Legislative Assembly of Ontario · Committee

Thursday, January 29, 2026

Standing Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs

The official transcript of the meeting, from Hansard, by heading. Ministers, officials and witnesses appear as the transcript names them; committees have no live transcript, so the record appears once the Assembly publishes it.

Thursday, January 29, 2026

Read from the beginning of the meeting

Meeting ended

Greater Sudbury Chamber of Commerce / Chambre de commerce du Grand Sudbury; Laurentian University of Sudbury; Niagara District Airport

00:25:20Official transcript

Mr. Stéphane Sarrazin

First of all, thank you to all of you for being here today, taking part in this budget consultation. As a parliamentary assistant of the Ministry of Francophone Affairs and as a parliamentary assistant of the minister of small business, je m’en voudrais de ne pas faire une petite partie en français de notre consultation aujourd’hui pour les francophones de Sudbury. Je vais m’adresser à Marie, qui est avec la chambre de commerce de Sudbury. On reconnaît, notre gouvernement, que les chambres de commerce—vous êtes un partenaire précieux avec tout ce que vous faites, les rapports que vous avez créés au cours des années. Je ne sais pas si on a eu la chance de se rencontrer. J’ai fait des tables rondes avec plusieurs chambres de commerce; je ne sais pas si une des vôtres. Pour nous, c’est toujours important parce qu’on sait que les petites entreprises sont 98 % de nos entreprises en Ontario, puis ce sont plusieurs millions de personnes qui sont employées par les petites entreprises. On sait que Sudbury joue vraiment un rôle important dans le secteur minier, puis avec ce qui s’en vient, le développement du « Ring of Fire », je pense qu’il y aura beaucoup de différents contrats, puis de petites entreprises qui vont bénéficier. On parle souvent des grosses entreprises dans le secteur minier, mais on sait qu’il y a plusieurs petites entreprises qui ont des grosses retombées économiques. Quelques questions : je vais juste lancer ça, puis tu pourrais me répondre—premièrement, merci. Ce serait intéressant d’entendre un petit peu plus à savoir ce que notre gouvernement peut faire, vraiment, pour aider. Je sais qu’on a eu, aussi, des fonds qui étaient livrés à travers notre « Skills Development Fund program », d’où beaucoup d’entreprises et de compagnies ont eu la chance d’avoir des fonds pour justement former des gens dans les « trades ». Je pense qu’avec le secteur minier, ça va être plus important que jamais. Je me demandais, est-ce que vous avez vu qu’il y a des entreprises dans le secteur minier, même de votre région, qui ont pu bénéficier de ça? Puis, juste à savoir : comment est-ce qu’on peut aider et continuer à être un bon partenaire, à créer les meilleures conditions possibles pour que les entreprises aient du succès en Ontario?

Official source

00:27:54Official transcript

Mme Marie Litalien

Merci. La première question, si vous n’avez pas lu « Mining 2030 », un rapport de la chambre de commerce de l’Ontario, s’il vous plaît, prenez le temps. Il y a des bonnes recommandations qui aident au Nord mais aux secteurs à travers l’Ontario. Alors, ça c’est très important. Partie du rapport : ce sont des partenariats avec nos personnes autochtones; le « Skills Development Fund »; des outils fiscaux qui peuvent aider; le coût de l’énergie—c’est très important pour le secteur minier; si tu parles à nos industries ici, c’est un défi—et aussi la main-d’oeuvre. Ce sont les quatre ou cinq défis qu’on a ici au nord de l’Ontario, que la province peut aider—vous avez des programmes, c’est vrai, mais je pense que ce sont les autres étapes qui peuvent nous aider.

Official source

00:28:46Official transcript

M. Stéphane Sarrazin

Je veux juste peut-être profiter de l’occasion pour vous remercier, comme je l’ai dit tantôt, pour votre travail précieux, pour les rapports que vous créez, puis avec tout le partenariat que vous avez avec toutes ces entreprises-là. Sûrement, on va consulter votre rapport. Merci encore. How much time left?

Official source

00:29:12Official transcript

Mr. Brian Saunderson

Maybe I’ll continue with you, Marie, but I want to thank all of our presenters. I’m short on time. Maybe I’ll pick it up in the second round, but I thank you for taking time to offer your expertise and insights into the upcoming budget—

Official source

00:29:29Official transcript

Mr. Brian Saunderson

—and for the important work you do in your communities. Marie, in my riding of Simcoe–Grey, we have MacLean Engineering in Collingwood, and MacLean is a big presence up here with their test mine. They are one of the world leaders in the electrification of mining equipment. You talked about the north being necessary, and I like your tag line: “quick, clear and purposeful.” So, mining: How important is the mining sector for Sudbury and the region here?

Official source

00:30:00Official transcript

Ms. Marie Litalien

Through you, Chair: It’s very important. It is one of the key sectors, and the mining supply and service industry, but it also services the entire north. So it doesn’t just benefit Greater Sudbury. We are fortunate to have a strong government and health care sector as well that helps us weather some of those economic downturns. The mining industry is cyclical, as I’m sure you know, so Sudbury is very resilient—

Official source

00:30:30Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time for that question. MPP Gélinas.

