Legislative Assembly of Ontario · Committee

Wednesday, August 12, 2026

Standing Committee on the Interior

The official transcript of the meeting, from Hansard, by heading. Ministers, officials and witnesses appear as the transcript names them; committees have no live transcript, so the record appears once the Assembly publishes it.

Wednesday, August 12, 2026

Read from the beginning of the meeting

Meeting ended

Ontario Veterinary Medical Association; Triple A Cheese Ltd.; Perth County Beef Farmers

00:23:50Official transcript

Mr. Joost van der Heiden

Some of the vets that are available in northern Ontario already work for the government in the form of the animal welfare services or inspections in livestock areas. If we can access and make use of their services on a part-time basis and provide more care in the north—because we are so limited in the number of vets that can actually practise in the north. The challenges of the north are, too, that because of distance, the veterinarian can maybe make five calls a day in the north, compared to veterinary down in this area can make 20 or 30 calls in a day and actually make a decent living.

Official source

00:24:28Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

And that’s the mobile part of being able to take it on the road. Typically, you don’t take to a facility, do you? Is most large-animal vet care on premises? You can educate me on that.

Official source

00:24:40Official transcript

Mr. Joost van der Heiden

In most cases, especially if the clinic is not set up for it, the veterinarian will visit the animal in question on the farm. Here in southwestern Ontario, sometimes we can bring animals to a clinic and they can be treated there. But most practically, and to reduce the stress on the animal, it’s normally better to do it on the farm than it would be to load an animal and transport them when they need care.

Official source

00:25:07Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

Okay. And then, I guess I wanted to take your comments to John Stevens. Hello. Hi there. What are your thoughts on what we just heard with dealing with vet care in the north and that proposal?

Official source

00:25:19Official transcript

Mr. John Stevens

I mean, we’re all here to discuss access to care, and I think one of the items to highlight at the beginning is the changing nature of access-to-care challenges. We’re talking both the large-animal and, of course, on our side, the small-animal world. We’re all familiar with pandemic pets and access-to-care issues during the pandemic. That has seen a significant change since the end of the pandemic. So, again, in the pandemic, you had long wait times at emerg clinics and veterinary practices not accepting new patients and that sort of thing. Really, what we’re seeing in the data, broadly speaking, is a slowdown. We do track veterinary practices that are hiring, who are looking for veterinarians, and we’re looking at a roughly 10-year low in terms of practices that are hiring. So what we’re really moving into is less of a broad access-to-care issue and not enough veterinarians. What we’re running into is not enough veterinarians in specific locations. OVMA has been very, very busy advocating with the various ministries and with this government on programs. We have seen the Veterinary Incentive Program that incentivizes new graduates to work in northern and remote communities. We’ve been very, very active on the Veterinary Assistance Program. That’s a program that provides support for veterinarians in northern and remote communities for travel costs, mileage. That will help increase access. We would like to see much, much more happening with that program. It has a significant level of potential. In terms of broad access issues, there is slower traffic within practices. We just need efforts to get more veterinarians in the places where they’re needed in remote and northern communities.

Official source

00:27:10Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

Kind of reflects human care, too, in this province. You talked about that team-based approach to veterinary care. What exactly does that look like? You were talking about the fact that the vets are the ones that do everything, from diagnoses etc. How does that team-based care model look in your eyes, on the ground?

Official source

00:27:31Official transcript

Mr. John Stevens

Well, it’s integrated, team-based care. The notion that we’ve been talking about through this whole project is, “one profession, two professionals.” So you have integrated team-based care working as a team within a practice. You have the veterinarian attending to duties that are appropriate for them and registered veterinary technicians attending to duties that are appropriate to them. When it’s in a singular practice or an integrated care environment, you have medical records that are consistent, you have communication and the animal owner has that proper expectation of what to expect. When you’re dealing with fragmented care, you would have the public with the perception that they’re going to one care provider that maybe actually can’t provide the level of care that they’re thinking about. You then end up in a situation where the animal owner perhaps has an acute problem, they’re going to seek that care from someone and that care is actually not available. So the best solution would be to have that integrated care facility, which is the veterinary practice.

Official source

00:28:41Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

Right. You mentioned some amendments that you’ve put forward. Can you just quickly highlight, for those who don’t know and don’t have access to those, in bullets—less than a minute—the key amendments?

