Due-process protections expand for child registry

Summary#

House Bill 954 would amend Idaho law by adding procedures for the Idaho Child Protection Central Registry; it does not create a new agency. Its stated goal is to protect the due-process rights of people listed in the registry. The bill is introduced and is not law; if enacted, it would take effect July 1, 2026.

  • Before the Department of Health and Welfare could list someone, the bill would require notice, a hearing, and clear and convincing evidence (a high standard of proof). It also says information may not be included without a criminal charge.
  • The department would have to request a hearing within 30 days of a court finding allegations substantiated. A hearing must be scheduled within 45 days of that request.
  • Before listing someone, the department would have to provide the full case to the child protection legislative oversight committee and the local citizen review panel for review.
  • The bill would limit most listings to 10 years or until the alleged victim turns 18, whichever comes first. People with a “level one designation” are excepted from that limit.
  • People listed could request expungement (removal of their name from the registry) at no cost. The bill also provides for $2,083 per month if the department keeps an unsubstantiated record or keeps a substantiated record past the stated time limit.

What it means for you#

  • People the department seeks to list: You would be entitled to notice, a hearing, access to the investigative file at no cost, and specified hearing rights, including counsel, presenting evidence, and questioning department witnesses. The department generally could not list you or release information to third parties until appeals were exhausted or waived and you had received written notice.
  • People already listed: You could request expungement under the bill, with no waiting period. Existing listings would not automatically be removed.
  • Children and families in a child welfare case: The oversight committee and local citizen review panel would receive the entire case file before a listing. The bill does not specify limits on their use or disclosure of that file.
  • Department staff and hearing officials: The department would have new notice, hearing, file-sharing, and removal duties. The Office of Administrative Hearings would schedule and conduct hearings and respond to expungement requests.
  • People seeking work, licences, or volunteer roles involving children: The bill would delay registry disclosures to third parties until the stated conditions are met. The bill does not otherwise change employment, licensing, or volunteer rules.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill requires department work, administrative hearings, case-file reviews, and certified-mail notices, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • People requesting a hearing or expungement would not pay for the procedures specified in the bill.
  • The bill provides for $2,083 per month for certain records kept too long, but does not say who would pay or how a claim would be made.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current Idaho Code or regulations. The bill’s intent section describes existing registry procedures, but the exact changes from current law cannot be verified.
  • The bill says a criminal charge is required for inclusion, and also ties notice and hearing deadlines to a court ruling that allegations were substantiated. It does not explain how those requirements fit together, or whether a charge must lead to a conviction.
  • “Level one designation” is not defined, and the bill does not set a time limit for those listings.
  • The bill does not explain what “written notice” must have been received before third-party disclosure, or how the department must determine that appeals are exhausted or waived.
  • The bill does not set out rules for protecting the full case files shared with review bodies, or explain how their reports would affect the listing decision.
  • The bill does not specify who pays the monthly amount for an overdue record or how the amount would be collected.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to reduce the risk that a person is placed on a registry, with effects on work and reputation, without a chance to challenge the evidence.
  • Requiring clear and convincing evidence, access to the investigative file, and a written decision could make listing decisions more careful and reviewable.
  • Notice of the allegations and possible consequences could help a person understand and respond to the case.
  • Time limits and expungement procedures could prevent some people from remaining listed after the stated period or when there is good cause for removal.

Case against#

  • Requiring a criminal charge, a court finding, and an administrative hearing may create a complicated process; the bill does not clearly explain how these steps fit together.
  • Requiring full case files to go to two review bodies could expose sensitive information about children and families. The bill does not spell out safeguards for that information.
  • The bill gives no cost estimate, while adding hearing, review, notice, and file-sharing duties for public bodies.
  • The undefined “level one designation” is exempt from the stated time limits, so the bill does not make clear how long those listings could remain.
  • The monthly payment rule and staff consequences may be difficult to apply because the bill does not explain who pays, how payment is determined, or how the referenced existing laws apply.