Canvassers would disclose payer and wear badges

Summary#

S-1449 would amend Idaho’s election and campaign-finance laws and add a new section on paid, in-person political canvassing. Its stated goal is to require disclosures from paid canvassers and revise rules for petition circulators. The bill is introduced and is not law; if enacted, its emergency clause says it would take effect upon passage and approval.

  • Under the bill’s text, petition circulators must be Idaho residents and at least 18. Paid petition circulators must tell each potential signer who is paying them, put a payment disclosure and payer’s name on each petition page, and wear a visible badge saying “paid petition circulator.”
  • A paid petition circulator’s sworn statement for each sheet must say that signers were told the circulator would be paid. It must also name the payer and give the payer’s address.
  • Paid in-person canvassers must be Idaho residents, tell people they contact that they are paid and name who pays them, and wear a visible badge saying “paid political advocate” with the payer’s name.
  • A petition circulated in violation of the petition-disclosure rules would be void. The bill also makes violations subject to civil fines and, if done knowingly and willfully, misdemeanor penalties.
  • The Secretary of State must make rules about the petition-page disclosure and “paid petition circulator” badge. The Secretary may make rules about the broader “paid political advocate” badge.

The current versions of the amended laws were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which petition-circulator rules already exist and which this bill would newly change.

What it means for you#

  • People approached by canvassers: You would be told when a canvasser is paid and who pays them. The bill does not require you to sign a petition or follow the canvasser’s request.
  • Paid petition circulators: You would have to meet the residency and age requirements and follow the petition-specific disclosure, badge and sworn-statement rules. Because petition circulation is also covered by the broader canvassing section, the text appears to require both a “paid petition circulator” badge and a “paid political advocate” badge naming the payer. How those requirements fit together is unclear.
  • Other paid canvassers and their payers: The disclosure rules cover in-person contact intended to affect voting or electoral participation, including talking with people at homes or public places and distributing materials. The bill exempts volunteers with only incidental expense reimbursement, phone banking, candidates canvassing for their own campaigns, and people whose canvassing is incidental to broader campaign employment.
  • Petition signers: If the petition is circulated in violation of the petition-disclosure rules, the petition—not just an individual signature—would be void.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill provides for civil fines of up to $250 for an individual and $2,500 for a non-individual. A knowing and willful violation may also be a misdemeanor, punishable by up to six months in jail, in addition to the fine.
  • No estimate is provided for government costs, staffing, or the cost of making the required rules.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define terms such as “incidental” to broader campaign employment or “incidental expenses.”
  • It does not explain how the two badge requirements would work for paid petition circulators, or how the petition-specific rules interact with the broader section’s exemptions.
  • The bill gives no deadline for the Secretary of State’s rules or details about how alleged violations would be investigated.
  • The current law text was not supplied, so the extent of the changes to existing petition-circulator rules cannot be verified.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that people approached about elections would know when a canvasser is paid and who is paying them.
  • Requiring the payer’s name on petition pages and on the broader canvasser badge could make payment arrangements more visible.
  • The petition rules would make the disclosure part of the sworn statement for each sheet, and the bill sets consequences for violating the disclosure requirements.

Case against#

  • The bill covers a wide range of paid, in-person election contact, not just petition gathering. Its residency and disclosure rules could limit who can do that work.
  • A petition could be void because of a disclosure violation, which may affect signers as well as the paid circulator.
  • The terms defining exemptions are not clear, and the text appears to impose two different badge requirements on paid petition circulators.
  • Civil fines and possible jail time for knowing and willful violations may be significant consequences, while the bill does not set out investigation or decision procedures.