Official source

00:30:35Official transcript

Mme France Gélinas

I will start with Laurentian. Everybody remembers in 2021, Laurentian University declared bankruptcy. Seventy-six programs, according to the Auditor General, were closed. Over 200 faculty lost their jobs. They are out of this. They are trying to turn the page, and as Mr. Ramakko said, reopening the pool would be a nice way to turn the page on this sad history. The pool was a community asset that everybody used. I can tell you that I played water polo. I learned synchronized swimming. I brought my kids there. I brought my grandkids there. It was a real, real asset. The Sudbury swim club talks about the reopening of the Laurentian pool every single day. Help us. It’s not a whole lot of money. It would help us turn the page on a really, really dark and tough place that we were in. It would bring people from all over not only northern Ontario—back to Sudbury. There used to be competitions at all sorts of levels, all the way to—we had a national competition taking place right here in Sudbury, where people from all over Canada would come to Sudbury to compete. They are ready, they have a plan, they have partners. It needs to be done. Did I miss anything?

Official source

00:32:01Official transcript

Mr. Brian Ramakko

No. Through you, Mr. Chair: A strong partnership with the city—Paul Lefebvre has written in support letters as well, and we have a working partnership with senior management and the city of Sudbury. So we are working on a solid plan and a solid base.

Official source

00:32:19Official transcript

Mme France Gélinas

Okay. Before I go on, I’ll just let you know that I’m not a really good synchronized swimmer, just so you know, but I tried really hard. My next question is back to the chamber of commerce. Merci, Marie. I want people to understand what the opioid crisis looks like in northern Ontario. Although we represent only 5% of the population of Ontario, 10% of the deaths are in northern Ontario. Every single week we lose at least three people to overdose right here in Sudbury and area. That happens on our streets every single day. Go have a look at the businesses downtown. We’re not very far from downtown in this hotel. Go have a look and you will see how many landlords are not able to rent their places anymore because businesses are leaving the downtown because of the opioid crisis. Those people are sick. Those people need help. We know how to provide help to the people who have mental illness. We know how to provide help to people who use substances. We need the resources to do this so that our downtown can flourish again. Marie, do you want to talk a little bit about the difference in what our downtown used to look like business-wise versus what it looks like now?

Official source

00:33:46Official transcript

Ms. Marie Litalien

Yes, thank you for the question. Through you, Chair, to MPP Gélinas: There has been a significant change. We know; we had a pandemic that affected a lot of that. I think it’s coming out of that pandemic that’s been difficult and challenging. Our downtown BIA is doing a lot of work. Our municipality is doing a lot of work. We’re not there yet. That’s why I think a more coordinated approach might be beneficial, and that’s why the chamber is recommending that. One of the things—and unpopular opinion coming, but there are some changes required to the Mental Health Act to how we deliver those services to crime and how we address crime and jails as well, so I think it’s important. Our desire is that there’s a coordinated approach between all those different areas so that we can try to address some of the challenges that are occurring, especially in the north and in our downtown.

Official source

00:34:52Official transcript

Mme France Gélinas

I represent the riding of Nickel Belt. There are more mines in Nickel Belt than in any other riding. Lots of people work in the mining industry. But I can tell you that every second week, one of those miners will overdose, will die and won’t be there to support their family, won’t be there to support their community anymore. This is really, really tough. You can have schooling available and all of this. But if they go out for 10 days, they come back for 10 days—I guarantee you, ask any EMS: They know when the shift change is happening at Côté Gold because when the guys come back into town, they’re guaranteed to have overdose calls go through the roof. For some of them, they won’t be there in time—

Official source

00:35:43Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time. MPP Smyth.

Official source

00:35:47Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

Good morning, everybody. It’s nice to see you all here today. Thank you for your submissions before this committee. I wanted to start with Marie at the chamber of commerce and come off of some of what our colleagues have been talking about when it comes to mental health and addiction and the situation in Sudbury. It is a story that we’re seeing right across this province in municipalities big or small. There was the mention of the HART hubs that have been promised by this government. What are you hearing in terms of timeline now—I guess it’s long past overdue, as of yet—and explanations as to why this hasn’t happened and what kind of hope there is on the horizon?

Official source

00:36:37Official transcript

Ms. Marie Litalien

Thank you for the question. Through you, Chair, to the MPP: It’s not a chamber of commerce project, so I’m not sure the question is for me. However, I do know that there are several social service organizations in town that are working very hard on that project and that there is an announcement coming. That’s the update that I have from those social service agencies, the ones that are the applicants on the projects, as well as the municipality. I don’t have a lot of knowledge of where that process is, just because it’s beyond our scope, but that is what I know.

Official source

00:37:18Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

Right. So there is a timeline, at least, that you’re hearing through businesses?

Official source

00:37:25Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

How critical is it that you’re hearing from these businesses that this gets implemented soon, not only for the people suffering but for the businesses that are clearly having a really tough time with this as well?

Official source

00:37:41Official transcript

Ms. Marie Litalien

Thank you. I think it is very important, and I think it is a step on the spectrum. I don’t think it solves everything, because there are many, many different aspects to this. It helps with one of the areas where there are challenges and where we need help, but it’s certainly not a solution for every step of someone’s journey through recovery for additions and mental health conditions.

Official source

00:38:09Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

Thank you for that. I wanted to move on, just to talk about travel and getting here on Highway 69. As my colleague MPP Cerjanec said—he made it here, after several hours—he had quite a journey. I myself had what we’re calling a harrowing journey up here, with a really bad near-collision on Highway 69 just north of Parry Sound. As we know, this project that you’ve been talking about has been going on forever but not happening fast enough when it comes to helping our economy, safety. We know how critical that is and how much you say that it would help workers get to their shifts, boost tourism. Like, the safety issue—what is the cost to Sudbury, from a safety perspective and business perspective, with the lag in getting this project finished?

