Heisman honor recognized for Mendoza

Summary#

HCR-18, “Recognizing Heisman Trophy winner Fernando Mendoza,” is an Indiana House and Senate concurrent resolution. It formally recognizes Mendoza; it does not amend an existing Act or create a general legal rule, benefit, or program. Its stated purpose is to recognize his football achievements and character.

  • The resolution recognizes Mendoza as the first Indiana University player to win the Heisman Trophy, as stated in its recitals.
  • It directs the House Principal Clerk to send copies to Indiana University athletics director Scott Dolson for distribution.
  • The supplied status lists the resolution as enacted. Its text is a formal recognition, not a new service or enforceable right.

What it means for you#

  • Fernando Mendoza and Indiana University: The General Assembly formally recognizes Mendoza. The resolution does not provide him with money or another legal benefit.
  • House Principal Clerk: The clerk must transmit copies of the resolution to Scott Dolson for distribution.
  • Everyone else: The resolution does not directly change anyone’s rights, duties, taxes, services, or eligibility.

Money#

No publicly available information on cost is provided.

  • The resolution requires the clerk to transmit copies, but gives no cost estimate or staffing details.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not say who will receive copies or when they will be distributed.
  • No publicly available information is provided about any cost of printing or distribution.
  • The resolution gives no further detail about what distribution by Indiana University entails.

Case for#

  • A formal resolution gives the state’s recognition to an athlete’s achievement.
  • The resolution’s recitals point to Mendoza’s Heisman win, team success, and season statistics as reasons for the recognition.
  • Sending copies to Indiana University provides a way to share the recognition.

Case against#

  • The resolution creates no practical benefit or ongoing service; its effect is ceremonial.
  • It includes judgments about Mendoza’s faith, family, and moral character as well as his athletic record. One concern is that these personal judgments are not needed to recognize his sports achievement.