Summary#
Bill 40, the Electoral Divisions Act, would repeal and replace Alberta’s 2017 Electoral Divisions Act. It would establish 91 electoral divisions for the Election Act, with names in a schedule and boundaries in a separate file; its stated goal is not given in the supplied material. The supplied text does not show passage or Royal Assent, so these changes are not yet in force.
- The new divisions would apply for the next general election when its writ is issued. A transitional rule would also treat the new divisions as in force for certain election-related actions before the writ.
- The boundaries are described in a USB file prepared by the Chief Electoral Officer and tabled in the Legislature. That file is not included in the supplied material.
- If a boundary passes through a building used for one or more residences, the Chief Electoral Officer may set the building’s division by regulation, after consulting the returning officers for the affected divisions.
- The transition rule applies to references to divisions in both the Election Act and the Election Finances and Contributions Disclosure Act. It does not authorize anyone to circumvent election expense limits.
What it means for you#
- Voters: Your electoral division for the next general election would be determined by the new boundaries. The bill does not change voter eligibility or how people vote.
- Candidates, parties and other people or organizations covered by election-finance rules: The transitional rule would apply the new divisions to certain actions for the next election before the writ is issued. The bill expressly does not permit circumventing expense limits.
- Chief Electoral Officer and returning officers: The Chief Electoral Officer may make a regulation to assign a residence-used building to one division if a boundary passes through it. The officer must first consult the returning officers for those divisions.
- Taxpayers: The bill requires no specific new tax, fee or payment from the public.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill gives the Chief Electoral Officer authority to make a regulation in the limited case of a boundary passing through a building used for residences, but gives no estimate of the cost of this work.
- No staffing, operating budget or other spending amount is specified.
What is unclear#
- The USB file containing the boundaries is not supplied, so it is not possible to identify which areas or voters would be moved.
- The 2017 Act and its boundaries are not supplied, so the available material does not show how many boundaries or division names would change compared with current law.
- The bill does not set out a public notice, hearing, review or appeal process for the boundary descriptions or for a regulation assigning a building to a division.
- The bill does not say when section 5, the transitional rule, starts. The main start date is the day the writ is issued for the next general election.
- “Building used for one or more residences” is not defined in the supplied text.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it sets out the electoral divisions to be used for the next general election, including their names and boundaries.
- The special rule for a boundary that cuts through a residence-used building gives the Chief Electoral Officer a way to assign that building to one division, after consulting the affected returning officers.
- Applying the new divisions to certain pre-writ election actions could avoid uncertainty about which divisions apply to those actions.
Case against#
- Without the boundary file, voters cannot tell from the supplied material whether their division would change or how the new boundaries would affect their area.
- The bill does not require public input or provide a way to challenge a boundary or a building assignment.
- The Chief Electoral Officer’s authority to assign a building is limited to the stated circumstance, but the bill does not explain what factors should guide that choice.