Official source

00:39:04Official transcript

Ms. Marie Litalien

Thank you. It affects businesses every day. I think this may be the issue that I hear about the most from our members, just in terms of supply chain deliveries, meetings, investment, potential, coming here, getting here on time or many different aspects—even just visiting family, tourism, meetings, conventions and conferences. There’s that potential here as well. That helps all of those different aspects of the economy—mining supply and services, of course—especially as the province declares the Ring of Fire a priority area. There’s a road that needs to go, and there’s many roads that need to go, but that’s also one of them. We connect the north to the south through Highway 69 and it’s critical that it be expanded, so we look forward to that.

Official source

00:40:00Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

Sorry for interrupting—what are you hearing is the biggest roadblock to this happening?

Official source

00:40:05Official transcript

Ms. Marie Litalien

I believe it is some agreements that need to be made with the different First Nations. There are three First Nations along that corridor, and there are agreements that need to be done respectfully and with the needs of those First Nations in mind.

Official source

00:40:20Official transcript

Ms. Marie Litalien

I believe that takes time, as we know—which it should. But hopefully, I think, we can hear some news and maybe get a little bit of a timeline. I think that would be the most important thing.

Official source

00:40:31Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

Just a question about the airport: We heard from Niagara that they are fully able and ready to expand service at their airport with the, I guess, 5,000-metre runway. What’s the status with the airport here in terms of the runway? Are you familiar with that at all?

Official source

00:40:47Official transcript

MPP Stephanie Smyth

Okay, that’s fair—just in terms of being able to handle greater capacity. I’m just going to move on to the pool at Laurentian. What kind of funding have you been able to secure federally at all with this project?

Official source

00:40:59Official transcript

Mr. Brian Ramakko

Nothing that I know of yet. I would defer that question to Sylvie Lafontaine, please.

Official source

00:41:04Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time for that question. We’ll have to get it on the next round. MPP Saunderson.

Official source

00:41:11Official transcript

Mr. Brian Saunderson

When we ended the last round, Marie, I was asking about the importance of the mining sector to the Sudbury economy. You had talked in response to my colleague’s questions about the importance of skills development, enhancing the grid up here and the mining competitiveness with Bill 5. I’m just wondering if you could speak to the opportunities that developing the Ring of Fire would bring to the mining industry and the supporting industries in town.

Official source

00:41:38Official transcript

Ms. Marie Litalien

Through you, Chair, to the MPP: There are significant economic benefits to our mining and mining supply and services companies, not only because of work and jobs that would come out of work being done in the Ring of Fire but because of the infrastructure investment that needs to go into that area, which then benefits our community and the communities surrounding it—so, significant benefits. Also, it’s not the only priority area for mining. I think northern Ontario—Timmins, north of Timmins, Sudbury area—has a lot of potential to develop as well, where those infrastructure investments could be done in already established communities as well to help us sort of expand what’s already here and what’s already happening. So there are benefits, I think, in many ways for mining supply and services and our ability to expand here.

Official source

00:42:26Official transcript

Mr. Brian Saunderson

Great. Thank you very much for that. I’m now going to turn to Laurentian University. Brian and Sylvie, thank you for your presentation today. I actually started my political career on a joint task force in Collingwood to develop our rec facilities, which was to include a 25-metre pool at the time, so I know the importance. I know at the time, they talked about how $1 invested in sport and recreation usually has a multiplier effect of saving $15. This was in 2001, I think. It had the ability to save $15 in future health care costs, from mental health to physical health. I’m sure that number has grown significantly. So I appreciate the work that you are doing. The government had a Community Sport and Recreation Infrastructure Fund that came out in 2024. There were two streams. One was to improve existing facilities. I know from your history you were focused on other things at that time, but I’m wondering if you had made an application to that funding at the time—whoever can answer that.

Official source

00:43:25Official transcript

Mr. Brian Ramakko

Thank you, Mr. Chair. I believe Sylvie would be best to answer that.

Official source

00:43:29Official transcript

Ms. Sylvie Lafontaine

Yes. Our understanding is that at that time, the municipalities would be eligible to apply for that particular type of funding and the city of Sudbury had applied for that particular funding with the understanding that they had a number of pools at that time that they were looking at for that particular funding, which was for $1 million. The Laurentian pool did not get to apply or receive funding in that particular envelope.

Official source

00:43:54Official transcript

Mr. Brian Saunderson

Okay. The partnership, I think, is a critical piece. When we were doing this back in Collingwood, we were partnering with the YMCA because these facilities now are becoming so much more expensive, and this was pre-pandemic. Since the pandemic, the prices have gone up exorbitantly, as I’m sure you know.

Official source

00:44:12Official transcript

Mr. Brian Saunderson

And so, leveraging the asset and the partnership to keep this pool going—50-metre pools, as you’ve indicated, are rare beasts across the province, and they’re critical. I know you’re looking at the sport tourism aspect of it, and you had a very successful model before that; it’s got great history, that pool. I’m wondering if you can talk to me a bit about the partnership arrangement that the municipality and the university are exploring at this point. I know it’s a difficult model, operating a pool. When I was doing this 20 years ago, a 25-metre pool fully programmed generally costs the municipality, or whoever’s operating it, about $250,000 a year—

Official source

00:44:52Official transcript

Mr. Brian Saunderson

—and I imagine that would be higher for a 50-metre pool. I’m just wondering what the partnership that you’re discussing looks like.

