:23Official transcript

Mr. Dave Smith

So, if I can summarize, there isn’t a single solution to it, this is something that is a little more complicated and just adding more vets won’t be—

Official source

01:38:35Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time. MPP Mamakwa.

Official source

01:38:40Official transcript

Mr. Sol Mamakwa

Thank you, meegwetch, to the presenters. I know there are a lot of things happening up here in the north. I know that recently there was a First Nations, specifically Nishnawbe Aski Nation, and Fort William First Nation was urging the city of Thunder Bay to declare a state of homeless emergency, especially during this cold that we just went through. I know people are dying. A lot of our constituents, members from my riding of Kiiwetinoong come to Thunder Bay. Not only that, but I think it’s important that they—I remember just a few weeks ago, there was a young lady that passed away at a bus stop because she had no home. I’m just kind of wondering, Tracey, do you support that call for the declaration of homeless emergency? But also if you can speak about the patterns of poverty in Thunder Bay. Meegwetch.

Official source

01:39:47Official transcript

Ms. Tracey MacKinnon

Thank you, MPP Mamakwa. I actually previously worked in a homeless shelter and that was the most heartbreaking job I think I’ve ever had in my life. It was this time of year and turning people away after we were maxed out was heartbreaking. I got to go home after my shift was done, and the people coming that we had to refuse had no place else to go. They wanted to come in, and we had to say, “No, we have no room. We’re at max capacity.” That was more than heartbreaking.

Official source

01:40:25Official transcript

Mr. Sol Mamakwa

Meegwetch. Also, Shawna, I just want to acknowledge and recognize the Ontario SPCA on the work that has been happening in promoting veterinary access in northern Ontario, and more specifically, in First Nation communities. I know, when I became an MPP, I didn’t realize how often I would find myself talking about veterinary services or the lack of it in the riding I represent in far northern Ontario. I’m just wondering, Shawna, if you can give us an idea of what happens in northern communities when there are no veterinary services and what the challenges look like. Meegwetch.

Official source

01:41:13Official transcript

Ms. Shawna Beaulieu

Well, the biggest challenge on the community members’ part is, like I spoke about, community health and safety. When we’re not offering spay/neuter services—and we can do that in north, and we continue to do it, but we need more veterinarians in order to do it very effectively, and that’s through MASH clinics coming in to community and offering spay/neuter services as well as vaccination services. Because when dogs aren’t altered, they’re not being spay and neutered, they do tend to pack up, there becomes an overpopulation, the dogs become aggressive, and that’s extremely dangerous for children and people in the community. As well as infectious disease—if we’re not vaccinating animals, then infectious disease becomes an issue. So that is an issue. There’s an animal welfare issue as well because if there’s an overpopulation of animals, then those animals aren’t being cared for. It’s also very difficult to even get pet food up to northern communities. That can be a challenge.

Official source

01:42:34Official transcript

Mr. Sol Mamakwa

Meegwetch. I know the extent of what happens. I remember travelling into a First Nation community, and they had a vet clinic at that time. In that community of 1,500 people, they had over 600 dogs. And I know the way they categorize that community—dogs as well—rez dogs could be stray dogs, but they also have the pets that are in the home. Also, one of the things I’ve learned about is the wild dogs. The wild dogs kind of start roaming around with the wolves, and that’s kind of scary and that’s what we’re dealing with. So I just wanted to say meegwetch for the work. Meegwetch.

Official source

01:43:24Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

We have no time left. Thank you very much. That does conclude the time for this panel. We thank all the panellists—a huge thank you for sharing your presentation with us, taking the time to prepare and the time to be here. We very much appreciate it. We look forward to using that in writing the report to bring back to the powers to be. Thank you very much for participating today. With that, the committee stands in recess until 1 p.m.

Official source

02:50:01Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Good afternoon, everyone. We’ll now resume the 2026 pre-budget consultation. As a reminder, each presenter will have seven minutes for their presentation. After we’ve heard from all three presenters, the remaining 39 minutes in this time slot will be used for questions from the members of the committee. This time for questions will be divided into two rounds of five minutes and 30 seconds for the government members, two rounds of five minutes and 30 seconds for the official opposition members, two rounds of five minutes and 30 seconds for the recognized third-party members and two rounds of three minutes for the independent member of the committee. I will provide a verbal reminder to notify you when you have one minute left for your presentation or speaking time. Please wait until you are recognized by the Chair before speaking. As always, all comments should go through the Chair. Any questions from the committee? If not, we will go to the first panel.

Official source

TakingITGlobal; North Shore Family Health Team; Thunder Bay and District Injured Workers Support Group

02:50:44Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

The first panel is TakingITGlobal, North Shore Family Health Team, and Thunder Bay and District Injured Workers Support Group. With that, you’ve heard the instructions. I will let you know we do ask each presenter, when they speak, to introduce themselves before they speak. If anyone is virtual, they also must introduce themselves when they speak so we can attribute the comments to the right people. With that, we will start with TakingITGlobal.

