Victim input at pretrial hearings expanded

Summary#

SB 35, titled “Revises provisions relating to pretrial release hearings,” would add provisions to Nevada law and amend existing pretrial-release rules. Its stated goal is to help victims exercise their constitutional right to be heard at a pretrial release hearing and have their safety considered. It is prefiled and is not law.

  • Police must give each victim written notice as soon as practicable after a person is taken into custody. The notice must include hearing information, how to ask to be heard, and prosecutor contact information.
  • A victim may be heard in person, remotely, in writing, through specified representatives, or by another method the court accepts.
  • Prosecutors may ask for a no-contact condition even if the victim has not asked for one. They may also ask for any release condition they consider necessary to reasonably protect a victim; the court is not required to grant the request.
  • The bill says failure to give the required notice is not a defence to prosecution and cannot be used to establish negligence or causation in specified civil actions against the officer, law enforcement agency, or prosecuting agency.

What it means for you#

  • Victims: You must receive written information about the expected hearing, how to ask to be heard, and where it will take place. If available, the notice must explain how to watch remotely. The bill does not require you to speak or guarantee that the court will impose a condition you want.
  • People arrested: The bill does not itself require release, change bail amounts, or require a court to impose a condition a prosecutor requests. Existing rules still govern the court’s release decisions.
  • Police and prosecuting agencies: Arresting officers must provide the notice. A failure to do so does not provide a defence to the arrested person or support negligence or causation in the specified civil actions.
  • Prosecutors and courts: Prosecutors gain express authority to request victim-protective release conditions, including no-contact conditions. The bill does not require prosecutors to make requests or require courts to grant them.

Money#

The fiscal note says the bill may affect local government; it reports no effect on the state or State Highway Fund.

  • No cost estimate is provided. The bill requires officers to provide notices, but the materials do not say what staffing or other costs this would require.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set a fixed deadline for notice beyond “as soon as practicable,” or say what happens if hearing details change after notice is sent.
  • The bill does not set a process or deadline for requesting to be heard, or explain how a court decides whether to accept another method of speaking.
  • The added provisions do not define “victim.” The supplied materials do not establish whether existing law defines it.
  • The existing statutes being amended were not supplied. The bill’s digest says victims already have a constitutional right to be heard and may request no-contact conditions, and that prosecutors may already request bail or release conditions. The full current statutory text was not available to verify other changes.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a right to be heard is more usable when victims receive timely information about the hearing and how to take part.
  • Allowing several ways to be heard could make participation possible for victims who cannot attend in person.
  • A prosecutor could seek a no-contact condition when the victim has not requested one, and could ask for other conditions aimed at reasonably protecting the victim.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set a precise notice deadline or say how agencies should handle missing or changing hearing information, which could make notice less reliable.
  • One concern is that notice duties may add work and local costs, while the bill provides no cost estimate.
  • The bill does not explain how courts should assess requests for conditions aimed at protecting a victim, beyond the existing release rules. This leaves important details to court decisions.
  • A victim’s ability to be heard does not ensure the court will impose the requested condition.