Official source

00:44:59Official transcript

Ms. Sylvie Lafontaine

Yes, at this time, we’re certainly working very closely. This particular working group has been put in place to get into the details, both from the governance point of view but also for the ongoing operating. Certainly, the city of Sudbury has the expertise and the staff across all of its inventory of pools, therefore leaving some of that more operational aspect of it, ensuring that there’s a good sense of the programming that would occur, that would serve both from the municipality and the communities as well as for the university. It would be really establishing—we have our working group, we have our guiding principle and we’re now into finalizing those types of details, but we’re working side by side with the municipality and leveraging—

Official source

00:45:43Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time for that question and also concludes the time for this panel. We thank you all very much for the time you took to prepare and for coming here and delivering the message. Hopefully, it will help us as we write the report from our exercise in the pre-budget consultations. Thank you very much for being here.

Official source

Medical Laboratory Professionals’ Association of Ontario; Ontario Federation of Labour; Ontario Catholic School Trustees’ Association

00:46:04Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

We will ask the next panel to come forward: the Medical Laboratory Professionals’ Association of Ontario, the Ontario Federation of Labour and the Ontario Catholic School Trustees’ Association. We thank you all for being here and, as with the others, you have seven minutes to make your presentation. At six minutes, I will say, “One minute.” At seven minutes, we will move on to the next one. We ask each presenter to make sure to introduce themselves as they start their presentation. With that, we start with the Medical Laboratory Professionals’ Association of Ontario.

Official source

00:46:38Official transcript

Ms. Jessie Clelland

Excellent, that would be me. Honourable members of the Standing Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs, thank you for taking the time to come to Sudbury to hear about our community’s priorities. I hope you had a restful holiday break. My name is Jessie Clelland. I’m a medical laboratory technologist by trade. I’m currently the manager at the Canadian Blood Services donation centre in Sudbury and also the former board chair for the Medical Laboratory Professionals’ Association of Ontario, or MLPAO for short. The MLPAO advocates on behalf of the medical laboratory profession, including medical laboratory technologists, medical laboratory assistants and technicians. Lab professionals test for thousands of diseases and disorders, including early cancer diagnosis, diabetes, heart disease, genetic markers and more. These tests are required to provide diagnostic and comprehensive care to Ontarians for publicly funded cancer screenings, surgeries and procedures. Combined, these professionals process and interpret over 280 million laboratory tests annually in Ontario and are the fourth-largest health care profession after doctors, nurses and pharmacists. Since the pandemic, our hospital, public health and community labs continue to experience significant labour shortages. Across Ontario, right now, 37% of medical laboratory technologists are approaching retirement in the next few years. According to a recent survey the MLPAO conducted in the fall of 2025, 68% of Ontario labs continue to experience these shortages: 44% of our members say laboratory technologist staffing shortages have stayed the same or worsened over the last year and 40% say their technologist staffing shortages are adversely affecting turnaround times for patient results. More medical lab training programs are being brought online by Ontario post-secondary institutions. We are grateful for that, but many labs are unable to take and train students due to the shortages. In fact, 37% of labs that currently do not take students indicated to the MLPAO that they would be able to take students for clinical placements if funding for a trainer was provided. This is common practice in other health professions and they are called preceptors. The MLPAO is proposing a modest but effective solution in our budget submission. We are asking for a one-time, time-limited investment of $6 million over three years in the 2026 Ontario budget to hire around 130 preceptors to train 1,300 students and alleviate labour shortages, especially in rural and northern labs. The MLPAO is ready to implement this solution immediately. We have part-time and recently retired MLTs ready to come back and train and support students with hands-on training opportunities. This solution also complements the recent government investments in the Learn and Stay grant, and the addition of 700 MLT seats to help the MLT recruitment and retention in the northeast and southwest regions of Ontario. These preceptors will allow the current MLTs to focus on processing and releasing test results, while the preceptor will spend one-on-one time with the MLT student. This will give the student the dedicated time that they need to learn, while not impacting the turnaround times and the testing being processed. Thank you for taking time to hear our proposal. We hope we can count on the government’s funding for our hard-working medical lab professionals in this year’s budget.

Official source

00:50:00Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. We now will hear from the Ontario Federation of Labour.