Official source

02:51:04Official transcript

Ms. Jennifer Corriero

Good afternoon. I’m grateful to be here. My name is Jennifer Corriero. I’m the executive director of TakingITGlobal, an Ontario-based charity that was founded in 1999, and we operate the Connected North program. We’ve been doing so for the past decade, so it’s my first decade with Connected North. I’m here today to express our sincere gratitude on behalf of 14,000 students in Ontario, 500 teachers in Ontario and 80 different schools across northern Ontario. This includes 50 public schools and 30 First Nations-operated schools that we partner with who access the Connected North program. To the government of Ontario, we thank you for your support over the past three and a half years. Connected North delivers live virtual field trips for students from kindergarten up to grade 12. We link these live experiences to the Ontario curriculum. These experiences are with galleries, museums, science centres, cultural centres, the Canadian space station, dentists. We have such a range of topics across every subject area. We work with 450 content providers—125 are based here in Ontario—and we pay per session. We send little science kits or art kits so that there are hands-on activities for students to access learning that would otherwise not be possible where they live. This also includes musical instruments, financial literacy sessions. We’ve been recognized by groups like the Canadian Association of Science Centres, by the United Nations World Summit on the Information Society—the only Canadian organization out of 1,000 globally selected in the e-learning category, so we’re making Ontario proud as an Ontario-based charity. We feature career options for students so that all students—with a focus on First Nation, Inuit and Métis students—can see different career options featuring people in different careers, including the trades, being a banker, being an entrepreneur. We’re featuring Indigenous excellence through our platform. This year, Connected North is seeking to expand support from the government of Ontario through a multi-year agreement of $975,000 per year each year for the next three years, as we have had to ask for annual funding over the past three years. This multi-year funding would allow us to have continuity of access, improve efficiencies and ensure that we maintain the momentum and trust with our community partners and strong track record rooted in respect. This renewed support will allow us to build a healthy homegrown economy. Our programs have a strong track record, and we look forward to sharing more of those details with you. I would like to now introduce a senior member of our staff, Jennifer Manitowabi, who will share a first-hand account from her experience with the program.

Official source

02:53:06Official transcript

Ms. Jennifer Manitowabi

Boozhoo. My name is Jennifer Manitowabi. I live and work remotely in Obishikokaang First Nation. I am deeply passionate about teaching and helping educators deliver dynamic learning opportunities for the students in Ontario schools. I am proud to work with Connected North, a virtual learning platform that provides access to education for students in remote communities across Canada. Connected North provides a vital connection to educational opportunities, from the science involved in working with the structures of beadwork, the math involved in birchbark and the levels of literacy it demands to become a published author. My personal favourite lessons involve hide tanning, traditional dancing and storytelling. It is a learning platform that enriches our students’ cultural understanding and provides support for their progress through K-to-12, and this can prepare them for a bright future. Many of our students are among the hardest to reach in Ontario. These communities might be accessed only by plane or winter road, and the opportunities that students access through Connected North are vital for their mental health. For students in rural communities, it is difficult for educators in the classroom to help our young people prepare for life beyond school and expose them to a wide range of job opportunities that they could have. I want to share a student success story. It comes from our provider, Kokom Scrunchies. During a Connected North session, 13-year-old Mya teaches students about how she started her own business, how she continues to gain resources and expands the future economy. When students see this, they too have the courage to better themselves. Through Connected North, they are able to use their skills and talents to imagine themselves as entrepreneurs and help Ontario thrive. The virtual sessions are delivered by Connected North and have grown into a movement that inspires each student we reach. At Connected North, we know that an integrated approach to learning is essential to realizing a prosperous future in Canada, where students can be inspired to learn and grow in all subjects.

Official source

02:54:41Official transcript

Ms. Jennifer Manitowabi

Over the past 10 years, Connected North has established a network of teachers—Anishinaabe knowledge keepers—and students have gone on to do amazing things. It has been a privilege to witness how our students have thrived as a result of these opportunities. Thank you.

Official source

02:54:53Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Is that it? Very good. Thank you very much for that presentation. Our next presenter will be North Shore Family Health Team. The floor is yours.