Official source

00:28:54Official transcript

Mr. John Stevens

Yes. With an accredited veterinary facility, we already have that level of delegation. But within the act’s regulations, in our recommendations, we’re looking for concepts related to the exemptions for being able to work in an accredited practice, including veterinarians working under the crown—that’s federal and provincial legislation—and veterinary technicians working under a treatment plan developed by a veterinarian. So again, integrated care. And that’s in our package, of course.

Official source

00:29:28Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

Thank you, MPP Smyth. We’ll turn back to the government side. MPP Cuzzetto, the floor is yours.

Official source

00:29:34Official transcript

Mr. Rudy Cuzzetto

I would like to thank all three presenters here, but I’d like to speak to Jay on this. Jay, it’s great to hear that your factory is set up in Mississauga. I know it’s north, not south where I live, but thank you for setting up there. Now, how large is your facility? I heard it’s 100,000 square feet, but compared to Santa Lucia, Salerno? I know Saputo is much bigger, but compared to Santa Lucia?

Official source

00:30:06Official transcript

Mr. Rudy Cuzzetto

Okay. Well, I’ve known Domenic for many years. I used to—

Official source

00:30:10Official transcript

Mr. Jay Kirktown

Actually, the other way around: Triple A Cheese would be larger than International Cheese.

Official source

00:30:20Official transcript

Mr. Rudy Cuzzetto

You were talking about the DFO affecting imported and domestic cheese. Can you elaborate on that a little bit more?

Official source

00:30:29Official transcript

Mr. Jay Kirktown

No, impacting domestic and imported ingredients such as skim milk powder and/or MPC or UF milk sort of thing—that’s where they would be targeting: the potential upcharge to get it back to the class pricing that they expect to receive for the product.

Official source

00:30:49Official transcript

Mr. Rudy Cuzzetto

And what would you like to see in this bill to avert that issue?

Official source

00:30:54Official transcript

Mr. Jay Kirktown

The simple answer is, I would like to see the Milk Act stay the way it is. I’m not a supporter of seeing DFO secure more authority around—again, DFO’s authority is exactly that: marketing milk, controlling the finished product—or, let’s call it semi-finished, which is cream and/or skim milk or even liquid MPCs that move a lot today. That should still be in their control because it’s not a finished product. Once you move to a finished product such as butter, skim milk powder or MPC, their authority should not continue. You’re now interfering with the marketplace and the value of various products.

Official source

00:31:45Official transcript

Mr. Jay Kirktown

Absolutely. As Matthew indicated, I’ve worked for a number of companies—a multinational, a very large co-op—and I’m very supportive of supply management. It has done wonders for both producers and processors in this country. But you just need to decide, where do we draw the line to say, “We need control of this system”?

Official source

00:32:13Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

MPP Gallagher Murphy, the floor is yours.

Official source

00:32:16Official transcript

Mme Dawn Gallagher Murphy

Thank you to the presenters today for being here. I have to admit, being a suburban gal, it’s wonderful to be out here in this great riding of Perth–Wellington, so thank you to everybody who lives in this wonderful riding for hosting us here today. My question is to John Stevens for the Ontario Veterinary Medical Association. Thank you very much for your presentation. There’s something I picked up on that I wanted to ask you a question about to make sure we’re on the same playing field here. We all know that the Veterinary Professionals Act was created in 2024. It has not yet been enacted because we are working out the regulatory items. That being said, I noted something you mentioned when you were answering a question to MPP Smyth. You talked about the concepts of exemptions. In the proposal that we have forward in Bill 109, we are specifically looking to get exemptions that would clarify, really, both the individuals and businesses who are providing the care services to animals outside of the accredited facility. So, that could be the veterinary technician. It could be, as you spoke about, the mobile care providers, which I think is great and something that I’ve been hearing just yesterday and so far today is necessary, to go and visit the farm. The team approach sounds like the perfect one. That being the case, when I think about OVMA, you truly have a long history—150 years, and that was in 2024. When you go back to how you originated, it was with surgeons who met up in Toronto in 1874. I think that’s an interesting history, so I’m glad you’re here at the table today because we are creating history here too. So, my question to you, John, is, how do you see Bill 109’s modernization of veterinary legislation building on the long history of the OVMA?

