Cemeteries would have to allow green burials

Summary#

SF-5305 would add a new rule to Minnesota’s cemetery law and amend the existing law on green burials. It would require cemeteries governed by that chapter to allow burials in accordance with a person’s recognized religion, including green burials; its stated goal is reflected in the bill’s title. The bill is at the introduced stage, so it is not law and may not pass.

  • Covered cemeteries would have to allow green burials, rather than only being required to follow green-burial rules if they already allow them.
  • Covered cemeteries would have to permit burial according to a person’s recognized religious rites, if the burial complies with Minnesota’s funeral and cemetery laws.
  • Green burials generally would remain subject to the existing limit of 300 burials per acre over 100 years. A cemetery would have to allow a higher density when green burial is part of the person’s recognized religious rites.
  • The bill does not set a different maximum density for those religious green burials.

What it means for you#

  • Cemeteries governed by the chapter: They would have to allow green burials and religiously required burial practices, subject to the stated legal requirements. The bill does not say how cemeteries must handle requests.
  • People arranging a burial: They would gain a legal requirement that covered cemeteries permit burial in accordance with their recognized religion. This would not remove the requirement to comply with the cited funeral and cemetery laws.
  • Other cemeteries and the public: The bill’s requirements apply to cemeteries governed by the chapter; the materials do not establish that every cemetery in Minnesota is covered.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require covered cemeteries to allow green burials and religious burial practices, but gives no estimate of costs to cemeteries or government.
  • The bill includes no appropriation, fee, or payment to cemeteries.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “recognized religion,” or explain who decides whether a religion or burial practice qualifies.
  • It sets no request process, decision deadline, appeal, or enforcement process.
  • It does not set a maximum density for religious green burials above the usual 300-per-acre limit.
  • The meaning of “green burial” is referred to in another law, but that definition was not supplied, so it could not be checked here.
  • The bill text supplied does not state when it would take effect.

Case for#

  • The bill would make green burial an option at all cemeteries governed by the chapter, instead of leaving that choice to each cemetery.
  • Requiring cemeteries to respect recognized religious burial rites could give people more assurance that they can follow those rites.
  • Allowing higher density for religious green burials could help accommodate a religious practice that may not fit the usual density limit.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define “recognized religion” or explain how a cemetery should assess a request, which could leave important decisions unclear.
  • The higher-density exception has no stated limit. That could allow more burials per acre than the general rule permits, without the bill specifying how much more.
  • The bill creates duties for covered cemeteries but provides no cost estimate or details about how compliance would work.