Ms. Mary Lynn Dingwell
Okay. Good afternoon and thank you for the opportunity to speak today. My name is Mary Lynn Dingwell and I’m the executive director of the North Shore Family Health Team, serving the communities of Terrace Bay, Schreiber and Pays Plat First Nation. Joining me virtually are colleagues from family health teams across the northwest. We share similar concerns of each of our northern communities having unique struggles. Trena is from Manitouwadge, Michèle from Marathon; Melissa from Nipigon, Shannon from Greenstone and Jennifer from Vermillion Bay. My family health team turns 20 in April. It started with an early win for an NP, as we were short a physician in our communities. My communities, as with my virtual colleagues’ communities, are funded under a RNPGA model. We were funded for four physicians, but we only had three. For several years when the family health team and the physician complement were full, we were able to offer a wide range of programs and services, including access appointments with the NP or physician. In the last five to six years, we’ve struggled to fill family health team and physician positions, and can no longer offer access appointments with primary care practitioners. This places extra strain on the physicians, as people will go to the emergency department, which, under RNPGA, is stocked by the same primary care physicians. The role of the family health team differs in rural northern communities. We end up being the catch-all, as community members look to us to provide the services that other organisations would provide in urban areas. We do this because these are our communities. The patients are our families, friends and neighbours, and if we didn’t offer the service, they would have to travel to Thunder Bay. It took me almost three hours to get here today, driving. Family health teams in RNPGA communities will provide service to all community members, regardless of attachment. RNPGA communities differ, as the same physician provides primary care, hospital care and 24/7 emergency access. In our rural communities, we see everyone. Their records are in our EMR, but they may be waiting a long time to see a provider, and they may not have a consistent provider, as we have sporadic locum coverage when we are short providers. The two biggest challenges we as EDs face in the north are not being funded for the number of staff needed to take care of the health needs of our communities, and difficulty recruiting or retaining staff as other organizations such as hospitals provide better compensation. By not funding the needed resources for primary care teams, you risk people not receiving preventative care, disease not being identified early and chronic disease not being managed regularly, which leads to an increased cost as people either need more specialized care in Thunder Bay or are hospitalized locally, which places more strain on the local physicians. In 2024-25, my four allied health care professionals provided service to over 1,236 unique patients. What we are asking for is that the province immediately release the remaining $115 million in committed workforce funding. This already-budgeted investment supports the invisible team: nurses, social workers, dietitians, other allied health care professionals and administrative staff who enable family physicians and nurse practitioners to practise at full scope and care for more patients. No new immediate funds are required. Releasing this funding will prevent further attrition and stabilize teams before the next expansion wave. Ontario should invest $430 million over five years to close the structural compensation gap. The 2025 funding provided for recruitment and retention was a 2.7% increase when it had been more than five years since the last increase. That remains a persistent 15% to 30% structural wage gap that must be addressed to stem the tide of staff burnout. This investment will align with primary care compensation and market rates, attract family physicians, nurse practitioners and allied health care professionals into team-based practice where attachment capacity is highest and enable new teams to become operational quickly and sustainably. We are asking for a shift to global budget for family health teams. This would allow family health teams greater flexibility, which is especially important in the north where we have difficulty filling leaves such as maternity leaves. It would provide more flexibility to work with our OHT partners in response to the needs of our communities, and it would support succession planning, as currently there is no funding in our HR budgets for succession planning. We would like the ability for small teams to carry over a small set amount of money. This would support succession planning so that new allied health care and executive directors are supported in the transition. My one NP had to retire before the new NP could start. There is no money in our budget for ED succession planning. We’re not able to mentor new leaders. We ask that the government be cognizant of the fact that some family health teams have only one manager, who is the executive director and who also may have HR, IT or building crises, and unnecessary or last-minute reporting interferes with the patient care. Lastly, we’ll always accept money, but money provided at the beginning of the fiscal will help ensure that the money is used in the most strategic manner possible. I have some stories to share. Both Michèle and Shannon have lost NPs to the hospital, which provides higher compensation. Shannon wants to hire an RN and pay for their training to become an NP, but no one will accept the position. Every one of us here today has had a position open in the last two years for at least three months, some for the whole two years—not a big deal in urban areas where those positions are one of many, but a very big deal in our rural communities where they’re one of one: one social worker, one NP, one dietitian and one reception. Many of our communities have an NP or physician position that they can’t fill. I had a social worker who we thought would take over the executive director role when I retire. Unfortunately, she left for a different position in our communities that allows her the opportunity to be a middle manager, a pay increase from her social work position and compensation that is close to mine but without the responsibility. I am Mary Lynn Dingwell, the executive director for the North Shore Family Health Team, and 30 years ago I accepted a position in health care after the organization used the metaphorical story of the river: instead of pulling people out of the river downstream, preventing them from getting into the river upstream.
Official source