Official source

02:55:00Official transcript

Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell

Okay. Good afternoon and thank you for the opportunity to speak today. My name is Mary Lynn Dingwell and I’m the executive director of the North Shore Family Health Team, serving the communities of Terrace Bay, Schreiber and Pays Plat First Nation. Joining me virtually are colleagues from family health teams across the northwest. We share similar concerns of each of our northern communities having unique struggles. Trena is from Manitouwadge, Michèle from Marathon; Melissa from Nipigon, Shannon from Greenstone and Jennifer from Vermillion Bay. My family health team turns 20 in April. It started with an early win for an NP, as we were short a physician in our communities. My communities, as with my virtual colleagues’ communities, are funded under a RNPGA model. We were funded for four physicians, but we only had three. For several years when the family health team and the physician complement were full, we were able to offer a wide range of programs and services, including access appointments with the NP or physician. In the last five to six years, we’ve struggled to fill family health team and physician positions, and can no longer offer access appointments with primary care practitioners. This places extra strain on the physicians, as people will go to the emergency department, which, under RNPGA, is stocked by the same primary care physicians. The role of the family health team differs in rural northern communities. We end up being the catch-all, as community members look to us to provide the services that other organisations would provide in urban areas. We do this because these are our communities. The patients are our families, friends and neighbours, and if we didn’t offer the service, they would have to travel to Thunder Bay. It took me almost three hours to get here today, driving. Family health teams in RNPGA communities will provide service to all community members, regardless of attachment. RNPGA communities differ, as the same physician provides primary care, hospital care and 24/7 emergency access. In our rural communities, we see everyone. Their records are in our EMR, but they may be waiting a long time to see a provider, and they may not have a consistent provider, as we have sporadic locum coverage when we are short providers. The two biggest challenges we as EDs face in the north are not being funded for the number of staff needed to take care of the health needs of our communities, and difficulty recruiting or retaining staff as other organizations such as hospitals provide better compensation. By not funding the needed resources for primary care teams, you risk people not receiving preventative care, disease not being identified early and chronic disease not being managed regularly, which leads to an increased cost as people either need more specialized care in Thunder Bay or are hospitalized locally, which places more strain on the local physicians. In 2024-25, my four allied health care professionals provided service to over 1,236 unique patients. What we are asking for is that the province immediately release the remaining $115 million in committed workforce funding. This already-budgeted investment supports the invisible team: nurses, social workers, dietitians, other allied health care professionals and administrative staff who enable family physicians and nurse practitioners to practise at full scope and care for more patients. No new immediate funds are required. Releasing this funding will prevent further attrition and stabilize teams before the next expansion wave. Ontario should invest $430 million over five years to close the structural compensation gap. The 2025 funding provided for recruitment and retention was a 2.7% increase when it had been more than five years since the last increase. That remains a persistent 15% to 30% structural wage gap that must be addressed to stem the tide of staff burnout. This investment will align with primary care compensation and market rates, attract family physicians, nurse practitioners and allied health care professionals into team-based practice where attachment capacity is highest and enable new teams to become operational quickly and sustainably. We are asking for a shift to global budget for family health teams. This would allow family health teams greater flexibility, which is especially important in the north where we have difficulty filling leaves such as maternity leaves. It would provide more flexibility to work with our OHT partners in response to the needs of our communities, and it would support succession planning, as currently there is no funding in our HR budgets for succession planning. We would like the ability for small teams to carry over a small set amount of money. This would support succession planning so that new allied health care and executive directors are supported in the transition. My one NP had to retire before the new NP could start. There is no money in our budget for ED succession planning. We’re not able to mentor new leaders. We ask that the government be cognizant of the fact that some family health teams have only one manager, who is the executive director and who also may have HR, IT or building crises, and unnecessary or last-minute reporting interferes with the patient care. Lastly, we’ll always accept money, but money provided at the beginning of the fiscal will help ensure that the money is used in the most strategic manner possible. I have some stories to share. Both Michèle and Shannon have lost NPs to the hospital, which provides higher compensation. Shannon wants to hire an RN and pay for their training to become an NP, but no one will accept the position. Every one of us here today has had a position open in the last two years for at least three months, some for the whole two years—not a big deal in urban areas where those positions are one of many, but a very big deal in our rural communities where they’re one of one: one social worker, one NP, one dietitian and one reception. Many of our communities have an NP or physician position that they can’t fill. I had a social worker who we thought would take over the executive director role when I retire. Unfortunately, she left for a different position in our communities that allows her the opportunity to be a middle manager, a pay increase from her social work position and compensation that is close to mine but without the responsibility. I am Mary Lynn Dingwell, the executive director for the North Shore Family Health Team, and 30 years ago I accepted a position in health care after the organization used the metaphorical story of the river: instead of pulling people out of the river downstream, preventing them from getting into the river upstream.

Official source

03:00:01Official transcript

Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell

After over 30 years in health care, I still see most funds falling into the downstream organizations. We are AFHTO members across Ontario. We use our expertise and drive to keep people out of the river, but we’re limited by the concerns I’ve discussed. We need you, the funders, to address these concerns and to join us to deliver on this historic opportunity to radically change health care. Thank you for your time.

Official source

03:00:46Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much for the presentation. We now will go to the Thunder Bay and District Injured Workers Support Group.

