Child restraint non-use could affect damages

Summary#

New Mexico SB 313, titled “Child Car Seat Fastening As Negligence,” would amend two sections of state law; it does not create a new law. Its stated aim is to remove rules that bar failure to use a required child restraint or safety belt from counting as fault or negligence or from reducing or apportioning damages. The supplied status says the bill was introduced and postponed indefinitely, so it has not changed the law.

  • It would remove that legal protection from the child-restraint enforcement law and the Safety Belt Use Act.
  • It would not change the existing requirements for restraining children in vehicles.
  • It would leave the requirement for the Motor Vehicle Division’s bureau to provide restraint-use education, to the extent funding allows, and evaluate the Safety Belt Use Act.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers and caregivers: The bill would not change who must secure children or which restraints are required. It would not add a new ticket or fine in the text provided.
  • People involved in injury claims: If someone was not using a required child restraint or safety belt, the bill would remove the current rule that says this cannot count as fault or negligence or affect how damages are limited or divided. The bill does not say that non-use automatically makes someone negligent or reduces their damages.
  • People who use safety belts: The deleted protection covers failure to use a safety belt as required by the Safety Belt Use Act, not just failure to fasten a child car seat. The bill does not change the belt-use requirements themselves.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The bill keeps an education duty for the bureau and two departments, but only to the extent funding allows. It gives no estimate for that work.
  • The bill does not set out a new fee, fine, appropriation, or staffing amount.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how courts would apply the removed protection or how much weight non-use could have in a claim.
  • It does not define “fault” or “negligence,” or set out exceptions or a process for deciding whether non-use affected an injury.
  • The available text does not explain how the change would interact with other laws governing injury claims.
  • The bill provides no start date. Its supplied status says it was postponed indefinitely.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that whether someone used a required restraint may be relevant to deciding how an injury occurred or how damages should be divided.
  • Removing the blanket bar could allow that issue to be considered in a claim, rather than excluding it in every case.
  • The bill leaves the existing restraint requirements and safety education provisions in place.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a person’s failure to use a restraint could affect their damages even when the bill does not establish that the failure caused the injury.
  • The bill does not set limits or exceptions for applying fault or negligence to children or to different circumstances.
  • Removing the bar may make outcomes less predictable, while the bill provides no process for how courts should weigh non-use.