Emmanuella Lambropoulos (Lib.)6:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for Etobicoke—Lakeshore.
Today, I rise to speak in support of Bill C‑41, the medical assistance in dying safeguards act. This is a bill that is particularly close to my heart and to which I am deeply committed.
This bill would prevent the planned expansion of MAID for mental illness and would allow for advance requests, subject to strict conditions and safeguards. I believe it takes a careful, compassionate and balanced approach that respects the will of individuals while recognizing our responsibility to protect those who are most vulnerable.
This is a deeply personal issue for me, as it is for many Canadians in this country. This is an issue that asks us to consider some very difficult questions about suffering, dignity and protecting people when they are at their most vulnerable.
I approach the subject knowing very well that we all have different experiences and beliefs when it comes to such a sensitive subject, and I respect that. Whatever our views, as politicians we have a responsibility to listen carefully and remember that every decision we make here affects real people and their families.
Today, I want to explain why this bill matters to me and why I advocated for caution in expanding MAID to people whose sole underlying condition is mental illness. I commend the Minister of Justice and Minister of Health for proposing reforms that would maintain this exclusion, would allow people diagnosed with conditions such as Alzheimer's to make advance requests, where permitted by provinces and territories, and would strengthen the national oversight of MAID.
Let us begin with the first pillar: preventing the scheduled expansion of MAID on the basis of a mental illness. March 17, 2024, was the original date that MAID was to extend to people suffering from mental illness alone. This followed a Senate amendment to the original bill, an amendment that introduced a provision that would expand MAID to mental illness. This would have given people suffering from a mental illness, including depression, the right to apply for assisted death.
Having a background in psychology, I was particularly concerned about what this expansion could mean. Mental illness can cause profound suffering. It can affect so many aspects of our lives, such as our relationships, work or physical health, and our ability to get through the day. For some, this suffering can go on for years. Symptoms can change over time, and recovery can be difficult to predict. People can respond differently to treatments, and finding the right balance of care and treatment can take time.
This left me with some serious questions about how we could determine that a person's condition would not improve and about how to ensure that people had meaningful access to treatment and support before they ever reached the point of applying for MAID. These apprehensions did not sit well with me at all. They led me to speak up and express my concern with my caucus colleagues in order to ensure that these difficult questions received the attention they deserved. I felt compelled to contribute to this discussion and explain why I believed more time was needed and why we needed a more cautious approach.
As the date approached, I felt a responsibility to my constituents in Saint-Laurent and to all Canadians to raise my concerns and sound the alarm. I kept thinking about the people and families who could be affected by this decision, people experiencing profound suffering, some of whom might still be struggling to find the right treatment or supports. I wanted us to take the time to work through these difficult questions and be confident that we could protect those at risk.
Ahead of the vote on a private member's bill addressing this issue, two of my colleagues and I voiced our concerns and worked within our caucus to advocate for the expansion to be postponed. These were constructive discussions about a deeply sensitive issue, and although these conversations were very difficult, I honestly did not believe that going ahead with the legislation as it was proposed with the extension was the right move.
My concern was whether we could move forward safely, whether our health care system was prepared and whether people living with mental illness had access to the treatment and support they needed. Most of all, if it is possible for people to recover from their mental illness and live functional and peaceful lives, would this legislation take this possibility away prematurely? As those important discussions continued, other colleagues shared their perspectives and concerns, contributing to a growing recognition that more time was needed before this legislation could be adopted.
The government decided to create the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying specifically to study whether it should be expanded to individuals suffering solely from a mental illness. That committee found that Canada was not ready to offer MAID for mental illness, and the government subsequently introduced Bill C-62, which received royal assent on February 29, 2024. The legislation postponed the expansion of MAID to people whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness until March 17, 2027. It also required a parliamentary committee review of the health care system's readiness.
Bill C-41 would prevent this expansion from happening. Today, I will share some of the main concerns that I raised with my caucus and that have shaped my position on this piece of legislation.
Originally, medical assistance in dying was allowable only in cases where a patient had an irremediable health condition. To have an irremediable condition means that the condition has become permanent and cannot be reversed. According to witnesses at the MAID committee, there is a lack of established criteria to determine if a mental illness is irremediable, as well as a lack of consensus among psychiatrists for if and when a mental illness should be considered irremediable. Furthermore, we are still learning about the brain and continue to do so every day. The brain is neuroplastic, meaning it continuously changes and grows in response to a person's environment and experiences. This does not mean it always changes for the better or that it improves, but it does mean that it can be difficult to predict if a mental illness will be irremediable or if it can be healed.
According to Sharon Reynolds in an article published in the National Institutes of Health journal, there are some properties in some types of psychedelic drugs that have shown promise as therapies for treatment-resistant depression and PTSD. They encourage growth of new neural connections in the brain, so it might be possible to develop related drugs that can promote brain plasticity without causing harmful and hallucinogenic effects. This would be a very promising development.
Another concern that I had with expanding MAID to individuals suffering solely from mental illness is the fact that we do not have adequate mental health care services in Canada. Therefore, people would be applying for MAID without trying other treatments for a lack of accessibility to them. According to the Canadian Institute for Health Information, there are several factors that contribute to unmet mental health needs across the country, and these include cost, as many services are not fully covered by public health insurance; caregiving or work responsibilities; a lack of support in navigating existing services; a lack of trust in the health care system; and the fear of what others may think for needing help in the first place, due to the stigma associated with mental health issues.
The second pillar speaks to another group of Canadians, those living with Alzheimer's or another form of dementia and the families who walk beside them. For these Canadians, there may come a day when they can no longer tell the people they love what they want at the end of their life. Today, under the Criminal Code, they cannot say it in advance. Advance requests are prohibited.
An advance request allows a person who has been diagnosed with a capacity-limiting disease like Alzheimer's to set out the circumstances under which they would want to receive MAID in the future after they have lost the capacity to consent. Canadians living with dementia have told us clearly that they want their wishes respected. Bill C-41 would permit advance requests so that a person diagnosed with a capacity-limiting disease can set one out while they still can. It does so with care, by setting minimum national safeguards in the Criminal Code for the lawful provision of MAID based on advance requests.
Over the past few weeks, people in my riding have put it better than I ever could: People struggling with mental illness deserve care that is compassionate, hopeful, and focused on suicide prevention, not medical assistance in dying. They told me that many people living with mental illness will reach such a low point that they will come to see MAID as the only way to escape their suffering. Furthermore, they asked me a question that has stayed with me: When that person is at their lowest point, what do we, as a society, say to them? Do we reinforce their sense of despair, or do we protect, support and care for them?
If we do not take action, the current exclusion will end on March 17, 2027. Bill C-41 addresses this. It takes a cautious approach, as there is still no clinical consensus and too many Canadians still cannot access the mental health care they need. A parliamentary committee composed of senators and members of Parliament from various parties heard from experts and stakeholders and recommended not moving forward. The bill follows through on that recommendation.
The bill is the result of listening. We heard from parliamentary committees, clinicians, the provinces and territories, disability groups and academics, and this decision follows the evidence so that people get the support they need. To those who are struggling, the bill offers hope and is a promise—
James Maloney (Lib.)6:30 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to stand up and speak to Bill C-41 for reasons that will become apparent as I move forward.
MAID is, frankly, one of the more difficult issues that I have had to deal with in my 11 years here as an MP. It is an issue that deals with people at the most vulnerable time in their life, making one of the most difficult decisions they will ever make. We have a great responsibility in getting this right. It is a discussion, of course, that people wish they never had to have, but it is a conversation that is necessary, and that is why this piece of legislation is so important.
MAID provides Canadians with the ability to make a choice about how they wish to live out their last days and to exercise some control over the most inevitable parts of human existence, and it brings comfort to their family members. It is also something that generates a lot of questions and concerns from Canadians, and rightly so.
People across the country are struggling with these personal issues. When family members are ill, sick and dying, they are dealing with medical professionals, and they need to know that this is a top priority for us. I know this because I, like every other member of Parliament in this chamber, have received phone calls and emails from constituents and people sharing these deeply personal stories.
The most recent iteration of the special MAID committee, which I had the honour of sitting on, completed its work in June. I see one of my colleagues across the way. She was on the committee with me, so she understands the great angst that we all experienced in dealing with these deeply personal issues. We heard from witnesses. We listened to testimony. We heard from professionals. We heard from families with lived experience. I think we got it right. It was a tough decision to make, and anybody who thinks that committee did not take its job seriously was not paying attention.
Bill C-41 would get us to where we need to be, in my opinion, and I am honoured to stand up here and speak to it. Firstly, the bill would conclusively halt the scheduled expansion of MAID on the basis of mental illness. Secondly, it would legalize the provision of MAID on the basis of an advance request. An adult diagnosed with a capacity-limiting illness could make a request while they still have the capacity to do so, in anticipation of a future loss of capacity.
I want to speak first about the mental illness decision. As I said, I was on this committee most recently. I was on the committee immediately prior to that, when we reviewed the issue. I was on the committee the first time there was a joint committee. I was also on the justice committee when the legislation was first considered and, ultimately, was introduced.
I have heard from all of the witnesses time and time again. I know how troubling this issue is. I struggled with it myself. Mental illness is a real issue. It is a real medical condition. However, we have to get this right. Until we have concurrence among the medical community, we as legislators would be irresponsible to do anything but introduce this bill and stop the law from coming into effect on March 17 of next year.
All three times, we heard from experts from across the country, people who practise in this area, people who are specialized and have particular knowledge. We heard from family members. The overwhelming majority view was that the system is not ready, the country is not ready, and we cannot responsibly and safely introduce MAID for people whose sole underlying condition is mental illness.
There is no consensus among the doctors. If we cannot get consensus among the doctors on a diagnosis, how can we possibly get consensus among the doctors on whether we should proceed? That is a very important distinction. This is not a value judgment. We have to listen to these experts, but if 10 doctors examine the same patient and cannot agree on the diagnosis, how can we possibly responsibly proceed and allow this to take effect? We cannot. That is where we are today.
An irremediable mental health condition is something the medical community can simply not agree on, full stop. That is why we are here talking about this today. This is not to say that mental illness is not a serious or grievous condition. We all know it is. We have talked about it many times. We all have people in our families who experience these challenges. Nobody makes light of this, I can assure members. It does not matter. It does not mean people cannot be helped. It does not mean there is not help out there for these people in their darkest moment to have something to look forward to. That is why this is so important.
The committee heard from experts about the insufficient mental health services available in this country. Let us call it what it is. We know that. That is something we have to address here. It is something the provinces have to address. It is something that I am proud to say this government, and in fact all parliamentarians as it is not a partisan issue, can agree on and something we have made great strides on.
This first part of the bill is not only important but urgent. If we do not pass it immediately, the law takes effect on March 17, 2027, so I am asking every member of this House to vote in favour of Bill C-41 for that reason and the reasons I have outlined.
The second part of the bill deals with creating a framework for baseline safeguards for the provinces and territories to be able to introduce their own legislation to allow MAID to be provided on the basis of an advance request. An advance request lets a person decide now, after diagnosis of a disease that in the future would strip them of the ability to consent to MAID, to make decisions about their end-of-life care while they still can. This generates great debate too.
The crux of the concern that I have heard is that people lose their ability to make the decision, which means we do not know if they have possibly changed their mind. Here is the thing about that. We know when we are making that decision that that is part of the equation. If I am presented with that scenario, and I know the action is going to be carried out after I have lost my ability to make that decision, I make that decision myself, and I know that going in. That is consent. I think people need to give that serious consideration.
I know my friend across the way is going to raise the issue of a perceived lack of study. It has been studied. I have been on all three iterations of this committee. Members can look at the report from the first one. The matter of advance requests was part of our discussion. We reviewed it thoroughly. We heard from experts. We gave it detailed consideration. This is not something the government just decided to do. This debate has been going on for several years. Not only that, but when this bill gets through the House, it will go to committee and we will have the opportunity to scrutinize it again. Members can rest assured that this will be done responsibly. I have great confidence that that is a fact.
Under Bill C-41, in order to qualify or make the decision for an advance request, the requester must be an adult, 18 years old or older; live in Canada and be eligible for publicly funded health care; have a diagnosis of an incurable, capacity-limiting disease; and have the capacity to make the decision about their own health care. I emphasize that again.
The advance request must be drafted with the assistance of a physician or a nurse practitioner and in consultation with an expert in this disease. The request reflects the person's voluntary and informed decision. I cannot put enough emphasis on this. It is an informed decision, when one has the ability and the capacity to make that decision. Is that not what we want? I say the answer to that is yes.
I know I am running out of time. I think this legislation would put our country where it needs to be. I feel very strongly about it. It is an issue I have been committed to for many years now, and I am very proud to be standing here in support of this bill.
Arpan Khanna (CPC)6:45 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with my great colleague from Cloverdale—Langley City.
In hearing the debates and discussions, I would say we all know this is a tough topic to talk about. It is an issue that affects everyone deeply. I am not here to change anyone's mind; I am here to raise concerns that I see on this issue.
I want to start by first sharing a story with the House. In 2014, my uncle was admitted to the hospital and then was moved to the ICU. He was not breathing on his own and had internal bleeding. The doctors said to us that his time was up and that he was not going to make it. We were told to make the funeral arrangements. My cousin and I went to the funeral home, booked the funeral, blew his picture up for the ceremony and called our family in the U.K. We were by his side for what we thought were his last moments.
The doctor then asked us if the family was done spending time with the patient, and we said no. She said she wanted us to witness his transition into his new life. My aunt asked what the doctor meant by “new life”. The doctor said he was not going to make it. He had internal bleeding in his brain, he was not breathing and he was in the ICU. My aunt said that God brought him in and God would take him out. Thankfully she said that, because he was alive for 12 years after that. He just passed away in August. He got to see his children's wedding, and he got to play with his grandkids. Those are moments with him that we will never forget. Had we taken the doctor's advice back then, he would not have been with us for them.
I was in the emergency room of another hospital, where people go to get help, and on the wall was a massive TV that asked, “Have you considered MAID?” Patients go to hospitals to get help and support, yet the hospital was pushing MAID.
This is a very touchy topic for everyone. I understand that the Liberals are now having conversations on this topic, and that is fine, but in this bill, there are two main components. One is the mental illness side and the other is advance requests. All parliamentarians have said that mental illness should not be the sole illness when it comes to MAID. We all agreed to it, yet the Liberals decided to vote that down a few weeks ago. They had the opportunity to have a bill that would satisfy the Supreme Court's requirements and meet the deadline for 2027, but they voted it down.
We all agree on the mental illness component in this bill. The Conservatives are united on that. That is why we have asked the government to work with us. We should work together and pass the bill. We should also split the bill. We all agree on the mental illness side, which would take care of the time constraint being put on us and would save lives, but the Liberals said, no, they would not do that. They have added the advance request to the equation. They are two separate issues that require two separate discussions.
I understand that the Liberals want to rush this bill through, but Canadians want an open, honest discussion. We want to bring in medical experts, provincial leaders, researchers, families, veterans and folks from indigenous communities to share opinions. The member opposite said that we have to get this right. Absolutely, we do. Let us put the mental illness side to rest. We all support it, and we would pass it tomorrow if the Liberals had a desire to do that. We would pass it at all stages tomorrow so we could focus on the issues that are still outstanding on advance requests. That seems like a common-sense idea. That seems like the right thing to do.
The statistics on MAID are insane. In Canada, 5% of all deaths are by MAID. Over 5% is one in 20. One in 10 people has said they know someone who has been offered MAID for a treatable condition. Safeguards have to be in place. We need to make sure there are safeguards protecting the most vulnerable.
I have talked to provincial leaders and spoken to doctors about the bill who are saying to hold on and are asking what the rush is. They ask, “Why are they combining these two issues into one vote?” They are confused. I understand that my colleague was talking about the studies the Liberals have done, so they should not be afraid to get back to the table and have a lengthy debate about this and call in the experts. There are two separate issues, and there are provincial jurisdictional concerns as well.
When I have conversations with members of the party opposite, they tell me that there might be some patchwork. Some provinces might buy into it and some might not, and that is a problem as well. We want to have a unified approach when it comes to these issues.
The other challenge we have is that MAID cannot be a substitute for bad health care. I understand that it is a provincial responsibility, but we have to make sure that any legislation we put forward can handle the current system. Sixty-three per cent of Canadians believe we are in a state of crisis when it comes to our health care. Canada has one of the worst wait times in the world for surgeries. We do not want people to feel so pressured and burdened when looking at the state of health care that they decide to end their lives. We have heard stories of that already, and it is a huge concern for us. MAID cannot be a substitute for bad health care.
I also believe that the language being used in this legislation could be tightened up. There is lots of room for amendments, but it has to go back to the drawing board. We have to have these conversations. We have to have these discussions. Again, we have offered the Liberals that solution. We have told them we will work with them. We made it very clear that this is not about party politics. Let us not make it about party politics. Let us make it about the lives of people, the innocent and vulnerable, who need that support. That will be my request going forward in this debate.
Conservatives are united on this: please, split the bill. Give us the time we need to study it. If we get this wrong, lives will be lost. This is a matter of life and death. I know my colleagues across the aisle agree that we have to get this right. They have the opportunity to do what is right to get this bill done. We have a responsibility as parliamentarians to protect the most vulnerable. It is our responsibility. We have to look at all options on this.
If someone needs help, we should have a health care system that supports them. We should be giving them care. We should be giving them the tools they need to get their lives back. If those do not exist, people will be pushed toward something they do not want to do. We do not want to be in a situation where we are taking away lives.
I always say that a person's worth should never be measured by their illness, their disability, their age or their need for care. I generally believe in that. I believe in the sanctity of human life. I believe that when someone is struggling, we should be there for them. We should be a country that is united in providing that care.