Official source

03:00:58Official transcript

Mr. Teddy Bobrowski

Do we have Eugene on Zoom? The vice-president of the injured workers group—he’s supposed to speak first.

Official source

03:01:10Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Well, we haven’t got him on, so you get to speak first.

Official source

03:01:16Official transcript

Mr. Teddy Bobrowski

I guess it’s me, then. Hopefully he’ll join us before I finish. Nice to see you all here today. This is my first time doing something like this. My name is Theodore Edward Bobrowski, but you can call me Teddy. I’m a long-time injured worker; 35 years I’ve been an injured worker, or 36 years now. I just turned 66 in December. The reason I’ve come and the reason I’m speaking is on behalf of injured workers. There has been a lot of misinformation about injured workers and the WSIB and I’m here to enlighten you as to what is really happening with injured workers. When I first hurt myself in 1990, I went off on compensation for eight months and I missed a doctor’s appointment and I was cut off. I was forced to return to work on painkillers. I had my doctor write a letter for me, at my request, so I could return to work, because I was losing everything. I ended up having a second injury in 1993 and was off work for another four months and I was cut off again by compensation—no explanation. I worked with the Worker Adviser of Ontario for the next seven years to get reinstated. The day I got reinstated for compensation benefits was in 2000—the summer of 2000. I had lost everything that I had worked my whole life for, up to that point. I was a homeowner. I was a business owner. I was a real estate owner. I lost everything. I ended up drug-addicted, homeless and suicidal. This is the true story of WSIB. This is what injured workers with complex or hard-to-prove injuries—it took me six years to get an MRI, and it was done through my own family doctor, not through WSIB. I ended up with a permanent psychological disability for what compensation put me through. I don’t want to see that happen to others anymore and it’s still happening today. I am not a one-off; I’m the 10%. Some 10% of injured workers—this is just a rough number, it’s not exact. But approximately, and there’s a small percentage, 10%—which is not actually a small number when you think how many thousands of injured workers there actually are just here in Ontario and that’s all I’m talking about. This is not just an Ontario problem, it’s not just a Canada problem; it’s a worldwide problem. Some countries don’t even have compensation for injured workers and if you seriously hurt yourself, you end up on the streets. You end up being a beggar. The day that I got reinstated was the day I was going to kill myself. I had a plan and I was going to do it, but before I did it, I thought, “I’m going to go down to the WSIB office in person and demand answers.” So I showed up on their doorstep. I got reinstated that very day for my benefits, after 10 years of fighting. I was living on $110 a month. That’s what I was getting in compensation. I was a construction worker, a labourer. I made good money. I lost everything and that’s why I’m here today, to fight for others and speak on behalf of others. WSIB has returned billions—billions; that’s with a B, not a M—billions of dollars to companies and corporations, off the backs of injured workers, off the 10% of injured workers with long-term, complex injuries. They’re denying, they’re deeming and they’re cutting people off, and people are forced to find their own way. Sir William Meredith wrote the five principles of the Meredith Act, which is going for second reading in the House. I believe Lise Vaugeois will be bringing that forward and—

Official source

03:07:20Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Your co-presenter is now on the line. You can carry on. The time belongs to both of you.

Official source

03:07:37Official transcript

Mr. Teddy Bobrowski

I’m going to wrap it up quickly. There’s so much I want to say and there’s so much that needs to be said, but I’m going to give the last two minutes to Eugene. He is the president of the local injured workers’ group here in Thunder Bay. I’m also on the board for injured workers here in Thunder Bay. I’m also on the board for ONIWG, which is the Ontario network of injured workers, and I’m also on the board for speakers’ school in Thunder Bay, which has helped me to do this, what I’m doing here today. It’s a spinoff of injured workers. The billions of dollars that are being returned to companies and corporations off the backs of injured workers is a shame and a sham. I see people; I run a peer support group every Wednesday—I ran it this morning. I took everybody to the casino for breakfast and bought them breakfast. But there are a lot of people, injured workers like myself, that are suffering. I got cut off at 65; I no longer have benefits from WSIB. My injuries didn’t go away. I thought at 65 I would be healed because WSIB cut me off. I assumed my injuries would leave; they didn’t. I still have them and I live with them every day, but I’m no longer compensated for them. That’s what the system was set up to do: compensate for our injuries. I’m going to now allow Eugene to speak for the last little bit.

Official source

03:10:00Official transcript

Mr. Eugene Lefrancois

Welcome to the 1850 Robinson treaty area, my area. First, I’ve got to say, WSIB is not using tax money. For some reason, Ford announced that he’s given away $2 billion of tax money. Tell him to stop. You guys don’t even know where your money is coming from. I’ve been saying this for the last 10 years. You have to support Lise Vaugeois’s private member’s bill, the Meredith Act. If you want to be fair to workers, there you go. We’re talking billions. If you’re financial, can you get the people in the Premier’s office to stop using WSIB as an election tool? Because that’s what—$10 billion? Stop that. You hide behind policy, not laws, because then it can circumvent the Legislature. That is fair, right? I would love to have said more, but Ted is good.

