A plan regarding security perimeters adjacent to educational facilities

Summary#

Introduction 175-B, sponsored by Council Member Eric Dinowitz, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code. It would require the Police Commissioner to develop a plan for possible security perimeters at educational facilities; the stated goal is to address safety and access risks while protecting free speech, assembly and protest. The Council passed it on March 26, 2026, but the Mayor vetoed it on April 24, so it is not law unless the Council overrides the veto. The supplied history does not show an override.

  • The Police Commissioner would have to send a proposed plan to the Mayor and Council Speaker within 45 days, and a final plan within 90 days. The final plan would also have to be posted online.
  • The plans would have to include considerations for NYPD on whether and when to use a perimeter, how long it should last, how far it should extend, and how to put it in place.
  • The plans would have to include considerations for communicating with facility administrators, the public and people seeking to assemble, protest, or enter or leave a facility.
  • “Educational facility” covers places where educational programming takes place, including childcare programs, schools, colleges and universities. The bill also defines physical obstruction, intimidation and interference.
  • The plans would have to address emergency access and egress, protect protest rights, and include a public point of contact. The bill says it must not infringe rights under federal labor law or New York labor law.

What it means for you#

  • Educational facilities and NYPD: If the bill became law, the Police Commissioner—not each facility—would have to produce the plans. The bill would guide NYPD’s decisions about perimeters, but would not require NYPD to set one at any particular facility or event.
  • Students, staff, visitors and people protesting or assembling: The bill would not itself create a perimeter or ban protests. It would require the plans to address safety, access and protest rights.
  • General public: The final plan and a NYPD contact point would have to be published. The bill does not require individuals to apply or take any other action.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require the Police Commissioner to prepare and publish plans, but gives no estimate for staff time or other costs.
  • It does not state an appropriation, fee or fine.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set detailed rules for when a perimeter should be used or how far it should extend; it leaves those considerations to the plan.
  • It does not require a perimeter, or spell out a process for deciding a specific case, notice, appeal or review.
  • The materials do not explain why the Mayor vetoed the bill or whether the Council later considered an override.

Case for#

  • The Council’s summary says the plan is meant to address risks of obstruction, injury, intimidation and interference while protecting speech, assembly and protest.
  • Having NYPD plan for when and how perimeters might be used could help account for emergency access and the needs of facility administrators, the public and people seeking to protest.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves key decisions—such as when to use a perimeter and its size—to considerations in a plan, without setting specific standards in the law.
  • The bill requires plans to include considerations for communication, but does not require consultation in each situation. It is unclear how affected people’s concerns would shape a specific decision.
  • No reason for the Mayor’s veto is provided in the available material.