As we progress, as we have conversations and debates, my only ask, again, of the Liberal government is to split the bill. Lives are at stake. Let us slow down. Irrespective of what side someone is on, whether they support advance requests or not, there are legitimate concerns with this bill the way it is written. We need the time and the expertise from across the board to analyze this so we do not lose any lives. Every single day that I stand in this House, that I have the honour of serving our country, I will fight for that.
Tamara Jansen (CPC)7:00 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, there is a cruel kind of thief that enters a home without breaking a window or turning a lock. It does not steal the family's silver or the money tucked away for a rainy day. The thief takes something far more precious. It steals memories, familiar faces and little pieces of a lifetime lovingly built together. About 10 years ago, that thief came for my auntie Grace.
She arrived in Canada from Holland in her early twenties, stepping off a ship in Halifax with a whole new life ahead of her. She found work as a maid at 24 Sussex Drive for Prime Minister John Diefenbaker, where she even served tea to President Kennedy. Each morning, as she brought Mr. Diefenbaker his tea, he would hand her the newspaper and ask her to read aloud. She was in Canada now, he told her, and learning English was important, and learn she did. She married my uncle John, raised a family and together they built a successful pest control business. When they were not working, they would hitch up their little tent trailer and explore the beautiful country they had made their home. It was a good life, filled with hard work, adventure and love, but Alzheimer's has a terrible way of unravelling even the most beautiful stories.
My uncle cared for her at home until about five years ago, when her needs became more than he could manage alone. Today, at 92, he drives from Langley to Surrey every single day to sit beside his wife, make sure she is eating and see that she is being cared for. I remember him sending me a little video. There she was, happily sorting a tray of mismatched socks into pairs, only to mix them up and begin again. My uncle was so excited to show me how happy she was.
These days, she does not recognize the man who has loved her for a lifetime or the children they raised together, but sometimes, when the family sings old, familiar hymns, she quietly hums along. Every once in a while, the faintest glimmer of recognition sparkles in her eyes. How precious those moments are to a husband who has devoted his life to loving his wife. Imagine another scenario.
Imagine that, years ago, while my aunt was still the capable woman who had built the business, raised her children and travelled across Canada, she had written down a simple instruction, that if the day ever came when she no longer recognized her husband or children, she did not want to go on living. Perhaps she could not imagine there might still be happiness in a familiar song or contentment in sorting mismatched socks or love in the quiet presence of a husband she could no longer name. Imagine that day has come and someone must decide whether the time has come to act upon her words.
There is something deeply troubling about asking someone to predict years in advance what will make their life worth living. When we are healthy and independent, we imagine all things we could not possibly bear. We tell ourselves we could never live without our memories and our independence, but something remarkable happens when people actually live through circumstances they once feared. Researchers call it the disability paradox.
In a study of people with disabilities, more than half of those with moderate to serious disabilities described their quality of life as good or excellent. Lives that others might look upon with pity were lives the people living them still very much enjoyed. Researchers in the Netherlands studying advance euthanasia requests among people with Huntington's disease also found that people making those requests recognized that their wishes might change as their illness progressed. The person writing an advance request is imagining a future they have never lived, but the person living that future may have discovered reasons to treasure it. When the decision is irreversible, that difference matters.
I think about my aunt sitting contentedly with her mismatched socks and my uncle watching her, grateful for every smile. What if she had signed an advance request? Who would speak for the woman she is today? Who would notice that she was happy? Who would ask whether the suffering she once feared had actually become the suffering she was experiencing? Who would stop it if someone got that decision terribly wrong? When I turn to Bill C-41, I do not find the protections that would give me confidence that those questions have been answered. There is no requirement to tell a person their life is about to be ended or consult the family who knows them best, or have a dementia specialist examine them when that final decision is made. When the family disagrees, there is no independent court or tribunal required to review the decision before it proceeds.
Then, there is the question of intolerable suffering. How can we be certain someone is suffering intolerably when they can no longer tell us what they are feeling? Researchers have spent years developing ways to recognize pain in advanced dementia, yet there is no gold standard assessment tool. A grimace might mean pain. Agitation might mean infection or an unfamiliar environment. These are things we should be trying to understand and treat, yet Bill C-41 would ask practitioners to determine not simply whether someone is suffering, but whether someone is suffering intolerably. How can we ask someone who cannot tell us what they are feeling to bear the consequences of another person's judgment about whether their life is still worth living?
I want to take us now into an Ontario care home on a summer morning this past July. An 83-year-old grandmother named Brigitte Stegemann was lying in her bed. She was someone's mother and grandmother, and a woman whose family had loved her for a lifetime, but this was the morning she had scheduled to die. According to her granddaughter, just two days earlier, Brigitte had broken down in tears when she learned the date had been set. She said she had made a mistake, but now the day had arrived. Her granddaughter describes a nurse struggling to insert an IV, leaving blood on Brigitte's nightgown and bedding.
When the doctor arrived, Brigitte lay quietly with her eyes closed and her hands clasped tightly together, almost as though she was praying. Perhaps she was praying. Her family does not know. When the doctor asked whether they could proceed, Brigitte gave no answer. She did not open her eyes. She did not nod. She did not speak. Her granddaughter says she felt a wave of relief, believing the procedure would stop without confirmation of her grandmother's wishes, but it did not, and within minutes, Brigitte was gone.
This happened under existing MAID laws, before Parliament had even authorized this new expansion. A granddaughter is left wondering whether their grandmother's wishes were respected and whether the safeguards meant to protect her worked at all. Now, Parliament is being asked to allow advance requests to be carried out when someone cannot consent nor confirm that they still want to die. If we cannot be certain that consent is being properly respected under today's system, how can we be confident we will recognize a change of heart in someone who can no longer tell us what they want?
The government has chosen to call Bill C-41 the medical assistance in dying safeguards act. What a remarkable name for a bill that purports to protect one group of vulnerable Canadians while opening the door to an entirely new expansion for people who can no longer consent.
What troubles me most is what the government chose not to include. When I introduced Bill C-218 to protect Canadians suffering from mental illness, people asked why I had not included more mental health supports. I would have loved to, but as a private member, I was limited to what I could do in my bill. The government has no excuse. Instead of including the treatment, counselling and compassionate care vulnerable Canadians desperately need, the Liberals chose to attach an entirely different expansion of assisted dying. The only reason these two decisions are tied together is for political spite. The government could protect Canadians struggling with mental illness right now by splitting the bill and passing the mental illness exclusion today and then give Parliament the time to properly scrutinize the rest of the bill. With the looming March deadline, the Liberals have made the protection of one vulnerable group conditional on expanding assisted dying to another.
As I stand here today, I keep thinking about my uncle John. Tomorrow morning, at 92 years old, he will get into his car and make that familiar drive from Langley to Surrey. He will find his wife and sit beside the woman he has loved for a lifetime. Perhaps she will recognize him. More likely, she will not. Perhaps they will sing an old hymn and she will happily sort her little pile of mismatched socks. My uncle will treasure every minute, because while Alzheimer's has stolen so much from my aunt, it has not stolen her ability to experience happiness and it has not stolen my uncle's love for her. Who among us has the wisdom to decide that those moments no longer matter? The thief has already taken her memories. Let us be careful that the law does not take away her tomorrows.
Luc Thériault (BQ)7:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, in this debate, which can get quite emotional, I am going to try to live up to my riding's name, and I will remain calm.
The bill before us today is really two bills in one. The government proposed that the vote at second reading be split. In fact, I expected the Conservatives to support that proposal, but that does not appear to be the case. Later, at third reading, we can discuss whether it is appropriate to split the vote or even split the bill. However, for now, it seems to me that it would have been wise for everyone to agree to hold separate votes at second reading. The reason is that mental illness raises a distinct set of issues, while advance requests raise a different set of issues altogether. In my opinion, there should have been two separate bills.
As I have said many times, when it comes to a human being determining the conditions of their end of life and determining what they consider to be the threshold of what is tolerable in this process, the law recognizes the principle of self-determination. The Baudouin ruling, which is an interpretation of the Carter decision, makes it clear that, in matters relating to mental illness, a blanket prohibition is discriminatory. What bothers me a great deal today is that, from the very first Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying, the question was not whether we should move forward on the issue of mental illness. On the contrary, we said that we would wait and see whether the network, the providers and the system were capable of proceeding safely. That was the issue. It was not about whether we should move forward with it or not. Why were we so convinced of that as soon as we saw the first report from the late Marc Garneau, who was the chair of the committee? It was precisely because a blanket prohibition is discriminatory in nature.
I heard all sorts of things about mental illness: astonishing intellectual shortcuts, horror stories and anecdotes. People are basing their positions on absolutely nothing. If what some are describing is actually happening today in the context of mental illness, that is, if people are being encouraged under the current law to choose medical assistance in dying, or if it is being suggested to people with mental illness, that is a criminal offence. It is that simple. One calls the police and reports it, because the Criminal Code already governs such situations. When witnesses come before committee and tell us anecdotal stories of that nature, I ask them whether they reported the matter to the police, because those cases are already covered by the Criminal Code.
However, if we have legislation that sets out all the safeguards needed to ensure that things are done properly, that is quite a different matter. I heard all sorts of claims. The point, here, is not to suddenly allow a suicidal or depressed minor access to MAID. Such a person would not even be assessed for that purpose. Simply making a request does not make someone eligible. Some witnesses came and told us that if the bill had been passed, they would not have been there, in front of us. What basis do these people have for making such claims, given that the assessment process is precise and rigorous?
The unfortunate thing about this debate is that very few lawmakers here have carefully read the experts' report laying out all of the safeguards that would be needed to safely provide medical assistance in dying for people with mental disorders.
Some will tell me that psychiatrists cannot assess irremediability. Fine, but they assess people's decision-making capacity every day. There are people with mental disorders who also have cancer, and their capacity to consent, or not consent, to MAID based on their cancer can be assessed. Everyone is capable of doing that. Psychiatrists do this regularly, but if a mental disorder is the sole condition, suddenly opponents say they cannot do that. They say that psychiatrists cannot accurately determine a prognosis or a diagnosis and that this justifies a blanket prohibition for all individuals who are unresponsive to all the available treatments for their mental disorder. These are individuals who have never refused a treatment that could improve their condition and who, after several decades, sometimes 25 or 30 years, have come to the conclusion that they would like to end their lives with dignity, following a proper assessment, and certainly not when they are in distress or experiencing a suicidal crisis.
A suicidal crisis is actually sometimes part of the expression of a mental illness or disorder. The fact remains that irremediability is a chronic condition established over time. That is a far cry from the scenario of a young man suffering from a broken heart who decides to put up his hand and say that he wants MAID. If the law were to pass, what would happen? By raising his hand, he would be raising a red flag, and instead of attempting suicide, thinking he is entitled to access MAID, he could be treated. He could be taken care of. However, right now, with a blanket prohibition, there is no preventive aspect in terms of there being a law to deal with the issue of mental disorders. As I said, this is unconstitutional.
Going back to my first point, the government had five years, since the first Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying, to ask the Supreme Court for an opinion. The government could have clarified whether the blanket prohibition imposed in the Carter decision unconstitutionally infringes on the rights of patients with a mental disorder and is therefore unconstitutional discrimination. However, it did not do that. It did not summon the courage to do so, and right now, if we decide to uphold the indefinite exclusion, it means there will be no more debate on this matter here. No future government would reopen the debate on this.
What is happening? The burden is being placed on vulnerable patients. The government says it wants to protect vulnerable patients, yet there is a contradiction there. The government says that these patients are vulnerable and lack the capacity to make decisions about their own end of life in the circumstances I have described, even after a comprehensive and rigorous assessment. However, the government expects them to navigate the legal system and take their case all the way to the Supreme Court to defend their rights. To me, that shows disregard for human dignity. To me, that shows cowardice, parliamentary cowardice. It is cowardice because Parliament has never been proactive throughout this entire debate on MAID. Now, suddenly, when it comes to mental illness and advance requests, Parliament has decided to be proactive. I will come back to that, but colleagues can surely understand why I find this somewhat surprising.
All the regulatory bodies told us that they were ready. The Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying refused to hear from the Canadian Psychiatric Association, which had established standards of practice. The government paid a committee to set standards of practice. All the practitioners told us that everyone was ready to move forward. In the end, the answer is no because there are some who oppose all forms of medical assistance in dying and who will seize on any anecdote to say that it will become a horror show, that it will be awful, that it will cause harm, and that the system is unable to deliver proper care.
There are indeed mental health challenges. However, when someone has been dealing with a mental disorder for 30 years, in keeping with the definition, I do not want to hear anyone claim that the system is incapable of treating that person and that this is why we have to wait for the system to be able to treat or cure them, especially when some psychiatrists say that no cure is even possible. People are effectively being told to continue suffering within reason. If this constitutes discrimination, does the first clause save the blanket prohibition? Absolutely not. What is really happening is that people are being told to continue suffering until a treatment is found that will finally cure them. These people are being told to be patient, after a lifetime of stigma and discrimination.
Only a small minority of people are likely to request MAID, and the assessment would ensure that they meet the criteria. On top of that, there was an additional safeguard in place for people with mental disorders. Prospective monitoring was advised. During the assessment, when it was time to intervene, a panel would be asked to review the process to see whether it had been properly implemented, which is not currently the case for other scenarios involving MAID. The bill has continued to move forward with regard to advance requests. This was a key recommendation of the first special joint committee. We agreed that while we should delay the decision to see whether the necessary provisions for mental disorders could eventually be implemented in practice, there were no reservations about advance requests five years ago.
It took the government five years to show some courage and do what had been proposed. If it felt that advance requests were a more delicate process, given that the person is assessed when they are incapacitated, all it had to do was set up an additional safeguard, an additional requirement. It was told that since the provinces are responsible for health care, it should require them to develop a “how to” procedure so that this is done by the book, and, that way, debates will take place in each provincial legislature. This could even become an election issue. If, for example, a province decides not to go ahead at all, someone will surely go to the Supreme Court and have the ban struck down or change the government so that the legislature passes a law.
Quebec has implemented a process based on a very interesting approach. First of all, a person is not told that MAID is an option before first undergoing an evaluation. An advance request is made based on a diagnosis, and once care begins following that diagnosis, the patient is given an explanation of the stages of the disease's progression. At some point during these stages, when the person is of sound mind, they sit down with the care team and establish the criteria that correspond to their personal threshold of what is tolerable.
A person might say that they would like to receive MAID when they become doubly incontinent, when they start playing with their own feces, when they resist being fed, when they are no longer able to recognize their own family or even interact with other human beings. There is no automatic threshold. In fact, at a certain point in the progression of the illness, in other words, when the patient has reached a certain level of incapacity, a third person is responsible for informing the care team that they believe the patient should be evaluated. The care team will evaluate the patient and may inform the third party that the patient in question has not yet reached that stage. The process would then continue.
This process is based on the clinical judgment of physicians or other professionals. The Quebec law states that, at the time medical assistance in dying is administered, the person must be “incapable of giving consent to care due to their illness”, they must be “exhibiting, on a recurring basis, the clinical manifestations related to their illness” and they must be in a medical state “of advanced, irreversible decline in capability...that gives a competent professional cause to believe, based on the information at their disposal and according to their clinical judgment, that the patient is experiencing enduring and unbearable physical or psychological suffering that cannot be relieved under conditions considered tolerable.” There is no mention of reasonable means.
My colleague, who was a social worker, told me about a lady who had what is known as “quiet dementia” or “happy dementia”. Incidentally, this is a transitional phase that leads the person towards the end of their life. It is a transitory state. It is not permanent. People with Alzheimer's often die from a secondary condition, because they are no longer mobile, because they are bedridden or because they are confined to a wheelchair. That is why the concept of what is considered tolerable is important. However, in the government's bill, instead of trusting provincial legislatures, it proposes a whole bunch of criteria and the aim is to set aside the criteria that the individual may have put in place, on the pretext that it would lead to MAID being granted in cases of happy dementia.
Let us imagine a woman with an illness who reaches a point where she is no longer aware of her actions and is no longer in her right mind. Let us imagine that she repeatedly undresses in public and smiles while throwing herself at men. She appears happy. Who was this woman? It is very important to understand that someone who reaches that stage of the disease and that stage of cognitive decline is not the same person anymore. This woman was a nun who had spent her entire life observing the strictest standards of modesty. Does anyone think that if this woman had set out her wishes in advance, she would have put up with this situation simply because she seems relatively bothered and even seems happy? The Supreme Court has been very clear. The whole question of dementia, whether or not the person appears happy, should be discussed at the formal meeting where the patient establishes their personal criteria.
A person could very well say at that meeting that if they reach that stage and wish to continue living in that condition, they should be allowed to do so.
I will end here. No one would be forced to make an advance request if they have a degenerative disease such as Alzheimer's or dementia. The Conservatives always make it seem as though it would be mandatory for everyone. It is not a requirement, but merely an option.
Cheryl Gallant (CPC)7:45 p.m.
Madam Speaker, I am sharing my time with the member for Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake.
I rise today on behalf of the caring Canadians in the compassionate riding of Algonquin—Renfrew—Pembroke to speak to Bill C-41, the medical assistance in dying safeguards act.
I want to begin by thanking the co-chairs and the elected members of the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying for their work in reviewing calls to expand medical assistance in dying to those who are not dying but instead suffering from mental illness. The committee is bipartisan. It recommended to permanently exclude mental illness as a sole condition for receiving medical assistance in dying, which is welcomed by my constituents and the vast majority of Canadians who have survived mental illness or who are currently living with severe mental illness.
My Conservative colleagues on the special joint committee included a number of supplementary recommendations that I believe should be highlighted before the bill is brought to committee.