Official source

03:11:04Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time for the presentation, and maybe we can get more of it in in the question period. That concludes the panel presentations. We’ll start the first round of questions with the government. MPP Dowie.

Official source

03:11:24Official transcript

Mr. Andrew Dowie

Thank you to all the presenters for being here. My first question is for Jennifer. Thank you so much for being here. I think I was able to take a fulsome trip to northern Ontario, probably for the first time, maybe just two years ago, realizing access to the things that we take for granted in the south just doesn’t exist. You don’t have a cell signal. You don’t have WiFi. You’ve got very, very limited access to technology. So, if we’re going to unlock the opportunities of the north, ensure that youth have the opportunity to make a great career right at home, we do need access to technology in northern Ontario, so I certainly commend you for the work that you’ve done and calling attention to this. So I wanted to better understand some of the barriers to access to technology that exist that you’re trying to remedy. Obviously, I know we are engaged on bringing broadband in, but some areas can’t. Satellite is not quite an option these days; hopefully it will be soon when we maybe have a domestic supplier. But I’m hoping you might be able to elaborate on what’s needed to get us to where our northern communities will truly be in a position to thrive.

Official source

03:13:01Official transcript

Ms. Jennifer Corriero

Yes, thank you for the question and focus on technology. I’ve been an advocate on access to technology since I started the charity in the early days of the Internet. Sometimes when we talk about access to technology there is a focus on the hardware or the software or the Internet connectivity. What I would also argue is it’s about meaningful content and that sense of community. So Cisco, which is the technology company that actually started the Connected North program in 2013, invested significantly in looking at the infrastructure that would be required for the high-definition video conferencing, and then they transferred the program to our charity. They responded to the call from our current Governor General, the Honourable Mary Simon, back when she was president of Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami, looking at the high suicide rates in Nunavut, Inuit Nunangat in general. Our program focuses on the content, and the prerequisite is high-speed Internet, is two-way video conferencing like what we’re experiencing now for this meeting for those who are not able to be here in the room, and to ensure strong representation, especially for our Indigenous students, to see themselves reflected in successful ways across all the subject areas. So through technology, students are able to travel places that might cost over $50,000 for them to travel, or just to rent a bus for the day it could be $600. So, yes, I can’t really comment on satellite versus bandwidth, because you probably have teams that know the infrastructure gaps better. But the investments that are being made are creating increased access, which is growing our waiting list of schools.

Official source

03:15:22Official transcript

Mr. Andrew Dowie

Yes, I do. Thank you, Chair. I do have a follow-up. Thank you for that, Jennifer. Just in terms of your organization and what you see as best practices that you’ve learned, we want to always make sure that we’re doing the right thing. So the outcomes that we’re able to measure, the kinds of skills that we’re able to see in youth—what are some results that you’ve seen from the efforts that your organization has put into improving this access?

Official source

03:15:59Official transcript

Ms. Jennifer Corriero

Thank you for the question. Carleton University has just completed—and we published this on our website—a one-year intensive evaluation. The methodology was called a contribution analysis. They studied our theory of change. They conducted interviews with teachers and with our content providers, and they looked at the student surveys as well as teacher surveys. The results are extremely positive and sound. I’ll give you some specific numbers: —96% of teachers feel that sessions—that would be live virtual field trips, all within an hour. The teacher is still in class; the virtual guest is facilitating as an instructor;

Official source

03:16:53Official transcript

Ms. Jennifer Corriero

—96% of teachers feel that it improves attendance and motivation for learning; —93% of teachers agreed the program affirms student identities and sense of pride in who they are; —89% of teachers are more confident using technology; and —96% of teachers say sessions spark curiosity and learning, so students want to learn more.

Official source

03:17:23Official transcript

Mr. Andrew Dowie

Thirty-three seconds? Okay. Jennifer, one final question for you: We see cyber security as a big issue. Student privacy is almost certainly paramount. We want their futures to be bright and not tarred with impacts. So do you have any recommendations for building on that?

Official source

03:17:45Official transcript

Ms. Jennifer Corriero

Absolutely. A lot of public school boards are suing social media companies, for example, because there’s nothing regulated. Everything we do is pre-screened; live monitoring support; we promote healthy cyber security skills with students. So we need to build skills.

Official source

03:18:08Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time. We’ll now go to MPP Vaugeois.

Official source

03:18:14Official transcript

MPP Lise Vaugeois

I’m hoping to get to both the family health team and to the injured workers in this round. Mary Lynn, actually, about your travel time: There was an accident on Highway 11/17 that just happened in the last hour, so the highway is closed west of Ignace 55 kilometres. I’m glad it only took you three hours to get here today and that the highway was open. I know that that 2.7% increase that you just got, which just doesn’t meet inflation, has come after a long many years without any increase whatsoever. Is that correct?

