Water standards updated and waters reclassified

Summary#

LD 2187, “An Act to Update Certain Water Quality Standards and to Reclassify Certain Waters of the State,” amends Maine’s water-quality standards and water classifications in Title 38 of the Maine Revised Statutes. Its stated goal is to update standards and classifications; the bill does not guarantee a particular environmental result. It was signed into law, but the supplied text does not give a start date.

  • The enacted text designates Abbott Brook and its tributaries, the South Branch Sandy River and its tributaries, Cottle Brook and its tributaries, and the Middle Branch Pleasant River and its tributaries as Class AA. It changes Mount Blue Stream and its tributaries from Class A to Class AA.
  • It adds an exception to the “as naturally occurs” standard for aquatic life in Class AA, A and GPA waters: activities involving fish stocking and fish management are excepted if approved by a state agency.
  • It changes wording for dissolved-oxygen standards and exceptions in several water classes, and includes bacteria limits for freshwater and marine classes. The supplied text does not show clearly which wording or numerical limits are new.
  • It also revises listed classifications or descriptions for other waters, including the East Branch Sebasticook River and Olamon Stream.

What it means for you#

  • People near the named waters: Those waters would be subject to the classifications stated in the law. The text does not create a new public application or review process for residents.
  • State agencies: A state agency’s approval is required for fish-stocking or fish-management activities to fall within the stated exception to the natural aquatic-life standard in Class AA, A and GPA waters.
  • Businesses, permit holders and municipalities: The bill sets water-quality standards, but the supplied text does not explain how any particular permit or activity would be affected.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change household taxes, fees, water access rights or eligibility for a benefit.

Money#

No publicly available information in the supplied materials.

  • The bill does not state a spending amount, staffing requirement, fee or fine.
  • The text does not estimate costs for agencies, permit holders or municipalities.

What is unclear#

  • The current version of the amended statutes was not supplied, and the bill text does not clearly mark deleted and added wording. So it is not possible to verify which standards are new and which are carried forward.
  • The text does not give an effective date.
  • It does not explain how state agencies would approve fish stocking or fish management, or how the exception would be applied.
  • It does not describe changes to monitoring, enforcement, permits, appeals or public reporting.
  • The text does not explain how the reclassifications interact with existing permits or programs.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that assigning Class AA to named waters would apply the standards for that class to those waters.
  • Allowing agency-approved fish stocking and management to be excepted from the natural aquatic-life standard could give agencies room to carry out those activities.
  • Updating standards and classifications in statute could make the rules for the named waters clearer, though the supplied materials do not show how much the standards change from current law.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the fish-stocking and fish-management exception does not spell out the approval process or limits.
  • The bill’s standards are difficult to assess against current law because the supplied text does not clearly show what wording is being replaced.
  • It is unclear how the changes would affect existing permits, monitoring or enforcement, and what those effects might cost.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1668561

    Defeated35 members voted

    Accept Minority Ought To Pass As Amended Report RC #786

    AGAINST · 22FOR · 13

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    22Against

    • Republican15
    • Democratic7

    13For

    • Democratic13