The first recommendation was to call on the government to support the member for Cloverdale—Langley City 's private member's bill to permanently exclude mental illness as a condition to access medical assistance in dying. Sadly, the government rejected the recommendation and voted down the bill. Instead, the government brought forward a bill expanding medical assistance in dying to allow advance requests, which had not been studied by the special joint committee. While the bill does include the permanent repeal of mental illness as an eligible condition by including it in the legislation to expand access to MAID and voting against a clean bill, the government has politicized this sensitive issue. This was a regrettable decision by the government, but I truly hope we can return to a more collegial approach when it goes to committee.
While the government has given this bill the short title of it being the medical assistance in dying safeguards act, its purpose is not to create safeguards but to allow advance requests. In setting out the criteria for advance requests, the government reveals how difficult any safeguards for advance requests would be.
The bill states:
if, by virtue of subsection (6), medical assistance in dying on the basis of the advance request was previously not provided because there was doubt as to whether the person’s words, sounds or gestures constituted a demonstration of refusal or resistance, ensure that there are at least 30 clear days between the day on which the words, sounds or gestures were observed by a medical practitioner or nurse practitioner and the day on which the medical assistance in dying on the basis of that request is provided;
What the bill is saying is that anyone who has given an advance request on the basis of having an illness where death is reasonably foreseeable can later refuse to go through with it. If there is any subjective doubt felt by the medical practitioner as to whether their patient has refused, the medical practitioner must wait 30 days before trying to administer a substance that would cause death. This alone calls into question any diagnosis that death was reasonably foreseeable. It creates that perverse incentive where a medical practitioner must decide if they doubt the patient's attempt at refusal or they doubt their own medical judgment. No Canadian's life should be lost to confirmation bias.
Even the criteria for administering MAID following an advance request includes a subjective opinion by the medical practitioner that the person who has lost the capacity to consent is experiencing intolerable physical or psychological suffering. If a person has lost the capacity to consent, how can their psychological suffering be assessed? Not only are the limited measures in the bill an insufficient safeguard, the government is downloading the job onto the provinces.
That the government would take this approach so soon after the Ontario government gutted its own MAID review panel is all the more troubling. The fact that Ontario's MAID review panel is run by the coroner's office only highlights the lack of safeguards.
This is why Conservatives made a different recommendation, which states:
The government should work with provinces and territories to establish minimum national standards for MAID oversight to ensure the effectiveness and enforceability of MAID safeguards.
Those standards should include prospective review mechanisms capable of pausing or stopping a provision where serious compliance concerns arise before death, stronger review of prior records and assessments, clear referral pathways for potential Criminal Code violations, and greater independence of oversight bodies from MAID delivery systems.
Given the irreversibility of MAID, genuine safeguards would ensure a case could be stopped before proceeding. Families should not be forced to go to court to protect their loved ones. Doctors should not be assessing patients for MAID in a Tim Hortons parking lot, then driving the patient to the clinic to be killed, as Dr. James MacLean did. Dr. MacLean only received a slap on the wrist from the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario for his drive-through MAID.
The bill provides no safeguards for the kind of doctor shopping that saw an Ontario man denied MAID in this province seek out Ellen Wiebe in B.C., who assisted in his suicide for irritable bowel syndrome. That man's family was not as lucky as the family of an Alberta woman who also was denied MAID in her province but was approved for MAID after a zoom call with Ellen Wiebe. That family secured a court injunction, and the woman stopped seeking MAID.
Those are just two examples of cases where the current safeguards failed to stop a doctor and MAID activist like Ellen Wiebe. That a court found Dr. Wiebe to be mistaken in granting a track 2 MAID approval called into question the current lack of safeguards. That no criminal charges have followed the court findings proves the safeguards are insufficient. Does anyone believe that doctors such as Ellen Wiebe or James MacLean would have any doubts if a patient who gave an advance request unclearly indicates a refusal?
Conservatives recommended a full review of the effectiveness and enforceability of current MAID safeguards to prevent vulnerable Canadians from being assisted in committing suicide, but instead of listening to our recommendations, the bill would expand MAID to advance requests. Fortunately, it is not too late. We can delete the clauses expanding MAID and turn the bill into a real set of nationally enforceable safeguards. While the government was playing politics and voting down my colleague's clean bill earlier, we can put that aside to transform this bill from one that would expand MAID to one that would provide real safeguards.
Elected parliamentarians from the Liberal Party and the Conservative Party worked together on the special joint committee to find common ground in rejecting the expansion of MAID to people solely suffering from mental illness. While we may disagree on expanding MAID to include advance requests, the majority of people on both sides of this debate are motivated by compassion, yet when it comes to mental illness, or it comes to those who are suffering but whose deaths are not reasonably foreseeable, offering MAID is not compassion, but an admission of our failure to provide the compassion required to live a life of meaning and purpose.
Tomorrow, the government will undoubtedly table a budget filled with more compassion for investors and corporations than for those suffering in silence, and while the government gives hundreds of millions of dollars to fake spaceports and fraudulent electric buses, Canadians linger in hospital hallways. We do not need half measures like five-year funding formulas that add marginal capacity to mental health services. We need bold moves like the Manhattan Project to fight mental illness. If we are not successful in eradicating mental illness, the effort alone could be the hope so many people need.
Killing is not compassion. Fighting for everyone to enjoy a life of meaning and purpose is compassion. If we do not take this opportunity to increase the safeguards and effectively roll back track 2 for all but the most extreme cases, then all we would be doing is greasing the slippery slope. Ever since the Supreme Court overturned precedent and invented a right to death, we have witnessed exactly what so many predicted would happen. Advocates keep on pushing to expand it. First it was those without terminal illness. Then it was those with only mental illness. Now we have doctors asking for the power to decide if an infant's life is worth living. They will not stop pushing it until they find a court to allow it. Nine unelected judges should never decide whose life has value and whose does not. It falls to Parliament to fight for life.
Do not go gentle into that good night. Rage, rage against the dying of the light.
Kristina Tesser Derksen (Lib.)8:15 p.m.
Madam Speaker, my remarks today seek to contribute to the discussion we have had in this House since 2016 regarding medical assistance in dying, commonly referred to as MAID, and particularly with respect to Bill C-41, the MAID safeguards act, which proposes to amend the Criminal Code and make two important updates. The first one is to end the expansion of MAID for mental illness as a sole condition, and the second is to allow Canadians to request MAID in advance for a time later in an illness.
MAID is a controversial topic, and it has generated much constitutional debate. For all the nuances, though, the main arguments are divided into two general opinions. From one perspective, providing legal access to MAID enhances the personal autonomy and dignity of people with serious illnesses, giving them control over the manner of their death. From another perspective, it could be a precarious medical advancement that could impact the lives of people who may already be vulnerable. This legislation would provide safeguards so that all Canadians can be assured of their rights and protections, specifically with respect to MAID for mental illness and MAID for advance requests.
Regarding the first change in Bill C-41, MAID for mental illness, MAID will not be available for those suffering with mental illness as a sole condition. The planned expansion for MAID to those with mental illness as a sole condition has been delayed twice to allow more time to consider questions around readiness and safeguards from the provinces and territories.
Most recently, a parliamentary committee made up of senators and MPs from different parties studied the issue, heard from experts and stakeholders and recommended that the expansion for mental illness not move ahead. I was a member of that committee, and the result of extensive discussions found that we cannot be assured that the provinces and territories are ready to safely and consistently assess and provide MAID for Canadians with mental illness as their sole condition. I will say that there was not necessarily consensus around the committee on all underlying issues and definitions, and that just indicates the variety of perspectives that were considered.
Without legislative action, the current exclusion for mental illness would expire on March 17, 2027, and this would have allowed MAID to be provided to eligible individuals on the basis of mental illness only. Given the lack of clinical consensus, Bill C-41 takes a precautionary approach and would maintain the exclusion.
I will make an important point here. Several people have contacted my office about this. The eligibility for people with other eligible conditions is unchanged. A person who has a mental illness may still be eligible if they meet all other legislative criteria. For example, someone with an advanced stage of terminal cancer who also has, for example, diagnosed clinical depression as a mental illness may still be eligible to access MAID on the basis of their cancer, so long as they meet all the other eligibility criteria. I will also note here that Bill C-41 uses the term “mental illness”, not “mental disorder”, so people with serious degenerative neurological disorders who are eligible today keep their access. We are talking about conditions like Parkinson's disease.
Mental illness can cause suffering just like the suffering experienced by a physical illness. Canadians living with mental illness deserve to have their suffering taken seriously, and our government takes it very seriously. We are working with provinces and territories to determine how we can best support Canadians living with mental illness in strengthening our public health care system. That is why we announced a $1.2-billion investment to extend the mental health and substance use agreements and home and community care agreements as we work with provinces and territories toward long-term solutions to prevent and treat mental illness. In addition, in 2023, we announced the working together to improve health care in Canada plan, which provides $200 billion over 10 years to provinces and territories, including $25 billion for shared priorities such as mental health.
Regarding MAID for advance requests, Bill C-41 would allow adults to make an advance request for MAID following an early-stage diagnosis of an incurable illness that is expected to take away their ability to make decisions. This would allow an individual to make an informed decision about their care while they still have capacity and would set out the circumstances in which they would want to receive MAID later in their illness. For example, someone diagnosed with early-stage Alzheimer's could make an advance request so that their wishes could be respected if they later lost the ability to make the decision for themselves. An advance request would not mean MAID is provided automatically. Eligibility requirements and safeguards would still need to be satisfied.
The role for the federal government relates to the Criminal Code. To implement this change, provinces and territories would still have to make advance requests available in their respective jurisdictions. Under the current law, a person must be able to give informed consent to receive MAID. They must understand their condition, their options and the consequences of their decision, and they must generally confirm their consent immediately made before MAID is provided.
Some illnesses, such as Alzheimer's disease and dementia, gradually take away a person's ability to make these decisions. As the illness advances, a person may no longer be capable of giving informed consent by the time they would want MAID. Under the existing law, this means they cannot receive MAID, even if they were clear about their wishes while they were still capable. Many Canadians feel this is inherently unfair.
Importantly, this is about respecting the wishes expressed by an individual while they are capable of making decisions about their own care. Importantly, a family member would not be able to make an advance request for MAID on someone else's behalf.
Provinces and territories would decide whether to make advance requests available in their jurisdictions, and our government will continue working closely with them as we move forward. This is because MAID eligibility is a shared federal-provincial matter. The provincial role in the MAID framework is crucial to the fair and consistent delivery of care to Canadians.
Individual provinces and territories have their own customized approaches to MAID to best serve their populations. Provinces and territories provide services, coordinate care and regulate providers so that Canadians in their respective provinces and territories have consistency and certainty. This must be done in deference to the autonomous choice of an individual as they approach the end of their life with a grievous and irremediable medical condition. In short, Canadians rely on their provincial and territorial governments to provide access to their charter right of security of the person in the context of MAID.
If the House will indulge me, I will provide a short legal and historical context for this discussion. I will take members way back.
A discussion about MAID became necessary in 2015 after the Supreme Court decision in the Carter case. Carter decriminalized medically assisted death. In that decision, our Supreme Court held that the criminal laws prohibiting assistance in dying limited the rights to life, liberty and security of the person under section 7 of the charter in a manner that was not demonstrably justified under section 1. As a result of the Supreme Court's decision, the Criminal Code provisions prohibiting assisted suicide and providing that no person may consent to death being inflicted on them were deemed to be in violation of Canadians' rights under the charter.
Responding to the Carter decision via Bill C-14 in 2015, MAID was legalized for competent adults whose natural death was reasonably foreseeable. The Criminal Code established eligibility criteria and safeguards for MAID, as well as made exemptions to criminal offences, including murder and aiding someone to die by suicide.
A subsequent case, Truchon, was heard at the Quebec Superior Court in March 2021, and the court's decision in Truchon expanded eligibility for MAID to adults whose natural death was not reasonably foreseeable. This created two tracks in the Criminal Code: one where natural death is reasonably foreseeable, track 1, and one where it is not, track 2.
In addition to eligibility criteria for those receiving MAID, notably that an individual must have a grievous and irremediable medical condition, the Criminal Code set out additional procedural safeguards that health care providers must follow before providing MAID where death is not reasonably foreseeable. The same legislation temporarily excluded persons from eligibility if their sole underlying medical condition was a mental illness. That exclusion for mental illness was originally set to end on March 17, 2027. Bill C-41 would permanently end the extensions.
I would hazard that this issue of expansion for mental illness has perhaps been one of the most contentious and complex issues we have grappled with in the development of MAID legislation. In the joint committee's third report, it was noted that although MAID is governed by federal law, health care regulations and medical standards fall within provincial jurisdiction. The division of authority introduces some added legal and administrative complexity in aligning federal policy with provincial implementation. With the benefit of the special joint committee's findings, we have determined that the provinces and territories simply are not ready to administer an expansion of MAID for mental illness.
I speak with some experience on end-of-life issues. Prior to entering politics, I worked in long-term care, I worked as a licensed funeral director and I worked as an estate planning lawyer. I have also sat as a board director of our local North Halton Hospice foundation. This is an organization seeking to build a palliative care hospice residence in my riding of Milton East—Halton Hills South.
In these professional activities, discussing death became a fairly innocuous exercise. Death is, most simply, a fact of life that when possible, is best planned for and discussed with loved ones and trusted professionals. It is my opinion that those discussions are best had without the pressure of prying eyes or proselytization from the outside world, and free from those who contend they know better about how an individual should move through this life and how they should move on to the next. Choosing a medically assisted death is a fundamentally personal decision and a very fundamentally personal right.
How MAID is delivered has become a main focus of the debate since 2015. Some of the concerns I have heard from people in my riding include the fear that vulnerable people will turn to MAID as a first option because they feel that other care or health services are too difficult to access or simply do not exist. Also, there is a concern that people could be coerced or influenced to opt for MAID, and this may be more likely for people who could already be vulnerable due to other socio-economic factors. It is important that Canadians are properly informed on the process to access MAID and the safeguards that exist to ensure that vulnerable persons do not improperly access MAID.
First, at least 90 days must pass between the day the MAID eligibility assessment begins and the day the person receives MAID. Second, two health care practitioners, independent of one another, must conduct assessments and confirm that the person is actually eligible for MAID. Third, these assessors must inform the person of all reasonable and available options for relieving their suffering and offer the person consultations with people who provide those services. Fourth, the person and the assessors must have discussed all of the options for relieving the person's suffering and agree that the person has seriously considered those options. Last, immediately before the person is to receive MAID, the MAID provider must give them the opportunity to withdraw the request for the procedure. If the person wants to proceed, the MAID provider must ensure that the person gives final consent.
In Bill C-41, which we are discussing here today, there would be additional requirements in the case of an advance request. First, generally, we would implement minimal national safeguards that would set out Criminal Code requirements for the lawful provision of MAID based on advance requests. Second, the implementation of provincial and territorial frameworks would have to be developed and would have to state that any province or territory wishing to permit advance requests must first enact its own legislative framework. Advance requests would remain prohibited in jurisdictions that do not have this framework. Third, operational rules and participating jurisdictions would be responsible for rules on making, validating, amending, storing and withdrawing requests, including a reliable storage mechanism to verify that a request remains valid. Fourth, the requirement for two independent assessments would be enhanced so that the two physicians or nurse practitioners must confirm that the circumstances in the request have occurred, that the person is in an advanced and irreversible decline, and that they are experiencing intolerable suffering. Fifth, as in any MAID case, refusal would end the process. MAID could not be provided to a person who refuses, and their advance request would then be invalidated.
When it comes to Quebec, Quebec's existing framework would be incorporated into the federal criminal law regime without the need to amend Quebec's legislation.
I want to note here the tremendous responsibility that frontline care providers would shoulder in fulfilling these criteria. Their expertise, training, compassion and courage in providing this service really cannot be understated. These safeguards show that the analysis in providing MAID in each unique case would be a process of some burden, and it should be.
I note the historical position of our Conservative opposition colleagues. They have been vocal on this, urging the government to scrap the expansion of MAID for what they call a mental disorder, most recently in a private member's bill, Bill C-218. Bill C-218 was premature at the time of its tabling, as the special joint committee had not yet had time to consider evidence or hear from witnesses, and the bill ultimately failed in this House.
In any event, our government's Bill C-41, currently before this House, aligns with the request in the Conservatives' private member's bill, Bill C-218, to end the expansion of MAID for someone with a mental illness as a sole condition. On that, we have agreement, although perhaps for different reasons. I am not sure of my Conservative colleagues' position on Bill C-41, but I cannot imagine on what grounds they would oppose it, since in one instance, it would provide what Bill C-218 asked for in ending the expansion for mental illness, and in the second, it would provide greater freedom and autonomy for Canadians in determining their own treatment and end of life through advance requests, a principle that is very popular, especially among older Canadians.
It is hard to deny that MAID can be a contentious topic, because for all the legalities, science, regulations and debate, we are essentially discussing an issue that is the most profound experience of being human. We are all going to die. Dying is still a great mystery, one that we must continue to navigate and explore together with conversations like this one that embrace mutual respect, empathy and understanding for the emotion and fundamental humanity of contemplating how we leave this world.
During my time working as a funeral director, I had the privilege of hearing the unfiltered experiences and stories of families as they found themselves as observers and helpers during the death journey of their loved ones. This is where the importance of individual autonomy and choosing the care and form of dying really became real for me. In the years that I have been serving on the hospice foundation board, a discussion has proceeded about how health care should address the experience, needs, beliefs and requests of each unique individual as they move through their own unique, individual death.
Not all of us will be able to plan for our death or have control over the circumstances and timing of our transition from this world, but many of us will. When that time comes, I want to have the autonomy to make the choice that is best for me, in consultation with my family, my health care provider and my own conscience. We all deserve that. I would argue that it is the role of legislators to work with experts to achieve this for Canadians, not only because of the moral imperative to do so but because security of the person is enshrined in our charter, which contains protections for individuals, allowing them to maintain control of their bodily integrity, personal integrity and basic freedom of choice.
