Complaints of housing violations

Summary#

Introduction 253, sponsored by Council Member Crystal Hudson, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code to set steps for the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) when handling housing-violation complaints. The bill’s apparent goal is to verify complaints before closing them; that goal is not a guaranteed result. It has been referred to committee and is waiting there.

  • HPD would have to visit within 30 days after notifying the building owner of a complaint.
  • If HPD cannot enter the unit, it must post a notice on the door and give one to the owner. After at least two visits on different days without entry, HPD must call and text the tenant or occupant to arrange an appointment.
  • If HPD cannot reach the tenant or occupant by phone or text, it must mark the complaint “unresolved” and post and provide another notice.
  • HPD may mark a complaint “closed” only after verifying that the condition was fixed, does not exist, or the complaint was otherwise resolved.
  • A tenant or occupant submitting a complaint must provide contact information, including but not limited to a phone number. Owners and complainants may contact HPD to arrange a visit.

What it means for you#

  • Tenants and occupants: You would have to provide contact information when submitting a complaint. If HPD cannot enter after at least two visits on different days, it must try to reach you by phone and text to arrange an appointment.
  • Building owners: HPD would have to give you notices about failed entry attempts and complaints marked unresolved. You may also contact HPD to arrange a visit.
  • HPD: The department would have to follow the inspection, contact, notice and complaint-status steps in the bill. Notices must be in English and the designated citywide languages.
  • The bill does not specify what happens if a complainant does not provide contact information.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires HPD to make visits, provide notices and contact tenants or occupants. It gives no estimate of the staffing or other costs.
  • The bill sets no fee, fine, tax or new benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The current complaint process was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which steps would be new.
  • The bill gives no deadline for an appointment or follow-up visit after HPD contacts a tenant.
  • It does not say what further action HPD must take on an unresolved complaint, or how a complainant could challenge that status.
  • “Otherwise resolved” is not defined in the bill. The languages required for notices are referred to in another code section but are not listed here.

Case for#

  • The bill’s text would require HPD to verify a reported condition before closing a complaint, which could reduce closures without verification.
  • The required notices would tell tenants and owners about attempted visits and how to arrange an appointment.
  • Marking a complaint unresolved when HPD cannot reach the tenant distinguishes it from a complaint HPD has verified as resolved.

Case against#

  • The bill’s contact-information requirement could make submitting a complaint harder for someone who cannot provide contact details; the bill does not say what happens in that case.
  • The required visits, notices and contact attempts could add work for HPD, but the bill provides no cost or staffing estimate.
  • The bill does not require a further attempt or set a timeline after a complaint is marked unresolved, so the complaint’s next steps may remain unclear.