Official source

00:34:39Official transcript

Mr. John Stevens

Great. Well, thank you for the question and thank you for the research. We’re very proud of this profession and the role OVMA has played in promoting it through the decades. Bill 109, in terms of the Veterinary Professionals Act—yes, so, it’s not been enacted, and we would like to see it move forward. This has been a long-standing project that we and other organizations would like to see finished with the official proclamation and enactment of the act. Bill 109 largely—perhaps I shouldn’t use the word—is housekeeping. There are a few minor amendments that were required to finalize the Veterinary Professionals Act. The bulk of the work through the VPA has already been completed, and we’re just looking forward to official enactment. We need the passage of Bill 109 to see that forward. The challenge that we’ve expressed is that there is language in there that’s creating unintentional results, where it’s too broad. So, we’re looking for very narrow amendments for concepts that have been approved by the College of Veterinarians of Ontario’s transition council. These are concepts that have been very well researched—

Official source

00:36:08Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

That concludes the government’s time. We will move on to MPP Vanthof. The floor is yours.

Official source

00:36:15Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

I’d like to go to Joost, and I’m following up: Bill 109 is one of the few bills where there’s no poison pill in it, and we all support it. I would like to follow up to Mr. Rae’s comment: We all are concerned about farmland being controlled by being a line item in a foreign corporation. My question to you: Is there much difference in being a line item in a foreign corporation than being a line item in a Bay Street hedge fund? Because that’s what’s happening in our area. We support this bill, but I’m wondering, should we also be looking at land speculation by not just foreign actors but other people who have no interest in agriculture other than the speculative value of farmland?

Official source

00:37:10Official transcript

Mr. Joost van der Heiden

I do believe that’s a great concern. I do believe we need to make sure that the farmland stays in the control of the farmers and that we prevent speculation, which could drive, ultimately, prices up and it make it inaccessible to farmers. So, yes—leave the farmland with the farmers and make sure there are rules in place so we know that what it’s going to be used for is going to be agriculture.

Official source

00:37:41Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Okay. Thank you. My next question is to you too: Beef Farmers of Ontario have been talking about expansion into northern Ontario long before other groups. You were talking about the Clay Belt before the Clay Belt was sexy. But, having said that—and we’re fully in support of developing the Clay Belt; I’ve made my living in the Clay Belt—would you agree with me that, if crown land is opened in the Clay Belt, it should be made available to farmers and not to investment funds and land speculators? To actual farmers—would you agree? Because what we’re afraid of is that the land, if it’s opened up, will be gobbled up and farmers will end up having to rent it, but the land’s speculative value will never go to them.

Official source

00:38:38Official transcript

Mr. Joost van der Heiden

Yes, this kind of builds on my answer to your previous question as well. Leave the land with the farmers so we avoid speculation and driving the land prices up, putting it out of reach of farmers, basically. Land owned by farmers will be maintained better than land rented by farmers. If it’s yours, it’s a lot easier and it makes more sense to take care of it as well. We are very willing to take care of the land, especially when it’s owned by the farmers.

Official source

00:39:14Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Yes. You mentioned community pastures and, obviously, crown land. Would your organization also be—would you be okay with long-term leases of crown land?

Official source

00:39:26Official transcript

Mr. Joost van der Heiden

I think long-term leases would be an excellent way to get young farmers started—it would be at a lower cost—as long as we make sure that the leases don’t get extended to such a length that it becomes almost an ownership position. That could create other problems, which means we would support leases, preferably less than 49 years but longer than five or 10 years, so it’s actually part of long-term planning for the farmer.

Official source

00:40:00Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

I hear you, because a lease for pasture—you need to be sure that when you make the investments needed, you can recoup those investments.

Official source

00:40:06Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

But possibly a long-term lease with a buyout provision that you have proven that what you’re using the land for is what it was intended for: That would be a viable solution?

Official source

00:40:15Official transcript

Mr. Joost van der Heiden

That would be a very viable solution. The other thing I do like to mention, too, is that when this would be put in place, the amount of area, the acreage, would be large enough for families to sustain. In southwestern Ontario, like you mentioned before, 100 acres can produce a fair bit. In the north, you probably need five times the acres to have the same production. So when we open this up for young farmers, make sure there’s enough land available so they can actually make a go at it and don’t have to supply their farming income with a part-time or full-time income off the farm, because it doesn’t work well.

Official source

00:40:45Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Coming from northern Ontario, as much as it pains me to admit that, yes, maybe 500 acres in northern Ontario is equivalent to 100 acres in Perth, I kind of agree with you—as much as it pains me. How much time do I have left?