Official source

00:50:03Official transcript

Ms. Laura Walton

Thank you so much, Chair. I’m Laura Walton, president of the Ontario Federation of Labour, representing 54 unions and over a million workers in Ontario. I sit before you today to ask you to invest in Ontario. Now, when I talk about investment, I’m not talking about abstract growth targets or projects that may or may not deliver public benefit decades from now. I’m talking about investment now, investment today that supports workers, their families and the communities that make this province function. In my role, I have the privilege of speaking with workers across this province in every sector and every region. What I hear is remarkably consistent: People are not asking for promises. They are asking for plans—plans that stabilize the systems that they rely on and allow them to build secure lives. Budgets are about choice, and Ontario’s current pressures are the predictable result of sustained underinvestment. Independent analyses show that program spending is not keeping pace with population growth or our real costs. In practical terms, that means there’s fewer resources each year for health care, education, housing and social services, even as our demands continue to rise. Ontario raises significantly less revenue per person than most other provinces and that gap shows up directly in underfunded public services. This context matters because it explains why systems across the province are under strain. We need a plan to invest in publicly funded, publicly delivered health care, not just in infrastructure, but in the people who deliver that care. Independent officers like the Financial Accountability Office and the Canadian Institute for Health Information have been clear that current funding trajectories do not maintain service levels as Ontario’s population grows and ages. Hospitals are operating in permanent deficits, and nearly half ran deficits in the last fiscal year. At the same time, reliance on private staffing agencies has increased costs and destabilized the workforce. Investing in public hospitals, long-term care and community care means investing in stable staffing, retention and working conditions that support people to stay in stable, sustainable employment. That’s how public dollars deliver better outcomes. We also need a plan to invest in our future through child care. Demand has increased, but supply has not kept pace. Projections show that more than 220,000 children are likely to be left without access to licensed child care spaces. Affordability means little if families cannot find care. Access depends on a stable workforce. That requires funding models that support trained, well-paid early childhood educators and allow centres to plan and grow sustainably. Our schools are the heart of our communities, and yet they’re being stretched thin. After inflation and enrolment growth, Ontario now spends $260 less per student than it did in 2018 and 2019. That represents a $561-million gap this year alone—over $6 billion lost over seven years. These gaps show up in larger classes, fewer supports, deteriorating buildings and increasing pressures on students, education workers and teachers. If we want safe, supporting learning environments, funding must reflect real costs. The same pattern exists in post-secondary education. Ontario universities and colleges received the lowest per-student funding in Canada. Institutions are cutting programs, eliminating jobs, struggling to meet demand, particularly in regional and northern communities. A province that expects its post-secondary institutions to train the workforce of tomorrow must fund them accordingly. That preparation doesn’t stop at colleges and universities. Ontario also relies heavily on union-led skilled trades training centres to deliver quality, industry-ready training in skilled trades, including but not limited to construction, manufacturing, energy and infrastructure. These centres already train thousands of workers every year and are closely aligned with labour market needs. However, much of this training is dependent on short-term or unstable funding. That limits long-term planning and restricts the ability to expand capacity when demand grows. Stable, formalized provincial funding for union-led skilled trades training centres allows programs to invest in equipment, instructors and long-term training capacities. It ensures Ontario has the skilled workforce that we need to deliver public priorities, from housing to infrastructure to hospitals and schools. Across both the public and private sectors, the strength of Ontario’s economy depends on the strength of our labour framework. Many workers, particularly those facing precarious employment, face weak employment standards enforcement and health and safety protections that have not kept pace with modern workplaces. Far too often, workers are unable to access their rights without unnecessary barriers or delay. This has fiscal consequences. Preventable injuries, unsafe workplaces and unstable employment increase pressures on health care, income supports and social services. Stronger enforcement and proactive prevention help support people to remain in the workforce instead of cycling into income supports and emergency services. The same applies to public investments that are structured in the private sector. Far too often, public dollars are flowing into private projects without clear expectations attached. When investments lack the conditions around job quality, training, safety and stability, the benefits are extracted while the risks are absorbed by workers in community. Housing is a clear example. Ontario needs affordable homes. Public investment in non-profit co-operative housing supports affordability while creating stable, high-quality employment and strengthening local economies. When housing investments are designed around public benefit, they deliver better outcomes for communities, workers and for the province.

Official source

00:54:56Official transcript

Ms. Laura Walton

Whether they’re public service or private sector projects, investments work best when there is accountability. You have the ability to change this landscape. You can choose to invest in people, rather than shift costs onto families and communities. You can choose plans over promises, stability over erosion and public value over privatization. I’m asking you today to make that choice. Choose the workers who make our province strong. Choose families and communities by investing in publicly funded, publicly delivered services. Choose a legacy of building Ontario by investing in the people who truly build Ontario. Thank you.

Official source

00:55:27Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. We’ll now go to the Ontario Catholic School Trustees’ Association.

Official source

00:55:31Official transcript

Mr. Michael Bellmore

Good morning, Mr. Chair, Vice-Chair and committee members. Thank you for the opportunity to speak to you on behalf of Ontario’s 29 Catholic school boards. My name is Michael Bellmore, and I’m honoured to serve as the president of the Ontario Catholic School Trustees’ Association, which has been representing those 29 boards since 1930. I’m also honoured to be the chair of the Sudbury Catholic District School Board, so welcome on this cold, crisp day to sunny Sudbury. We are very grateful to have the opportunity to share with you some of the key financial priorities of our association and our Catholic school boards in this province. We acknowledge the many competing and complex interests and demands faced by your committee and this provincial government. Saying that, though, we know that effective, transparent and accountable publicly funded school systems are essential and key to promoting and sustaining caring and economically strong communities. In this regard, we support the government’s commitment to building a strong foundation for student learning, including focused resources and support of literacy and numeracy, and expanding opportunities in skilled trades and apprenticeship programs. To cite a few areas of particular challenge or priority, we recommend urgent attention and sufficient funding be provided in the upcoming provincial budget in the following areas—and I’m going to talk about a few and then Patrick Daly, our executive director who is joining us virtually, will come in at the end as well. The financial cost associated with the sick leave provisions contained within our collective agreements has increased significantly and, for a number of years, has placed significant financial pressure on school boards. Currently, all employee groups are able to access up to 11 days payable at 100% and 120 days payable at 90%, for a combined total of up to 131 paid days of sick leave per year. Cost increases with these provisions, combined with the indirect costs associated with the replacement of support staff and occasional teachers, as well as the increased administrative burdens in managing higher utilization, are leaving many of our Catholic school boards struggling to meet their obligations. In addition, the resulting absenteeism has a significant effect on the instructional environment and safety for students, particularly when occasional teachers and support staff are unavailable. It is our recommendation that the government adequately fund costs associated with current levels of sick leave and absenteeism. Student mental health: We welcome the government’s commitment to increasing funding to address student mental health and well-being, given how students have been impacted in the context of school closures in response to COVID-19 and a number of other factors. With the prolonged absence from school, the virtual learning context and limited social interactions due to health and safety concerns, boards have seen a significant increase in demand for their supports and services in this area. Catholic school boards appreciate recent enhancements in core education funding, but we urge that continued attention and priority be placed in this important area. Our recommendations are pretty straightforward: —that the government continue to review funding for student mental health needs and that it’s equitable and sustainable for all students over time; —that the Ministry of Education continue to support funding of a board-level mental health lead into the core education funding structure; —we also encourage the government to monitor and update the financial supports to boards to support local mental health and student well-being initiatives; and —that the Ministry of Education continue to address the changing nature of student mental health and well-being needs as evidenced in the need for ongoing enhanced prevention and intervention, and align staff professional development supports for students with mental health and behaviour regulation challenges. Catholic school boards remain committed to, and are working hard to, ensure the needs of their students with special education requirements are supported. However, providing the necessary level of support while ensuring health and safety presents unique challenges—for example, the need for specialized personal protective equipment for students and staff. The vast majority of our Ontario Catholic schools continue to run deficits in meeting the educational, psychological and support needs of our exceptional students. More sophisticated diagnostic techniques related to autism spectrum disorder have resulted in a significant increase in identifying this segment of the student population and have led to increases in demand on special education services in our boards. We recommend that the government establish a special education working group to review the adequacy and flexibility of special education funding. We further recommend that the government review needs-based funding models for high-needs special education students to supplement the overall funding model. And further, we recommend that the government continue to survey and monitor the current situation with boards and provide program and financial support as required to ensure students with special education needs can be provided psychoeducational assessments in a timely manner so boards can make the necessary accommodations. At this time, I call on Pat Daly.

