Giving council members the power to make appointments to community boards

Summary#

Introduction 322, sponsored by Council Member Frank Morano, would amend the New York City Charter. It would give Council Members direct power to appoint some community board members; its stated goal is to give them appointment power. It is not law: as of the latest supplied history, it was laid over in the Governmental Operations, State & Federal Legislation Committee on June 22, 2026.

  • Under current Charter wording shown in the bill, borough presidents appoint board members, with at least half drawn from Council Member nominees. The bill would split appointments: half by borough presidents and half by Council Members whose districts include part of the community district.
  • Each Council Member’s share would be proportional to the part of the community district’s population they represent. The City Planning Commission would calculate those proportions after redistricting.
  • Borough presidents and appointing Council Members could remove members for cause; vacancies could be filled by either official, depending on who made the appointment.
  • Borough presidents’ annual reports would identify the appointing Council Member or other nominating party, count vacancies by appointing authority, and describe coordination with Council Members on recruitment.

What it means for you#

  • Council Members: They would gain direct appointment power, and could remove members they appointed for cause and fill vacancies in those positions.
  • Borough presidents: They would retain half of the appointment power and their existing duties to report on recruitment and board membership, with added reporting about Council Member appointments and coordination.
  • Community board members and applicants: The bill retains limits on membership, including that a member must have a residence, business, professional, or other significant interest in the district. A Council Member or borough president could not appoint someone they employ to a board where that official has appointment power.
  • Community boards: Members would remain subject to existing term limits and other membership rules in the Charter. Council Members would remain non-voting board members.
  • The bill does not create a new community board application or appeal process.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The bill adds reporting details for borough presidents, but the materials provide no estimate of the work or its cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how to handle appointment counts if a board’s membership is not evenly divisible between borough presidents and Council Members.
  • It does not set application, selection, or appeal procedures for Council Member appointments.
  • It does not specify how disagreements between a borough president and Council Members would be resolved.
  • The law would take effect only after voters approve it at the next general election after enactment. The materials do not state when that election would occur.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that Council Members elected from a community district would have direct responsibility for choosing some of its board members, rather than only nominating candidates.
  • The population-based allocation could match each Council Member’s appointment share to the part of the community district they represent.

Case against#

  • One concern is that shared appointment power could make recruitment and filling vacancies more complicated, especially where several Council districts overlap one community district.
  • The bill does not explain how Council Members should choose among applicants or how the public could assess those decisions.