Sheriff Elections Would Drop Party Labels

Summary#

HB 6479 would amend Michigan’s 1954 Michigan Election Law and add a new chapter on county sheriff elections. Its stated goal is to require sheriff elections to be nonpartisan; the bill is introduced and is not law. The current version of the Michigan Election Law was not supplied, so I could not verify which sheriff-election rules in the bill are new and which restate existing law.

  • Sheriff candidates would run in a nonpartisan election, with no party designation on the ballot. The bill removes sheriff from the list of offices elected through party primaries and includes it among nonpartisan offices.
  • A nonpartisan August primary would be held when needed. If the number of candidates is no more than twice the number of positions to be filled, the county clerk would certify the candidate or candidates as nominees and omit the office from the primary ballot.
  • Candidates could file nominating petitions or pay a nonrefundable $100 fee, which would go to the county’s general fund. Candidates must be registered and qualified county electors by the filing deadline.
  • The bill sets out election, recount, recall, vacancy, and removal rules for sheriffs. It assigns election tasks to county clerks and canvassers, and gives the governor a removal process for specified grounds. The available materials do not show which of these rules change current law.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: You would vote for sheriff without party labels on the ballot. If there are few enough candidates, there would be no August primary for sheriff; the contest would go to the November election.
  • People running for sheriff: You would need to meet the county-elector requirement and file petitions or pay the $100 fee. Petition signatures could be challenged.
  • County election officials: County clerks and canvassers would have the filing, ballot, certification, and election duties described in the bill.
  • Sheriffs and the public: The bill does not directly change sheriffs’ day-to-day duties or create a new public service. It includes rules on sheriff vacancies and removal; whether those rules differ from current law is unclear.

Money#

The bill sets a $100 candidate filing fee but provides no estimate of public costs.

  • A candidate could instead submit petitions; the filing fee is nonrefundable and would go to the county general fund.
  • County officials would have election-related duties, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The supplied text identifies no appropriation, tax change, or other public funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • The current Michigan Election Law was not supplied, so the exact changes to existing sheriff-election, vacancy, and removal rules could not be verified.
  • The bill relies on a separate law for the required number of petition signatures and the petition form; those rules were not supplied.
  • The supplied text does not state when the law would take effect. It says the new election method would apply beginning with the 2028 general election.
  • The bill does not explain how election officials would handle details beyond the procedures it lists.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that sheriff candidates would appear without party labels, making the election formally nonpartisan.
  • The bill sets out an election process, including filing options, a primary when needed, and November election procedures.
  • A primary-free path when there are few candidates could avoid holding a separate primary contest for sheriff.

Case against#

  • Without party labels, voters would have less party-based information on the ballot. The bill does not specify another way to provide comparable information.
  • When the primary is omitted, voters would not choose among sheriff candidates in August.
  • The bill assigns election duties but provides no cost or staffing estimate, and the available material does not show how its rules fit with current law.