Severability rules could keep remaining provisions

Summary#

SB 1797 would amend Missouri’s Chapter 1 by adding two provisions about what happens when a court finds part of a legislative act unconstitutional or invalid. Its stated goal, reflected in its title and text, is to keep the rest of an act in force when it can still be carried out as intended. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • For an unconstitutional provision, a court would have to sever it and presume the remaining provisions would have been enacted without it.
  • That presumption would have an exception: if clear and convincing evidence shows the General Assembly would not have enacted the remaining provisions without the invalid one, the court would also have to declare those provisions invalid. The bill says evidence could include a finding that the remaining provisions are incomplete and cannot be carried out as intended.
  • A second provision says the General Assembly intends for the remaining parts of an act to stay in force as far as they can be carried out as intended. It also declares that each part would have been passed even if another part, or its application, were invalid.
  • The bill addresses what happens to the rest of an act after a court finds a provision invalid. It does not change which provisions are constitutional.

What it means for you#

  • People affected by a law challenged in court: If a court invalidates one part, other parts could remain in force. Under the bill, they would not remain in force if the court finds clear and convincing evidence that the General Assembly would not have enacted them without the invalid part.
  • Courts: They would have to apply the bill’s severability rules when deciding what remains of an act. The bill does not set out a separate application or review process.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, conduct rules, or public services. Its practical effect would depend on how courts apply the rules to particular laws.

Money#

No cost information is in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not state an appropriation, fee, fine, staffing requirement, or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include current Chapter 1, so it is not possible to verify what severability rules already apply or how much the bill would change them.
  • The bill does not explain how its two new provisions would work together, especially when one declares that each part would have been passed regardless of another part’s invalidity while the other allows remaining provisions to be invalidated based on clear and convincing evidence.
  • The bill does not define “legislative act” or “legislative intent,” or explain how the clear-and-convincing-evidence exception would apply.
  • The text does not say whether the new rules would apply to acts passed before the bill takes effect. It also does not provide an effective date.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that one unconstitutional provision should not automatically undo other parts of an act that can still work as intended.
  • The bill gives courts a rule for deciding whether remaining provisions should stand, while allowing them to invalidate those provisions if the stated evidence threshold is met.
  • Keeping workable provisions in force could preserve parts of a law that remain valid and executable.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the presumption favoring the remaining provisions could keep them in force even when the law’s overall design depended on the invalid part—unless the court finds clear and convincing evidence otherwise.
  • The bill’s broad declaration that each part would have been passed independently may be difficult to apply alongside the exception that allows the remaining provisions to be invalidated.
  • The bill does not explain how courts should interpret key terms or how the new rules fit with existing severability law; the supplied material does not show what current law already provides.