Official source

00:40:57Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

A minute? Back to Mr. Stevens: I know we’ve got more seats in Thunder Bay for vets, but is there anything else that we can do to ensure that there are going to be adequate veterinarians across the province, including northern Ontario? Is there anything else that we’re missing?

Official source

00:41:11Official transcript

Mr. John Stevens

I would suggest passage of this act with the amendments that we have put forward to tighten those exemptions, and that would ensure speedy passage of this. The work that the Ontario Veterinary College is doing to increase more seats, following the Northern Ontario School of Medicine model, is very, very strong, and we’ve seen data that shows NOSM having results in the north on the human health care side of things. The veterinary assistance program that I mentioned earlier is under a different ministry than this one. That one, as I’ve shared—we’ve been very, very busy working with that ministry and would like to see some significant changes to that program. And then, the continuation of the veterinary incentive program for new grads would be a very strong option as well.

Official source

00:41:48Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

Thank you very much. We’ll move to MPP Smyth. The floor is yours.

Official source

00:41:51Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

I want to go back to Mr. van der Heiden and talk about farming and farmland, and regarding the purchase of crown land for farming. Would you support the idea of selling crown land with a farmland easement, so that it can never be developed and only used for farming?

Official source

00:42:06Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

And when it comes to clearing crown land for farming, especially in, say, northern Ontario, how should we draw the line between agriculture and forestry and natural spaces?

Official source

00:42:14Official transcript

Mr. Joost van der Heiden

Some of the land that’s available in northern Ontario, to my understanding, has already been cleared, and it would be very easy to access for further development as farmland. When it comes to primary lands that haven’t been touched, I do think we need to preserve the land for what it is. It’s a very fine line, and it’s going to be an interesting challenge for the people who want to expand there.

Official source

00:42:34Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

We’ve talked a lot about—you’ve mentioned hedge funds and foreign ownership, and that is a real concern. That’s happening because there’s a speculative side of it but there’s also the side—and you said a few times here, “Leave the farming to the farmers.” How do we get the farmers? How do we maintain the farming industry domestically in Ontario, in our regions here? Being someone from the city, it’s not often you hear, “Let’s go start some farming. Let’s be a farmer.” It’s intergenerational, right? How does this sector get preserved so that it is passed on? Because we were talking about the cost of farming equipment, the cost of land. Farms can be passed down, but then my colleague here—he’s got children, he’s a farmer, but they’re not farming. So what’s the magic answer here?

Official source

00:43:12Official transcript

Mr. Joost van der Heiden

I don’t think I have the magic answer to the question—but making it attractive for young people. I immigrated myself. I came here to look for greener pastures—it might be fitting—and opportunities that weren’t available in Europe. And yes, I’ve seen them. I was able to build a farm enterprise that has been successful. My sons are not part of it full-time—they work part-time off the farm—but they’ve definitely seen the benefits of it as well. We need to make it attractive. I think in the last number of years, instead of people looking down at a farmer, we’ve actually gained respect. We need to do a better job in educating the consumer where their food comes from and appreciate what we’re doing, and I think that’s going to be one of the ways to get more people back into farming and interested in farming. We see more first-generation people farming than we have ever seen in the past. That’s an indication that there’s people willing and trying and want to choose, because farming is not just a job; it’s a way of life.

Official source

00:44:01Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

It sounds like a really good PR campaign for farming. Get the marketing going on there.

Official source

00:44:06Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

You mentioned you’re an immigrant. What are your thoughts on immigrants who want to come to this beautiful country, and access to farmland and how that should be handled?

Official source

00:44:15Official transcript

Mr. Joost van der Heiden

I think people that have a plan in place for what they want to do should definitely be considered in what they want to do. And whether that’s in farming or whether that’s in a profession where there’s a need, I would embrace people coming here with a passion for what they do and the willingness to work.

Official source

00:44:29Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

Okay. Thank you. I wanted to go to Triple A Cheese. Everybody is very, very interested in your comments about what’s happening with Triple A Cheese and with the DFO. The bottom line here is, does the survival of a small-to-mid-sized business—a non-milk buyer—is that in jeopardy with what’s going on with this situation with the additional authority to the DFO?

Official source

00:44:47Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

You’re worried. You’re clearly worried about what’s happening in this industry.