Official source

03:18:58Official transcript

MPP Lise Vaugeois

Also, you’re dealing with a lack of equitable pay, people doing the same kind of work for family health teams but paid quite a bit less than people doing that work in hospitals. I know in the official opposition, we feel that it’s very, very important that those pay rates need to be made equitable and consistent regardless of where you are working. Perhaps you could come back to us a little bit about the kind of stresses it creates on your institutions. But it also creates conflict within communities when hospitals then poach the people that you’ve brought because they can pay more, but you need your work to done also in your family health teams.

Official source

03:20:00Official transcript

Ms. Shannon Kristjanson

Okay. Thanks, Lise. Yes, I’ve been struggling with this for quite a few years now. Just a quick example: I am funded for four nurse practitioner positions. Those nurse practitioners would be the MRP for patients, which means they’re the most responsible provider. They would take care of all of their health care. I only have one of those positions filled at the moment, and actually, for the last couple of years, I’ve only had one of those positions filled. The hospital, which is in the same parking lot as where we are—you can make around $40 an hour more as a nurse practitioner at the hospital. So it’s really difficult to recruit or retain almost all of the positions in health care in the north, but specifically nurse practitioners, just because of the pay difference. It’s huge; it’s very significant. Just to speak a little bit to the internal conflict that it causes: We’re a very small group. We have to work with each other everyday in health care in these small, rural communities, and it does cause conflict when one agency is really struggling and another agency is able to have a lot of resources, because they’re able to offer a much higher pay.

Official source

03:21:20Official transcript

Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell

Yes, and it’s not just allied health care professionals as well. Jennifer just lost her reception to the Ontario health team and Melissa is always on pins and needles, because her reception is very good and could get higher funding elsewhere, so she is always trying to bend over backwards for her. Just for the financial part: I actually started as a social worker in 2006, and if you look up until the last increase, out of that whole time, it would’ve equaled a 0.63% increase per year when I look back on the numbers. That’s for the social work position with a family health team. The last increase increased that by another 2.7%.

Official source

03:22:04Official transcript

MPP Lise Vaugeois

Thank you. We’ll come back in the next round. Teddy, I wonder if you can explain to people, what does deeming do? What is deeming under the current WSIA and why is it such a big problem?

Official source

03:22:17Official transcript

Mr. Teddy Bobrowski

Deeming is a nightmare for injured workers, and it should be illegal. It was brought before the United Nations, I believe, and found to be not worthy of what they’re doing—they said it shouldn’t be being done. So it’s still happening. When it happened with injured workers, they tell the injured worker they have a job that doesn’t exist, and they cut their benefits by minimum wage. So if someone is earning $20 an hour and their benefits will be reduced by that amount of money.

Official source

03:22:51Official transcript

Mr. Teddy Bobrowski

So if minimum wage is $17-something an hour now, that’s how much your benefits would be reduced by. You only get 85% of your net and then reduce that by minimum wage. People are existing on nothing. It’s not worth it. People are turning to OW and ODSP, which is taxpayer-based, and it’s letting companies and corporations off the hook. By deeming somebody, they say that you have a job. So here in Thunder Bay, they might say you might be a parking lot attendant. Does anybody know of any parking lot attendant jobs here in Thunder Bay?

Official source

03:23:28Official transcript

Mr. Teddy Bobrowski

There are none. A Walmart greeter—they don’t hire disabled people at Walmart; they only hire internally. So that job doesn’t exist as well. But they will cut you benefits, saying that you have a full-time job that doesn’t even exist.

Official source

03:23:44Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time for that question. MPP Fairclough.

Official source

03:23:50Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

Thank you to all of you that have made time to come and talk to us today. I will be asking questions of all three of the presentations over the course of my two time slots. I am going to start with you, Mary Lynn. Thank you for travelling three hours here today to come to talk to us. I really appreciated your very specific asks of what you feel like you need to be able to deliver effective primary care in the north. One of the things that really struck me—and I would say, some of what you ask for echoed what we heard from the Timmins Family Health Team yesterday as well; very similar. But you’ve made this comment about how it’s time to shift to global budgets for family health teams, especially up here, especially knowing that people who are working in the hospital are really all the care that’s available in town. Can you talk a bit more about why that would be an advantage, what flexibility it might give you and how would you ensure you’d still be able to be accountable to meeting the needs of people’s health care in the community with that model?

