Counties urged to expand historic preservation

Summary#

HCR-177 is a House Concurrent Resolution, not a bill that changes state law. It urges Hawaiʻi’s counties to establish, strengthen, or expand historic-preservation work in county government; its stated goal is to complement state efforts and help protect historic and cultural resources. It is introduced and has been referred to a House committee, so it has not been adopted.

  • Counties are urged—not required—to create or expand preservation functions.
  • Those functions may include county offices, commissions, advisory boards, or designated staff.
  • Counties are encouraged to develop local policies, inventories, and procedures to identify, evaluate, and protect resources, consistent with state and federal preservation laws.
  • The resolution describes the State Historic Preservation Division as responsible for work including maintaining the state register, reviewing projects, and coordinating compliance with preservation laws. HCR-177 does not change that division’s duties.

What it means for you#

  • County governments: The resolution asks them to consider adding or expanding preservation capacity. It does not require them to do so or set a deadline.
  • Residents, property owners, and developers: The resolution itself does not change permits, land-use rules, property rights, or project-review requirements.
  • State preservation staff: The resolution does not change their authority, staffing, or review process.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The resolution does not provide funding or estimate costs.
  • If a county chooses to add offices, staff, or other functions, that could require county resources; the resolution gives no cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • Which counties already have preservation functions, and what they would add or change.
  • What resources counties would use to carry out the proposed work.
  • What authority or procedures any county office, commission, board, or staff would have.
  • How county reviews would relate to state or federal reviews, beyond the call for consistency with applicable laws.
  • The resolution does not define “historic and cultural resources” or set timelines, reporting duties, or measures of success.

Case for#

  • The resolution appears intended to add local capacity to identify and consider historic and cultural resources during county planning and permitting.
  • County-level work could complement the State Historic Preservation Division’s statewide responsibilities.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that local policies and resource inventories could help counties recognize important places earlier in their own processes.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not require counties to act, so it may not lead to any new preservation work.
  • It does not specify funding, staffing, powers, or procedures, leaving the proposed functions’ scope and cost uncertain.
  • County-level reviews could overlap with state work; the resolution does not explain how that would be avoided or coordinated.