Official source

01:00:00Official transcript

Mr. Patrick Daly

Thank you very much, Mr. President, distinguished Chair and committee members. As Mr. Bellmore as said, the recommendations made by OCSTA are made on the basis that the education funding system of Ontario must respond to four essential principles. First, that it must distribute education dollars equitably amongst all school boards and their students. Secondly, that the level of funding for education must be adequate to ensure—

Official source

01:00:50Official transcript

Mr. Patrick Daly

—quality education for students. Thirdly, that it must provide sufficient flexibility. And finally, that the education funding model must include mechanisms to support accountability. So in that regard, Mr. Chair, we just want to indicate that the intersection between inadequate funding and a lack of flexibility is placing school boards under significant financial pressures and really limiting their ability to maintain current programs and to add additional programs that are much needed by students. So in that regard, we recommend that the government reduce restrictions enveloping on operating funds that decrease school board flexibility and, secondly, that the government increase local priority funding to assist school boards in meeting their distinctive missions to deliver to the unique needs of the students in their system. In light of the time restraints, I’ll turn it back over to Mr. Bellmore.

Official source

01:02:35Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much for that. The time is up and maybe we can get the rest of the presentation in our rounds of questions. We’ll start with the first round. MPP Cerjanec.

Official source

01:02:55Official transcript

Mr. Rob Cerjanec

Through you, Chair: Thank you all for your presentations today. Mr. Bellmore, you raised some really important issues in our public education system and impacting Catholic education, in particular, talking about mental health and the importance of mental health supports in schools. Can you explain the importance of those mental health supports in schools and what’s needed for students to have access to them?

Official source

01:03:42Official transcript

Mr. Michael Bellmore

Yes, absolutely. Thank you for the question. I think it’s important to note—first of all, again, welcome to Sudbury—when you look at rural, remote, northern communities, particularly, I would say that those are most impacted and most disadvantaged because of our ability to retain and maintain the professionals that are required to deliver consistent programs and services. I would say it’s a problem province-wide but particularly more evident in our more rural and remote locations. We’ve seen an uptick on this, particularly going back to just prior to the pandemic, and it was highlighted after the pandemic, where we saw a burgeoning concern amongst our student populations. Pat, I’ll ask you to add to that as well.

Official source

01:05:05Official transcript

Mr. Patrick Daly

Yes, thank you, Michael. Just very briefly, what I would add to it is clearly the complexity of the challenges that young people are experiencing today and the increase in the number of students that—whether it’s mental health or all kinds of other challenges that they are experiencing in their lives, what that brings to schools and school systems has caused enormous pressure. So really, to add to Mr. Bellmore’s comments, the complexity aligned with the increase in the number of students is placing severe pressure on school board resources.

Official source

01:06:08Official transcript

Mr. Rob Cerjanec

Thank you. Around core education funding, we don’t know when that announcement is going to be, when the province informs school boards of when funding is going to take place. Can you talk to us about the impact of a delayed core education funding announcement?

Official source

01:06:40Official transcript

Mr. Patrick Daly

Thank you, Michael. For sure, a great question. Any delay limits a school board’s ability to effectively plan for the upcoming school year, particularly in the area of staffing. You know, a school board’s staffing from March through till the end of June is absolutely critical in planning for the next school year, so any delay will really limit the board’s ability to plan effectively for staffing. So that would be the biggest challenge, absolutely, in terms of staffing. But as well, to plan to ensure that they’re fiscally responsible, the more time it gives the finance staff and that to do a better job and the recommendations they can bring to the board of trustees.

