Diesel-emission enforcement blocked by bill

Summary#

HB 3515 would add a new section to Chapter 1 of Missouri law; it does not amend a named existing Act. Its stated goal is to stop taxpayer resources from being used to enforce federal laws about emissions-control equipment on diesel engines. The bill would remove authority to enforce those federal actions and create civil liability and penalties for certain knowing conduct.

  • The restriction covers federal laws, orders, rules, regulations, statutes, and ordinances governing removal of emissions-control devices from listed diesel-powered vehicles, including buses, trucks, farm tractors, and school buses.
  • It applies to any person or entity, including state and local public officers and employees. It says they have no authority to enforce or attempt to enforce the covered federal actions.
  • An employer could be sued if someone it employs knowingly violates that restriction while acting under color of state or federal law. A court could award reasonable legal fees and costs to the prevailing party, except when the state or a political subdivision prevails; immunity would not be a defense.
  • An entity employing a federal government official, agent, employee, or deputy could face a $100,000 civil penalty per occurrence if that person knowingly enforces or tries to enforce the covered federal actions, or materially assists someone doing so. A person who lives or does business in the relevant jurisdiction could seek a court declaration about alleged conduct.

What it means for you#

  • Diesel-vehicle owners and operators: The bill does not itself require anyone to remove emissions equipment, make removal lawful, or change vehicle ownership rules. It restricts enforcement of the specified federal actions.
  • State and local officials and employees: They would have no authority under the bill to enforce or attempt to enforce those federal actions.
  • Federal employees and their employers: The bill would expose an employing entity to a $100,000-per-occurrence penalty for an employee’s knowing enforcement or material aid. The text does not explain how the penalty would be imposed.
  • People seeking to challenge conduct: A person who lives or does business in a jurisdiction and believes an individual acted in violation could seek a declaratory judgment (a court ruling on the parties’ legal rights) in the county where the conduct allegedly happened, or in Cole County for the specified federal-related conduct.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the available material.

  • The bill requires no stated appropriation and gives no estimate for administering or defending cases.
  • It creates potential $100,000-per-occurrence penalty exposure for covered employers, plus possible court costs and legal fees.
  • It does not say who would receive any civil penalty.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define what it means for a federal action to “govern” removal of emissions-control devices, or what counts as one “occurrence.”
  • It does not explain how a civil penalty would be assessed, collected, or challenged, or how a declaratory judgment case would result in that penalty.
  • The bill does not set out procedures, timelines, or rules for these cases.
  • The supplied material does not include current Missouri law, so I could not verify what enforcement authority or limits already exist.
  • The bill is listed as introduced. It is not yet law, and the text gives no start date.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent state and local resources from being used to enforce the specified federal actions.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that a clear limit on enforcement, backed by liability and penalties, could discourage covered conduct.
  • A person affected by alleged enforcement could ask a court for a ruling, rather than relying only on government officials to address it.

Case against#

  • The restriction applies broadly to any person or entity and does not explain how it would interact with other enforcement duties or existing programs.
  • The $100,000 penalty applies per occurrence, but the bill does not define an occurrence or explain how penalties would be imposed.
  • Employer liability, fee awards, and the ability to bring declaratory-judgment cases could lead to costly disputes; the bill provides no estimate of those costs.
  • The text does not clarify how its restrictions and penalties would apply to federal government entities or employees.