A plan regarding security perimeters adjacent to places of religious worship

Summary#

Introduction 0001-2026, sponsored by Council Member Julie Menin, amends the New York City Administrative Code. It requires the Police Commissioner to make a plan for security perimeters near places of religious worship; the stated goal is to address safety risks while protecting speech, assembly and protest. It became law without the Mayor’s signature and took effect immediately.

  • The Commissioner must send a proposed plan to the Mayor and Council Speaker within 45 days, and a final plan within 90 days.
  • The plans must include considerations for NYPD on whether and when to use a perimeter, how long it should last, its size, and how to implement it without curtailing protected activity or blocking emergency access.
  • The plans must cover communication with worship leaders, the public, and people seeking to protest, assemble, or enter or leave a place of worship. The final plan must be posted online and include a public contact point.

What it means for you#

  • NYPD: Must prepare and publish the plans. The law does not require NYPD to use a perimeter in any particular case.
  • Places of worship and their leaders: NYPD’s plans must consider communication with clergy and administrators about their needs and concerns.
  • Protesters, the public and people entering or leaving: The plans must consider their needs and concerns and how to protect speech, assembly and protest.
  • People at places of worship: The law defines physical obstruction, intimidation and interference. It does not itself ban protests or create a process for people to request or appeal a perimeter.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of preparing or carrying out the plans.

  • The law requires NYPD to prepare the plans, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The law does not define “security perimeter” or set specific rules for deciding when one should be used.
  • It does not detail how NYPD must consult the groups named in the law.
  • It does not set out a process for reviewing a perimeter decision or challenging it.

Case for#

  • The Council summary describes risks of obstruction, injury, intimidation and interference at places of worship. A plan could give NYPD considerations for addressing those risks while protecting protest rights.
  • The law requires the plan to consider both emergency access and the concerns of worship leaders and people seeking to protest or assemble.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the law leaves key choices—including whether to use a perimeter and how large or long-lasting it should be—to NYPD, without setting detailed rules in the law.
  • The law requires consideration of affected groups’ concerns but does not specify how that input must affect decisions.