Clere retirement honored

Summary#

HR-39, “Honoring Representative Edward D. Clere,” is an Indiana House resolution, not a bill that changes state law. Its stated goal is to honor Clere as he concludes his legislative service.

  • The resolution formally honors Clere.
  • It requires the Principal Clerk of the House to send him a copy.
  • Its recitals describe Clere’s service and accomplishments; they do not create or change programs, rights, duties, or funding.
  • It does not amend a statute or establish a new government office.

What it means for you#

  • Representative Clere: The House’s resolution recognizes him upon his retirement.
  • Principal Clerk of the House: Must transmit a copy of the resolution to Clere.
  • Everyone else: The resolution does not directly change services, rules, taxes, or benefits.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution does not specify an appropriation, fee, or other payment.
  • It requires the Principal Clerk to send a copy, but gives no cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied status says “first reading: adopted” but also lists the stage as “introduced.” The resolution’s final status is unclear from the available material.
  • The resolution sets no deadline or method for sending the copy. No publicly available information.
  • The recitals describe achievements and outcomes, but the supplied material does not provide evidence for those claims.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the resolution is that it publicly recognizes Clere’s nine terms in the House and his work on issues named in the resolution.
  • It records specific parts of his service, including work on health policy, education, and legislation concerning syringe service programs and nurse licensing.
  • Sending him a copy gives the recognition directly to the person it honors.

Case against#

  • A possible trade-off is that the resolution is symbolic: it does not change policy or address an ongoing public need.
  • The recitals include claims about the effects of programs, but the resolution itself does not provide evidence to assess those claims.
  • The available material gives no cost estimate or detail about how the required transmission will be carried out.