Conversations such as the one we are having here in the House work to expand minds, address misinformation, open the dialogue and provide space for each of us to learn and share. These debates are absolutely imperative in bringing the best care to our citizens and helping government move toward legislation that will serve all Canadians.
Michael Cooper (CPC)8:40 p.m.
Madam Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the Leader of the Opposition.
The Liberals have learned absolutely nothing over the past five years from their disastrous planned expansion of MAID for mental illness. They decided to move ahead with this planned expansion before studying the issue. They did so by accepting an eleventh-hour Senate amendment to Bill C-7, legislation that had nothing to do with MAID and mental illness, until of course they accepted the amendment. They then proceeded to shut down debate and ram through the bill without any meaningful debate, consultation or study, thus setting the train in motion for MAID for mental illness.
Had they studied the issue first, rather than recklessly moving ahead with it, they would have heard what has been now made loud and clear by leading experts, including psychiatrists, namely that MAID for mental illness cannot be implemented appropriately and safely. The Liberals, because they did not do their homework, had to bring in two emergency bills to delay implementation. Here we are, five years and four bills later, and they have finally admitted they got it wrong all along and are now bringing forward legislation to put an indefinite pause on MAID for mental illness.
At the same time, here we are again, with the Liberals' recklessly seeking to ram through a new expansion of MAID, this time advance requests, by shoehorning advance requests into a bill to put an indefinite pause on MAID for mental illness, an expansion that will take place unless a bill is passed by March of next year. What the Liberals are doing is shutting down parliamentary debate and parliamentary scrutiny of the complex issue of advance requests. If there ever was an issue that deserves careful scrutiny, it is advance requests, because there are profound legal, ethical and practical issues at play, and there are significant risks.
The most significant risk identified in its 2018 report by the expert panel the Council of Canadian Academies, which is appointed by the government, by the way, is that in the case of advance requests, MAID could be administered against a patient's wishes. That is not an isolated or remote risk. It is a very real risk underscored by Health Canada's data in its annual reports on MAID, which show that each year, anywhere between 10% and 20% of patients who withdraw their consent withdraw it immediately before the administration of MAID.
The possibility that MAID could be administered against a patient's request really gets to the heart of the central issue around advance requests, and that is the issue of consent. On the question of consent, the Supreme Court of Canada, in the Carter decision, said that in order to qualify for MAID, a patient must clearly consent. The court used those words multiple times in that decision, “clearly consents”, which arguably implies that such consent must be contemporaneous. Hence, advance requests raise serious legal questions about whether they fall outside the parameters for MAID set by the Supreme Court, and whether explicit contemporaneous consent is constitutionally required.
Not only are there issues that are legal in nature, but there are also profound ethical concerns involving consent, because when consent is made in advance, it can never be fully informed consent. That is because it is made based upon future assumptions about one's circumstances, capacities or preference, not upon one's lived experience.
There is abundant research into effective forecasting that demonstrates that when a person is diagnosed with an illness or a condition, they are often poor predictors of what the future will look like. As Dr. Romayne Gallagher, a clinical professor in palliative medicine, told the Special Joint Committee on MAID:
...medical and social science literature reminds us that people are poor at anticipating what life would be like with a life-changing illness or disability. People adapt to illness and disability and adjust their needs for a decent quality of life. Many medical conditions have long and unpredictable courses.
If consent cannot be contemporaneous and therefore cannot be fully informed, it raises the question, can there be true consent? If there cannot be true patient consent, then how can we ethically proceed with an advance request regime?
Now, proponents of advance requests often cite individual autonomy, but I would submit that individual autonomy in the context of advance requests is illusory. That is because advance requests necessarily result in not patient consent but third party consent, based upon observations that are often highly subjective in nature. After all, how does a MAID assessor confidently and accurately determine if a patient is suffering intolerably, which is a prerequisite for MAID to be administered, if the patient cannot communicate the degree to which they are suffering? That is what we invite with advance requests, namely, the administration of death based upon third party, often highly subjective observations of patients who cannot communicate and often have no ability to withdraw their consent.
Then there are other issues that need to be considered, including legitimate concerns that advance requests will lead to abuse and coercion resulting in vulnerable persons having their lives ended. There are concerns from a human rights perspective that advance requests undermine human dignity and will lead to discrimination against persons with cognitive disabilities, that a message is being sent that their lives are not worth living and that they are lesser human beings, completely undermining a fundamental principle of human rights: the universal and equal value of all human beings.
All of this underscores the need for careful study and meaningful consultation, none of which has happened, by the way. The Liberals have not done any meaningful consultation since the 2018 expert review, which recommended against moving ahead with advance requests, but instead the Liberals have learned nothing. Here we are again with the Liberals recklessly trying to ram through a complicated expansion of MAID. Canadians deserve better.
Pierre Poilievre (CPC)8:55 p.m.
Madam Speaker, imagine someone's phone rings and the voice on the other end of the line, a stranger, gives them the surprise request that they need to pick up their 26-year-old son at the morgue because of medical assistance in dying. He had no life-threatening illness. He had type 1 diabetes and some vision problems, but other than that, it was just depression. He had been denied medical assistance in dying because he was not eligible.
That was the story recounted to me by Margaret Marsilla, who came to visit me in this building. Kiano was only 26 years old, and although he struggled with diabetes and depression, he was not facing any end-of-life medical emergency. In fact, in Ontario, medical professionals had said he was not eligible. He shopped around for a different opinion and got one from a British Columbia doctor. I met his heartbroken mother in March, and her story is all too common.
In the last few years, we have seen the predictable consequences of a medical assistance in dying regime that fails to protect the vulnerable and even preys on them. Canada has become famous around the world as a cautionary tale for abuses in a system that too often sees death not as a last resort for patients suffering but as a first option for an overburdened health care system.
The statistics are stark. More than one in 20 Canadian deaths are by MAID. If we dig in, the numbers get even worse. One in 10 Canadians knows somebody who was offered medical assistance in dying even though they had no life-threatening condition and all of their conditions were treatable. Almost half of those who died by MAID in 2024 had reported feeling like a burden on family, friends and caregivers, raising the risk of induced death by guilt. Then there are individual horror stories, such as the Canadian Armed Forces veteran who contacted veterans affairs agents asking for government support for his ailments and was instantly offered MAID, or Father Larry Holland, a Catholic priest who went into the hospital for a fractured hip and was offered MAID not once but twice.
These are not isolated cases. Even the BC Civil Liberties Association, which was one of the interveners that sued the government to legalize euthanasia in the first place, now believes the procedure has gone too far. Last year, it was “aware of 'concerning reports' of people being offered MAID in circumstances that may not legally qualify” as well as people accessing MAID as a result of intolerable social conditions, not medical conditions but people living in misery, poverty or loneliness and being told that the best option for them is to die.
The organization called for safeguards to protect the more vulnerable patients so that they do not feel pressured to end their lives. Under these circumstances, the government had no choice but to pause its planned expansion of MAID for mental illness. I am pleased that the Liberals have once again reversed themselves on yet another radical experiment they had planned to impose on the Canadian people. Just as with net zero, mass immigration, catch-and-release criminal justice, legalized drugs and the carbon tax, they have been forced to reverse themselves yet again.
The committee that studied the question heard from doctors who were worried about allowing patients to make a decision in a moment of personal crisis and despair that can and often does get reversed later on. The close link between mental illness and suicide also raises a practical problem. One psychiatrist actually testified that there is a problem, an incoherence, in that “Psychiatry claims it can both prevent suicide in one patient and help finalize suicide in another with [both of them having] the same suffering.”
While I am glad the Liberals reversed themselves on one bad idea, I am disgusted that they have gone forward in the very same bill with another bad idea. In the same bill we are debating, which bans MAID for mental illness, the government would also legalize it for advance directives. These would allow persons to request MAID, at a time when they would not be eligible for it, for a future moment when they become eligible.
Doctors have sounded the alarm at the impossible situation in which this may put them and the family members of the suffering person. Imagine the case of a patient suffering with dementia. They have signed an advance directive, but now they are smiling. They are happy. They enjoy sitting outside with the sun shining on their face. Their grandkids are sitting on their lap, enjoying an ice cream after dinner. However, they have signed an advance directive. Everyone knows that this person, though they have lost their faculties, is happy going on living. What does a doctor do at that point? Do they administer MAID to a patient who looks happy and who everyone knows wants to live on, or do they refuse the directive the government says they have to follow and consider the family?
Most members would be aware of the story of Lisa Raitt, a former member of the House. She recently wrote online about her husband, who has been suffering with dementia for the last 11 years:
“If Bruce had signed an advanced directive, would I have been left to make the decision on when to apply MAiD?
“Even after 11 years, yesterday I saw him smile, laugh, interact and enjoy his meals while being non-mobile, incontinent and non verbal.
“I can promise you, I would ignore any advanced directive. Yes, he is a different man with a different life now but subjectively and objectively he is comfortable and content. I would not believe this Bruce would want to stop living.
“In this case, would the ‘state’ step in to provide MAiD over my objections and experience? We are rushing to a set of really complex entanglements. So much room for harm.”
Instead of looking for more ways to end life, we should be looking for ways to allow people to live the fullest life, with better care, more support, pain treatment, love and compassion.
We also know there is the fundamental problem that advance directives may not be accurate measures of what a patient would actually want in future circumstances. We have all said to ourselves that if such and such were to happen, we would want X or Y. Then when that eventuality comes about, we change our mind because the experience was different than what we thought. The attitude of a young person to death, for example, may be very different from an older person's and may be different from that of the person they become. It would be easy to say that someone would not want to live that or live under those circumstances, but when they find themselves in those conditions, it can turn out to be that life is better than they thought and they no longer desire death.
Many Canadians who are suffering serious health conditions can tell us from personal experience that there is hope they find and comfort they reach in the loved ones who surround them. Assuming that the conditions they live with would be reasons for someone else not to live ignores the experience and risks here, devaluing the lives of people in those circumstances.
I am not prepared to take away from doctors or from family members like Lisa Raitt the ability to act for their loved ones when no one else really knows what the loved one wants and no one else has a greater interest in the well-being of that loved one. These are painful decisions for doctors and families at the best of times. We should not make harder by rushing through dangerous legislation.
Unfortunately, the government has forced me and many others in this room into an impossible dilemma, those of us who want to ban MAID for mental illness and give people hope that they can have a brighter future and can come out of the bottom of the valley and get back to the mountain top. We want to vote to save their lives, but we do not want to vote to introduce new dangers that could end other lives that people would believe are worth living.
That is why we are calling for the government to split this bill. There is no reason to rely on the arbitrary deadline that is necessary to repeal MAID for a mental illness in order to avoid it coming into effect in March, to also then apply it to the swift passage of an extremely complex and highly dangerous new practice that is done almost nowhere in the world and that is fraught with serious risks.
This is literally a matter of life and death. I ask the government to split this bill to allow Canadians and their parliamentarians to express their conscience by voting on each section separately so that we can stand in this place and offer hope, compassion and love to the people who need it most.
Kevin Lamoureux (Lib.)9:10 p.m.
Madam Speaker, there are mixed emotions when approaching this particular debate because it is very much an emotional type of debate. I have had the opportunity to witness it first-hand for many years. In fact, when I look at its origins, I go back to just prior to the 2015 election, when a Supreme Court of Canada decision was made that ultimately put it on the agenda after Justin Trudeau was elected as Prime Minister. Under a new government, we had to deal with the issue. There was time for the Conservatives, even back in 2015, to attempt to bring forward legislation, but they did not do that.
If I reflect on the number of comments I have heard thus far, a lot of those comments are related to members wanting more debate. They want to have more discussion. It is not that often that I agree with a member from the Bloc, but I can tell members that I believe there has been a great deal of discussion and debate for decades now. One only needs to turn to the province of Quebec, where we see strong leadership on this debate.
It is a highly personal debate. What could be more intimate than discussions with family? I know this from my limited first-hand experience with the passing of my grandmother, when I was sitting at the St. Boniface Hospital, talking with my uncle and my father at her deathbed and listening to what the professionals had to say. Then a number of years later, and unfortunately the gap was not that great, came the passing of my father at the Riverview Health Centre. It is a bit better environment than St. Boniface Hospital, but the same questions were being asked, in particular with my father, who was scared of dying. Who blames an individual when that bridge comes?
There is a point in time in most lives where for an extended period of time, they reflect on that. When that time comes, I believe it is critically important for family, friends and health care professionals, who play a critical role, along with spiritual leadership quite often, to get engaged in a very real and tangible way. I think we often underestimate the important role that our health care providers and those who support them play when it comes to end-of-life care.
I think of my father's passing. When we got him into the Riverview Health Centre, it did not look very promising. There were some medications that ultimately made him feel a whole lot better. I remember him saying to me, “I'm feeling better today than I was three weeks ago.” I talked to the doctor about it, who said that a lot depended on the medications and that while they had been very successful, we should not build our hopes up because it would be very short term. The doctor was right. It did take place relatively quickly.
My father, in the discussions he was having with me, was talking about the cemetery and where he wanted to be buried. He wanted us to understand that he did not want something prolonged like what he had witnessed, to a certain degree, with his mother, my grandmother, at the St. Boniface Hospital.
We really never know until we are put into that position, but I do believe, at my core, that it is the person who should have the ability to make that decision. When we take a look at what has taken place over the last few decades, I go to Sue Rodriguez who, during the early 1990s, had Lou Gehrig’s disease. She raised the discussion, not only on a national level, but back then it was taken into consideration around the world.
When it came to MAID back in 1993, our Supreme Court of Canada made the decision, 5-4, not to move ahead, no doubt for all sorts of reasons. However, the debate has evolved significantly since then. I would like to read what Sue, apparently sometime in December 1992, stated. She said, “I want to be in charge of my life and my death.”
I was a parliamentarian back then and I followed the news quite closely. I can tell members that it ignited a fierce discussion, and it was not just in Manitoba. I believe that discussion has never ended. When we take a look at the Carter decision, which was made prior to the 2015 election, maybe it was at the end of 2014 or 2015, but if we take a look at the arguments, I suspect that the world had changed, because even when the decision was made about Carter by the Supreme Court, there were actually a number of countries that had already put MAID into place, or some form of MAID.
Public opinion has changed on the issue of MAID, even in the last decade since we passed the original legislation, which is why I was posing the question to members opposite. I was not trying to be mischievous. I believe that opinions have changed. If we canvassed Canadians as a whole, we would find that a majority of Canadians want us to move in this direction.
When I think of the individuals who show up at my discussions at McDonald's or in other environments, it seems to reinforce the public opinion that we need to look at moving in the direction that this legislation is bringing us. It is why I highlighted that it is important when we look at legislation, in good part, that we reflect on what a majority of Canadians would want us to be saying.
We can still have our strong personal beliefs, and that is why I asked one member what they felt their constituents would have to say. Is there not a responsibility at least to have more of a balanced approach in debating the legislation? I have not seen that balance coming from the Conservative members thus far in the debate. That even includes the leader of the Conservative Party.
I do believe we need to have a perspective that deals outside our personal opinions. This is why I think it was important for me to talk about a bit of the history and how it has been evolving. As I said, with the Carter decision, there were countries that had MAID. Since that decision, we have seen many other countries explore MAID and I suspect some of those countries are even looking at what Canada has been doing with MAID, because Canada does matter, not only on economic issues, but on social issues also.
We talk about establishing a framework that would allow provinces to put into place a process that protects the integrity of the system. I can appreciate that there are examples that are going to be brought forward during this debate and even previously where there might have been very strong allegations, some of them no doubt proven to be true, which cause a great deal of concern to every member of the House, no matter what side of the debate they are on. For example, when I hear about a veteran who has been instructed, that concerns me greatly, as it would for any Canadian who has been hoodwinked or made to believe they do not have any other options. That does disgust me, but it does not mean we get rid of the opportunity for the thousands of people who have accessed MAID because they believed it was important for them. This is why I say that this has been evolving.
When we talk about establishing the framework with strong guardrails, the debate does not end here. The debate will continue on in provincial and territorial regimes in Canada. Members across the way will say they want one standard practice across the nation. It does not work that way. We have provincial jurisdiction. They are constitutionally given jurisdictions that we have to be sensitive to and respect. This means we have to work with provincial and territorial governments in hopes that the provinces that want to continue to provide MAID are in a position to do so.
I would expect those provinces and territories to add to the very basic guardrails we would be putting into place, and I believe they will. I believe that just as I believe that every member in the House of Commons is genuinely concerned about the subject matter. After all, we are talking about life. I believe the provinces and territories will also take the issue as seriously as members of Parliament do. As we, the Supreme Court and other courts have recognized, it is time that we see the charter, understand what a right is and bring forward laws that would enable MAID not only to exist, but to be supported and, at the same time, protect the individual.
That is something that is within this legislation. There is no need to divide the legislation, as the Conservatives are arguing for. In my opinion, we cannot justify it. If someone says that they want more debate time, what they are really saying is that they do not want it to pass, because we have had decades of commentary and debate, inside the House and outside the House. The public has weighed in. Our courts have weighed in. Parliament has weighed in.
I was here through the many debates that we have had inside the chamber over the last decade since we actually decriminalized it in 2016. I witnessed members of all political entities cry, share their stories and talk about what had taken place in the committees, which was gut-wrenching, no doubt, at times. We have had the opportunity, and we are going to have still more debate and more committee meetings on the issue. However, let us say, for the sake of argument, that we were able to pass the legislation with the its principles still intact. I do not want to preclude what could happen at the committee stage.
We should be able to pass this, hopefully before Christmas. I believe that is a reasonable request, but one of the ways we can ensure that, and have time at the committee stage, would be for the House leadership teams to work on a way that we could actually pass this legislation to committee stage.
Why oppose its going to the committee stage? At committee stage, there would be ample opportunities for stakeholders and parliamentarians to continue adding comments, issues, concerns and so much more. The opportunity is there, but I believe that we need to move forward with the principles of the legislation, as I would ask of those individuals who want to continue debate.
