Task Force to Study Dialysis Outcomes

Summary#

HB 1632, titled Anthony McCarthy Task Force to Study Dialysis Outcomes, would create a temporary task force by standalone act; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to study dialysis outcomes and recommend ways to improve them while minimizing taxpayer burdens. The supplied status lists the bill as introduced and at first reading, so it has not yet become law according to that information.

  • The task force would include 10 members: four Maryland legislators, two representatives of the Maryland Department of Health, a urologist, a nephrologist and two people in Maryland who have received dialysis. The Governor would appoint the doctors and patients and name the chair.
  • The Department of Health would have to provide staff. Members could not be paid for serving, but would be entitled to travel-expense reimbursement as provided in the State budget.
  • The task force would have to evaluate current dialysis outcomes and study options including in-home dialysis access and training, home health aide certification, grants for patients and renal-friendly food, public education and community screening events.
  • It would have to send findings and legislative recommendations to the General Assembly by May 31, 2027. The proposed act would end on June 30, 2027.

What it means for you#

  • People receiving dialysis and caregivers: The task force would study possible support, including in-home treatment training, patient grants and food assistance. The bill does not create those programs or guarantee anyone assistance.
  • Home health aides: The task force would study whether to create mandatory certification for aides who support people receiving in-home dialysis. The bill itself would not require certification.
  • Maryland Department of Health: The department would have to staff the task force and provide one member.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not set up a grant program or specify new payments to patients. It does allow reimbursement of task force members’ expenses under the State budget.
  • The public: The bill would create a temporary study body, not a new independent agency or a front-line dialysis service.

Money#

The bill requires Department of Health staffing and allows expense reimbursement, but gives no cost estimate.

  • Members could not receive compensation for serving; they would be entitled to expense reimbursement as provided in the State budget.
  • The bill does not fund the grant, training, certification, education or screening options it asks the task force to study.
  • No publicly available information on the cost of staffing or expense reimbursements.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “dialysis patient outcomes” or set a method for evaluating them.
  • It does not specify how the task force would gather information, involve patients or caregivers, or decide which recommendations to make.
  • It does not set a budget or say how many staff the Department of Health must provide.
  • The supplied status says first reading, while the bill’s proposed effective date is June 1, 2026. The materials do not explain that timing difference.

Case for#

  • The task force would bring legislators, health officials, doctors and people who have received dialysis together to study outcomes.
  • A possible argument for studying the listed options is that the task force could compare different ways to support patients before recommending new laws or programs.
  • Requiring recommendations to consider taxpayer burdens makes cost part of the task force’s assignment.

Case against#

  • The bill creates no patient services or funding; any practical benefits would depend on later decisions by the General Assembly or other officials.
  • It sets a deadline for recommendations but does not require the General Assembly or the Department of Health to act on them.
  • The bill does not explain how the task force should measure outcomes or assess whether its recommendations would improve them or limit costs.