Private school students could join public school activities

Summary#

Missouri HB 3485 would amend the existing law on students’ participation in public school activities. It would add some private school students to the groups who may take part, subject to conditions; the bill’s stated aim, reflected in its title, is to authorize that participation. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • As shown by the bill’s deleted text, current law already covers certain students receiving instruction through an FPE school, a home school, or a full-time virtual course or program. The bill would also treat a private school student as eligible if the private school is not a member of a statewide athletic association and does not offer the activity.
  • Eligible students must be given an opportunity to try out and, if they pass any tryout, participate in covered activities at the charter school or public school district where they reside. Covered activities include athletics, fine arts, integrated cocurricular activities, and related extracurricular occurrences.
  • Schools could not require eligible students to attend classes or attend public school for part of the day to participate. Exceptions allow required instruction components for certain fine arts, career and technical student organizations, and integrated cocurricular activities.
  • Eligible students must meet the same directly related conduct and performance standards and financial requirements as enrolled students. Sports participants must provide a physical, including details about relevant underlying conditions.
  • Schools may set attendance or discipline policies for required coursework, rehearsals, practice, or training, but must apply them in the same way to all participants and tryout candidates.

What it means for you#

  • Private school students and families: A student could seek a place in a covered public school activity without enrolling in public school, but only if the private school is not a member of a statewide athletic association and does not offer that activity. The student must meet the bill’s residency, tryout, conduct, and payment conditions.
  • Students already covered by the law: The bill continues coverage for students in FPE schools, home schools, and full-time virtual courses or programs.
  • Public school districts and charter schools: They must provide eligible students an opportunity to participate, subject to tryouts and the bill’s exceptions. They cannot set separate attendance or discipline policies for eligible students.
  • Public schools and private schools: The bill does not require a private school to offer an activity, or require public schools to include eligible students in other gatherings or special occasions outside the listed activity types. Schools may set a policy about participation in those other events.
  • Students who leave a public school: A student who leaves because academic performance or disciplinary status would bar participation is ineligible for 12 calendar months for activities in the school or district they left.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill gives no amount for any added costs to districts or charter schools, such as handling eligibility or participation.
  • Students must meet the same financial requirements as enrolled students. The bill does not set new fees or specify an amount.

What is unclear#

  • “Statewide athletic association” and whether an activity is “offered” by a private school are not defined in the bill.
  • The bill does not set an application process, decision deadlines, or an appeal process for eligibility or participation decisions.
  • It does not explain how schools should handle limited spaces or conflicts between eligible students and enrolled students.
  • The bill does not specify when it would take effect or provide funding. Its passage is uncertain because it is only introduced.

Case for#

  • The bill could give private school students access to public school activities their own school does not offer, without requiring them to attend public school classes.
  • Applying the same conduct, performance, financial, and activity-related attendance rules to eligible and enrolled students could support consistent standards.
  • Allowing tryouts where applicable means participation can still depend on meeting the activity’s selection requirements.

Case against#

  • A student’s eligibility would depend on whether their private school belongs to a statewide athletic association, as well as whether it offers the activity. The bill does not explain why that membership test is used.
  • The bill creates an opportunity to participate, not a guarantee of a place; it does not explain how schools should manage limited space or disputed decisions.
  • The requirements to provide sports physical information, prove residency, and meet financial requirements could create barriers, but the bill does not describe how those requirements would be handled in practice.