Official source

00:44:51Official transcript

Mr. Jay Kirktown

Absolutely. But because I’m worried about what’s going to happen, does that mean they’re not going to survive? No. Does it put more pressure on them, the processors that are non-milk buyers, to find avenues for their products? Absolutely. Does that mean their demise? I think it depends on their size, the range of products they can produce and where they are trying to market their products. Some of these processors that market locally may survive, but their business model will not last for an indefinite period of time. It’s just not sustainable. They’re paying a penalty for manufacturing products because they don’t buy milk from the DFO. It just doesn’t work.

Official source

00:45:23Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

What about the bottom line with the cost to these producers with these changes?

Official source

00:45:31Official transcript

Mr. Jay Kirktown

Again, it depends on the product mix they have. Unfortunately, I’m not going to quote numbers of the impact for Triple A Cheese in public. It just wouldn’t be fair.

Official source

00:45:39Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

No—understood. But you can see the economics of this.

Official source

00:45:42Official transcript

Mr. Jay Kirktown

Oh, yes. Absolutely. It could be large dollars, for sure.

Official source

00:45:46Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

You know, I’m okay. I’m done. Thank you very much, everybody.

Official source

00:45:49Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

That will conclude the second round of questions. Thank you to all the presenters for the time and effort you put into your presentations.

Official source

Perth County Federation of Agriculture; The Ontario Greenhouse Alliance; Northern Bruce Peninsula municipal drainage committee

00:45:56Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

We’ll now call up our 11 o’clock panel of presenters: Laura Good of the Perth County Federation of Agriculture, Jan VanderHout from the Ontario Greenhouse Alliance and John Rodgers of the drainage committee of the Northern Bruce Peninsula. We will begin with our first presenter, Laura Good of the Perth County Federation of Agriculture. You’ll have seven minutes for your presentation. Please state your name for Hansard and you may begin.

Official source

00:46:17Official transcript

Ms. Laura Good

Laura Good, Perth County Federation of Agriculture. I’m here on behalf of more than 1,800 farm families that reside here in Perth county. I’m representing Perth County Federation of Agriculture, and I am here to speak in support of the intent of the legislation in Bill 109, Protecting Ontario’s Food Independence Act. With regard to schedule 2, the Farming and Food Production Protection Act, we at Perth County Federation of Agriculture have concerns regarding merging boards into larger tribunals in the name of efficiencies. We are concerned that the larger tribunal will de-specialize agricultural dispute resolution and will, in fact, result in slower timelines and cases being assigned to adjudicators without relevant transferable knowledge. It is essential that any panel hearing involving a normal farm practice dispute is staffed by adjudicators with agricultural knowledge. Perth county farmers deserve to be heard by professionals that understand our industry. With regard to schedule 3, the Farmland Security Act that bans designated persons, foreign nationals and prescribed foreign entities from directly or indirectly purchasing or acquiring any interest in Ontario farmland, we hope you will consider tracking beneficial ownership by looking through corporate layers. We hope you will protect foreign individuals intending to reside and actively farm in Perth county. It is a diverse patchwork of immigrant farmers. I myself and Mr. Vanthof are only second-generation Canadians. Without protecting foreign-born individuals who intend to reside here from this legislation, I would not be here; in fact, an overwhelming number of Perth county farmers would not be here. We hope that this legislation will ensure that no red tape is added to domestic farm transfers and ensure that we are not adding red tape and extra burden to our farmers here in Perth county. New Canadians, recent and from past generations, have contributed significantly to building Ontario’s agricultural sector by bringing their knowledge, skills, innovation and strong work ethic to rural communities across the province. Agriculture continues to provide meaningful pathways to employment, entrepreneurship and community legislation for immigrants seeking to establish new lives in Ontario, and very much so in Perth county. As the sector continues to face labour shortages and growing demand, we want to continue welcoming new Canadians and creating opportunities for them to contribute their talents, experience and perspectives to Ontario’s agricultural future. Here in Perth county, we sorely need more new farmers. We need help. The farms here in Perth county are lacking people to work for us, and it is a wonderful way to get your foot in the door to being a farmer here in Ontario. With soaring farmland costs posing a significant barrier for new, young and expanding farmers, in a recent survey, over 80% of OFA members indicated the price of farmland was too high given the income generated from farming it. With the price of farmland in Perth county sometimes eclipsing $50,000 an acre, farm ownership is next to impossible. For farmers under the age of 35, 100% of respondents told OFA the price of farmland was too high relative to farm income. OFA believes that the Protecting Ontario’s Food Independence Act can work to partly address soaring farmland costs by restricting international investors from making future speculative investments in Ontario farmland. Although past records indicate low levels of foreign purchases of farmland, this legislation could prevent a future surge in farmland purchases by foreign speculators. According to Ontario land transfer tax information, only 147 farm property transactions in 2018 and just 138 in 2019 involved a foreign purchaser. Agriculture is a highly capital-intensive industry. As we look at ways to curb speculative purchases of farmland, we must be careful not to implement blunt policies that inadvertently choke off the vital investment needed to modernize and grow Ontario’s agri-food sector. As you look down Perth county side roads, very few farmers that live here now did so 70 years ago. Our rural landscape continues to change and evolve, and the faces will also continue to change with the evolution of agriculture. Ensuring that those that buy our farmland intend to settle here is paramount. We at PCFA would like to commend the provincial government on making Ontario’s food independence a priority and with a few exceptions, we feel that Bill 109 will be exceptional legislation. Thank you for your time and consideration.

