Education would require evidence-based methods

Summary#

HB 129, called the “Science in Education Act,” would amend New Hampshire’s existing education law, RSA 193-E, by adding a definition and requirements for “evidence-based” methods in public education. Its stated goal is to give the term a definition based on repeatable scientific studies. The supplied status says the House adopted a motion to find the bill “inexpedient to legislate” on January 7, 2026; it is not law.

  • The Department of Education, school districts, and other regulatory bodies that prescribe teaching methods would have to use evidence-based methods for public education, including educator training, policies, and teaching methods tied to curriculum—but not the curriculum’s content.
  • A method would qualify if it is reproducible in multiple well-designed studies within one discipline, or independently confirmed by well-designed studies across multiple disciplines. Peer-review status would not affect whether it qualifies.
  • Surveys, self-reported data, and subjective measures—including reports of student progress and learning—could not count toward the definition.
  • The Department and school districts would have to make public the studies they relied on. They could require a third-party curriculum provider to supply those studies.
  • The Department would have to adopt rules to implement the requirements.

What it means for you#

  • Department of Education and school districts: They would have to apply the new definition to covered methods and make their relied-on studies public. Their use of “evidence-based” in communications would also have to match the definition.
  • Other bodies that prescribe teaching methods: Their methods for public education would have to meet the definition.
  • Third-party curriculum providers: The bill would not directly require providers to disclose studies to the public. The Department or a school board could require a provider to give studies to them.
  • Students and families: The bill would not change curriculum content directly. It would exclude reports of student progress and learning from the evidence that can establish a method as “evidence-based”; it does not say those reports could not be used for other purposes.

Money#

The fiscal note estimates state costs of $118,000 in FY 2026, $123,000 in FY 2027, and $127,000 in FY 2028; local costs are indeterminable.

  • The Department says it would need one education consultant to review methods, assist local education agencies, and work on revising state requirements that conflict with the bill.
  • The bill provides no funding and does not authorize new positions. The estimates are costs, not appropriations.
  • The fiscal note estimates local school district spending would increase, with the amount varying by district. It cites review work and possible replacement of methods, materials, and training.
  • The fiscal note estimates no state or local revenue change.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of RSA 193-E was not supplied, so the existing legal meaning of “evidence-based” and how much of this would be new could not be verified.
  • The bill does not define “well-designed studies,” “reproducibility,” or “independent confirmation,” or explain how disagreements about whether a method qualifies would be resolved.
  • The Department would make rules, but the bill does not specify review procedures, timelines, appeals, or oversight.
  • It is unclear which existing methods, requirements, or training would need to change, or how the bill would interact with other laws and programs.
  • The bill would take effect 60 days after passage, but the supplied status says the House adopted a motion against legislating it.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to set one definition for a term used in public education and require public bodies to follow it.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that repeated results across studies provide a consistent basis for calling a teaching method evidence-based.
  • Requiring public access to the studies relied on could make the basis for those claims easier to examine.

Case against#

  • The definition excludes surveys, self-reported data, and subjective measures such as reports of student progress and learning. One concern is that this could rule out information that may be relevant when judging teaching methods.
  • The bill does not explain how to decide whether studies are “well-designed” or results are reproducible, leaving important choices to later rulemaking and implementation.
  • The Department anticipates staffing costs and districts may face added administrative and implementation costs, but the bill provides no funding or positions.
  • The requirement covers a broad range of methods, training, and policies; it is unclear how many current practices would need to be reviewed or changed.