Official source

01:07:57Official transcript

Mr. Rob Cerjanec

We hear a lot from this government in talking about school boards lately. One of the biggest challenges, though, is the chronic underfunding of our public education system, where there’s only so much juice you can get out of a lemon at the end of the day. We’re hearing issues around special education—I think that’s probably one of the biggest issues that we’re facing in public education right now. Kids with special needs are not getting the support that they need. The EAs, the ECEs, the support staff at schools—frankly, there’s not enough of them, number one. And then, number two, we have students with very complex needs—students with autism and just so many other challenges in our school system—where it’s impacting other kids in the classroom. So you spoke about establishing a special education working group at the province that I assume would involve labour, that would involve parents, that would involve advocates, that would involve school board trustees as well. How important would it be that the province actually get special education right?

Official source

01:10:00Official transcript

Mr. Michael Bellmore

I think it’s critical. As a trustee now—I’ve been a trustee for 20 years; Pat has been a trustee, prior to becoming our executive director, a lot longer. I’ve been a member of our special education advisory committee for the entirety of my being a trustee. And when I think back 19 years ago, what we were concerned about and what our priorities were then—

Official source

01:10:22Official transcript

Mr. Michael Bellmore

—and we fast-forward to today, we are seeing an increasing number of concerns coming forward. We’ve adopted a more integrated model, but that integrated model needs to be supported. If we’ve got a class size of 35 and even two of those students are high-needs requirements, those supports have to be in place, and we think that committee would help us retool, restructure and look at the importance of the funding in that area.

Official source

01:10:48Official transcript

Mr. Rob Cerjanec

Thank you very much. Very quickly: Jessie, there’s an issue with LifeLabs in Sudbury right now. How important is it that that diagnostic testing takes place within the communities that people are requesting it?

Official source

01:11:01Official transcript

Ms. Jessie Clelland

Specific to the LifeLabs closing, in my personal opinion, it’s going to be detrimental to this community. The LifeLabs testing facility in Sudbury tests samples from the Sudbury community but also from other communities as far as—

Official source

01:11:15Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time for that question. MPP Racinsky.

Official source

01:11:20Official transcript

Mr. Joseph Racinsky

Thank you to all the presenters for coming this morning. I really appreciate you sharing your perspective as we make our budget deliberations and get that feedback. I’ll continue with the Medical Laboratory Professionals’ Association of Ontario. We heard a very similar presentation a couple of days ago in Kapuskasing. I’m privileged to be able to have attended 11 of the 12 committee meetings all across Ontario so far, and it’s great to see some of the consistency and, obviously, nuance in different regions of the province. Just about your request of the 330 preceptors: You mentioned our Learn and Stay grant, which is a great program, especially for rural and northern areas. How do you see those things working together?

Official source

01:12:08Official transcript

Ms. Jessie Clelland

Yes. But the preceptors will work very well with the Learn and Stay grant, because it will allow the labs here more time to spend with the students to make sure that we’re really getting the best workforce release that we can, and it will help alleviate a lot of the delays in testing that are caused by having students. So with the Learn and Stay grant, we get the students here, they’re staying in the community, they’re working locally—fantastic. But this preceptor will just bring it that much further to ensure the best training without taking away from the care that we’re providing in the labs at the same time.

Official source

01:12:46Official transcript

Mr. Joseph Racinsky

Thank you for that. Last year, we announced $5 million to the Ontario Wet Labs Program to create a new wet lab housed in the University of Ottawa. How are investments like that supporting your industry?

Official source

01:12:58Official transcript

Ms. Jessie Clelland

Those are great as well. It’s really hard for some areas for these students to actually get clinical placements. Again, it ties into this: If they don’t have the staff to run the lab as it is, they’re not going to have staff to spend time with those students. So these wet labs allow a simulation lab where these students can go, they can get hands-on experience while not in a functioning laboratory per se. So it’s more of a—there’s a word that I’m looking for that’s escaping me—but it allows more training to be done without that extra pressure on the labs.

Official source

01:13:33Official transcript

Mr. Joseph Racinsky

Thank you. I want to try to get everybody in my five minutes, so I’ll move on to you, Michael. In the 2024-25 school year, our government announced 41 capital projects, 1,700 student spaces. In my riding, a few weeks ago, I was able to announce over 70 additional spaces at Sacred Heart Catholic Elementary School in my riding in the community of Rockwood. How important are those capital investments for our boards around the province?

Official source

01:13:59Official transcript

Mr. Michael Bellmore

We certainly have been very vocal in supporting your government and appreciate all the capital investments that they have made. There is a definitive backlog in the province of repairs that are required, and new builds. I think one of the key things, and I’ll let Pat talk about it a little further, is the moratorium on school closures really needs to be examined and spoken about. We talk about it in all the presentations we make. I am not aware of any trustee in my 20 years, and Pat can attest to his 40, that gets up in the morning and decides they want to go and close schools. That’s not what most people I know who sign up for this commitment are involved in. But we have to look rationally, since the moratorium was in place on school closures, about how many empty spaces boards are having to maintain and care for, which is a cost to the bottom line of that board’s budget, while those spaces aren’t filled because they don’t require that space anymore. Or we take an example like here in Sudbury: If I wanted to expand a school, if we go out north to the valley, which is 25 minutes from where I might have an open classroom space available, I can’t expand because I have an empty class that’s 25 minutes away. So the logistics of that, especially when we’re dealing with rural and remote locations, do have an impact. But we certainly are appreciative of the investments that have been made to date. Pat, you might want to add to that?

Official source

01:15:28Official transcript

Mr. Patrick Daly

Yes, thank you, Michael. I would just add to the appreciation. I had the pleasure of being at the historic announcement last year with the government’s announcement regarding capital funding. But as Michael said, there remains a significant backlog, and additional funding for sure is required. Michael’s comments with regard to the moratorium—the concerns around that cannot be overstated.

