House would lock doors during calls

Summary#

HR-29 is an Idaho House resolution proposing to amend Rule 18, an internal rule of the House of Representatives. It aims to keep members present during a “call of the House” (a procedure for requiring members to attend). The resolution has been introduced but is not yet in effect.

  • During a call, the Sergeant at Arms would close and lock doors to the east wing of the Capitol’s third floor. Rule 18 also says members may not leave the Chamber.
  • Members would have to remain at their floor desks while the House is under call, unless the presiding officer puts the House at ease.
  • Under the rule’s text, the House may take up regular business under a call after the Sergeant at Arms reports that all members absent without leave are present, and a majority of the entire House votes to proceed.
  • The rule also provides for the Sergeant at Arms to bring in absent members. Arresting a member would require an order supported by a majority of members present.

What it means for you#

  • House members: If the resolution is adopted, members would face the stated door-locking and floor-desk requirements during a call of the House.
  • Sergeant at Arms: The rule assigns this officer the tasks of locking the specified doors and bringing in absent members.
  • Other people in the Capitol and the public: The text does not say whether or how the door change would affect their access.
  • People outside the House: The resolution changes an internal House rule; it does not directly change public services, taxes, or individual rights outside the House.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The text assigns duties to the Sergeant at Arms but gives no cost, staffing, or funding estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text does not clearly mark which words in Rule 18 would change. The title identifies the door-locking and floor-desk changes, but the exact edits are difficult to verify against the current rule.
  • The text does not say when the doors would be unlocked or set out an exception for emergencies.
  • It is unclear how the locked doors would affect access by people other than House members.
  • The resolution is introduced, not adopted; whether it will take effect is not yet known.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the change is that keeping members in the Chamber and at their desks could help the House complete a call and resume business with members present.
  • Locking the specified doors could support the rule’s requirement that members not leave the Chamber during a call.

Case against#

  • The text requires doors to be locked and says members may not leave the Chamber, but does not explain how emergencies or other urgent needs would be handled.
  • The resolution does not explain how access for other people in the Capitol would be affected.
  • Because the supplied text does not clearly show every edit, readers cannot confirm exactly which parts of the existing rule would change.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1669273

    Defeated70 members voted

    House Third Reading

    AGAINST · 16FOR · 54

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    16Against

    • Republican16

    54For

    • Republican45
    • Democratic9