Summary#
The Employment Standards Code Amendment Act (Right to Religious Observance) amends Manitoba’s Employment Standards Code and makes a related change to The Remembrance Day Act. Its stated goal is to allow more religious observance at work; the supplied text leaves the assent date blank, so it is not clear whether the Act is in force.
- An employee who does not observe Good Friday or Christmas Day may make a written request to substitute one religious observance day for that holiday. The employer must reasonably accommodate the request unless doing so would cause undue hardship.
- The request must be made at least 30 days before the holiday and identify both dates. The employer must decide in writing within seven days and give reasons for a denial.
- If the business operates on Good Friday or Christmas Day, an employee who requests a substitute day must receive holiday pay for that substitute day and their regular wage for hours worked on the holiday. If the business does not operate, it must pay holiday pay for either the holiday or the substitute day, but not both.
- A retail employee may refuse to work on a Friday, Saturday or Sunday for religious observance, subject to regulations and notice requirements.
- Employers must reasonably accommodate religious practice during the workday and religious clothing, subject to limits for business operations, safety and other applicable laws.
What it means for you#
- Employees who do not observe Good Friday or Christmas Day: You may request a substitute religious observance day. The bill does not guarantee approval: the employer’s duty is to reasonably accommodate the request only if it does not cause undue hardship.
- Retail employees: You may refuse a Friday, Saturday or Sunday shift for religious observance. Normally, you must give at least 14 days’ notice. If you are scheduled less than 14 days ahead, you must give as much notice as is reasonable and practicable. Regulations may affect this right.
- Employees seeking time for religious practice or clothing: Your employer must reasonably accommodate religious practice during the workday and religious clothing, but accommodation is limited where it unduly restricts business operations. Clothing accommodation must also comply with workplace safety and other applicable laws.
- Employers: You must follow the accommodation and notice rules, and meet the written decision and pay requirements for holiday substitution requests.
- Other people: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or general holiday dates.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the supplied material.
- Employers may have wage costs under the holiday-pay and regular-wage rules. The text does not give a dollar amount.
- The bill does not specify public spending, staffing, fees or new funding.
What is unclear#
- The Employment Standards Code and The Remembrance Day Act as they currently read were not supplied, so the full change from current law cannot be verified.
- The bill does not say what information may be prescribed for a holiday substitution request, or what regulations may require for retail employees.
- It does not explain how an employer should assess undue hardship or when an accommodation would unduly restrict business operations.
- The bill defines a religious observance day by reference to the religious denomination with which an employee is affiliated, but does not explain how affiliation or the requested observance would be established.
- The supplied text leaves the assent date blank. It says the Act comes into force on royal assent, but does not confirm whether that has happened.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to let employees observe religious holidays without losing the pay protections tied to a general holiday, while setting notice and decision timelines.
- A possible argument for the accommodation duties is that employees can observe religious practices or wear religious clothing at work, with limits for business operations and safety.
- The retail notice rules give employers advance notice in most cases while allowing shorter notice when shifts are scheduled less than 14 days ahead.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill does not explain how employers should apply the limits for undue hardship or business operations, which could leave employees and employers uncertain.
- Employers may face scheduling or wage costs, but the materials provide no estimates or detail on how those costs might vary.
- The bill leaves key retail rules subject to regulations, and the supplied text does not include those regulations.
- The bill sets a written process for holiday substitution requests, but does not set out a process for resolving disputes about the other accommodation duties.