Rule Review Bill Approves Most Agency Rules

Summary#

SCR-128 is an Idaho concurrent resolution that approves temporary and pending state agency rules submitted for review during the 2026 session, with exceptions. It uses the existing rule-review process described in the resolution; it does not create a new agency or program. Its stated purpose is to review whether rules are consistent with legislative intent.

  • The resolution approves all submitted rules except the listed rules or parts of rules. It declares the exceptions null and void when the Legislature adjourns sine die (ends the session).
  • Exceptions include: Agriculture seed rules, section 112’s new subsections .01–.05; Fish and Game licensing rules, sections 700.02 and 800.02, and big-game rules, section 410.04.g and .h; the entire Idaho Public Safety Communications Commission docket; the entire daycare licensing and Idaho Child Care Program dockets; drinking-water and wastewater professional rules, section 400; the entire occupational therapist, physical therapy, building safety, and Sexual Offender Management Board dockets; the entire temporary public works contractors docket; Parks and Recreation rules, sections 075 and 250; the entire stream channel alteration docket; license plate rules, section 012.03; groundwater rules, section 003 and section 200.01.a; and administrative procedure rules, sections 011, 012, and 515.
  • Most approved pending rules take effect July 1, 2026. Four approved pending dockets take effect at adjournment sine die: short-term health insurance rules; the pending public works contractors rules; a separate Sexual Offender Management Board docket; and public drinking water system rules.

What it means for you#

  • People and businesses covered by state agency rules: The resolution approves the submitted rules unless they are among the exceptions. The resolution does not include the rules’ full text, so their specific requirements cannot be described here.
  • People affected by an exception: The listed rules or rule parts are declared null and void at adjournment sine die. The resolution does not say what rules, if any, will apply in their place.
  • People using or working in daycare and child care programs: The resolution rejects the entire two listed Department of Health and Welfare dockets, at the department’s request.
  • Taxpayers: The resolution itself does not create a tax, fee, benefit, or new agency.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution does not state an appropriation, staffing cost, fee, or expected saving.
  • The underlying rules could have costs or financial effects, but their text is not included here.

What is unclear#

  • What most of the approved rules require, and what practical effects the rejected provisions would have had.
  • Why the Legislature found the listed rules or parts inconsistent with legislative intent; the resolution gives no reasons for each exception.
  • What rules or requirements will apply after rejected rules take effect as null and void.
  • The resolution cites an existing Idaho Code rule-review process, but the Code text was not supplied, so its account of current law could not be independently checked.

Case for#

  • The resolution gives the Legislature a way to approve rules while rejecting specific rules or parts it finds inconsistent with legislative intent.
  • Approving most submitted rules, while setting out exceptions, could be seen as allowing state agencies’ rules to take effect while preserving legislative oversight.
  • The resolution sets effective dates for approved pending rules, including four dockets that take effect at adjournment rather than July 1.

Case against#

  • The resolution approves a broad set of rules, but its text does not show what those rules require; readers therefore cannot assess their effects from this resolution alone.
  • It does not explain why the rejected provisions conflict with legislative intent or what will replace them.
  • Rejecting rule provisions may leave uncertainty for people and organizations subject to those rules, particularly where the resolution does not state what applies instead.