I unfortunately do not have enough time. I would have loved to talk about the issue of hospice care. I would have loved to talk about the issue of palliative care. It is not just money. It is an important aspect, but the greatest threat to health care is not just financial resources, but it is how we manage the changes that are necessary so that we can have the type of quality health care that Canadians want and expect. There needs to be more financial accountability in that area. We need to look at personal care facilities, hospice care facilities and how our hospital institutions administer and provide palliative care, as an example.
I look forward to seeing provinces and territories enter into the debate and discussions, and to taking a look at what the province of Quebec already has on the table. There are already things in place that other jurisdictions can look at. I suspect, over the coming weeks and months as the bill leaves Parliament, that we are going to see more debates on it at the provincial and territorial level, where they will no doubt be expanding on the issue of safeguards and protecting the rights of the individual.
I see my time has expired. I appreciate the opportunity to share a few words.
Tako Van Popta (CPC)9:40 p.m.
Madam Speaker, at the outset, I would like to note that I will be sharing my time with my colleague, the member for Elgin—St. Thomas—London South.
Tonight, we are debating Bill C-41, the medical assistance in dying safeguard act. This bill would do two substantially different things. First, it would permanently cancel the expansion of MAID for those who are suffering from mental illness. Second, it would introduce a framework for advance medical directives allowing individuals to make decisions in advance about receiving MAID if they later lose the capacity to consent. I support the first measure. I cannot support the second.
The permanent exclusion of mental illness as the sole underlying condition for MAID is a necessary and long overdue correction. It reflects what many medical experts have been saying, including mental health professionals and disability advocates, which is that our health care system cannot reliably distinguish between a treatable mental illness and an irremediable one. The risks are simply too great. I am happy that the Liberals have finally come to that conclusion as well.
Advance medical directives, on the other hand, raise a very different and a far more complex set of ethical and legal questions. They touch on issues of consent, autonomy and the value of human life at the moment when a person may no longer be capable of expressing their wishes. These two issues should never have been bundled together in one single bill. One requires urgent legislative action before a deadline that is only six months away. The other demands careful study and thoughtful consideration.
To understand why the government is finally reversing course on the first issue, medical assistance in dying for those who are suffering from mental illness, it is useful to explore how we arrived at this point. It all started with the Sue Rodriguez case in 1993, where the Supreme Court of Canada upheld the Criminal Code provision that prohibited assisting somebody to die, to commit suicide. Twenty years later, the Carter case came along, and the Supreme Court of Canada changed its mind. It came to quite a different conclusion.
Faced with the circumstances of Ms. Kay Carter, who suffered from ALS, a progressive and incurable neurodegenerative disease, the court found that an absolute prohibition of physician-assisted dying was a breach of section 7 of the charter. The court stated that MAID could be available for people in Ms. Carter's condition as long as that adult was one who clearly consented to the termination of life and it was a grievous and irremediable condition causing enduring and intolerable suffering. It was those two things: clear consent and an irremediable condition. Importantly, the court also emphasized that it really was limited to those specific facts, which is exactly what courts usually do. It was making no pronouncement over any other situation where physician assistance might be sought, for example, for mental illness.
Parliament responded to that Carter decision with Bill C-14, establishing a MAID framework that included a further requirement, that natural death had to be reasonably foreseeable. We thought that was going to be our MAID regime going forward into the future. Unfortunately, that proved to not be the end of the story.
For the next chapter in how the Liberals have mismanaged this whole MAID file, we turn to the Truchon decision in Quebec, where two individuals successfully challenged the “reasonable foreseeability of natural death” provision. What happened next was remarkable. Rather than appealing a lower court decision that struck down an act of Parliament, the Liberal government, the attorney general, chose not to defend the legislation that had been adopted in the House after one of the most significant ethical debates in modern Canadian history. The result was Bill C-7. The legislation created two tracks, one for those whose death was reasonably foreseeable and the other for those who were not in a situation of dying. Significantly, Bill C-7 expressly stated that mental illness alone would not qualify a person for MAID.
After Bill C-7 passed in the House of Commons, the Senate, shockingly in my opinion, proposed amending the bill. It proposed removing the mental illness exclusion after a sunset period of two years. Instead of rejecting the amendment, which the Liberals should have done, the Attorney General, who also should have done it as it is his job to defend the laws of Parliament, accepted it. They caved to the MAID activists. That decision launched Canada down a path that many experts have said is dangerous.
For example, in November 2023, the chairs and heads of numerous psychiatric departments across Canada said that there is “no...accepted definition of irremediability” in mental illness and “no reliable way to distinguish a MAID request from suicidal ideation.” That is what the experts were saying. I am happy that the Liberals finally listened to that and are convinced. They cautioned against expanding MAID in these circumstances, saying that it would risk facilitating preventable deaths and undermine suicide prevention efforts.
The Liberal government did the right thing, sort of. It postponed the implementation date, at first by one year and then later by three more years. Here we are, after six years of uncertainty. The government has finally arrived at where many experts and Canadians believed it should have been all along: MAID for mental illness alone is not sound public policy. The government made the right decision in the bill that is before us, and we agree with that part of it.
However, while retreating from one problematic expansion of MAID, the government would now advance another that is even more problematic. Advance medical directives would allow individuals to specify in advance the circumstances under which they would wish to receive MAID if they later lose the capacity to consent. Now, at first glance, many Canadians might think, well, that makes sense. We write wills. We write powers of attorney. We write health directives. Why should we not write advance medical directives for MAID?
MAID is substantially and fundamentally a different matter. Advance directives concerning MAID authorize an irreversible act that results in death, with someone else, a third party, being tasked with making the ultimate decision. The Liberals talk a lot about the importance of the autonomy of the person. Well, someone has lost autonomy when somebody else is making the decision. That is why many experts urge caution.
For example, Dr. Pageau of Université Laval told the Special Joint Committee on MAID that it is simply not ethical to permit MAID for persons with dementia through advance requests. He posed this question: As the disease progresses, are we honouring the wishes of the person who exists today, or the wishes of someone who existed years earlier? People change their mind. That question deserves much deeper examination before Parliament accedes. We should not be rushing through this very complex ethical question.
The strongest concern with advance medical directives is the issue of consent. The Supreme Court's decision in Carter began with the simple and essential principle that an individual “clearly consents to the termination of life”. Advance directives risk undermining that basic principle.
Dr. Alice Chung appeared before the special joint committee and posed an important question. She asked this: What right does the 60-year-old version of ourselves have to determine the quality of life experienced by the 80- or 90-year-old version of ourselves? She went on to note that medical evidence demonstrates that many individuals adapt to their severe illness, to their disability or to their cognitive decline in ways that they had not anticipated when they might have signed advance directives. What once to them seemed intolerable looking into the future, being uncertain of the future, may later become meaningful and a worthwhile life.
These are not abstract scenarios. They are real-world examples that we received from experts, which raised difficult questions about autonomy, dignity and the risk of ending the life of someone who may no longer share the wishes they had expressed years earlier.
In conclusion, we applaud the government for proposing to stop the expansion of MAID, but we say that it must not—
Andrew Lawton (CPC)9:55 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is always a great honour to rise in the House, and, I will say, especially so to speak to this legislation.
One of the reasons I got into politics, one of the planks of my campaign for the nomination for my party, was to put an end to MAID for mental illness. That is a position that up until a few months ago, the Liberal government was dead set opposed to. For years, the Liberals have argued that MAID must expand to include people with mental illness. Even when concerns were being raised about the lack of readiness and the lack of willingness by provinces and physicians, they would not abandon this. They instead kept kicking the can down the road.
It was a great privilege to serve on the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying, a committee that was assembled by Parliament and was tasked very specifically and narrowly to explore the issue of whether MAID could ever be safely or reasonably expanded to people with mental illness. The committee turned back a single recommendation, which Liberal and Conservative members on the committee were united on: that the expansion of MAID to people with only a mental illness not proceed.
To have Liberals and Conservatives in alignment on a matter of conscience, on a matter such as that, is so important, especially on something that just a couple of years ago, just in the previous Parliament, the majority of the Liberal caucus voted against doing.
When Bill C-314 was put forward, a bill to stop the expansion of MAID to mental illness, only eight Liberal members supported it. That is a huge problem. I am grateful they have now come around to the conclusion that Conservatives were warning about for years: that we must protect the vulnerable. People struggling with mental illness need our support.
Yes, we need services and treatment. More importantly, we need to be instilling hope, not sending a message that someone is better off dead than alive. I have said in the House many times, and I will reiterate it so everyone knows, this is an issue that is very personal to me. I nearly lost my life to suicide just under 16 years ago, and I very likely would not be here today if MAID for mental illness had been available in 2010, when I was in my darkest days. I can say that with a level of confidence, seeing how existing safeguards have not worked, how existing safeguards in the MAID regime have not prevented people who do not meet the legal criteria from accessing MAID.
Earlier today, the leader of the official opposition mentioned in his speech the case of Kiano Vafaeian, a 26-year-old who dealt with diabetes and partial blindness, and, more importantly, had a range of mental health issues. He was denied MAID in Ontario, but he went doctor shopping. He went to another province, found one of the most prolific purveyors of MAID in Canada and received it. His family got the call that he had died at the hands of a doctor.
There have been other cases that we heard about at the special joint committee, and others that we have heard in the media. People have also reached out to me with their stories. There are stories of people who have been offered MAID who do not want it and stories of people who do not meet anything resembling the legal criteria right now but who have nonetheless been found eligible or told they would be.
There is a very fundamental question facing parliamentarians right now: If existing safeguards on the current MAID regime right now are not working, how would it be anything other than reckless and irresponsible to expand the system in any way?
This brings us to Bill C-41. Despite the singular recommendation that Liberals and Conservatives agreed on to stop the expansion of MAID to people with mental illness, Bill C-41 is not a bill about that. In fact, the 12 pages of Bill C-41 contain three sentences dealing with MAID for mental illness. Two and a half clauses, but three sentences, of the 12-page bill would stop the expansion of MAID that would allow people with depression, schizophrenia or an eating disorder access to this regime, to a medically guided, medically directed death.
The rest of the bill, the rest of the 12 pages of Bill C-41, proposes an expansion of MAID called advance requests, MAID for people who would not be able to consent because they will have lost the capacity, but who wish to consent ahead of time. This would be people with very real, very serious degenerative neurological conditions such as Alzheimer's and other dementias.
This is something we find deeply concerning, if we have been following the lack of safeguards already. When I look at this bill, I see a range of issues, some of which we have heard mentioned in debate tonight, such as the fact that one does not need to be told that MAID is about to be administered before it is; that a doctor or nurse practitioner has tremendous latitude to make, in their own opinion, a determination as to whether someone's suffering is sufficiently intolerable for the request to be actioned, a request that might have been made a decade earlier; and that if the person says no but the practitioner believes there is sufficient doubt as to whether they were really saying no, the practitioner can simply try again in 30 days. That is what the bill says: They can try again in 30 days if there is doubt as to whether the person was refusing it.
Some of the MAID practitioners in Canada who have become quite well known talked about this issue before Bill C-41 was tabled. Some of these physicians have said that if someone who has an advance request is screaming “no” and flailing their arms around, doctors would disregard that, as they do not believe that is legitimate because they have made a determination that this person does not know what they are saying or doing. Doctors have already said they intend to ignore what I think are already quite lax guidelines and stipulations set out in Bill C-41. If existing safeguards are not working, how can we ever expect an expansion to not lead to many more problems?
At every step of the journey, as we have discussed MAID in Canada, there have been those warning of the slippery slope. If we expand it to this, then there is going to be something else next. At times, many on the Liberal benches have said they are fearmongering. We are barrelling down the slippery slope right now. Every single prediction that has been made about where this is going has come to pass.
I would note that the Liberals have done something very cynical. By marrying the provisions stopping the mental health expansion with advance requests, they are holding a gun to the heads of members of Parliament, forcing us to put a complicated and divisive bill forward on a timeline that is not necessary, because we are all committed on the Conservative benches to ensuring that the mental health expansion does not kick in in March of next year.
If we do nothing, if no legislation is passed, people with a mental illness as a sole underlying condition will be eligible for MAID. That is why Liberals could have done the right thing two weeks ago and voted for Bill C-218, legislation that I was proud to cosponsor and that was put forward by my colleague from Cloverdale—Langley City, legislation supported by the Green Party leader, New Democrats, a couple on the Liberal benches and huge numbers of Canadians, including disability rights advocates and mental health organizations. If the Liberals had supported that bill, we would have been off to the races. We could have had the time necessary to debate and discuss advance requests, hear witness testimony and ensure that all sides and many Canadians had the opportunity to have a say. Instead, we have comments like those from the member for Etobicoke—Lakeshore, who said that the first part of the bill is not only important but urgent, because if we do not pass this bill immediately, this law will take effect on March 17, 2027. He asked every member of this House to vote in favour of Bill C-41 for that reason.
The Liberals are already saying that we are the ones who have to force this bill through to meet a timeline that they are setting by their refusal to separate these two fundamentally distinct provisions. They refuse to allow separate bills or even separate votes on whether to expand MAID to people with mental illness and whether to expand MAID to people who wish to make an advance request. That is a tremendously reasonable response from us to the Liberals, if the Liberals are serious about, as they keep saying, getting this complicated issue right. They should split the bill and dispense with these cynical, divisive politics that are gambling with people's lives.
Jenny Kwan (NDP)10:10 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill C-41, the medical assistance in dying safeguards act. This is one of the most profound questions Parliament can consider. It touches on life, death, dignity, autonomy, compassion, equality and our responsibilities to one another. It is deeply personal, affecting individuals confronting serious illness, their families, caregivers and medical professionals. There are deeply held differences of opinion on this issue shaped by personal experience, ethical traditions, religious beliefs and understandings of human dignity. For that reason, this is a matter of conscience and a free vote for the New Democratic caucus.
At the heart of this debate is a fundamental human rights question: How do we respect individual dignity, autonomy and rights while protecting those who may be vulnerable? Every person deserves to live and die with dignity. That means respecting the right to make deeply personal decisions about one's body, health and end-of-life care. It also means ensuring that people are not abandoned by the systems and institutions meant to support them.
Canada's debate about assisted dying has been shaped by decades of advocacy, legal challenges and difficult ethical questions. We all remember the case of Sue Rodriguez in 1993. Former NDP MP Svend Robinson stood by her. It was a difficult moral issue then, and it remains difficult today. Living with ALS, Rodriguez challenged Canada's prohibition on assisted dying. She argued that she should have the right to seek assistance in ending her life before her illness took away her ability to do so. The Supreme Court rejected her challenge in a narrow 5-4 decision, but her struggle brought questions about autonomy, equality, security of the person and dignity into the national conversation.
More than two decades later, the Supreme Court revisited those questions in Carter v. Canada. In February 2015, the court unanimously found that the Criminal Code prohibitions on physician-assisted dying violated the charter rights of certain competent adults experiencing grievous and irremediable medical conditions causing enduring and intolerable suffering. That decision was a landmark moment in Canadian human rights law.
Parliament responded with Bill C-14 in 2016, establishing Canada's first federal framework for medical assistance in dying. In 2021, Bill C-7 expanded eligibility for certain individuals whose natural death was not reasonably foreseeable, while introducing different safeguards. Subsequent legislation, including Bill C-39 and Bill C-62, delayed the proposed expansion to people whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. Now Bill C-41 is before us to respond to the courts, and Parliament is addressing two critical questions: one, the issue of advance requests and, two, those whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness.
On the first question, what Bill C-41 would do is establish a framework for advance requests for MAID, and it would only be permitted in provinces and territories that have the required legislative regime in force. Because Bill C-41 stipulates that an advance request is permitted only in provinces or territories that have the required legislative regime in force, it raises serious concerns about unequal access. Canadians should not have different rights depending on where they live, yet this is where we are at with Bill C-41. I will have more to say about that.
On the second point, the bill would maintain the exclusion of people whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. There are different human rights perspectives on that question. Excluding people solely because of a mental illness raises serious charter equality concerns. There is an argument that people should not be denied access to a legal medical procedure simply because of their diagnosis and that eligibility should be considered through appropriate individualized assessments and safeguards.
At the same time, mental health experts and disability rights organizations have raised concerns about the ability to determine when a mental illness is irremediable, the availability of appropriate treatment, and profound disparities in access to care. There is no question that these concerns deserve serious consideration. For example, end-of-life advocacy groups view the exclusion of mental illness as discriminatory and unconstitutional, emphasizing bodily autonomy and equity under the law.
Dying With Dignity Canada expressed deep disappointment over legislative barriers, stating that preventing a group of people from having access to a legal medical procedure simply because of their diagnosis violates charter rights. The organization maintains that individuals should have equal rights to apply based on rigorous individualized assessments.
On the flip side, Inclusion Canada, a leading disability rights group, argued that expanded eligibility perpetuates dangerous ableist assumptions that life with a disability is not worth living. Meanwhile, the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health notes that there is a lack of established criteria and consensus among psychiatrists for if and when a mental illness should be considered irremediable, alongside stark disparities in access to care.
To that end, there is another dimension to this debate that we cannot ignore. The right to make a choice is meaningful only when people have real choices available to them. Experts, disability advocates and health care organizations have raised concerns about whether people experiencing profound suffering always have access to the care and support they need. Some warn that assisted dying risks becoming an answer to suffering that could be alleviated through better access to health care, affordable housing, disability supports and community services. The government's own report has identified inadequate funding for mental health services.
A person living with a disability should not have to fight for basic services, appropriate housing or the resources required to live independently. A person experiencing mental health challenges should not face inaccessible treatment, long wait-lists or a shortage of community-based supports. Someone approaching the end of life should not be denied quality palliative care because of where they live or their financial circumstances. Telling someone that a service exists is not the same as ensuring they can access it.
