Pelicans: memorial urges federal action

Summary#

HJM-22 is an Idaho joint memorial, not a bill that changes an existing law. It records the Legislature’s findings and urges the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to reduce the number of pelicans in Idaho, or allow that reduction, and the federal government to compensate Idaho for resource losses. Its stated goal is to address what the Legislature describes as pelican overpopulation and its effects on fish and fishing.

  • The memorial supports and urges federal action; it does not itself authorize anyone to capture or kill pelicans.
  • It asks the federal government to compensate Idaho, but does not require payment or set an amount.
  • It directs the Idaho House Chief Clerk to send the memorial to named federal officials and agencies.
  • The memorial says pelicans are protected under the federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act and cannot be taken without prior federal authorization. It does not change those protections.

What it means for you#

  • Idaho residents and fishers: The memorial does not directly change your rights, fishing rules, or access to fishing areas.
  • U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and federal government: They receive the Legislature’s request. The memorial does not require them to reduce pelican numbers or pay Idaho.
  • Idaho House Chief Clerk: The clerk is directed to send copies to the listed federal officials and agencies.

Money#

No cost estimate or payment amount is provided.

  • The memorial requests federal compensation for Idaho but does not appropriate money or create a payment requirement.
  • It does not state a cost for sending the memorial.

What is unclear#

  • What methods, locations, or limits the Legislature has in mind for reducing pelican numbers.
  • Whether federal officials will act on the request or compensate Idaho.
  • How any compensation would be calculated or paid.
  • The memorial presents claims about fish consumption, tagged fish, and effects on ecosystems, but the supplied material does not include evidence to assess those claims independently.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the memorial is that the Legislature believes pelicans are harming fish populations and fishing opportunities, and that federal action is needed because the birds are federally protected.
  • The memorial cites fish-tag data and the economic importance of fishing as reasons to ask for action and compensation.
  • Asking the federal agency to act, or allow action, puts the decision with the federal authority the memorial says controls permission to take protected birds.

Case against#

  • The memorial does not set criteria for deciding whether, where, or how many pelicans should be removed.
  • It gives no plan for measuring effects on fish, pelicans, or wetland ecosystems.
  • Its claims about harm and overpopulation are not independently supported by evidence in the supplied material.
  • The request for compensation does not explain what losses qualify or how they would be measured.