Student heart screenings expand in schools

Summary#

HB-5809, the Student Cardiac Safety Act, is an introduced bill that would create a new Illinois law. It would require heart-related screening for student athletes beginning in the 2027–2028 school year, then for all K–12 students at annual well-child visits beginning in 2028–2029. Its goal appears to be identifying possible heart disease and informing families about conditions that can cause cardiac arrest or heart failure.

  • A qualified health care professional would have to include a cardiovascular prescreening in a student athlete’s physical exam. The exam must be no earlier than three months before the student’s athletic season.
  • A student athlete with a positive finding must be referred to a cardiologist for further evaluation and testing.
  • Beginning in 2028–2029, a qualified health care professional would have to include the prescreening at the annual well-child visit of each patient who is a K–12 student.
  • The Department of Public Health must publish annual screening and referral data. It also must provide training and continuing education for health care professionals.
  • The State Board of Education and Department of Public Health must distribute educational materials; school districts must annually send them to parents or guardians of student athletes with athletic permission forms.

What it means for you#

  • Student athletes and families: The required screening would ask about personal and family history and include a focused physical exam. A positive finding must lead to referral to a cardiologist, but the bill does not say who pays for the evaluation or testing.
  • Other K–12 students and families: Starting in 2028–2029, the screening would be part of the student’s annual well-child visit. The bill does not create a separate screening appointment or say that every student must have a well-child visit.
  • Health care professionals: They would have to perform the required screening for the covered exams and visits, and the Department must provide education on risk assessment, physical findings, and referrals. The bill does not define “qualified health care professional.”
  • School districts: They would have to send the educational materials to parents or guardians of student athletes each year. The bill does not require schools to conduct the medical screenings.
  • Current law: No current-law text was supplied, so existing Illinois screening requirements and how they would change could not be verified. The bill is introduced and is not yet law.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires state agencies to provide materials, training, rules, and annual reporting, but gives no cost estimate or staffing numbers.
  • School districts must distribute materials. The bill gives no estimate of district costs.
  • The bill’s heading says reimbursement under the State Mandates Act may apply. The materials do not explain whether reimbursement would be required or how much it might be.
  • The bill sets no screening fee and does not say whether insurance or families would pay for cardiology visits or testing.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “qualified health care professional” or explain what counts as a positive finding.
  • It does not set out consent, referral timelines, follow-up requirements, or how the state would check whether referrals happened. The annual report must include follow-up information and false-positive rates only “if possible.”
  • It does not say who pays for referrals and additional diagnostic testing, or how students without an annual well-child visit are covered.
  • It assigns the Department of Public Health to adopt rules for most of the Act, but assigns the State Board of Education, in consultation with the Department, to adopt rules for the professional-education section. How those rulemaking roles fit with the Department’s duty to implement training is unclear.
  • The bill’s text does not include a start date for the Act as a whole, though it names school years when screening and distribution duties begin.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that asking about symptoms and family history, along with a focused exam, could help identify warning signs before a student participates in sports.
  • Requiring referrals after positive findings creates a clear next step rather than leaving the response to the screening unspecified.
  • Training for health care professionals and evidence-based educational materials could support more consistent screening and better information for families.
  • Annual reporting could show how often screenings and referrals occur and, where data are available, what follow-up finds.

Case against#

  • The bill requires referrals after positive findings but does not establish who pays for specialist visits and tests, or how students would get care if access is limited.
  • The bill does not define key terms or set out consent, timelines, or required follow-up, leaving important parts of the process to rules or practice.
  • Screening and referral duties, state training and reporting, and school distribution duties may require resources, but no cost estimate or funding plan is provided.
  • The state’s ability to assess results may be limited because follow-up and false-positive data are required only if they are available.