Official source

03:25:04Official transcript

Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell

Michèle and I both sit on our hospital boards, for NOSH, and we see the difference between the flexibility that the hospital has to respond to the needs of the communities, but then also the people that are available to hire in the communities. They have the flexibility to do that. I lost my social worker. We have somebody in the community who is trained in palliative care. She’s an RN. We wanted to hire her. I had to get permission from Ontario Health to hire her. We are hiring her part-time because she’s already on a contract until the end of March, so I had to put in a request to hire her part-time and then a social worker virtually part-time. We would never see that at our hospitals. They would never have to go through that process, so I think that’s just a simple example of that. Melissa has a receptionist who does so much more than reception and she is not able to pay her more out of her operational budget to make her an admin assistant. We don’t have the flexibility to do that.

Official source

03:26:13Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

Before I became an MPP, I was the president of a hospital. I’ve worked around health care a lot of years, 27 years, and I’ve often wondered this: How do we give more flexibility in the way we can use the investments that being made to meet the needs of people in the community. I was really pleased to hear you actually articulate that today and some of the advantages.

Official source

03:26:38Official transcript

Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell

Our family health teams have boards of directors, so we are doing what’s in the best interest of our communities.

Official source

03:26:46Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

I really agree with you on that. I wanted to also just ask—you talked about releasing the workforce funding. We heard that yesterday, too. Again, can you highlight how you’d use that today, if there was that release?

Official source

03:27:01Official transcript

Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell

What we actually did with my family health team, our board gave us an extra 1% increase over the 2.7% just to do a little bit of stabilization for us. That has made people happy, so they want to stay little more in their positions. But if we have that funding now, we are giving them more than a 2.7% increase, which is not comparable to the hospital and other sectors, but it’s better than 2.7%.

Official source

03:27:28Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

My next question—I find sometimes people worry that we are not as creative as we should be in our publicly funded health system, but in my experience, particularly people working in the north come up with some of the most creative solutions, actually, to develop systems of care etc. Do any of you want to highlight something that you have done, that you’re particularly proud of, to creatively address some of the challenges that you’ve got of delivering care in the north?

Official source

03:28:01Official transcript

Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell

Yes, we can highlight a lot. Trena’s family health team is part of the hospital. Trena, you can explain that. Before you do that, Michèle, Shannon and I are in very different communities where we’re a few hours apart, but we share IT, we share a quality improvement decision support specialist that helps us. She works remotely, our IT works remotely, so we’ve become creative in how we share resources.

Official source

03:28:30Official transcript

Ms. Trena Roberts

Here in Manitouwadge, we are unique in that we’re integrated with our hospital, so with the shortage of funding that we’ve had, we are able to share resources such as IT, HR, maintenance, cleaning. That has helped us be able to maintain our budget without going into a deficit at this time.

Official source

03:28:50Official transcript

Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell

Michèle works really closely with the physician groups, as well. They do a lot of shared programming and students, and you could speak more to that, Michèle.

Official source

03:29:01Official transcript

Ms. Michèle Lajeunesse

[Inaudible] NOSM University so we often have our students working here with us. We also accept placement students as part of our Marathon Family Health Team, so we do a lot of that work. Something that I’ll highlight, too, which has helped with recruitment and retention, that we’ve done in the past few years is incorporate a compressed workweek. Our workers—

Official source

03:29:26Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time We will now go to MPP Sarrazin.

Official source

03:29:31Official transcript

Mr. Stéphane Sarrazin

Thank you to all of you for being here today. It’s always a good opportunity for us to understand better. I will start, I guess, with Mary Lynn. I’m just trying to understand, now that we’re talking about the North Shore Family Health Team—so there’s actually multiple clinics? Can you explain how many physicians you have and how many nurse practitioners? Is it all the same team, or it’s different locations?

Official source

03:30:00Official transcript

Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell

So, with all of us, we’re all in different communities. We’re all different teams. We all are unique family health teams. My community is three hours away. Michèle is an hour past me. Trena is an hour past her. Shannon is the other way, and Jennifer is up to the west. So we’re all different. My family health team supports two doctors’ clinics. One is funded for two and one is funded for two and a half physicians. Each of us support the doctors’ clinics in our communities. All of our communities are funded for physicians to be RNPGA model.

Official source

03:30:41Official transcript

Mr. Stéphane Sarrazin

If it wouldn’t be for a recruitment problem, you would each have many more physicians at each location? I’m just trying to understand how many patients you serve and how many patients you’ve got on a waiting list. I’m just curious, because I know, in my area, I’ve got some stats, and we’ve heard a lot about different health teams—just out of curiosity.

Official source

03:31:08Official transcript

Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell

I’ll speak for my community really quickly. We have 3,000 patients. Our physicians do everything in the community. There’s no wait-list; there’s nobody waiting for attachment, because we see everybody. So if they can’t get in to see a physician, they might see the RN for diabetes. But the wait time is a long time. Trena’s community and Shannon’s community are even—we’re short two physicians; they’re short a lot more. So Geraldton and Manitouwadge have even more of a struggle to get physicians. I’ll let them speak quickly about their population and their physicians. Trena?

