Surrogate Status Wouldn't Grant Record Access

Summary#

SB 4226, titled “HEALTH CARE SURROGATE-RECORDS,” would amend Illinois’s Health Care Surrogate Act. It would say that being a health care surrogate, by itself, does not entitle someone to inspect or copy a recipient’s record; access remains possible as authorized under the Mental Health and Developmental Disabilities Confidentiality Act. The supplied material does not state a separate goal for the bill.

  • The new records rule applies to a surrogate decision maker’s access to a recipient’s record, as that term is defined in the Confidentiality Act.
  • The rule does not make all record access impossible: it preserves access authorized by that Act.
  • The text also includes existing rules barring most surrogates from consenting to certain mental health services for an adult, while allowing them to petition for those services. The supplied synopsis identifies the records rule as the change.
  • The bill is introduced and referred to Assignments; it is not law. The supplied text gives no start date.

What it means for you#

  • Surrogate decision makers: You would not gain a right to inspect or copy a recipient’s record just because you serve as the surrogate. The Confidentiality Act may authorize access in some circumstances.
  • People receiving care: The bill would limit access based solely on another person’s role as your surrogate. It does not say that every disclosure to a surrogate is barred.
  • Patients and surrogates dealing with mental health services: The bill text retains rules on consent to specific mental health services, including psychotropic medication, electroconvulsive therapy, or admission to a mental health facility. The supplied material does not establish whether those rules would change from current law.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill states no appropriation, fee, fine, or spending amount.
  • It does not estimate any staffing or record-handling costs.

What is unclear#

  • The current version of the Health Care Surrogate Act was not supplied, so the exact difference from current law could not be checked. The bill’s synopsis identifies the records restriction as the change.
  • The bill does not explain how a surrogate would seek access under the Confidentiality Act or how quickly a request would be handled.
  • It does not explain whether a surrogate could access records on some other legal basis, separate from serving as surrogate.
  • The bill gives no start date, and its passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that serving as a surrogate should not automatically grant access to confidential records. The rule would preserve access that the Confidentiality Act authorizes.
  • The bill places the records restriction in the same section that addresses surrogate decisions about certain mental health services, making the limits on a surrogate’s role clearer in that section.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a surrogate may need records to understand a recipient’s care, but the bill does not explain how the surrogate could request access or what process would apply.
  • It is unclear how the rule would work when a surrogate has another basis for access, or how it would interact with other rules governing record disclosure.