Official source

00:50:00Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

Thank you very much. We’ll move to the Ontario Greenhouse Alliance. Mr. VanderHout, the floor is yours. I believe you’re virtual.

Official source

00:50:14Official transcript

Mr. Jan VanderHout

Yes, thank you very much. Jan VanderHout with TOGA, the Ontario Greenhouse Alliance. I’m happy to be able to present to you today on behalf of all the greenhouse growers in Ontario. I really want to speak to Bill 109. It’s precision, not breadth, that should govern Ontario’s farmland security framework. Ontario has identified a real problem: the real risk to our domestic food and agriculture security from unaccountable foreign capital acquiring farmland in the province. At the same time, it is also true that foreign capital can also be beneficial and a real asset to Ontario’s agri-food sector. This includes Ontario’s greenhouse sector. The introduction of the bill includes a contextualization that the effort to limit foreign ownership is precautionary, rather than reactive, legislation. Minister Jones stated the legislation is intended to be forward-looking legislation to avert risks, citing the possibility of land being banked and left fallow or farmed only to export a single crop. Independent estimates of foreign ownership of Ontario farmland suggest the current scale of the problem is modest. The rationale is nonetheless coherent. Ontario is aligning with five other provinces and a number of US states that already limit or restrict non-domestic farmland acquisition. The act’s definition of farmland is broad by design—that is, land used or capable of being used for farm purposes and buildings on it. There is no carve-out distinguishing open-field agriculture from controlled-environment agriculture, CEA. Indeed, the government’s own communications around the bill have pointed to a CEA operation, a highly automated greenhouse facility in King City, as an exemplar of the food sovereignty outcome the legislation is meant to protect. Greenhouse and floriculture land is therefore squarely inside the bill’s scope. Ontario’s greenhouse sector is among the most capital-intensive segments of the province’s agri-food economy. New builds and expansion projects are frequently financed through structures that include institutional and pension capital, minority foreign equity, joint-venture partnerships and long-horizon debt. Because of the capital intensiveness of the sector, we often interact with domestic and international capital markets that operate on a fundamentally different logic than the land banking or single-crop export activity that the bill is designed for. While TOGA supports the objectives of the bill, we would caution that a regulatory framework calibrated to stop opportunistic land acquisition by unaccountable capital could, if not carefully drawn, also catch the accountable, productive capital that many greenhouse expansions depend on. There are three points of genuine exposure, in our consideration: (1) The undefined corporate designation: The criteria that will determine whether a corporation, partnership or other entity counts as a designated person have been left entirely to regulation. Until published, every greenhouse operator with a joint-venture partner or an institutional minority investor is planning transactions against an undefined standard. (2) No compensation, no defined timeline: Section 22 of the act bars any claim for compensation arising from its application, and the minister’s permission process under section 7 carries no published service standard. For a sector where financing is typically committed years ahead of construction, that combination is itself a source of cost through higher risk premiums, more conservative lending and slower deal execution. These risks are independent of how the final regulations are written. (3) Succession exposure: “Foreign national” is defined by reference to federal immigration law, not by any test of economic control. Multi-generational greenhouse operations with adult children, in-laws or estate beneficiaries of residents outside of Canada face a live question about whether ordinary succession planning could trigger the act’s prohibition. This is a risk outcome we believe would not be intended by a bill aimed at sovereign capital. So, the case for sectoral precision—again, we are supportive of the bill’s underlying premise. TOGA’s position is not that Ontario farmland should be open to acquisition by state-linked sovereign capital with no accountability to the province’s food and agricultural system. Concerns in that direction, including with respect to sovereign wealth fund activity, are legitimate and merit a targeted legislative response. We believe the legislation should be narrow in its definition, that the instrument built to solve that problem should be precise enough to solve only that problem and limit unintended consequences. It will also be important to ensure that we do not limit Ontario farmers’ and investors’ access from ownership in farms outside of Canada and that any restriction will not drive repercussions for companies with landholdings in other countries. Thank you very much for the opportunity to share our perspective this morning, and we look forward to the ongoing conversation.

