Retired officers may rejoin police work

Summary#

SF-5308 would amend Minnesota’s Public Employees Police and Fire Retirement Plan law and add a new section on reemploying retired police officers. Its goal is to let some officers return to city police work while continuing to receive their retirement annuity. The bill is introduced and has been referred to a Senate committee; it is not law.

  • An eligible officer could return to a city police job covered by the plan as soon as the second day after leaving service, if the officer is at least 55.
  • The officer’s annuity would continue without changing because of the reemployment. The officer would not earn more pension service credit, and contributions made during reemployment would be refunded with interest after the officer leaves again.
  • The officer and employer would still have to make pension contributions during reemployment.
  • The officer could keep participating in the statewide public employees insurance program, but would pay the cost unless a collective bargaining agreement or personnel policy provides otherwise.
  • The bill would set limits on how many returning officers a city may employ, based on its police staffing in the preceding calendar year. It also keeps fingerprinting requirements while exempting these officers from certain other rules.

What it means for you#

  • Retired or retiring police officers: You would qualify only if you are covered by the Public Employees Police and Fire Retirement Plan, are a police officer as defined in existing law, left service with at least five years of allowable service, and are receiving or have applied for an annuity. You must be at least 55 to return as early as the second day after leaving service.
  • Officers who return too soon: The retirement plan’s executive director must seek repayment of annuity payments made if you return before the permitted date. The director may waive repayment if the mistake was inadvertent or was no fault of yours.
  • Returning officers and their employers: Both would make required pension contributions, but the officer would earn no additional service credit. After the officer separates again, the plan’s executive director must refund the officer’s reemployment contributions with interest.
  • Returning officers: You could continue participating in the statewide public employees insurance program. You would pay for that participation unless a collective bargaining agreement or personnel policy says otherwise.
  • Cities: A city with five or fewer police officers in the preceding calendar year could employ any number of eligible returning officers. A city with more than five but fewer than 100 officers could employ up to five or 25% of its prior-year staffing, whichever is greater. A city with 100 or more could employ up to 25 or 10% of prior-year staffing, whichever is greater.
  • Current-law comparison: The bill expressly creates exceptions to parts of existing law and rules. The current versions of those laws and rules were not supplied, so I could not verify exactly how much of the proposed arrangement would change current practice.

Money#

No publicly available information on cost estimates was included in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires employee and employer pension contributions during reemployment, but gives no estimate of their amounts or the overall cost.
  • The officer would pay for continued insurance participation unless a collective bargaining agreement or personnel policy provides otherwise.
  • The bill requires the plan to refund the officer’s reemployment contributions with interest after the officer leaves the job.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how to round the percentage-based city limits when the result is not a whole number.
  • It does not explain how a city’s number of police officers is counted if staffing changes during the year.
  • The supplied material does not include current versions of the amended statute or the cited rules, so the precise difference from current requirements is unclear.
  • No fiscal estimate, implementation details, or explanation of how the required contribution refunds would affect the plan is provided.
  • Passage is uncertain because the bill is introduced and not yet law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let cities rehire some experienced officers without stopping or reducing those officers’ annuities.
  • Continuing annuity payments may make returning to police work possible without giving up the retirement income the officer is already receiving.
  • The city limits place a higher ceiling on reemployment in cities with larger police forces while allowing small cities to employ any number of eligible returnees.
  • The bill still requires pension contributions and fingerprinting, while specifying that returning officers earn no new service credit.

Case against#

  • One concern is that an officer could receive an annuity while also being reemployed, while the bill does not provide a cost estimate for the arrangement.
  • Cities must make employer pension contributions, but the bill does not explain how those costs compare with the pension benefits earned; returning officers earn no additional service credit.
  • The city limits could restrict how many eligible officers larger cities may rehire, while the bill does not explain why these particular thresholds were chosen.
  • The bill does not explain how the new rules would interact with the current rules it exempts or how the percentage limits should be applied in practice.