Bill tightens surgery rules and out-of-state care

Summary#

HB 3484 would repeal and replace Missouri law section 334.010, which concerns unauthorized practice of medicine and surgery. It would define “surgery” and “practice of medicine across state lines,” and set out exceptions to the physician-licensing requirement. The bill’s stated subject is unauthorized practice; the text does not promise a particular result. It is introduced and is not law.

  • The bill’s definition of surgery includes certain changes to body tissue and injections of diagnostic or treatment substances into specified body areas. It excludes certain injections given by a licensed nurse on a physician’s order and within the nurse’s scope of practice.
  • It defines out-of-state medical practice to include giving a medical opinion or treatment to a patient in Missouri based on patient information sent from Missouri.
  • An out-of-state physician would not need a Missouri license in listed situations, including consultation with a Missouri-licensed physician who keeps ultimate responsibility for the patient’s diagnosis and treatment.
  • Other listed exceptions cover certain evaluations, opinions, testimony or records for legal proceedings, utilization review, and sports-related care for specified team members and staff. The sports-care exception requires a written agreement with an athletic team and does not allow care at a health care facility.
  • The supplied text does not set out a penalty, despite the bill’s title referring to penalty provisions.

What it means for you#

  • Physicians and other medical providers: The bill would put definitions and exceptions into section 334.010. Because the current version of that section was not supplied, it is not possible to verify which of these rules would be new and which would continue existing law.
  • Out-of-state physicians: The bill lists situations in which they would not need a Missouri license. For consultation, the Missouri-licensed physician must retain ultimate authority and responsibility for diagnosis and treatment.
  • Nurses: The definition of surgery excludes subcutaneous, intramuscular, and intravenous injections given by a licensed nurse when ordered by a physician and within the nurse’s scope of practice.
  • Patients: The bill does not create a new patient service, application process, or right to receive care from an out-of-state physician.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill text contains no appropriation, fee, or cost estimate.
  • The available material does not say whether the proposed wording would change staffing or enforcement costs.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of section 334.010 was not supplied, so it is unclear how much of the bill changes current law.
  • The bill text does not explain how the new or stated definitions would affect existing professional scopes of practice.
  • The text does not set out a penalty, enforcement process, or who would enforce the section.
  • No start date or fiscal estimate is provided in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that defining surgery and practice across state lines could make the boundaries of unlicensed medical practice clearer.
  • The listed exceptions could allow some out-of-state physicians to consult, take part in legal proceedings or utilization review, or provide limited sports-related care without obtaining a Missouri license.
  • Requiring a Missouri physician to retain ultimate responsibility in the consultation exception keeps that responsibility with a locally licensed physician.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the definition of surgery covers several kinds of tissue alteration and injections, but the bill does not explain how it would interact with existing professional scopes of practice.
  • It is unclear which provisions are new and how the wording would change current law.
  • The bill text does not specify a penalty or describe how alleged unauthorized practice would be handled.