Official source

01:00:00Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

Thank you very much. We’ll move to John Rodgers, chair of the drainage committee of the Northern Bruce Peninsula, virtual. Mr. Rodgers, you have seven minutes. Please state your name for Hansard and you may begin.

Official source

01:00:17Official transcript

Mr. John Rodgers

Thank you very much. Yes, my name is John Rodgers. I am the chair of the drainage committee of the municipality of the Northern Bruce Peninsula. I guess, upfront, I should ask first. This presentation is basically directed at increasing sector resilience, which is part of this initiative under which Bill 109 falls, but I also don’t want to distract the committee from their important work on Bill 109. So if I could get some indication that this is an appropriate presentation to make at this time, I would like that to start with.

Official source

01:00:59Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

Mr. Rodgers, you’re free to present what you feel is necessary for the committee to know.

Official source

01:01:06Official transcript

Mr. John Rodgers

Well, thank you very much. I think I have covered my introduction and my position. Just basically, the drainage committee of the municipality of the Northern Bruce Peninsula is a committee of council that was instituted just in 2024. What I’ll be covering today is trends in climate or trends in rainfall that we have seen and what the implications are for agriculture and the resilience of the sector, some of the short-term strategies that we have been dealing with to cope with those and then tools for long-term management as we move forward with upgrading our drainage infrastructure. I’m also vice-chair of a local committee known as the Bruce Peninsula Biosphere Association. Basically, we initiated a sedimentation study of a lake at the terminus of one of our important drainage channels. This was done by Kyle McCarrel in 2019, supervised by Dr. Jackie Cockburn of the University of Guelph. Basically, the sediment analysis provided a physical multi-decade record of exactly what’s happening with rainfall patterns here in the Bruce Peninsula and probably reflects those patterns that are happening on a wider scale. In particular, this sedimentation study was nailed down by isotope analysis, so basically looking at the isotopes and the layers that were released by nuclear events, like nuclear testing and, of course, the Chernobyl incident. Basically, the outcome of the study indicated that the timing of peak flows has changed significantly even within that short amount of time. So rather than being in a single event, which tended to happen sometime in April, now there are multiple rainfall events that cause severe flooding, and they tend to happen any time of the year. So we’re getting the once-in-100-year rainfall every few decades. The implication for having a big flood or a large rainfall event during a warmer period basically is the impact that it has on crops. Because the temperatures are higher, respiration demands are greater. For every 10 degrees of increase, you get double the oxygen requirement, and so we see a lot of crop damage as a result of the change in the rainfall. The upshot is, basically, our old drainage infrastructure is probably not set for the new rainfall pattern. It’s interesting to note that, really, there hasn’t been all that much increase in the total amount of rainfall in the year, but it has been the distribution that’s made the difference. Anyway, there’s an accompanying presentation. But basically, what we’re trying to do in the short term is manage the shoulders of the flooding, so prior to the flood stage, trying to manage the water, trying to move more water through the system and then, at the end, trying to hold more water in storage in places where it’s more desired. As we’ve moved through this, we have noticed that there are questions related to who owns the drainage infrastructure. For example, we’ll end up with bridges where the drain ends, and the drain will have been re-reported and re-channelled, but underneath the bridge, basically, the drain is the old drain, and nobody knows who it belongs to. There are similar pieces of infrastructure put in by other ministries that do not conform to the drain report for individual drains, and they have a pretty big implication for the ability to manage that water in the shoulders of the flooding. The tail end of the shoulder—basically, one of the things we’re working on with the biosphere association is trying to increase the water storage in headwaters areas that are non-agricultural by decommissioning old drainage infrastructure. This is challenging, and it’s not a provincial issue, but basically, as you decommission drains, they are considered a restoration effort. It’s considered the same as any construction effort where the by-product of what you’re doing cannot be considered as an offset. So if you are building a pier, you couldn’t consider providing fish shade as an offset, but if you’re restoring something, you can consider the restoration to be an offset. It makes it twice as expensive to conduct those exercises. As a drainage committee, we’ve noticed that there are technologies that are available and developing that make questions easy to answer and probably could be used in a more widespread manner and could be used by the province. One of them is the—

