Discipline data to be published publicly

Summary#

HB 1636, Primary and Secondary Schools—Discipline-Related Data—Collection and Publication, would amend Maryland’s Education Article; it does not create a new agency or directly change the rules for disciplining individual students. Its stated goal is to identify and reduce differences in discipline between student subgroups and to reduce high suspension rates. The bill is listed as introduced and not yet law, so passage is uncertain.

  • The State Department of Education must publish discipline-related data on its website in a usable format, searchable by state, local school system, and school. The data may include suspension counts and rates, comparisons between schools, and information about high-suspending schools.
  • The department must disaggregate annual discipline reports by subgroup and type of discipline. Subgroups include race, ethnicity, gender, disability status, socioeconomic status, grade level, and English language proficiency. The reporting list includes public and nonpublic schools, charter schools, and several named state schools and programs.
  • The department must maintain and use a risk ratio and a State comparison threshold of 2.0 to identify a school’s discipline process as having a disproportionate impact on a subgroup. The bill defines these measures in terms of student removals and removal rates.
  • An elementary school is “high-suspending” if it suspends 10% or more of its students in each subgroup; for a secondary school, the threshold is 25% or more.
  • If a school is identified as high-suspending or as having a disproportionate impact, the school or local school system must submit a corrective action plan to the State Board. The plan must set out actions to reduce the problem within one year and eliminate it within three years. The department must provide support and resources.
  • Starting October 1, 2028, the department must publish these plans and related suspension or disparity data. The bill sets an effective date of July 1, 2026.

What it means for you#

  • Students and families: The bill does not create a new individual right to appeal discipline, ban suspensions, or require schools to use restorative practices. It would make more discipline data public.
  • Schools and local school systems: If identified as high-suspending or as having a disproportionate impact, they must send the State Board a corrective action plan with the one- and three-year targets. The bill does not set out penalties for missing those targets.
  • State Department of Education: It must publish searchable data, apply the 2.0 measures to identify schools, provide support and resources, and publish corrective action plans and related data.
  • Taxpayers: The bill creates public reporting and support duties for the department, but gives no estimate of their cost.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The department must provide support and resources to schools and local systems, but the bill does not state how much support, staffing, or funding is required.
  • The department must maintain and publish data and plans; no cost for that work is given.
  • The bill creates no tax, fee, fine, or direct payment to students or schools.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how the 2.0 risk ratio and State comparison threshold are calculated in practice. The definitions refer to student removals and removal rates, but do not provide calculation rules.
  • The “high-suspending” definition says a school meets the threshold when it suspends the stated percentage of students “in each subgroup.” The bill does not explain how to apply that test when subgroup sizes or data differ.
  • The bill does not set rules for protecting student privacy in published subgroup data, including where a subgroup is very small.
  • It does not specify how the department will identify schools, what evidence or process schools can use to respond, or what happens if a school misses its action-plan targets.
  • The bill text includes marked changes to the existing law, but the parent law was not supplied separately. The available material does not allow an independent check of the full current law or every change from it.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that searchable school-level data could make differences in discipline easier for families, schools, and the public to see.
  • Requiring subgroup reporting could help show whether discipline affects some groups more than others.
  • The action-plan requirement sets deadlines for schools identified as high-suspending or having a disproportionate impact, rather than relying only on public reporting.
  • The bill requires the department to provide support and resources alongside those plans.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain how the 2.0 measures work in practice. Different calculation choices could affect which schools are identified.
  • Schools and systems must meet reduction and elimination targets, but the bill does not say how progress will be assessed or what happens if targets are missed.
  • Publishing subgroup data without specified privacy protections could raise concerns where small groups make students easier to identify.
  • The bill assigns new duties to the department but gives no cost estimate or staffing plan.