Official source

01:15:53Official transcript

Mr. Patrick Daly

There are clearly strategies to ensure that we deal with those one-school communities and rural school communities while resolving the issue of over-capacity in many, many boards.

Official source

01:16:03Official transcript

Mr. Joseph Racinsky

Thank you. And just really quick, Laura, I’m sorry I don’t have much time left for you. But our government is really committed to building infrastructure—highways, hospitals—in record amounts. How are those kinds of infrastructure projects benefiting the people you represent?

Official source

01:16:20Official transcript

Ms. Laura Walton

They are a benefit, and I will never say that they aren’t a benefit, but they need to start. What we don’t need is, “We’re going to build something,” and the people who haven’t even started school yet aren’t going to be on those job sites. Their children might be on those job sites. But we also have to look at the people who actually are doing the work in those buildings that we’re building. Are we actually funding so that we have teachers and education assistants in the same schools that we’re proud of opening? Are we hiring enough doctors, nurses and health care workers in the same hospitals that we’re building?

Official source

01:16:58Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time. MPP West.

Official source

01:17:05Official transcript

Ms. Laura Walton

I just want to be clear that we need both. Building a building or building a road without actually ensuring that we are able to maintain the road with the people who plow, making sure that we have enough people in the actual workforce providing those services—it isn’t either-or. It has to be both.

Official source

01:17:23Official transcript

MPP Jamie West

Thank you. And going back to your presentation, I would assume that part of the need for child care ensures that people are able to get to work so that they can—

Official source

01:17:33Official transcript

Ms. Laura Walton

Absolutely, yes. When we look at the child care spaces, 220,000 children languishing, that means that people aren’t getting to work. They’re having to take sick leave, unfortunately, because they don’t have adequate child care spaces. These are the folks who are going to be setting our children onto a pathway to the workforce. We need to make sure that they have the most well-trained folks in place so that we can set them off in the right direction.

Official source

01:18:01Official transcript

MPP Jamie West

I’m going to swing around because we only have five minutes, unfortunately, to ask questions. I want to give Jessie an opportunity to talk about LifeLabs. It’s a major issue in Sudbury. For those of you coming from out of town, there are 40 people in Sudbury alone, technologists—what’s the other word I’m looking for?

Official source

01:18:21Official transcript

MPP Jamie West

Technicians, thank you—I don’t want to forget either of them—who will be losing their jobs. So, they’ll draw the samples here and they will send them to southern Ontario. Just recently, they talked about the Learn and Stay grant, and what stood out to me is if you’re trying to attract people into a field where you’re losing 40 positions, that might put a chill on people coming into that field. Can you just expand on what this means and the importance of saving these jobs in northern Ontario?

Official source

01:18:51Official transcript

Ms. Jessie Clelland

Of course. The LifeLabs comparison to everything else is its own separate beast, but closing this LifeLabs and having these positions vacant—these 40, 45 people are losing their jobs. They might be able to get in at a hospital. They might be able to get in at another testing centre. Luckily, the medical laboratory professional schools are backlogged with people trying to get into it. This shouldn’t affect the number of people who still want to go through to pursue this career. What it will affect is the community. Do you want more details on that?

Official source

01:19:25Official transcript

MPP Jamie West

No, I wanted to underscore how important it is. The government ran on a “protect Ontario workers” campaign last year and you need to start protecting these workers. I keep seeing these things where they pour a bottle of Crown Royal down and those workers lose their jobs. I keep seeing them shrug their shoulders about LifeLabs and not protecting LifeLabs jobs. In Sault Ste. Marie, a thousand workers are out of work, and we gave them $100 million with no strings attached. We can’t keep doing this; either rip up the banner and get a new slogan or walk the talk.

Official source

01:20:00Official transcript

Ms. Jessie Clelland

Exactly. A lot of those jobs—like you said, I’ve heard people say, “Oh, they can go work at the hospital,” but there has to be availability at the hospital. There are different departments within the laboratory, so depending on where these people have worked—they may have spent their whole career in the hematology department, and there’s no hematology position available, so that means that they have to go elsewhere. They have to leave Sudbury to go find work somewhere else.

Official source

01:20:31Official transcript

MPP Jamie West

Thanks. Michael, it’s been a long time. I was thinking about how we first met when I had hair and you didn’t have glasses. I want to compliment you, because you have had a consistent career in education, and advocate not just in Sudbury but at Queen’s Park on a regular basis and bring that voice forward. The part that stood out to me—and it connects with Laura’s presentation as well, because I was making notes: Ontario now spends $260 less per student than it did in 2018-19. This year alone, that’s a gap of $561 million, and $6.53 billion lost over seven years. When you talk about supports for kids who need EAs—a lot of people come to my office who are frustrated, because they don’t have the supports and are frustrated and feel bad for the students and teacher in the class because their child gets overwhelmed and disrupts the classroom. What is the impact of that lack of funding?

Official source

01:21:28Official transcript

Mr. Michael Bellmore

Well, I think when you saw my comments about the amount of sick leave time and the increase in sick leave time, some of that can be attributed to some of these instances that we’ve had in some of our classroom situations, which are unfortunate situations. The more integrated model, that road that we’ve gone down—obviously, if you increase the demands in your classroom of requiring—again, if you have two students who are high-needs in that classroom, and they need those supports and those supports aren’t available, that impacts the entirety of that classroom. So in a classroom of 35 kids, if two are particularly high-needs, that’s 35 kids that are suffering, not just two—

Official source