Official source

01:06:53Official transcript

Mr. John Rodgers

—models of the—so, for example, the digital elevation model. I think I’m out of time. Anyway, thank you very much for your time.

Official source

01:07:04Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

Thank you very much. We will begin the next round of questions with the official opposition. MPP Vanthof, the floor is yours.

Official source

01:07:14Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

In the spirit of full disclosure, Laura is my cousin. She is one of the people who legitimately can call the member of Oxford county Uncle Ernie.

Official source

01:07:27Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Well, I was about to say, don’t hold it against her that she’s related to me. Anyway, Laura, you brought up some really good points. One point that you brought up that hasn’t been brought up a lot is the merging of the tribunals. We farm a long ways away from each other, and the issues that might come up at a tribunal in Timiskaming could be totally different than the issues that would come up in Perth. Could you just elaborate on how important it is that the people sitting on those tribunals know the local conditions and also that the tribunals are actually quick enough—because this is touted as a way that’s going to be more efficient. How important is it to actually have the tribunals, the renderings and the hearings quick enough that they actually help the person who’s being hauled before the tribunal?

Official source

01:08:32Official transcript

Ms. Laura Good

Almost all of the things that we do are seasonally based. So if there is a problem, it needs to be—honestly, a 30-to-60-day window is all that we have, because in 60 days, crops could be off. In 60 days, a fenced road is—I’m not even sure how big the farm practice problems could be. But we live in such tiny—we turn over crops. We turn over livestock. Everything gets turned over so fast in our line of work that to wait 120 to 200 days to see a tribunal—everything that has happened, we can’t even show it to you anymore. It’s gone. It has grown; it is gone. To explain those things, the jargon and the positions, to explain that to people that have no agricultural background, it’s not impossible but is next to impossible. It’s going to take twice as long, three times as long just to explain what the difficulties we are having are. To sit that in front of people who have no agricultural background, it’s next to impossible to make people understand what it is that we’re talking about. Right now, we have people in place that are going to take care of it and have an agricultural background.

Official source

01:10:00Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Okay. Am I fair to say—because we’re also in favour of the bill—that it’s not so much the merging, it’s that you want to be ensured that the new process is actually stronger and quicker than the old one, that it’s not just a cost-cutting measure?

Official source

01:10:18Official transcript

Ms. Laura Good

Yes, that’s right. If you just add it to another pile and add more days, it’s not going to work for us. We need fast and effective land disputes. We need fast and effective. That’s what we’re looking for.

Official source

01:10:34Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

My next question is going to be to you and to Jan because you talked about the same things. I’m going to use a term that Jan used that I haven’t heard before, and I really liked it. It’s unaccountable investment, unaccountable foreign investment. That’s a good term because foreign investment—if we put regulations in to not allow anyone from another country to invest in agriculture, there would be a lot of empty back roads—

Official source

01:11:07Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

—in all parts of the province. But we all agree. I call it speculative investment, but unaccountable is probably better. I ask this to everyone: Is there a difference between unaccountable foreign investment and unaccountable Bay Street hedge fund investment? Is there really a difference? Should we also be looking at that investment in agriculture that really isn’t tied to agriculture, that’s simply a line item that says it’s better to invest in farmland than crypto at the moment? It’s a serious question.

Official source

01:11:46Official transcript

Ms. Laura Good

I think we would just like to ensure that the people buying farms are wanting to come here and farm. We not only need the investment; we need the bodies. If you want to invest here, that’s great, but we want to make sure that the people buying farms here are living here, are paying into our pay structures here and doing things here.

Official source

01:12:13Official transcript

Ms. Laura Good

And I appreciate that there are lots of suitcases of money floating around, but there needs to be accountability to that as well.

Official source

01:12:25Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Jan, I’m going to go back to you. Again, how important is it that if we change these rules, it’s predictable for your industry?

Official source