Deputy Defenders Could Practice Private Law

Summary#

SB 20, “Revises provisions relating to indigent defense,” would amend Nevada’s existing laws on the State Public Defender and the Board on Indigent Defense Services. Its stated goal is to allow deputy state public defenders to engage in some private legal practice, subject to approval and regulations; the bill is prefiled and is not law.

  • Deputy state public defenders, who are state-employed attorneys, could practice private law other than criminal law only with approval from the Department of Indigent Defense Services’ Executive Director and subject to Board regulations. Current law generally prohibits their private practice.
  • The Board must adopt regulations setting the circumstances in which the Executive Director may authorize that practice.
  • The bill does not require the Executive Director to approve any deputy’s request, or require deputies to practice privately.
  • Most of the other Board duties and powers shown in the bill are existing provisions, not new changes.

What it means for you#

  • Deputy state public defenders: If the bill takes effect, you may be allowed to take private legal work outside criminal law, but only if the Executive Director approves and you meet the Board’s regulatory conditions.
  • Indigent defendants and the public: The bill does not directly change who qualifies for indigent defense or create a new service or complaint process.
  • State officials: The Board must set the circumstances for authorizations. The Executive Director would decide whether to authorize private practice under those rules.

Money#

The fiscal note says the bill may have a state fiscal impact, but gives no amount.

  • The Board must adopt regulations, and the bill allows preparatory administrative work to begin upon passage and approval. The materials do not estimate those costs or identify staffing needs.
  • The fiscal note reports no effect on local government or the State Highway Fund.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “criminal law” or specify the types of non-criminal private work that may be allowed.
  • It leaves the circumstances for approval to Board regulations. The bill does not set an application process, decision timeline, appeal process, or reporting requirement for authorizations.
  • The bill does not specify how conflicts of interest, workload, or a deputy’s availability for public duties would be handled.
  • The supplied material does not include the full current statutes. The bill’s digest says private practice is generally prohibited now, but the full current law and its interaction with the bill could not be checked.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give deputy state public defenders a limited way to do private legal work while keeping criminal-law practice off limits.
  • Requiring both Executive Director approval and Board regulations could allow exceptions while setting conditions for them.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that it offers deputies more professional flexibility without requiring the state to allow every request.

Case against#

  • Private work could create conflicts or compete for time with a deputy’s public duties. The bill leaves key safeguards and limits to regulations rather than stating them in the statute.
  • It is unclear what work counts as “criminal law,” which could make the boundary difficult to apply.
  • The bill does not require the Executive Director to approve requests or explain how decisions will be made, so deputies may not know in advance whether a particular type of private work will be allowed.