Medicaid abuse penalties expand civil liability

Summary#

AB-38, “Revises provisions relating to Medicaid,” would amend Nevada law; it does not create a new agency. Its stated goal is to revise Medicaid rules, including rules on provider liability, corporate criminal cases and payments to Medicaid recipients. The bill is prefiled and is not law; its provisions would start upon passage and approval.

  • It would require the Attorney General to bring a civil action against a Medicaid provider who abuses, neglects, exploits, isolates or abandons an older or vulnerable person—or knowingly or reasonably knowingly allows someone else to do so. The person need not be a Medicaid recipient, and a criminal case would not be required.
  • It would set civil penalties, including at least $25,000 for each instance when the bill’s billing-based penalty does not apply; extra penalties for death and for abuse in a licensed facility; and three times the State’s reasonable enforcement expenses.
  • It would prohibit offering or giving remuneration (money or anything of value) to a Medicaid recipient when the person knows or should know it is likely to induce certain actions, such as sharing information needed for a claim or choosing a particular provider.
  • In Medicaid fraud criminal cases against corporations, the corporation would have to appear through counsel at every stage. A court could enter a guilty plea and impose a sentence if the corporation fails to appear at a proceeding where it must enter a plea.
  • Money collected under the new civil-liability section would be appropriated for medical aid to people with low incomes through programs administered by the state Health and Human Services Authority.

What it means for you#

  • Medicaid providers and licensed facilities: A provider could face civil penalties for abuse or neglect of an older or vulnerable person, even if that person is not enrolled in Medicaid and no criminal case is brought. If the abuse occurred during or in connection with services, the penalty would be three times the amount billed to Medicaid for those services. If that penalty does not apply, the penalty would be at least $25,000 per instance. Death adds a penalty of at least $50,000. At a facility licensed under chapter 449, the bill also sets a fine of at least $5,000 for each day the conduct occurred.
  • People dealing with Medicaid recipients: A person could face criminal penalties for offering or giving a recipient something of value to influence the recipient to share claim information, use a particular provider, practitioner or supplier, or take part in certain Medicaid violations. The penalty would be a gross misdemeanor if the value is under $650, or a category D felony if it is $650 or more. The bill exempts certain extra services or benefits from a Medicaid managed care organization when intended to encourage use of a particular provider.
  • Medicaid recipients: The bill does not directly change eligibility, covered services or benefits. It would restrict certain inducements offered to recipients.
  • Corporations charged with Medicaid fraud: A corporation would have to appear through a lawyer throughout the criminal case. A court could enter a guilty plea and impose a sentence in the specified failure-to-appear situation.
  • The Attorney General and state government: The Attorney General would have a duty to bring civil actions under the new liability section. Money collected under it would go to medical aid for people with low incomes.

The bill changes existing Medicaid laws. The supplied digest describes some current rules, but the parent statutes were not supplied, so the full current wording and exact baseline could not be independently checked.

Money#

The fiscal note says the bill may affect state finances and may increase or newly provide for jail or detention terms at the local level; it gives no dollar estimate.

  • The Attorney General would have to bring the new civil actions, but no staffing or enforcement-cost estimate is provided.
  • Civil penalties and repayments collected under the new section would be appropriated for medical aid to people with low incomes.
  • No estimate is given for penalties collected, local detention costs, or any other public cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “provider” in the new section’s text, and the supplied materials do not include the full existing definition.
  • It does not explain how “each instance” of abuse or neglect would be counted, or how the different civil penalties would be applied together in a particular case.
  • The bill does not set out procedures, timelines or review rights for the new civil actions.
  • The bill does not say how the new liability rules would interact with existing licensing discipline or other enforcement.
  • Passage is uncertain. The bill says it would take effect upon passage and approval; it does not provide separate implementation rules.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to hold Medicaid providers financially responsible when they abuse or allow abuse of older or vulnerable people, without making a criminal conviction a condition of civil liability.
  • The penalties could make serious harm costly to providers, including when it happens in a licensed facility.
  • Directing collected money to medical aid could support the bill’s stated public-service purpose.
  • Restricting inducements could help prevent payments from influencing recipients’ choices or the sharing of information used for claims.

Case against#

  • The civil penalties could be substantial, including minimum per-instance and per-day amounts, an added penalty if a person dies, and three times the State’s reasonable enforcement expenses.
  • Liability would not require a criminal case. The bill does not explain the process for resolving disputed facts or how the penalties would be calculated.
  • The terms “each instance” and “provider” are not defined in the new section, leaving important questions about who is covered and how penalties apply.
  • A corporation’s failure to appear at the specified plea proceeding could lead to a guilty plea and sentence entered by the court; the bill does not explain how that power would work in practice.