Palliative care, counselling, disability services and mental health treatment must be timely, affordable and appropriate. This is not an argument against individual autonomy. It is an argument that autonomy must be supported by the social and economic conditions that allow people to exercise it meaningfully. The federal government has a responsibility to work with the provinces and territories to address these gaps. Dignity cannot be separated from the material conditions in which people live.
In June, the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying recommended that the federal government indefinitely exclude people whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. The committee also identified a pressing need for increased and more equitable access to adequate mental health services. People deserve timely access to treatment, counselling, psychiatrists, psychologists and community-based services. The committee's call for more equitable mental health services must not be lost in this debate. Maintaining an exclusion in the Criminal Code cannot substitute for the government's responsibility to invest in mental health care.
We must also consider how this legislation would affect people differently. People living in poverty, experiencing homelessness, living with disabilities or living in remote communities can face significant barriers to accessing health care. First nations, Inuit and Métis communities have experienced generations of inequities in health care, including inadequate access to culturally safe services and palliative care.
The government must engage indigenous governments and organizations meaningfully in implementation, respecting indigenous self-determination and the diversity of perspectives within indigenous communities. We must ask whether every person can make an informed and voluntary decision without pressure, discrimination or the absence of meaningful alternatives. This is a fundamental human rights question.
I began by noting that Canada's debate about assisted dying has been shaped by decades of advocacy, legal challenges and difficult ethical questions. I suspect that this is not the end to legal challenges on this question. There are people who believe that the right to die with dignity is inseparable from the right to make decisions about one's own body and the circumstances of their death. There are others who approach this question through concerns for the sanctity of life, the protection of the vulnerable, disability rights and the responsibilities of society. We must make room for these differences and chart a path forward.
Regardless of which party one belongs to in the House, we can all agree that every person deserves dignity, compassion and access to appropriate health care and support. No one should be made to feel that their life is less valuable because they live with a disability, an illness, poverty or circumstances that make life more difficult. The right to make decisions about one's own life and death cannot become an excuse for the government's own withdrawal from its responsibility to provide care.
There is the important work of the parliamentary committee. People with lived experiences, families, disability advocates, indigenous organizations, medical professionals and other experts must have the opportunity to contribute and be heard. We must not rush the bill through committee. We owe Canadians a process that is thoughtful, transparent and grounded in human rights, and we must respect the dignity of people at the end of life, protect those who may be vulnerable to coercion or who have inadequate support, and build a health care system that gives everyone the opportunity to live and die with dignity.
David Bexte (CPC)10:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to stand in this House and speak for the constituents of Bow River. This is a deeply held and personal issue for so many people across the country. I am often skeptical of government intervention in the economy, on the farm and in the private lives of Canadians. I believe the government should respect the freedom of people in their own decisions.
I also believe Parliament has the duty to protect life, especially when the law puts vulnerable people at risk of irreversible harm. That duty brings us to Bill C-41 with respect to medical assistance in dying, and to a straightforward request to split the bill, pass the permanent exclusion where mental illness is the sole underlying medical condition and give the issue of advance requests the separate scrutiny that it deserves.
On October 7, the Liberals voted against Bill C-218. Introduced by my colleague, the member for Cloverdale—Langley City, that bill would have permanently prevented MAID eligibility where a person's sole underlying medical condition was a mental illness. Twenty days later, the government has now introduced Bill C-41 with provisions to maintain that exclusion, but attached them to a separate proposal on advance requests. They have deliberately turned this into a moral paradox. The Liberals rejected the Conservative solution, then returned with the protection we had sought tied to a much broader change in the law, a change that would expand the availability of MAID. The first part of this bill is necessary because we cannot ensure that someone suffering from a mental illness is competent to make a final and binding decision to engage in MAID. This bill then goes on in the second part to do just that and enable MAID when a person is unable to give competent consent or competent refusal by design. The Liberals owe Canadians an explanation. If we agree that people whose sole underlying condition is mental illness must be protected, why make that protection dependent on settling a separate debate?
Conservatives are united on the way forward. Let us split the legislation. We are prepared to work with the government to pass the mental illness provisions through all stages of this House without delay and send them to the upper house. The current exclusion expires on March 17, 2027. Unless Parliament acts, the scheduled expansion will take effect. The Liberals have already delayed the expansion of MAID for mental illness more than once, which is exactly why they should not rush a separate and complex change through Parliament at the same time. They are going to make the same mistakes. There is no corresponding federal deadline requiring Parliament to authorize advance requests. The government should not use the deadline on the issue of mental illness to rush a different and complex change through this House.
The Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying recommended that people whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness be excluded indefinitely. Our proposal would have provided a lasting protection without another expiry date. The committee heard warnings about two fundamental problems that remain unresolved. First, doctors and nurse practitioners warned that they cannot reliably determine when there is no possible recovery from a mental illness. Put plainly, they cannot reliably predict that a person will never improve. Severe, prolonged suffering does not itself settle that question. Second, witnesses warned that clinicians cannot reliably distinguish a request for MAID from a desire for suicide in this context. There are different clinical views on these questions. When the consequence of an error is death, Parliament must take those warnings seriously. A person whose condition could have improved with treatment must never lose that chance because the law moved ahead of the evidence.
The committee also heard serious concerns about whether existing safeguards and oversight are working in practice. Before Parliament extends the law further, Canadians deserve answers about how those protections are enforced and what happens when they fail. Bill C-41 acknowledges significant unresolved concerns about the safe provision of MAID on the basis of mental illness. Ministers should act on that acknowledgement and work with us to put this protection into law, now. People living with mental illness deserve to have their suffering taken seriously. They deserve care that is available when they need it and a country that remains committed to their recovery.
I recognize that this debate raises questions about autonomy and equality. The Canadian Civil Liberties Association has raised those concerns about the exclusion. Those arguments deserve a serious response. Section 7 of the charter protects life, liberty and security of the person. Section 15 guarantees legal equality, including protection against discrimination. Parliament must consider all of those rights. Protecting people from the irreversible consequences of a mistaken assessment is a legitimate and necessary responsibility of government. We can respect the dignity of people living with mental illness while insisting that the law protect their chance to recover.
The second part of Bill C-41 raises a very different question. Herein is the paradox. It would permit an adult to make an advance request after a diagnosis of a serious incurable illness expected to permanently take away their capacity to consent. This is important on the “expected” part, which I will get to in a moment. By the time MAID was administered, that person would no longer be able to give informed consent to the procedure. Families facing dementia and other devastating conditions deserve a careful hearing, and so do people who fear that a past request could be acted on in circumstances that they never understood or anticipated.
The bill contains safeguards, including two independent assessments and rules about refusal and resistance. Parliament must examine whether those rules can reliably protect someone who is no longer lucid. A clear refusal would prevent MAID under that request. Where a practitioner is unsure whether a reaction means refusal or resistance, the bill would require a pause of at least 30 clear days.
The legislation proposed already anticipates uncertainty in the practitioner. How would that uncertainty be resolved after the waiting period? Who would review the decision? How would the conditions distinguish an involuntary reaction from a person trying to resist? More importantly, the real question here is can the practitioner understand what a person is trying to communicate at the last moment? I submit this is the crux of the problem. It is not so much whether the patient is able to communicate. Is the practitioner equipped to understand what they are communicating?
We have all heard examples of locked-in syndrome, where there is complete consciousness and lucidity, but the inability to move or communicate. How would suffering be assessed when a person cannot really describe it? What would happen when a request is many years old and the treatment circumstances or preferences have changed?
These questions concern the moment when someone is least able to speak for themselves. They require evidence, clear legal rules and enforceable accountability. When ambiguity exists, we must err on the side of caution and prevent advance requests.
The advance request provisions would also depend on provincial legislation. Alberta and other provinces must be heard on their responsibilities, on the safeguards they would administer and on how the federal framework would operate in practice.
Doctors, legal experts, families, veterans and people living with disabilities must have a meaningful opportunity to testify. Members of Parliament should be able to assess the proposal to allow MAID by advance request on its own merits, separately from the urgent mental illness protection.
As Remembrance Day approaches, we should reflect on our particular responsibility to veterans. Veterans Affairs' own investigation confirmed four incidents in which a single employee inappropriately raised MAID with veterans. That was shameful. It was a shameful failure toward people who served our country. The government must ensure it never happens again.
Veterans living with trauma, chronic pain or physical injuries deserve timely treatment and comprehensive support. When a veteran needs help, Canada's response must demonstrate that their life and service matter.
That responsibility extends to every vulnerable Canadian. People must have meaningful access to health care, mental health support services, disability supports and palliative care. If someone feels MAID is their only realistic option because adequate care is unavailable, Parliament has a duty to confront that failure. A list of services on paper means little to a person who cannot actually get them.
We have common ground before us. The government now proposes to prevent the expansion of MAID for mental illness. Conservatives are ready to pass that protection immediately. Members of the House may reach different conclusions about advance requests after hearing the evidence. The government should give them the opportunity to consider that question separately with the care it demands.
The Liberals keep asking for co-operation. The Minister of Justice can put aside petty politics and work with us today. Separate the two measures. Let us pass the protection on which we agree. Parliament can examine the rest. Canadians living with mental illness should not have to watch their protection evaporate.
Conservatives will continue to fight to ensure vulnerable Canadians are met with help to live, not a pathway to state-facilitated death. Split the bill, pass the exclusion and give advance requests to the study they need.
Guillaume Deschênes-Thériault (Lib.)10:50 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, tonight, we have gathered to discuss a particularly sensitive issue that raises legal, ethical and social questions affecting patients suffering from an incurable disease, their families and health care professionals. I believe this is a topic we all take very seriously.
Let us take a step back. The law on medical assistance in dying came into effect in Canada in 2016. That marked a significant change in Canadian society's approach to end-of-life care. MAID provides eligible individuals with an additional choice regarding their care by allowing them to end their suffering with dignity. There are certainly strict guidelines in place. Medical assistance in dying is reserved for adults who meet strict eligibility criteria. We are talking, for example, about people living with an incurable illness who are approaching the end of life, such as cancer patients, or individuals with an incurable condition that causes irreversible physical decline and significant suffering, such as certain neurodegenerative disorders.
There are guidelines that must be followed. The consent must be informed. The person has the right to withdraw consent at any point in the process. The passage of the bill in 2016 was not the end of the debate. I would say that it was the beginning and the continuation of an ongoing societal discussion on the subject of MAID. Over the past decade alone, we have pondered substantive questions about MAID, such as whether a person has a right to set the conditions for their end of life. This led to questions about dignity and suffering. As we know, the law was expanded in 2021. Initially, it was for naturally foreseeable death. The law was amended in 2021 to include people suffering from an irreversible illness that causes significant suffering. At the time, as a citizen, I heard very touching testimony from people who asked that their situation be taken into consideration so that they could have the right to make this choice for themselves.
This also raises questions about the protection of vulnerable individuals, consent, and the ability to make a free and informed decision, as well as what to do when an illness deprives a person of that ability. With Bill C-41, we aim to update Canada's legislative framework on medical assistance in dying, particularly with regard to people with mental illness and advance requests. We are therefore clarifying matters with respect to these two elements. I would say that this is another step in a collective reflection that began more than a decade ago.
One key component of Bill C-41 seeks to allow for advance MAID requests. Under the current legislation, a person must be able to give informed consent to receive this care. They must understand their medical condition, their options, and the consequences of their decision. As a general rule, they must also confirm their consent immediately before MAID is administered. Very strict guidelines are in place. However, some diseases, such as Alzheimer's disease and other forms of dementia, can lead to a gradual loss of decision-making capacity. As the disease progresses, a person may lose the ability to make an informed choice at the time they wish to receive MAID. Under the current rules, they cannot access this option, even if they had clearly expressed their wishes earlier in life when they were still capable of making that decision.
Our government believes that Canadians with terminal illnesses should be able to make informed decisions about their future care while they still have the capacity to do so. That is why, with this bill, we intend to allow eligible adults who receive an early diagnosis of a terminal illness that is likely to cause them to lose their decision-making capacity to make an advance request for MAID. For example, an adult diagnosed with early-stage Alzheimer's disease could specify in advance the conditions and circumstances under which they would want to receive MAID at a more advanced stage of their illness, when they would no longer be able to make that decision for themselves.
The underlying objective is to respect the person's wishes and their individual end-of-life choices, which I believe are based on deep and careful reflection. We heard some very moving testimony. Loved ones of people with Alzheimer's said that MAID should be expanded to allow people in these situations to make informed choices while they still can.
An advance request does not necessarily mean that MAID will automatically be administered at a later time. The eligibility criteria must be met and the strict guidelines must be followed. For example, two independent assessments will always be required for advance requests to ensure that the conditions described in the request are met. There must be confirmation that the person is in an advanced and irreversible state of decline and experiencing profound suffering, so the independent assessments still need to be carried out.
The person may also signify, through sounds or gestures, that they withdraw their consent when MAID is about to be administered. If the person does not appear to consent to MAID, the procedure will be stopped. Obviously, a family member cannot submit an advance request on behalf of someone else. The aim is really to respect the choice of the person who made the request while they still had the capacity to do so.
In our discussions tonight, it is important to understand the key role that the provinces and territories will play in this matter. At the federal level, we can amend the criminal framework, including the Criminal Code, since this falls under our jurisdiction. However, the delivery of health care services is a provincial responsibility. The federal government alone cannot oversee the implementation of advance requests for MAID. Even if Parliament were to amend the Criminal Code for this, the provinces would also have to take steps to ensure that advance requests would be available in their health care systems. As I mentioned, the provinces are responsible for the organization and delivery of health care in their jurisdictions, and it will be up to them to decide whether they want to implement this option and how it will be carried out. What I mean is that, even if the federal law changes, it does not become automatic across Canada. The provinces will have to decide whether to implement the framework within their borders. Co‑operation with the provinces and territories will therefore be critical so that everyone who is eligible can have access. As the federal government, we will continue to work with the provinces as we make progress on this matter.
I will now discuss the second part. Through Bill C-41, we will maintain the exclusion for cases when mental illness is the sole underlying health condition. After careful consideration, following committee deliberations, and after hearing from numerous experts, we came to an agreement that MAID should not be expanded to cover individuals for whom mental illness is the sole underlying health condition. That said, we recognize that mental illness can cause profound suffering, even when it is not necessarily as visible as in the case of other physical health conditions. Canadians living with mental health issues deserve to have their suffering taken seriously.
In the context of MAID, however, serious concerns remain regarding the ability to assess these situations safely and consistently. For these reasons, we decided not to expand MAID eligibility to individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. As I mentioned, this decision was not taken lightly. A parliamentary committee made up of senators and MPs from the various political parties examined the issue. Health experts and stakeholders also gave evidence. Finally, following all these consultations, the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying recommended against expanding medical assistance in dying. At the same time, other consultations took place. The conclusion was that uncertainty remains as to whether these situations can be assessed reliably and consistently. In light of that, our government believes that the current exclusion is the most appropriate approach.
In closing, we are debating substantive issues tonight, issues that affect the choices people make when they are considering their end of life. I think it is important that legislators put a framework in place, particularly for people suffering from conditions such as dementia or Alzheimer's. It is important to give these individuals the opportunity to make a free and informed choice about their end-of-life care.
Jamil Jivani (CPC)11:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I would like to begin my comments today by reiterating a request that has been made by many of my colleagues here in the House of Commons, which is to split the bill.
Bill C-41 is a real moral dilemma. The way it has been politically manipulated is of great concern. It is only by splitting the bill into two separate decisions, two separate votes by members of the House, that I think it could be fairly presented to the public as an appropriate examination of the very serious medical and moral issues that are embedded within it.
I was trying to explain to one of my constituents earlier what the moral dilemma is exactly. What I found to be helpful was a reference to the movie The Dark Knight. There is a scene in which the Joker calls Batman and tells him that his girlfriend, Rachel Dawes, has been left in one room. On the other side of Gotham, the DA, Harvey Dent, has been left in the other room. The Joker tells Batman that he has to make a choice and that it is going to suck regardless. It is going to be a really hard, horrible decision. He only gets to make one decision on who he gets to save.
That is what has been presented to us with Bill C-41. Every member of the House, from all parties, is being put in this situation by the Prime Minister and whomever in the government is making the decision to combine these two elements of a very complicated and dense issue into one bill. Whoever is making that decision is putting every single one of us in the exact same situation that the Joker put Batman in.
We are not going to feel good about the decision we make at the end of the day. Either we are going to vote against the bill, which has a very important and needed element in it, to further protect people with mental illness from euthanasia, or we are going to vote against the bill, because it also expands euthanasia to include people with dementia and other illnesses. These are really two things that should not be combined.
I feel obligated to point out the cynical, cold and callous nature in which these two things have been combined into one bill. Every member of the House had an opportunity to vote on a Conservative private member's bill that would have only addressed the expansion of MAID to those facing mental illness. All members of the Conservative Party voted for that bill. All members of the NDP voted for that bill. In fact, we even had one bold, brave soul on the other side of the aisle, in the Liberal ranks, vote for that bill. The remainder of that party voted against it. Why? What would possibly be the reason, other than the cold and cynical ploy to wedge those of us, with a heavy heart and a heavy conscience on this issue, into combining our very well-intentioned opposition to the expansion of euthanasia to those with mental illness and forcing us to also reconcile that with the expansion to more Canadians?
That is not the way this place should work. I will be honest. I appreciate that politics is an ugly and dirty game. I can appreciate that a lot of this is about wedging people constantly. On something so heavy, on something that is such a matter of conscience, I really do hope that the government will reconsider and split the bill when it comes time to vote.
