Summary#
The Pharmaceutical Amendment, Regulated Health Professions Amendment and Public Health Amendment Act amends Manitoba’s Pharmaceutical Act, Regulated Health Professions Act and Public Health Act. Its stated goals include allowing pharmacists to make therapeutic substitutions, allowing health-profession regulators to amalgamate, and clarifying court processes for public-health detention orders.
- A pharmacist may prescribe a substitute drug with different active ingredients if the pharmacist decides it has the same or a similar therapeutic effect. The rules must follow regulations, and the pharmacist must not substitute if the prescriber or patient instructs otherwise.
- The health minister may start an amalgamation of two or more health-profession colleges or associations if the minister considers it in the public interest. The Lieutenant Governor in Council must make a regulation to bring the amalgamation into effect.
- Before an amalgamation, a first council may prepare rules and standards and designate committee members and officers for the new college. A minister-appointed administrator may also carry out specified powers and duties of the existing colleges or associations to help with the process.
- On amalgamation, the existing colleges or associations continue as one corporation. Their rights, property, debts, obligations and liabilities become those of the amalgamated college; the Act also says the amalgamation is not an assignment or transfer of property.
- A medical officer or a person subject to a public-health order may apply to a provincial judge to vary a requirement. Requests to extend detention are heard by a provincial judge rather than a Court of King’s Bench judge.
What it means for you#
- Patients and pharmacists: A pharmacist may make a therapeutic substitution, but it is not required. A patient may tell the pharmacist orally or in writing not to substitute, or to dispense the originally prescribed drug. A prescriber may give that instruction on the prescription or orally. The pharmacist must record the instruction and who gave it. For continuing prescriptions, the instruction remains unless the patient or prescriber rescinds it.
- Health-profession colleges and associations: One or more may ask the minister to start an amalgamation, but the minister may also start one on the minister’s own initiative. The minister can appoint the first council and, if considered in the public interest, an administrator. Members of each existing college or association must be consulted before the first council makes rules, by-laws, standards or a code of ethics.
- People subject to public-health orders: You may apply to a provincial judge to vary a requirement in the specified orders. The bill does not say a judge must grant the application.
- Current law: The supplied material does not include the parent Acts, so I could not verify all changes against current law. The explanatory note describes the intended changes. The bill text gives no assent date; Parts 1 and 2 start on a day set by proclamation, while Part 3 starts on royal assent.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- The minister may require first-council pay and expenses to come from the funds of the existing colleges or associations.
- The minister may authorize administrator pay and expenses from those funds.
- The bill sets no cost limit or amount and does not provide a spending estimate. It does not change taxes or fees in the supplied text.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “same or a similar therapeutic effect.” Regulations are to govern substitutions, but their contents are not supplied.
- The bill does not set out a standard process or timeline for proposing and completing an amalgamation. The minister’s “public interest” test is not defined.
- The minister may direct the first council to use specified powers, and may act if the council does not comply. The bill does not set out an appeal process for those directions.
- The bill allows regulations to deal with transitions, including registrations, licences, applications, complaints, proceedings, committees and staff. The details for any particular amalgamation are not provided.
- The text does not explain what the Pharmaceutical Act provisions it disapplies would otherwise require.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the substitution power is that it gives pharmacists a way to prescribe a drug with a similar therapeutic effect while preserving the patient’s and prescriber’s ability to refuse.
- A single college could bring the regulation of several professions under one corporation. The bill provides tools to prepare rules, offices and committees before the amalgamation takes effect.
- The bill sets out how existing property, obligations, registrations and legal proceedings can continue through an amalgamation, which may help avoid gaps in regulation.
- Allowing a person subject to an order to apply to vary it gives that person a route to ask a provincial judge to change its requirements.
Case against#
- “Same or a similar therapeutic effect” leaves room for judgment, and the bill does not itself specify how that judgment is made. The regulations that would govern substitutions are not included.
- The minister can initiate an amalgamation and appoint the first council; the minister may also appoint an administrator with specified powers from existing regulators. This concentrates important transition powers in the minister.
- Amalgamation may change governance and end the terms of existing board and council members, committee members and officers who are not appointed to the new body. The bill does not estimate the cost or practical disruption.
- The bill leaves major transition details to future regulations, so the effects on members, staff, pending applications and complaints may depend on decisions not included here.