Social workers face new training rules

Summary#

House Bill 956, titled “Relating to Social Workers,” would amend several parts of Idaho law and add new rules for social workers and the Department of Health and Welfare. Its stated goal is to establish provisions regarding social workers; that is a purpose, not a guaranteed result. The bill is introduced and is not law; the supplied material does not include the current versions of the laws it would amend, so the exact changes to existing rules cannot all be verified.

  • The Department of Health and Welfare would have to make reasonable efforts during an abandonment investigation to ask why a child was abandoned and where the parent or guardian was. Department staff and agents, including social workers, could not say or imply that abandonment would bring no penalties or other adverse outcomes.
  • Licensed social workers would have to complete specified autism and introversion training, and the department’s director would have to attend the annual Child Welfare League of America conference.
  • The bill would make specified conduct violations of the social-work code of professional conduct, including directing a judge how to rule and making false or misleading statements to parents about their legal rights or duties.
  • In child-protection work, licensed social workers would have to include only factual findings supported by clear and convincing evidence in reports. They would also have to follow applicable rules and the law.
  • The Department of Health and Welfare would have to require a job-related psychological suitability evaluation after making a conditional job offer to a licensed social worker. The bill sets limits on the evaluation and how its records are shared.
  • A licensed social worker who violates the new reporting rule could face board discipline, loss of employment, or other action. A parent or guardian aggrieved by a violation of the new duties and limits would have a cause of action against the person alleged to have violated them.

What it means for you#

  • Social workers: The bill sets training and reporting requirements. It also says a social worker who does not follow a supervisor’s decision in a child-protection case, or makes a contrary decision, is immediately subject to termination—unless the supervisor’s decision violates a law, rule, or legal right.
  • Social workers applying to the department: After a conditional job offer, you would have to undergo an evaluation by an independent licensed psychologist or psychiatrist. The department could receive a suitability opinion and its job-related reasons, but not diagnostic labels, raw test data, or detailed clinical findings. A mental-health diagnosis or treatment history alone could not be used to exclude you.
  • Parents and guardians: During an abandonment investigation, the department would have to make reasonable efforts to ask about the circumstances. The bill does not change the stated rights to refuse questions, entry, or questioning of children; it adds the abandonment-related rules described above.
  • People involved in child-protection cases: Social workers could not speak negatively to or about parents, guardians, children, or anyone else involved in a case. The bill does not define “negatively.”
  • Taxpayers: The bill requires department staff time and a conference attendance, but does not state how those requirements would be funded.

Money#

No publicly available information gives an estimate of the bill’s cost.

  • The bill requires training for licensed social workers, conference attendance by the department’s director, and psychological evaluations for applicants who receive conditional offers.
  • It does not say who pays for the evaluations or training, or how many evaluations may be needed.
  • It declares an emergency and sets July 1, 2026, as its effective date.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the amended Idaho Code sections were not supplied, so the exact difference from current law—including which code-of-conduct rules already exist—cannot be confirmed.
  • “Biannually” is not defined; it could mean twice a year or once every two years.
  • The bill does not set a process for challenging an evaluation result, or say how the department should act on a “not suitable” opinion.
  • It does not explain how the new cause of action would work, or specify remedies.
  • “Speak negatively” and “factual findings supported by clear and convincing evidence” are not defined in the bill.

Case for#

  • The training requirements could help social workers recognize autism and introversion, and the bill expressly says a person may not be removed from a parent’s custody based solely on either.
  • Job-related evaluations with limits on what the department receives could help assess suitability while protecting private clinical information.
  • Requiring reports to follow rules and be based on a demanding evidence standard could be seen as a safeguard against unsupported findings in child-protection cases.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define “speak negatively,” which could make it hard to know what conduct is prohibited.
  • Requiring “clear and convincing evidence” for factual findings in reports could make reporting difficult; the bill does not explain how this standard applies in practice.
  • Immediate termination for going against a supervisor’s decision may put pressure on social workers to follow that decision, even though the bill provides an exception when it would violate law, rules, or legal rights.
  • The bill requires evaluations and training but leaves their cost, administration, and review process unsettled.