How I would like to use the remainder of my time is to address why this is such a concern for people. I think a good place to start is to capture the fact that since 2016, MAID, or as I call it, euthanasia, has become a very common form of death for people in this country. In 2016, it was slightly over 1,000 people that were killed by euthanasia. In 2024, it was 16,499, which is the most recent statistic, in one year. In total, over an eight-year period, over 76,000 Canadians have had their lives ended through the practice of euthanasia.
I raise this because I think that there are two ways that people look at that information. Some people might look at that and think that this is a sign of progress. I shudder at that thought, as do many Canadians. I look at that number and my heart breaks. I know many people who have been in very serious situations, facing very serious illnesses.
I am a stage 4 cancer survivor. There was a time in my life when my mother and I sat in a room and a doctor said to me that I might not live. I know what that is like. I know what it is like to sit in a cancer ward and see people who are on their third, fourth or fifth year of chemotherapy. I know what it is like to sit in a hospital waiting room and see people lined up waiting to go through radiation, hoping that maybe this time it is going to work. I have seen people face death. I have faced death, so when I see numbers like this, my heart breaks, because I wonder how many of those people made the decision to end their life based on fear and because they were scared. I have been there, and I have seen people there.
When we talk about advance directives and a medical professional approaching a sick person saying that they should make a decision now about how their life is going to end, it is very concerning. The emotional roller coaster of a serious illness is very real. There are times when a person may be depressed. There are times when their spirit may be broken, and they might consider it a good decision to end their life at some point on their own terms. However, we never know what life is going to throw at us, and we never know how our life is going to change. We do not know how it is going to feel in the moment. Opposing advance directives is about saying that at minimum, people deserve the dignity to make such a choice of great finality in the moment, and that we should not have a system designed such that potential coercion or the exploitation of a very emotional and difficult situation leads to a decision that a person may pay the ultimate price for.
We have heard from families on the other side of this debate. We have heard from people with loved ones in very extreme situations on the other side of this debate. I do not want to pretend that this is simple. I am not trying to diminish another point of view. I get that this is complicated. I am not trying to point a finger at anyone and say there is a bad guy in this story. What I am trying to do is point out that these are very serious things we are debating in the House of Commons, both from a moral perspective and from a health care perspective. I am trying to point out that people come to their conclusions on these issues for very good reasons, whether that is their personal life, family life or religious or philosophical convictions, whatever they may be.
Wherever we wind up on this debate, I believe, humbly, that it is a cheapening of the issue to combine both of these very complicated questions into one bill. If I could leave anyone listening to my words with one message, it would be to please consider the weight of this. If we are taking this as seriously as we should, then it should not be something that gets lumped into some kind of omnibus euthanasia discussion. Every single way we decide which Canadians become vulnerable to the practice of euthanasia and which ones do not should be treated with the weight of significant individual policies and legislative decisions in mind, as it should be.
I would also like to elaborate on why I think it is very important that we consider the difficulty of asking an ill person to make this decision in an advance request context.
I remember when I was first told that I might pass away from stage 4 cancer. The hardest part of the entire ordeal for the year and a half that I was a hospital patient, in the hospital every day, was seeing my mom go through it. I can absolutely understand why a sick person might say, “I do not want to put the responsibility on my family to have to make a difficult decision about my life one day.” I can absolutely understand why someone would say, “The moral thing to do is to take that responsibility onto myself.” To anyone who feels that way, my word of encouragement would be that if they talk to the relatives of people who have been in those situations, they will find that many of them were very happy to have taken care of their ill loved ones and were very happy to have been by their side even when it was difficult.
Marc Dalton (CPC)11:20 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, there are few debates in Parliament that are more consequential and more deeply impactful than when we are called to debate life-and-death legislation. Issues of this importance require us to look beyond being partisan, and this is not the first time the chamber has had to grapple with such profound moral weight. We just have to look at our history.
I am thinking of capital punishment. A private member's bill was introduced to abolish it in 1914. For decades, in the 1950s, 1960s, 1970s, 1980s and 1990s, parliamentarians in this chamber grappled with that issue. They debated whether deterrence prevented murders, the morality of a state taking a human life, whether life imprisonment was a sufficient punishment and the irreversible possibility of making a mistake. We fast-forward to today. Medical assistance in dying is, without question, one of the most consequential public policy decisions this Parliament has ever made. It is a matter of life and death, literally, and that is precisely why we cannot afford to get this wrong.
When Canada first introduced medical assistance in dying in 2016, Canadians were assured by the government that it would be a carefully controlled, exceptional measure built on very clear limitations and uncompromising safeguards. We were told it was strictly an end-of-life compassionate option for those facing a reasonably foreseeable natural death. That is what we were told, but look at where we are today.
The data tells us a staggering story. In 2024 alone, 16,499 Canadians received MAID. Since its introduction, more than 76,000 Canadians have died through this program. It is approaching 100,000 now, in 2026. In 2024, MAID accounted for approximately 5.1% of all deaths across Canada. This is an extraordinary number. To put this in perspective, let us look across the border at California. It is a jurisdiction with about the same population size as Canada. Medical assistance in dying was legalized in both Canada and California at exactly the same time, yet we can look at the comparison of numbers: in Canada, 76,475 deaths, versus just 5,423 in California. In 2024, as I mentioned, there were 16,499 in this country versus 1,032 in California.
I think about how dramatically our legislation has evolved. In 2021, through Bill C-7, the government expanded eligibility far beyond those whose natural deaths were reasonably foreseeable. We created two distinct tracks, including a track for individuals who are not approaching the end of life. In so doing, Canada became one of the most permissive jurisdictions in the entire world when it came to assisted dying. By removing the requirement of natural death to be reasonably foreseeable, the government extended MAID to people with disabilities and chronic illnesses who were not otherwise dying. This approach is far outside the traditional, globally recognized end-of-life care model.
Mental illness was initially excluded from this expansion, but only temporarily. Ever since, Parliament has repeatedly had to step in to extend that exclusion as a matter of crisis management. Bill C-39 kicked the deadline down the road. Bill C-62 extended it again, to March 17, 2027, a date that we are now quickly approaching.
We must ask ourselves why MAID for mental illness was delayed in the first place. It was delayed because committees heard testimony after testimony from the front lines stating that this was an incredibly dangerous direction to go in. There was substantial, overwhelming agreement among mental health advocates, disability advocates, psychiatric professionals and academic experts. The special joint committee's recommendation was clear, to permanently exclude mental illness as a sole underlying condition for MAID, and Conservatives agree entirely with this.
We believe that someone suffering from depression, PTSD or another severe mental illness should be met with access to treatment, support and hope, not a path to assisted death. Mental illness can be utterly devastating. It distorts how a person sees themselves, how they view their current circumstances and how they perceive the future. However, we know that circumstances can change. Treatment can work. People can recover. People who once saw absolutely no hope can go on to live incredibly meaningful, beautiful lives.
I have shared this before, but it bears repeating. In my early twenties, I went through a clinical depression. It was a very dark period of time in my life. I had suicidal thoughts. Thankfully, I never made any attempts, but in that darkness I received vital support from health care professionals and those closest to me. I came out of it. Today, that dark period is a very distant memory. I feel no pain from it, but at the time I felt utterly incapacitated. With time and support, I recovered. I went on to go to university, become a teacher, an MLA in British Columbia, a member of Parliament, a father and a grandfather. I have lived a full and rich life and I am thankful. If MAID for mental illness had been legal and readily marketed for people like me at that time, how many would have gone that route?
The government itself has recognized these serious concerns, which is why it repeatedly extended the exclusion. However, with the current exclusion set to expire on March 17, 2027, there is an urgent need to act, and Conservatives have acted. The member for Cloverdale—Langley City introduced a private member's bill, Bill C-218, which would have permanently and cleanly excluded mental illness as a sole underlying condition for MAID. What happened? The Liberals voted against it. On October 7, this House had a clear opportunity to advance that protective legislation and the government voted it down. Now, just weeks later, the government has introduced its own legislation, Bill C-41, which we are debating right now as we approach midnight. What has it done? It has taken the exact permanent exclusion for mental illness and attached it to a completely separate, massive and entirely undebated element, the advance request for MAID. Let us call it what it is. The Liberals do not want to subject their new expansion of MAID to the raw public scrutiny that the mental illness expansion faced. The more the expert witnesses, physicians, psychiatrists and professional organizations spoke out about mental illness, the more the general public became concerned. They do not want to go in that direction. By chaining these two issues together in Bill C-41, it is trying to sneak a massive new policy under the radar. I say, shame.
The political dynamic in this House has shifted. Following the by-elections and floor crossings earlier this year, the Liberal government now holds a majority. It no longer needs collaboration with the opposition. It no longer needs to seek multipartisan consensus on matters of life and death. Because of this, it has the raw numbers to pass legislation independently, and it is using that power to ram this through. It is rushing this bill through the House, cutting off the thorough, isolated scrutiny that each one of these profound issues desperately deserves.
Conservatives are deeply concerned with the safeguards in this bill, particularly with the sudden expansion to advance directives. The cold, hard fact is that there is already widespread abuse and inappropriate promotion with our current MAID regime. Time and again, I talk with residents in my community who tell me horror stories about family members having MAID actively promoted and suggested to their loved ones. One of my own staff members was offered MAID three separate times because of the migraines he suffered from a fall a decade ago. Another man told me how his father was offered MAID because of a hip injury. The son had to step in and tell providers that his father needed exercises and stretching, not MAID. He helped his father get the proper rehabilitation and guess what. He is out of the hospital. He is not dead.
Marie-Hélène Gaudreau (BQ)11:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is late, but it is never too late to talk about what life is all about.
In fact, death is a fact of life. That is what we are discussing tonight. Let me begin with my conclusion. We have heard our colleagues repeatedly point out that Quebec was ahead of the curve, that it conducted multiparty consultations and that it even took the time to examine each step of the process. Today, we are saying that Quebec is not only ready, but that it also needs the latitude, insofar as the Criminal Code is concerned, to fully implement its legislation.
Here, we began studying medical assistance in dying five years ago, looking in particular at what took place in Quebec. That work yielded a wealth of findings that now allow us to clearly distinguish between two situations: advance requests and individuals who have been suffering from unbearable mental illnesses for decades.
What I am beginning to realize is that we are not going to make it happen. Some people want to divide the bill, others want to have two votes. Basically, I cannot even keep up. There is one thing I do understand, though. Can we take action together and agree that if certain provinces and territories are not ready, that is their business? If we in Quebec are ready, because we have been talking about it for years, then please let us implement what we believe is right for us. This would illustrate that such a sensitive bill was drafted through a collaborative process. I do not think we will achieve that here in the House. We have perfectly legitimate differences of opinion, but when it comes to end-of-life care, human dignity is being set aside when the individual should come first regarding decisions about their own life.
When someone is making a decision for themselves, I would feel very uncomfortable doing or saying anything that might influence that person. It is not up to me to tell them, no, they cannot die, or yes, they can die. It is up to the individual.
I am saying this because I have been through it myself. I am talking about it, but I am certainly not trying to oversimplify things and suggest that the law should be based on my experience. I want that to be clear. I have lived experience. In 2017, my father was diagnosed with ALS. People who were here more than a decade ago knew the MP Mauril Bélanger. ALS is a devastating disease. It causes tremendous suffering. It can reach a point where a person is no longer able to endure that suffering, which in this case is both physical and psychological because the person is trapped in their own body.
In 2017, my father participated in several research studies. At the time, even I, as his young daughter, would tell him that he could not possibly be thinking about death. He told me that death is just part of life. However, after discussing his case with researchers and scientists, he chose to die with his illness rather than from it. In the final stages of ALS, swallowing and breathing become increasingly difficult. The heart does not stop, but people generally end up suffocating. Because my father was eligible for MAID, he chose to die without having to endure that suffering. No one wants their parents to leave them, but he made me understand something.
It was only afterwards that I realized how understandable it is not to want to lose a loved one. It is out of love. What I am hearing in these discussions is, above all, a fear that the person might miss out on something, that there could still be moments of happiness. I could have a colleague tell me that a person with dementia has experienced 24 hours of complete lucidity over the course of three months. Ultimately, it is up to the person who is caring for their loved one. We are unable to come to an agreement about the role of loved ones this evening.
I am thinking back to when my father told me he was going to die from his illness. Of course, there was the possibility of intervention, but no one was ever able to intervene. I experienced it myself. How many times did we have to reaffirm the legitimacy of my father's right to refuse treatment, to ask that he not be allowed to suffer, and to have his end-of-life wishes respected?
He had been trapped in his body for 20 years. He told me one day that he had been using a ventilator, a BiPAP, for eight years, that he never took it off and wore it 24 hours a day, seven days a week. He could not take it anymore. The ventilator had replaced his lungs. I told him it was a natural reaction.
That is what this is all about. Let nature take its course and let us not try to save lives. If we are sick, let us die. That is what I hear, and it troubles me. In my father's case, he lived for eight years with a device that prolonged his life, but on the day he could no longer bear having that machine on his face all the time, we respected his wishes. It may have been that way from the start, eight years earlier, but he would have missed my wedding, he would not have seen my children grow up. Is it not selfish to want more time with our loved one?
Essentially, today we are debating and talking about other people. When we are talking about others, perhaps we should ask the person who is making the choice what they want, particularly in the case of advance requests. That is also what worries me. Some say that people can live a whole other life.
Earlier, I shared an analogy, or rather a story, about a colleague. I asked him what an advance request was. Simply put, sometimes we know somebody for 50, 60 or 90 years, and then they are diagnosed with Alzheimer's. This person gets to say what they will and will not endure. They may not want their personality to change completely. They may not want to have to be fed. They may not want to be confined to a chair because they tend to wander around the building. I suggested a scenario where a person who has been in politics his entire life undergoes a 180-degree personality change, causing him to strip off his clothes and flirt with everyone he encounters. If this person acted happy, people would see it in a positive light. They would think he had certain wishes that he expressed when he still had the capacity to choose. Now that he no longer has the capacity to say that this is not the end of life he wanted, however, his wishes are no longer valid. That is what I am having a hard time understanding.
As long as our discussions do not focus strictly on ethics and the protection of each individual's right to choose, simply saying that we are going to hold more meetings and conduct more analyses will only prolong the debate.
We will never see the end of it in the House.
What I want is for every individual to be able to make their own decisions about how their life ends.
Todd Doherty (CPC)11:50 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it has been said before, and I said it in the original debate in 2016, that nothing in our lifetime prepares a member of Parliament to vote on such a consequential piece of legislation. There really is not. It truly is life or death. This legislation, as it stands today, raises serious questions about how Canada approaches medical assistance in dying, how we protect vulnerable people and what responsibilities the government has to Canadians who are suffering.
From the moment I landed as a member of Parliament, I have fought every day for those who serve our country and our community and for those who are struggling and suffering silently. For over 1,000 days, I pushed the previous government to launch a national suicide hotline, 988. I believe life is so precious that we should be doing everything to fight for every breath we have in us.
Since 2016, when I really struggled with that vote, I have contacted my pastor a number of times. It went against everything in my faith, in my fibre, everything that I had fought for in the 30 years leading up to my being elected as a member of Parliament. How could I vote with that? Since 2016, I have spoken with probably hundreds if not thousands of Canadians who had loved ones who suffered from cancer or ALS and chose MAID.
In December 2023, my mother, from whom I was estranged, was diagnosed with acute leukemia. It was going to attack her brain. It was a painful disease. She chose MAID, and she set a death date. Whatever background we had, I put it aside and sat by her bedside for probably about four months as we marched toward that death date. I was tasked with making her a mixtape, as a matter of fact, to play on that day.
Imagine my surprise and my brother's surprise, as we had mentally prepared for that day, regardless of what our background was with our mother, when we arrived to be told by the doctors that when they were preparing her, she said no. We were frustrated because we knew what was lying ahead for my mom, but that was her choice. We met with the doctors, the medical team, the MAID team, and they said they could not in good conscience administer the final dose of the medication to end her life. That is my story, so I understand where families are.
I am troubled by the number of Canadians, such as veterans, who are being offered MAID because they are struggling with PTSD or a mental illness. One in 10 Canadians knows someone who has been offered MAID. Approximately 13 Canadians die by suicide every day. Approximately 100,000 Canadians attempt suicide every year. That is 250 per day. About 20,0000 Canadians are hospitalized every year for self-harm. The MAID numbers are staggering. We are approaching 100,000 Canadians who have chosen to die by MAID. We are seeing commercials for end of life on TV and on social media.
I sat with a veteran who was offered MAID. He phoned Veterans Affairs and was offered MAID. Not once, not twice, but three times he was asked if he had considered MAID. I have sat with people who have gone to their doctor for injuries that were causing them unbelievable pain.
Our concern is with advance directives, and experts in the medical community have these same concerns. We are asking to split the bill to deal with mental illness and the advance directive separately to give us time to get this as close to right as possible, to put those further safeguards in place.
I come at this with the purest of intentions. There was a time when I was consumed with death. It was for about five years. My best friend had died by suicide, and I did not see a way forward. My childhood had been filled with dysfunction and abuse. I was struggling, and I attempted suicide numerous times. I have thought about this, and if MAID had been available at that time, I would have taken it.
Then I think about all the things I would have missed. Here I am so many years later, 38 years later, and I love life. I am so thankful I am here. I think of watching my four beautiful children grow up to be amazing adults; of my grandchildren, Ren and Meyer; and of finding the love of my life just at the end of that period of darkness.
As Conservatives, we believe that we have to do everything in our power to offer opportunities for getting better, getting the supports people need. We believe in hope. We are in a mental health crisis and an addiction crisis in this country, yet time and again we hear empty promises from the other side. Tomorrow is budget day, and I hope there will be supports in place for mental health. We now spend more money in servicing our debt than we do in health care transfers. The health care transfers that go to our provinces for mental health are pennies on the dollar. We do not view mental health in parity with physical health. If we did that, as a country, we would be healthier and happier, and we would see the numbers go further down.
