Housing zoning change rejected

Summary#

Calgary City Council defeated, 2 to 13, a motion to approve a land use change at 2330 and 2332 – 5 Avenue NW in West Hillhurst, Ward 7. The motion would have changed the lots from Residential – Grade-Oriented Infill (R-CG) to Housing – Grade Oriented (H-GO); that change was not adopted. City staff said the proposed change aimed to allow more housing choice and use existing infrastructure and nearby services more efficiently.

  • The motion would have allowed a wider range of attached or stacked homes on the 0.10-hectare (0.24-acre) site.
  • It did not approve a specific building plan. A separate application for eight units and eight secondary suites was under review when City staff wrote their report.
  • Councillors McLean, Wyness, Chabot, Dhaliwal, Kelly, Tyers, Yule, Pantazopoulos, Atkinson, Clark, Ward, Jamieson and Johnston voted against the motion.

What it means for you#

  • People living nearby: The land use change was rejected. The supplied report identifies R-CG as the lots’ existing district. The Council decision did not decide the separate development-permit application.
  • People seeking housing in West Hillhurst: The proposed H-GO change was not approved, so it does not create the additional housing options described in the staff report.

Money#

City staff reported no anticipated financial impact; the materials give no cost estimate.

  • The report does not identify a fee, fine, grant or other payment connected with the decision.

What is unclear#

  • City staff said the permit application for eight units and eight suites was under review. The materials do not say what happened to it after Council rejected the land use change, or whether development could proceed under the existing district.

Case for#

  • City staff said H-GO would allow more housing types and choice, which they said could better serve people with different ages, lifestyles and needs.
  • City staff considered the proposed density appropriate and compatible with the neighbourhood, and consistent with the Municipal Development Plan and Riley Communities Local Area Plan.
  • Two public letters supported the change, citing the site’s proximity to transit and the potential for more housing and nearby amenities or small businesses.

Case against#

  • City staff reported 14 objection letters. Concerns included more traffic and parking pressure, effects on neighbouring homes’ value, less sunlight and privacy, and whether infrastructure and amenities could handle more users.
  • The West Hillhurst Community Association opposed the change, raising concerns about building height and size, street noise, materials and the streetscape. These are concerns raised in submissions, not findings that those effects would occur.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 831017

    Defeated15 members voted

    Public Hearing Meeting of Council, item 7.2.4 (Land Use Amendment in West Hillhurst (Ward 7) at 2330 and 2332 – 5 Avenue NW, LOC2025-0132, CPC2025-0948): That with respect to Report CPC2025-0948, the following be adopted: That Council give three readings to Proposed Bylaw 7D2026 for the redesignation of 0.10 hectares ± (0.24 acres ±) located at 2330 and 2332 – 5 Avenue NW (Plan 5612FO, Block 12, Lot 55 and 56) from Residential – Grade-Oriented Infill (R-CG) District to Housing – Grade Oriented (H-GO) District.

    AGAINST · 13FOR · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    13Against

    • Independent7
    • Communities First4
    • A Better Calgary Party1
    • The Calgary Party1

    2For

    • Independent2