More Deaths Would Require Forensic Exams

Summary#

SB 47, titled “Revises provisions relating to decedents,” would amend Nevada laws on death investigations and death records. It would broaden when a coroner must arrange a postmortem examination, and change who may complete death and stillbirth certificates. Its stated goal is not provided in the supplied material; the bill is prefiled and is not law.

  • A coroner would have to arrange an examination by a forensic pathologist (a doctor trained to investigate deaths) in several added situations, including certain unexpected deaths, deaths in state custody, and bodies that cannot be identified.
  • A physician assistant could sign a medical certificate of death or stillbirth. A death certificate would have to be signed within 72 hours, by the last provider in attendance or by certain other providers specified in the bill.
  • A physician, physician assistant, or advanced practice registered nurse who signs a death certificate in good faith would be immune from professional discipline and civil liability for acts or omissions related to the determinations on that certificate.
  • Funeral directors would have to notify a local health officer or coroner and refer a death for investigation and certification when it occurs without medical attendance or without “current care.”
  • The bill defines “current care” as care for an acute or chronic condition not caused by a single incident. It also lets a local health officer certify a death if there was no qualified provider in attendance or the person had not received current care in the prior 18 months.

What it means for you#

  • Families and the public: A death meeting one of the bill’s listed conditions would require a postmortem examination by a forensic pathologist. The bill does not require an examination in every death.
  • Coroners: They would have to arrange examinations when the listed conditions apply. These include suspected violence or a related act; unexpected or unexplained circumstances; a previously unreported or undiagnosed disease that threatens public safety; possible unnatural death; death in state custody; a need to determine cause and manner of death; or an unidentified body. For a possible drug-related death or poisoning, the bill keeps an exception if death follows a hospital stay of 24 hours or more.
  • Physicians, physician assistants, and advanced practice registered nurses: They could sign death certificates under the bill’s rules. For a death in a medical facility by natural means, the facility could designate a provider to sign. For a death outside a facility caused by an acute or chronic condition or its complications, a provider who gave current care in the prior 18 months could sign. A provider authorized to sign could also face a fine of up to $250 for refusing or neglecting to complete a certificate when required, or for knowingly making a false certification.
  • Funeral directors and local health officers: Funeral directors would have to refer deaths without medical attendance or current care for immediate investigation and certification. A local health officer could certify in the circumstances listed above, using information from relatives or others with adequate knowledge.
  • This bill does not create a new agency, benefit, or tax. It changes duties and powers under existing state laws.

Money#

The fiscal note says there may be a local-government fiscal impact and no state fiscal impact; it gives no dollar estimate.

  • The bill labels its local-government costs an unfunded mandate and says the usual statutory provision on local-government costs would not apply.
  • The bill requires coroners to arrange examinations in more cases, but the material gives no estimate for examination costs, staffing, or how those costs would be covered.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “violence or some other related act,” “unexpected or unexplained circumstances,” or what qualifies as a disease that “constitutes a threat to public safety.”
  • It does not explain how a coroner would decide that an examination is necessary to determine cause and manner of death, or how disagreements about that decision would be handled.
  • It does not set out how providers or facilities would be selected to sign certificates, or how the 72-hour deadline would work if the required information is not available.
  • The bill does not explain how local governments would pay for added examinations or what the likely costs would be.
  • The full current versions of the amended laws were not supplied, so the available material does not allow an independent check of every change against current law. The bill’s summary identifies several existing rules, but does not show the full baseline.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that requiring examinations in more kinds of uncertain or potentially unnatural deaths could help determine how people died.
  • Allowing physician assistants to sign certificates could give facilities and families another qualified provider option.
  • Letting a provider who gave current care sign for some deaths outside medical facilities could address cases where no provider was present at the time of death.
  • The 18-month definition gives a time limit for deciding whether a provider’s prior care qualifies.

Case against#

  • The added examination triggers include terms the bill does not define. This could leave important decisions to coroners without clear limits in the bill.
  • More required examinations could add costs or workload for local governments; no cost estimate or funding source is provided.
  • The bill grants broad immunity for good-faith certificate decisions, including immunity from licensing discipline and civil liability. It does not explain how mistakes would be addressed through other processes.
  • The bill does not explain how facilities would choose designated signers or how local health officers would verify that a person had or had not received current care.