Population-based justice count moves to odd years

Summary#

AB 28 would amend Nevada Revised Statutes (NRS) 4.020, which sets how many justices of the peace each township has. It would move the population count used for that decision from even-numbered years to odd-numbered years, and change who receives a notice when justices oppose an increase. Its stated aim is to revise provisions about justices of the peace; the bill gives no broader goal.

  • The Governor-certified township population used to set the number of justices would be counted in odd-numbered years instead of even-numbered years.
  • If a majority of a township’s justices, after consulting the county commissioners, decide the caseload does not justify an increase, they would have to give notice by March 15 of the odd-numbered year.
  • The Legislative Counsel Bureau Director would send that opinion to the Assembly Speaker and Senate Majority Leader for consideration, rather than to the next regular legislative session.
  • The population-based formula for the number of justices remains. If it calls for an increase, the additional justice or justices are elected at the next biennial election, unless the objection process applies. In that case, the number cannot increase during the relevant period unless the Legislature approves it by resolution.

What it means for you#

  • Justices of the peace: The population count and deadline for objecting to an increase would shift to odd-numbered years. The bill does not otherwise change the population formula or create a new process for assessing caseload.
  • County commissioners: They would still consult with the justices on whether caseload warrants an increase. They would also receive any notice of the justices’ opinion.
  • Legislative officials: The Legislative Counsel Bureau Director would send the opinion to the Assembly Speaker and Senate Majority Leader. The bill does not require either leader to act on it.
  • Township residents and voters: The bill does not directly change court services, the election method, or the formula for the number of justices. It changes the timing of the population-based determination and the route for an objection.

Money#

The bill’s fiscal note says it would have no effect on state, local, or State Highway Fund finances.

  • The bill assigns notice and forwarding duties to existing officials, but gives no separate estimate of any administrative costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill is prefiled and has not become law; whether it passes is uncertain. The supplied text gives no start date.
  • The current NRS 4.020 text was not supplied. The bill’s digest says the current population determination occurs in even-numbered years, but that comparison cannot be independently checked against the current statute here.
  • The bill does not define the “period” during which an increase is blocked after an objection.
  • It does not explain what consideration by the Assembly Speaker and Senate Majority Leader involves, or whether they must respond.
  • The fiscal note gives no explanation for its no-effect estimate.

Case for#

  • A population-based formula remains in place, so the number of justices would continue to reflect township population.
  • The bill keeps a way for justices to object when they believe caseload does not warrant an increase, while leaving the Legislature able to approve one by resolution.
  • A possible argument for changing the timing is that it updates the schedule for making these decisions. The bill does not explain why odd-numbered years are preferred.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain why changing the count and objection deadline by one year would improve the process.
  • Sending an objection to two legislative leaders for consideration is less specific than submitting it to a regular legislative session. The bill does not say what happens after the leaders receive it.
  • The bill leaves the meaning of “during that period” unclear, which may make it harder to know how long an increase is blocked after an objection.