Reporting on food and nutrition education in New York city schools

Summary#

Introduction 0080-2026, sponsored by Council Member Gale A. Brewer, would amend the New York City Administrative Code to require the Department of Education to report each year on food and nutrition education in city schools. Its stated goal is to make information about that education public. The bill is waiting in committee; it has not become law.

  • The Department must send a report to the Council, post it on its website, and publish it in the city’s open data portal in a machine-readable format.
  • The report must cover the preceding school year, including how often and how long students receive instruction, student counts by grade and school disaggregated by race and ethnicity, gender, and free or reduced-price lunch eligibility, and staff training.
  • For schools using external providers, the report must name and describe each provider and say whether the school has added costs or receives extra funding.
  • The report must include the Department’s method for tracking some of the data. Student information cannot be reported in a way that violates privacy law or conflicts with law-enforcement interests.
  • The bill text does not require reporting on certified dietitians or whether nutrition education is combined with other health education, despite the Council’s summary saying it would.

What it means for you#

  • City schools and the Department of Education: The Department would have to prepare and publish the reports. The bill does not expressly require schools to provide data to the Department or change what schools teach.
  • Students and families: The report would include school- and grade-level data about students receiving instruction, with the listed categories. The privacy safeguard applies, but the bill does not set out how the Department would prevent identification.
  • Schools using outside providers: The report would disclose provider and funding information. The bill does not require schools to hire providers or change existing contracts.
  • Public: You would be able to access the reports online, including through the city’s open data portal.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Department to produce and publish reports, but gives no estimate for staffing or other costs.
  • The report would disclose whether schools incur extra costs or receive funding for outside programs; the bill itself does not provide that funding.

What is unclear#

  • The bill says the first report is due by August 31, 2023, a date that has passed, and then requires reports by August 31 each year. It does not say what the first deadline would be if enacted.
  • It does not explain how schools’ data would be collected or verified, or how the Department would handle missing data.
  • The report must use school- and grade-level categories, but the bill does not explain how privacy risks would be assessed beyond requiring compliance with privacy laws.
  • The bill lists the average frequency and minutes per week twice, with the same wording.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give the Council and public regular information about how much nutrition education students receive and who provides it.
  • Reporting provider names, training, costs, and funding could make differences among schools easier to see.
  • Publishing the data in a machine-readable format could make it easier to compare or reuse.

Case against#

  • One concern is that preparing detailed school- and grade-level data could add work for the Department; the bill gives no cost estimate or data-collection plan.
  • Student information grouped by school and grade could raise privacy concerns, even with the bill’s legal safeguard.
  • The bill does not set out how the Department would check the data or address gaps, which could make reports hard to compare.