Official source

03:31:53Official transcript

Ms. Trena Roberts

Here in Manitouwadge, we have about 2,000. We are funded for three physicians, and we only had one permanent physician for the last 20 months, who does the primary care, the emerg department, long-term care, hospitalist and also is our chief of staff. We have been in a predicament for, like I said, 20 months, trying to do locums, which has been a challenge.

Official source

03:32:21Official transcript

Ms. Shannon Kristjanson

We’re also part of an RNPGA group. We are funded for seven physicians; we currently have three full-time physicians. We’ve never had even close to our complement. If you look at our whole primary care situation, we have about an 80% vacancy. When you think about that, we’re the same as Mary Lynn, where we just see anybody. We don’t necessarily have to roster patients; we just see them if they’re in the community. However, that doesn’t mean that everybody is rostered. We have about 4,000 people in our community, and we have hundreds and hundreds—probably over a couple of thousand—of people that, at any time, might not be rostered because we just don’t have enough primary care providers to roster them.

Official source

03:33:18Official transcript

Ms. Michèle Lajeunesse

Yes. We are funded for seven physicians; we currently have six. We also have an NP position that has been vacant for 19 months now. One thing I’ll highlight too: that physician recruitment is a challenge, but it’s the family health team and as well as the other administrative support that supports that physician group. So if we want to attract physicians to work in our communities and in affiliation with our family health teams, it’s really beneficial to fund family health teams appropriately, because we are the ones who allow physicians to be working at their full scope, attach more patients and increase their capacity. Without adequately funded family health teams and interdisciplinary care providers, it’s really difficult for us to retain positions. So these two issues are very closely linked.

Official source

03:34:25Official transcript

Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell

—but the NP and the other allied health care. Jennifer, I know your physician is going to retire soon.

Official source

03:34:33Official transcript

Ms. Jennifer Loewen

Yes. Thank you. Yes, we have a long-standing physician who has worked in our community for approximately 36 years who is getting ready to retire. We are having a difficult time recruiting that position. Again, I totally agree with Michèle: The work that the NPs, the RNs and all of the other allied health care professionals do supports that physician. They see that when they come and do site visits. Again, even our admin staff—our receptionist, our clerical—the work that’s being done from all of those positions to support the team is incredible. To lose them, yes, it’s very stressful. We have a really great team, a really great community. We just want to keep providing that service, and hoping that we can recruit the team and retain the staff that we do have. It’s—

Official source

03:35:32Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time. We’ll now go to MPP Mamakwa.

Official source

03:35:38Official transcript

Mr. Sol Mamakwa

Meegwetch, Chair. Meegwetch, thank you, to the presenters: the two Jennifers from TakingITGlobal; but also the North Shore Family Health Team, certainly Mary Lynn, Michèle, Melissa, Jennifer, Shannon and Trena; and also Eugene and Teddy from Thunder Bay and District Injured Workers Support. I think what I’m hearing from the North Shore Family Health Team is that the team that you have is a very team-based care, that is underfunded. It sounds like a very good program. For a number of years before I became an MPP, I did health administration and health policy, and I understand how it works, where you have to provide need-based care. I think, especially in more of the rural areas in northern Ontario, there should be no way where the people in the north should go through this, trying to provide access to health care in these areas. So I again implore the government members here to, again, start looking at—you cannot forget the north. You cannot forget who we are. Just because we are from the north does not mean that we should not have access to the equitable health care that is there. Also, again, TakingITGlobal: I want to acknowledge but also recognize the importance of working with youth, students—and especially students and youth from northern communities. I know we face a gap in educational equity for students in northern Ontario, and I believe what I heard is that is what Connected North is helping to address. Just a very quick question: What is your vision for Connected North?

Official source

03:37:33Official transcript

Ms. Jennifer Corriero

Thank you. I’ll answer, and, Jennifer, I’ll give you the floor. Lifting the aspirations of students—you know, we’re hearing about gaps in different fields—and inspiring future nurses, future teachers, future politicians, future entrepreneurs, and giving those pathways and being able to respond to the need. I fly to Marten Falls First Nation in just a few hours. They were on our waiting list for two years a year ago, and we were able to get them started with accessing the program. It’s just that sense of belonging for students. Jennifer?

Official source

03:38:14Official transcript

Ms. Jennifer Manitowabi

I drive right to Geraldton after this meeting as well. Our vision for Connected North is to expose students to opportunities that they would not see otherwise, like eye dissections, squid dissections. These sciences, this is what will get them to NOSM, and that is my vision. Meegwetch.

Official source

03:38:36Official transcript

Mr. Sol Mamakwa

I know that we will be on the road either today or tomorrow, but I know that my colleagues will be flying to Sudbury. One of the things I guess I want to ask the North Shore Family Health Team: I know the underfunding—is there a certain amount that you’re asking for to address the issue that you’re facing today?

Official source