Council keeps three recommendations confidential

Summary#

Calgary City Council carried a motion on October 20, 2026, adopting three confidential recommendations in a verbal personnel matter. The motion also set confidentiality rules, but the recommendations themselves are not public, so their substance and practical effect cannot be explained.

  • Recommendation 1 is to remain confidential pending a public announcement by the Mayor.
  • The closed-meeting discussion, the document received for the corporate record, and Recommendations 2 and 3 are to remain confidential and not be released. The motion carried 14 to 1; Councillor Johnston voted against.

What it means for you#

  • Public: The available record does not say what Council decided in the confidential recommendations. It only says which records and recommendations are to remain confidential.
  • Mayor: A public announcement is the stated condition for Recommendation 1’s confidentiality to end. The motion does not say when an announcement will happen or what it will disclose.

Money#

No publicly available information about costs or amounts.

  • The public motion gives no spending, staffing, payment, or other financial details.

What is unclear#

  • What Recommendations 1 through 3 require or change.
  • Whether, when, and how much of Recommendation 1 will be made public after the Mayor’s announcement.
  • The reasons Councillor Johnston voted against the motion; the record provided does not state them.

Case for#

  • The motion cites personal privacy, confidential evaluations, and advice from officials as grounds for keeping the records confidential. Protecting those matters is a possible reason for limiting disclosure.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the public cannot assess the substance or effects of the recommendations from the available record.
  • Councillor Johnston voted against the motion, but no reason for his opposition is provided.

Votes

Calgary City Council, item 12.2.1 (Personnel Matter (Verbal), C2026-0957): That with respect to Confidential Verbal Report C2026-0957, the following be adopted: That Council: - Adopt Confidential Recommendations 1 through 3; - Direct that Recommendation 1 remain confidential pursuant to Sections 20 (Disclosure harmful to personal privacy), 22 (Confidential evaluations), and 29 (Advice from officials) of the Access to Information Act, pending a public announcement by the…

For (93%)
Against (7%)