This debate requires Parliament to think carefully about what kind of country we want to be. We must approach suffering people with compassion, respect and dignity, but compassion cannot simply mean offering another option at the end of someone's suffering. It must mean doing everything we reasonably can to help that person live, to provide treatment, to offer support and to ensure that they are not left alone.
On the question of MAID for mental illness, we are clear that we do not support it. I do not support it. We do not believe it should ever be permitted where mental illness is the sole underlying medical condition. Mental illness should be met with treatment, care and hope.
Canadians deserve a health care system that gives them a genuine opportunity to recover and a government that works to make care accessible. I truly understand that there are Canadians who are suffering with unbelievable illnesses for whom MAID is perhaps the right choice for them, but as parliamentarians, we must do everything in our power to make sure those safeguards are in place as we move this legislation forward.
Arnold Viersen (CPC)12:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise to speak to the issue of medical assistance in dying, or as we call it more often in this country, government-assisted dying.
Canada is a pariah on the international stage when it comes to the way we have implemented this. Here is an interesting story. California and Canada legalized assisted dying, or assisted suicide in the case of California, in the same year at about the exact same time. California has about the same population as Canada. California has a very similar political outlook on the world as Canada. The difference in the application of MAID is profound, just in the raw numbers of it. In Canada, we have over 15,000 people a year ending their lives through MAID. It sounds like it is going to be more this year. In California, there are about 300 people per year. That is a huge difference, and there are lots of reasons for that. We can speculate about all of those reasons, but I just wanted to put that out there.
We are a distinct outlier in the world, in Canada, in terms of the MAID regime. I would point out that both Great Britain and Slovenia have looked at Canada, have had referendums on this issue and, because of the situation in Canada, have rejected the MAID regime entirely. They said they would not poison people to death and would demand that their health care systems promote the health care of their people, not the death of their people.
I remember back in 2016-17 when the first MAID bill came in. I remember saying that it was a radical bill and that this was going to be a slippery slope. I was wrong about that. It has been a cliff, not a slippery slope. We are now on our sixth piece of legislation expanding MAID. We thought Justin Trudeau was a radical prime minister on this file.
I remember being quite skeptical of Jody Wilson-Raybould and Jane Philpott. They kind of led the charge when it came to the Liberals bringing in the bill in the first place. I remember calling them radical and thinking they were radical. It turns out now that they were the voices of restraint when it came to this. I remember there were Liberals at the time who voted against the bill because they did not feel it went far enough. Here we are, once again, with an expansion of MAID in this country. There seems to be no concern or upper limit to the Liberals' desire for Canadians to have the right to end their lives.
Now, I would say that in Canada, the deaths of despair, whether they be drug overdose or whatever they are, continue to increase. We hear constantly, story after story, from family members of somebody who was offered MAID when they did not want it or took MAID when their family was unaware that they were even ill, and there is no recourse. There is no ability for the family to question what went on. They have no ability to get any information about it because the patient is dead, the patient is gone, and there was a discussion between the doctor and the patient.
Now the government wants to expand MAID once again, with advance directives. I would point out that advance directives have been a part of the discussion all the way through, and since 2015-16, they have been rejected all the way through. They have not been studied in depth the same way that MAID for mental illness has, and I would suggest that Canadians have firmly rejected MAID for mental illness.
The government has been supremely cynical by doing the thing that Canadians wanted it to do, by repealing MAID for mental illness, but putting advance directives for MAID in the same bill, pairing one off against the other. That is supremely cynical on behalf of the government. The Liberals had their opportunity to vote for Bill C-218, and they rejected it. I thought they just wanted to take credit for it, and they can take credit for it now that they are bringing the bill forward.
The piece around advance directives is about contemporaneous consent. I remember moving motions and amendments to the original bill, trying to emphasize contemporaneous consent. The California model requires that in the moment that MAID is being administered, a nod must be given or the patient must press the button, essentially.
Back in 2017, I felt the original MAID bill, I think it was Bill C-14 at the time, did not do enough to ensure contemporaneous consent, and here we are with advance directives being so far away from contemporaneous consent, because an advance directive could be signed decades before the situation ever arises. Maybe nobody has had a conversation for years about what advance directives even mean, but suddenly a number of different motivations have come into play. Suddenly, a bunch of people who are not the individual would be making a decision about whether this person should be euthanized or not, with no contemporaneous consent.
We have examples from around the world, such as from the Netherlands, where this kind of thing happens. There is a particularly horrific story about a Dutch lady who had dementia. She was physically very healthy. She was not in pain in any way whatsoever. She was happy and she ate well. She was living in an extended care facility, and her advance directive said that when she could no longer recognize her children, she would like MAID. That was what her advance directive said. She still had her faculties and could still participate in conversation. She knew what was happening day by day, but she did not recognize her children most of the time. That is 100% the truth.
On the day that she was going to be euthanized, she knew she was going to be euthanized, and she pleaded with everybody she came into contact with that day, telling them that she did not want to die. However, because there was an advance directive, her coffee was drugged and she was compelled. The horrific part about it and why it ended up being in the news is that her family had come and gathered around her, and they had to restrain her because the drugs from her coffee wore off. They had to restrain her while they euthanized her. That was a horrific experience for all involved, but it was what the advance directive said.
Despite the fact that she repeatedly said to multiple people that day that she did not want to die, she was euthanized. She was euthanized because her advance directive said that when she could no longer recognize her children, she did not want to live anymore. She was perfectly healthy. There was nothing physically wrong with her. She was eating well and she had joy in her life, but she could not recognize her children any longer.
That is not the case for every dementia patient. Some dementia patients live with a lot of angst, and we need to work to minimize the effects of dementia. Dementia is a horrific disease that I know about. I have experience with family members who had it, and it is a horrific disease. It is tragic to watch a loved one decline in that respect, but offering them MAID or having to compel somebody else to murder them is no solution to the problem.
Garnett Genuis (CPC)12:20 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, tonight, I am addressing the House on Bill C-41, the latest attempt to further expand the cases in which a doctor or nurse practitioner is legally permitted to end the life of their patient, a practice which is generally, if euphemistically, called MAID in Canada.
The bill proposes to allow the use of so-called advance directives for MAID. Bill C-41 would allow a patient to sign an advance directive permitting a doctor or nurse practitioner to kill them under certain future circumstances, perhaps years or decades in the future. Necessarily, other people would have to assess and determine whether the conditions in the signed document had been met. The patient would have delegated the power over life and death for themselves to another person. Bill C-41 would eliminate the legal requirement that a person consent to their death when they are dying. It would replace the requirement for contemporaneous consent with advance consent.
Of course, advance consent is inevitably less clear in practice than contemporaneous consent. In the signing of an advance directive, a person would be making a prediction about how they think they would feel under certain future circumstances that they likely have not experienced before. They would be making a prediction about how their future self would feel and what their future self would want. They would be judging the situation from the outside without lived experience.
In practice, people would likely be presented with pro forma advance directives based on a common template and told that typically people in such a situation sign something like this or want something like that, etc. We already know these kinds of proposals to people who are not asking for them are occurring. Perhaps these pro forma advance directives would be given to people right after a new diagnosis is given, when a person is understandably scared about the unknown and about what they would feel under new circumstances, and they would trust authority figures and sign these pro forma documents.
This would then provide those same authority figures with options, but certainly not clarity. They would later look at a patient and compare that pro forma directive with their assessment of the patient's current condition. Do they seem happy, content? Is their life worth living? How does what they wrote or signed on the page compare to what we guess might be going on in their head today?
Certainly in so many cases there would be a variety of different interpretations. Perhaps the burnt-out spouse and caregiver would think the conditions of the advance directive are met, while the adult children would think otherwise. Importantly, the law as written would not require the patient to be asked or informed again once they have written the advance directive. One day the clinician changes the substance of what is in the patient's IV, and the patient dies. “It was her wishes,” says the doctor. “No, it wasn't”, say the grandchildren, but at the end of the day, she is dead, because someone killed her based on their interpretation of a piece of paper that she signed years ago. Welcome to Canada.
Maybe grandmother was a bit of a people pleaser. Maybe she talked about her illness in slightly different ways to different people, depending on what she thought they wanted to hear. This is very normal, of course. All of us are people pleasers to some extent, but Bill C-41 would require other people to interpret her feelings, her sufferings and her wishes, and to turn them into their own judgments about whether she should be killed, again with no obligation to talk to her about it once the initial paper had been signed.
Families would inevitably be deeply divided over who decided to kill Grandma and whether the conditions of the signed document were met. Confusion is inevitable. The ambiguities are legion, involved in assessing someone else's suffering based on a directive made long ago by a person who at the time had no experience of the illness. This means in practice that someone else would decide when and whether someone dies, and they will not ask before they kill them.
Underneath these practical problems is a deeper moral question about advance directives. Can I bind my future self in matters as weighty as life and death? Can I make a choice that would permit someone to kill my future self, especially when that self may not remember or be conscious of the previous decision?
When we allow advance requests today, it is purely in the case of a negative, a person signing an order to not have something done to them. Signing an advance request to not have something done to me is very different from a directive that licenses someone to do something to me when I am not aware of what is happening and under nebulous, difficult-to-define circumstances.
Not only do we not allow this type of definitive advance determination, generally speaking, but we have done painstaking work to correct a grave moral error of the past in this regard, the idea that consent, once given, is given forever.
The most obvious context in which this applies is sexual consent. Recognizing the need for contemporaneous consent in every sexual encounter was a real and important moral development. Previous but clearly flawed legal doctrines of the past regarded consent to marriage as furnishing a definitive future consent to sexual relations, and thus did not prosecute the offence of marital rape. It was a critically important and clearly positive moral development to recognize the importance of contemporaneous consent in every sexual encounter, that receiving consent in the moment is necessary, regardless of a past commitment.
Everyone in the House agrees, I am sure, that marital rape should be prosecuted. It is hard for me to understand, then, why some members would regard advance consent in matters of death as permissible, while rejecting it in matters of sexuality. Introducing the idea of violating a person's autonomy on the basis of a piece of paper signed in the past would seem to be a step in undoing the moral progress that has been made in this regard.
A person also cannot consent to slavery. Some, though certainly not all, systems of slavery are based on the idea that a person can sell themselves, an act through which the present self binds the future self. Today we would understand such systems as grossly immoral and as representing a denial of human dignity and of autonomy, yet death is more final than slavery. If the past self cannot bind the future self in the case of slavery, then why would it be so in the case of death? What began in the name of autonomy has lost the plot by now denying the autonomy of the present self to adapt to new circumstances and to make new choices.
The practical and philosophical problems inherent in the operationalization of advance directives for MAID likely informed the decision of members of the Conservative Party of Canada to explicitly adopt a position opposing advance directives for MAID. I am proud to be part of a party that officially opposes this expansion in its member-driven policy document.
These problems have led virtually every other country in the world to also reject going down this road. Most notably, I think the problems with such advance requests also informed the decision of the Justin Trudeau Liberal government to reject calls to implement a system of advance requests for MAID. In each past stage, there were those who argued for advance directives, yet the Trudeau Liberal government evidently decided, based on the moral and/or practical risks associated with them, that it was not going to go down this road.
However, now we have the new Prime Minister, who is hell-bent on pushing Canada's MAID regime further than Justin Trudeau by pursuing an expansion that even Justin Trudeau rejected. As a fellow Catholic, while not expecting that a shared religious identity would lead us to agree on every issue, I did expect better from the Prime Minister. I expected that he would at least have some sensitivity to the idea of universal human dignity, the need to prevent the devaluing of the lives of people with disabilities and the need to avoid further MAID expansion. It is difficult for me to reconcile his stated convictions with his decision to advance legislation that would allow a patient to be killed in their bed without even being asked for contemporaneous consent.
Canada already has the most radical MAID regime in the world, and the Prime Minister, the Catholic Prime Minister, is now wilfully presiding over the further expansion of a MAID system that is already the most radical in the world. It is frankly hard to tell what the Prime Minister believes at all, even if his frequent reversals of conviction have brought him some measure of political success thus far.
All of these events call to mind the alleged remark of Pope Urban VIII following the death of Cardinal Richelieu. He quipped, “If there is a God, the Cardinal de Richelieu will have much to answer for. If not...well, he had a successful life.” This is worth contrasting with the observation of St. Teresa of Calcutta, who said that we are not called to be successful, but faithful. The point is one of general application, regardless of fundamental beliefs or philosophical commitments; that is, to be a statesman is to stand for something.
Our calling as members of Parliament is to faithfully defend the national interest of Canada and the common good, to defend it from the shame that it already faces as a global pariah and embarrassment when it comes to the fundamental rights of people with disabilities. On that basis, I will fiercely oppose this expansion, as it would turn my country into a place where patients are killed without even being asked, based on a document that they signed years ago.
As a brief final coda, I note that Bill C-41 contains provisions around limiting the application of MAID in the cases of mental health. These provisions on mental health are supported by over 90% of MPs and could easily be proposed separately and adopted rapidly. That debate has thankfully already been won, but it is the height of cynicism for the government to tie those provisions to its radical new expansion of MAID.
We must defeat this bad, cynical bill. Of course, I agree with the mental health provisions in the bill, but those could easily be passed in a separate bill in 48 hours. No one should fall for this devious legislative trick. That is why we must oppose the expansion in Bill C-41.
John Barlow (CPC)12:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I am somewhat displeased to have to rise to speak to Bill C-41, as I have risen in the House on a number of occasions since 2017, when the Liberals brought forward the initial MAID bill. I want to go back to that initial MAID bill to show why I am raising some concerns with where we are today.
I held a number of town halls throughout my riding of Foothills when the initial MAID legislation was brought forward. In fact, I brought some of my colleagues who were participants in the MAID committee established by the government to study the initial MAID legislation, because I wanted some experts at the town halls in my riding to discuss the possible implications of this legislation and what it actually meant.
I will say that of all the town halls I have held in my riding over my 11-plus years as a member of Parliament, there was never the kind of attendance and engagement from my constituents as there was on the medical assistance and dying proposal. Hundreds of people attended every town hall of the several I held throughout my riding, and I have to admit that it was very split. Constituents were on both sides of this issue. Many were unclear on what it would mean.
When the time came to stand up in the House and vote on that legislation, I voted against it. The main reason I voted against it is that there was no assurance or confidence from what I heard from the various speeches in the House. I even sat in on the MAID committee on a number of occasions just to learn more about what the implications of this legislation would be. In listening to those experts, to the testimony at the MAID committee and certainly to my constituents, I can say that two things really stood out for me.
As I said, there was no confidence that the safeguards being proposed in that legislation would be adhered to. As my colleague before me mentioned, someone would have had to have two doctors sign off before MAID was implemented and anyone requesting MAID would have had to have a mental health assessment. MAID was only supposed to be available for those with a terminal, incurable disease with a foreseeable end. We have certainly seen over the years that that has not been the case. MAID has grown and expanded well beyond that despite the safeguards that were allegedly in place.
The second thing that stood out for me, especially after participating in the MAID committee several years ago, was the real push, especially from members of the Senate at that time, to expand MAID well beyond those with just a terminal illness. There were discussions about having it for people with mental illness, people with disabilities and even minors at that time. I have to admit that I was stunned by how far some members of that committee wanted to push this legislation.
As a decision of conscience, I voted against MAID at the time. I feel that my vote has been justified with how far MAID has expanded in Canada. We are now seeing exponential growth. In fact, we are leading the world on the issue, which I do not think is something we should be proud of. We have seen what I was concerned about, what I was worried about: MAID being expanded to those with mental health issues and those with disabilities.
One story really stands out, which I want to raise in my speech tonight. I remember a call I received from a constituent who was an army veteran, a peacekeeper, with the Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry in Calgary and who lived in Okotoks. He called me to say that he was a counsellor for other veterans with PTSD. He certainly suffered from PTSD. Mark Meincke was his name. He said he needed to let me know that he was getting calls from veterans who, when they were making calls to Veterans Affairs Canada and talking to their caseworkers, were being offered MAID.
I found this claim to be quite astonishing. A veteran, someone who has put their life on the line for the service of our country, when they were reaching out to their caseworker at Veterans Affairs Canada, asking for access to mental health services, to counselling or even to check the status of their disability claim, was being offered MAID instead of being offered mental health services. In fact, we found these claims to be quite true. He brought us recordings of phone calls with Veterans Affairs and a number of cases of calls he had had with other veterans, and it was astonishing.
In fact, we asked Mr. Meincke to come to the veterans affairs committee to lay out his story, and the testimony that he gave at that committee was astonishing. I want to give a couple of quotes that Mr. Meincke raised at that time. As I said, he served in Croatia. He witnessed some of the most devastating horrors that one would ever want to see.
He said he was devastated by the phone call from Veterans Affairs, saying, “It's called ‘sanctuary trauma’, where the place you go for help steps on your neck. That's what happened here.” He said the comment from the case worker at Veterans Affairs was that, if they have any suicidal thoughts down the road, MAID was an option, that “it's better than blowing your brains out against the wall.” These were the pieces of advice that our veterans were getting from Veterans Affairs.
Our fear right from the beginning was that MAID would be expanded far beyond what it is or what it was intended to be. This is our concern.
The Liberals are talking out of both sides of their mouth on this piece of legislation. On one hand, they are saying that they are going to delay the decision to offer MAID to people with mental illness as the sole underlying factor, which we completely support. However, at the same time, they are offering advance directives, which requires much further study because the history of the Liberals getting this right is one of failure.
Conservatives are united on splitting this bill. We would fast-track the portion about mental health as quickly as possible to ensure those with mental health concerns are protected, but the underlying factor of advance directives deserves much further scrutiny and debate. Canadians deserve this. I do not want the Liberals to play politics on this. This is a matter of life and death, which has clearly been shown with our veterans, and that is not right. Let the Liberals do the right thing and split the bill so Canadians can have their say.