Ombudsman for common ownership disputes proposed

Summary#

SB 981, the Common Ownership Communities – Ombudsman Unit, Governing Document Database, and Local Commissions bill, would add provisions to Maryland’s Commercial Law, Housing and Community Development, and Real Property laws. Its stated goal is to help community members understand their rights and address disputes; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. The supplied status lists the bill as at first reading, so it is not law and has not created these duties.

  • It would create an Ombudsman Unit within the Attorney General’s Division of Consumer Protection, with a full-time ombudsman who must be a member of the Maryland Bar. Staff would be provided as set out in the state budget.
  • Common ownership communities would have to file governing documents and amendments with the Department of Housing and Community Development (DHCD). DHCD would have to make a public website database and could charge filing fees.
  • A county could establish a local commission by local law; the bill does not require every county to establish one. If established, a commission would have required members, duties and dispute procedures.
  • A commission could issue binding decisions on disputes within the bill’s scope. Filing a dispute would generally pause enforcement of the community governing body’s decision, subject to a process for lifting the pause.
  • A community that fails to file required documents would face a $500 fine. In a county with a commission, a community that fails to register annually—or gives false information on its registration—could not file a dispute there.

What it means for you#

  • Members of a condominium, cooperative or homeowners association: You could complain to the Ombudsman Unit about a final adverse decision by a governing body or community manager. The unit must respond, but it may refer the complaint to a local commission or decide whether the decision conflicts with law. It is not a court, and the bill does not give it power to reverse the decision.
  • Owners and community governing bodies in a county with a local commission: The local process would generally require you to first try the community’s own procedures and wait at least 60 days after starting one. A filed dispute would usually pause enforcement of the governing body’s decision. A hearing panel could make a binding decision; a party could appeal to court.
  • Common ownership communities statewide: You would have to file governing documents and amendments with DHCD. The bill does not set filing deadlines or explain how the $500 fine would be imposed.
  • Counties: If a county establishes a commission, it must follow the bill’s rules. The county must also designate an agency or office to provide listed services, including technical assistance and dispute resolution.
  • People generally: The bill would not itself change property ownership, create a right to a particular dispute outcome, or require every county to create a commission.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s total cost.

  • The bill requires a full-time state ombudsman and staff as provided in the state budget, but gives no staffing count or cost estimate.
  • DHCD could charge up to $100 for an initial filing and up to $25 for each amendment.
  • A county that establishes a commission could authorize reasonable service fees, including annual per-unit charges, dispute-resolution fees and charges to developers for recording documents. Fees must be published and used to maintain the commission.
  • Commission members could not be paid for serving, but would be entitled to expense reimbursement under county travel rules.
  • A $500 fine would apply to a community that fails to make a required DHCD filing.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include current versions of the laws being amended, including the referenced DHCD definition of “common ownership community.” I could not verify how the bill’s requirements compare with current law.
  • The bill does not set filing deadlines, explain how DHCD would collect documents or fines, or say when the public database must be ready.
  • The Ombudsman Unit’s complaint rules are not specified: for example, the bill does not set filing deadlines, decision timelines or an appeal process. “Final adverse decision” is not defined in the supplied text.
  • Counties may choose whether to create commissions. The bill does not say how many would do so or how county costs and fees would vary.
  • The bill defines which disputes local commissions may hear and excludes some types, but the boundaries of terms such as “good faith” and “undue harm” are not explained.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make governing documents easier to find and to give community members a route to information and dispute resolution.
  • A possible argument for local commissions is that they could offer mediation and hearings closer to the communities involved.
  • The Ombudsman Unit would have to publish information, assist members in understanding available rights and processes, and report on complaints and outcomes.
  • A pause on enforcing a disputed decision could help preserve the situation while the commission considers the dispute.

Case against#

  • A pause in enforcement could delay a community’s decision even when the dispute is not yet resolved. The bill allows a request to lift the pause, but says an urgent request is deemed granted if it is not decided within 20 days.
  • Local commissions would make binding decisions, while court review would generally be limited to whether the decision follows law, has substantial evidence and is not arbitrary or capricious. That gives commissions significant decision-making power.
  • The process could require staff, mediators, hearings and expense reimbursement. The bill does not provide a cost estimate or require counties to use the same fee schedule.
  • Required document filings and annual local registration could burden communities; failing to register, or filing false information, would remove access to the local dispute process.