Voter Identity Checks by Officials Could Alter Ballots

Summary#

HB 317, “Allowing a supervisor of the checklist to verify a person's identity, with identification, if they personally know that person,” amends New Hampshire’s election laws, RSA 659:13 and RSA 654:12. It is signed into law and takes effect 60 days after passage; its stated goal is to allow identity verification by an election official who personally knows a voter.

  • A voter without valid photo identification must be directed to the supervisor of the checklist. A moderator, clerk, supervisor, or selectman may verify the voter’s identity if they personally know the voter.
  • The supervisor must review the voter’s qualifications and decide whether both the qualifications and identity are established. If not, the voter may not vote, but may immediately appeal to superior court.
  • An official who verifies identity must complete and keep an attestation under penalty of perjury. A moderator or clerk who did not make the attestation must also witness it.
  • For voter registration applications, the bill removes language allowing “other evidence” to include identity verification by a moderator or another election official. It retains a separate route for a nursing-home or similar-facility administrator, or their designee, to verify a resident’s identity.

What it means for you#

  • Voters without valid photo ID: You may be able to vote if an authorized election official personally knows you and your identity and qualifications are established. The bill does not guarantee that the supervisor will find them established.
  • Voters denied a ballot: You may immediately appeal the supervisor’s decision to superior court. The appeal procedure is referenced in another law, whose text was not supplied.
  • Election officials: Identity verification requires a written attestation and a second official’s witness statement. The voter must be listed on the checklist at that voting location.
  • Nursing-home or similar-facility residents applying to register: The facility administrator or designee may verify your identity; the application is treated as if you proved identity with photo ID.
  • Other voters and the public: The bill does not change the general requirement to establish voter qualifications, and it does not create a new agency or benefit.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires election officials to complete and retain forms, but gives no estimate of staffing or administrative costs.
  • It provides for an immediate court appeal but gives no estimate of related court costs.
  • It creates no fee, fine, tax, or appropriation in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • The full current texts of RSA 659:13 and RSA 654:12 were not supplied, so the bill’s broader interaction with current law could not be checked.
  • The bill does not define what it means for an official to “personally know” a voter.
  • It does not set out standards for the supervisor’s decision or explain how the required second official will be available.
  • The details of the immediate court appeal are in another law not supplied here.
  • No publicly available information on the date of passage is included, so the exact effective date cannot be determined from the supplied material.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a voter without valid photo ID could still have their identity verified by an election official who knows them.
  • The supervisor must check both identity and voter qualifications; the bill does not make personal recognition alone an automatic right to vote.
  • The attestation, penalty of perjury, and witness statement provide a written record of the verification.

Case against#

  • One concern is that “personally know” is not defined, leaving the standard open to differing judgments.
  • The supervisor decides whether identity and qualifications are established, and the bill does not explain the decision standards.
  • The required form and witness step add duties for election officials, but the bill gives no estimate of the time or cost involved.
  • The bill removes election-official verification as an example of evidence for registration applications while creating a specific personal-knowledge route for voting. How those rules work together in practice is not explained in the supplied material.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1705305

    Passed356 members voted

    Adopt CofC Report

    FOR · 197AGAINST · 159

    197For

    • Republican193
    • Democratic3
    • Independent1

    159Against

    • Democratic157
    • Republican2

    35 members were paired and sat out the vote.