Summary#
Introduction 74, sponsored by Council Member Oswald J. Feliz, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code. It would add certain cannabis-related activity to the city’s Nuisance Abatement Law; its stated goal is to make that activity subject to court injunctions. It has been referred to a committee and is waiting there; the supplied history does not name the committee, and the bill is not law.
- A building, dwelling, or other place could be treated as a public nuisance if it is used for the specified cannabis activity without the required New York State registration, license, or permit, or in violation of a state cannabis law provision involving a person actually or apparently under 21.
- The Corporation Counsel (the city’s lawyer) must bring and maintain a civil court case to permanently enjoin these nuisances.
- A court could issue a temporary closing order or temporary restraining order without notice if the Corporation Counsel proves the nuisance by clear and convincing evidence and shows an immediate need to protect public health, safety, or welfare.
- After such a temporary order, the court must hold a preliminary-injunction hearing within three business days and decide the motion within three business days after the hearing ends.
- If enacted, the local law would take effect immediately.
What it means for you#
- Cannabis sellers and deliverers: The new nuisance category covers distributing cannabis for sale, selling it wholesale or retail, or delivering it to consumers without the required state registration, license, or permit. The Council summary says the under-21 category covers selling, delivering, or giving cannabis to a person under 21; the bill text ties that category to a violation of State Cannabis Law section 85(1).
- Owners and occupants of places where the activity occurs: A place, including a one- or two-family dwelling, could be named in a nuisance case. A court could order the relevant part temporarily closed, or restrain further nuisance activity and the removal or interference with furniture, fixtures, and movable property. These orders are not automatic; a court must grant them.
- City government: The Corporation Counsel must bring and maintain the civil proceeding for a nuisance covered by the bill. The text does not create a new agency or specify a separate application process.
- People generally: The bill creates civil nuisance remedies; it does not set a new criminal penalty or fine.
Money#
No publicly available information.
- The bill does not state a cost estimate or provide a funding amount.
What is unclear#
- The supplied materials do not include the current Administrative Code or the cited State Cannabis Law provisions, so the existing rules and the precise scope of those state-law violations could not be verified.
- The bill does not explain how nuisance cases would be selected, or how the city would apply the new category to places used for more than one purpose.
- It does not give a start date beyond saying the law takes effect immediately if enacted.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to give the city a way to seek court orders against places used for unlicensed cannabis sales or deliveries and the specified activity involving people under 21.
- A possible argument for the approach is that court orders could stop the activity at a location; temporary orders could address cases where a judge finds an immediate need to protect public health, safety, or welfare.
Case against#
- One concern is that a temporary closing order or restraining order may be issued without notice, potentially affecting a place and its movable property before a preliminary-injunction hearing.
- The bill includes dwellings in the definition of places that may be treated as nuisances, but does not explain how cases involving homes or mixed-use buildings would be handled.
- The text does not provide a cost estimate or explain how the city would resource the required civil cases.