Affirmative action rules repealed, bias training added

Summary#

HF 5143, titled “Affirmative action requirements for state agencies repealed,” would amend Minnesota Statutes and repeal several state laws and rules; it does not create a new stand-alone law. Its stated goal is to repeal affirmative action requirements, while retaining the state’s policy of equal employment opportunity and adding a training duty about bias in hiring and performance reviews. The bill is introduced and is not law; whether it will pass is uncertain.

  • It would repeal the statewide affirmative action program and agency requirements for plans, goals, progress reports, audits, and affirmative action officers.
  • It would repeal specific state requirements for recruiting, hiring, and advancing people with disabilities through agency affirmative action plans. It would not repeal the Human Rights Act as a whole.
  • It would remove affirmative action certificate requirements for certain public contracts, along with related fees, fines, and contract remedies.
  • It would repeal affirmative action plan requirements for the Metropolitan Council and other covered metropolitan agencies.
  • Department and agency heads must still train managers and supervisors who hire or evaluate employees about bias in those processes. The bill does not set the training’s content or schedule.

What it means for you#

  • State agencies: They would no longer have to follow the repealed statewide and agency affirmative action planning, goal-setting, auditing, reporting, and officer requirements. Agency heads must provide the specified bias training.
  • State job applicants and employees: The bill would remove those specific affirmative action plans and processes. It retains the state policy that personnel decisions be based on ability to do the job, without regard to listed characteristics, and that state employment provide equal opportunity consistent with the Human Rights Act.
  • Businesses seeking covered public contracts: They would no longer have to obtain the repealed affirmative action certificate or meet the related plan requirements. Under the supplied current-law text, the certificate rule covered certain goods and services contracts over $100,000 with businesses meeting an employee-size test, and some state-funded capital projects.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill changes government requirements and contract conditions; it does not create a new public service or benefit.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill would remove the $250 fee for an affirmative action certificate and the associated fee account. The amount of fee revenue affected is not given.
  • Agency heads must provide bias training, but the bill gives no estimate of staffing or training costs.
  • The effect on agency spending from ending planning, reporting, and related work is not estimated.

What is unclear#

  • The bill gives no start date and no transition rules for existing plans, certificates, or contracts.
  • It does not define “bias” or say what training must cover, how often it must occur, or how completion would be checked.
  • It does not explain how the changes interact with affirmative action requirements under other laws or programs that the bill does not repeal.
  • The bill removes the definition of “protected groups” used for affirmative action purposes. The supplied material does not explain how remaining policies that refer to protected groups would be applied.
  • The bill does not set out a replacement process for measuring employment patterns or handling issues previously addressed through the repealed plans and reports.

Case for#

  • The bill would remove detailed planning, reporting, audit, and certificate requirements, reducing administrative steps for agencies and businesses.
  • It retains the state’s stated equal-employment and nondiscrimination policies.
  • Requiring training for managers and supervisors about bias keeps a specific prevention duty while removing the broader planning system.

Case against#

  • Removing goals, workforce data, audits, and reports could make it harder to identify or track underutilization and assess whether agencies are making progress.
  • The bill repeals mechanisms for disability-focused recruitment, advancement planning, and accommodation planning within agency affirmative action plans. The bill does not explain what, if anything, would replace those mechanisms.
  • Ending contract certificates and related enforcement tools removes a condition and accountability process that applied to some public contractors.
  • The bill requires bias training but does not specify its content, frequency, or oversight, so the duty’s practical effect is unclear.