Summary#
Bill 15 would let some pension plans pay small pension entitlements as lump sums, and let some former members living outside Canada withdraw their deferred pension value. It would amend the Pension Benefits Act and related pension laws; the bill is at first reading, and its start date would be set by proclamation.
- A plan may pay a former member a lump sum if the yearly pension is at or below 4% of the Year’s Maximum Pensionable Earnings, or the pension’s commuted value is below 20% of that amount. A plan may also pay a qualifying joint-and-survivor pension as a lump sum after a former member dies.
- People entitled to those lump sums may direct the plan administrator to transfer the money to a registered retirement savings plan or registered retirement income fund. Any amount above the federal transfer limit must be paid to the person as a lump sum.
- Administrators must send certain unclaimed lump-sum amounts to New Brunswick’s Director under the Unclaimed Property Act.
- A plan may exempt a qualifying non-resident former member from keeping a deferred pension in the plan: the member may withdraw its commuted value after giving the administrator a declaration of non-residence.
- The bill also exempts certain collectively negotiated plans from rules in the Pension Benefits Act, changes other pension rules, and removes a paragraph from the Teachers’ Pension Plan Act.
What it means for you#
- Former members and surviving pension recipients: If your plan offers a lump sum and you meet the bill’s threshold, you could receive the value instead of a pension. You would have 90 days after receiving the specified written statement to direct an eligible transfer.
- Former members living outside Canada: You could withdraw the commuted value of a deferred pension if you are not resident in Canada for federal income-tax purposes and give the administrator the required declaration.
- Pension-plan administrators: You would have to deliver qualifying unclaimed lump-sum amounts to the Director. The bill also gives regulation-makers power to set rules for withdrawals from retirement savings arrangements.
- Members of affected collectively negotiated plans: The bill would exempt certain multi-employer plans, and certain defined-benefit plans with fixed employer contributions, from specified rules. The effect of those exemptions depends on what those existing rules require.
Money#
No cost estimate or spending amount is stated.
- Administrators would have to deliver certain unclaimed amounts to the Director; the bill gives no estimate of the administrative cost.
- The bill does not set a fee, fine, tax, or new public benefit.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not state what the exempted rules require, or explain the effect of removing the paragraph from the Teachers’ Pension Plan Act.
- A plan may offer the lump-sum payments; the bill does not require every plan to offer them or set a process for deciding.
- The bill does not say when it would start. Its provisions would take effect on dates set by proclamation.
Case for#
- Allowing small pension entitlements to be paid as lump sums can give former members access to money that may otherwise remain in a pension plan. The transfer option lets eligible people direct the money to a registered retirement savings arrangement, subject to federal limits.
- Letting non-residents withdraw deferred pension value gives people who have left Canada a way to access that value rather than leave it in a pension plan.
- Sending qualifying unclaimed amounts to the Director puts them under the province’s unclaimed-property rules instead of leaving them with pension administrators.
Case against#
- Paying a small pension as a lump sum gives up future pension payments in exchange for money now. A former member who takes the lump sum would bear the risk of making that money last.
- Because plans may offer the lump sums but do not have to, people with similar pension entitlements could have different options depending on their plan.
- Exempting specified collectively negotiated plans from existing rules could reduce protections for members of those plans. The bill does not describe the rules being set aside or explain how the exemptions would affect members.